r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Aug 27 '25

WoD Non-binary and transgender Garou?

9 Upvotes

I've been mulling creating an assigned-female-at-birth Children of Gaia Garou for a chronicle that uses they/them pronouns. The game is set in the modern age. Would this gender expression be tolerated in the Children and Garou nation at large?


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Dec 06 '23

VTM Serious discussion: I feel that the Caine lore is the weakest part of V:TM.

2 Upvotes

I hope i'm not stepping on any toes when i say this, and i mean it in no disparaging or judgmental way. But personally the lore surrounding Caine being the Father of Vampires never sat well with me, and it's been a recurring stumbling block.

I find it difficult to take it seriously, as in essence V:TM is asking you to admit straight-up and accept that The Old Testament is simply true. Adam and Eve were indeed the first humans, Caine and Abel were their sons, and as a result it brings with it the baggage of several millennia's worth of religious development being hammered into a singular volume, that being inconsistencies.

In a book of religious scripture you can deal with this for the most part even if you're a non-believer, because you can understand that it is a product of centuries of religious development and the development of the Jewish Bible itself, but when V:TM uses it to essentially say that 'as a matter of fact it actually IS true, Caine is the Father of Vampires, he actually WAS cursed by the Hebrew God who is real', it suddenly brings all those inconsistencies and makes them tangible in a way that makes it difficult to ignore, at least for me.

It feels like it's weakest link, because then you have to ask yourself the pressing questions: how did the human race come around then if Caine was Adam and Eve's only living son? Where did Lilith come from? How were then first cities then formed? I am not the first person in my personal life who encountered this as an issue to a lesser or greater extent. Of course, there are also some who don't mind it, which is obviously fine. On it's own, the idea is great. It's a very tempting narrative proposition, it establishes that Kindred are directly cursed by a divine power and will never see the light of Heaven.

But the issue also comes from the fact that V:TM wants to eat their cake and have it too, in the sense that the game will tell you on one hand that this might all well be something someone made up and that it will rarely, likely never actually, factor into your un-life. If you simply assume that this is simply Kindred foklore that is unlikely to be true, you can easily dismiss the inconsistencies as just that, inconsistencies in a belief and not a tangible reality.

On the other they reserve just enough wiggle room and plausible deniability to be able to say that actually maybe it's true, and it's this intellectual and creative cowardice that raises my hackles. If it were simply the former, where it's widely considered that Noddism is a crock of shit that is only sincerely held by a small sect of Kindred it'd be fine.

But then you have to contend with the Antedilluvians, who (unlike Caine) have at one point or another and to one extent or another, been active in the lives of their progeny. The Antedilluvians trace their lineage directly back to Caine and it's much harder to them dismiss the Book of Nod as simply being Kindred folklore.

I understand of course that the reason behind this is to allow Storytellers to craft their own narratives and pick and choose what they want to believe is true, but regardless it feels like taking such a vital part from a major world religion and claiming it as objectively true, to be clumsy. And yes, granted, you can simply safely engage in this game without ever worrying or thinking about this, as the nature of Caine or the Antedilluvians will likely simply never come up in a way that should concern you, but it's still a large Bible shaped hole right there in the corner of your eye.

I hope i didn't offend anyone, this is naturally only my opinion.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Jul 31 '26

Am i the only one that is interested in V6 ?

0 Upvotes

After reading alot of the packet, I am (cautiously) interested. I never saw the big appeal of the Hunger Dice. To me the removal is not a negative point or positive point. Blood costs are predictable, Disciplines mature with higher ratings, and clans have stronger mechanical identities.

I especially am intersted the clan specific beasts. They may be restrictive in some cases, but they give each clan a distinct internal struggle and will give new players a lot of guidelines what your clan actually entails. From there you can deconstruct it again (if you have the experience).

I am also interested in the new Humanity system. I am not yet convinced by the symmetrical Monstrous/Mortal structure, but it is genuinely different and could create interesting character development and stories. I do need to see how it works over several sessions though.

Unlike some, I like NPC Levels. I already use a similar shorthand for less important NPCs, although major characters would probably need more differentiation and in the end i would just "create" them normally, but still, good from my pov.

My main concerns are Vitae combining blood, health and power fuel, the very small Skill list, and the amount of metacurrency/player-authored complication through Quickening, Drama and Devils Bargains. Social conflict currently looks a bit “meh” and potentially overstructured, but I would need to actually play it before judging it properly.

Overall, it seems to restore some of the Vampire flavour I miss from revised/v20 while moving the underlying system even further toward narrative abstraction than V5... which idk i want to try?

Oh and it is def not DnD.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Sep 23 '24

Blood Pool bad, genuinely change my mind

26 Upvotes

To be blunt, the more I learn about the blood pool system compared to V5's hunger system, the more it just kind of seems like a tool to make the personal horror in the game of personal horror a complete non-issue. Unless the ST forces otherwise, the beast is a joke and a vampire could go a week without feeding to literally no side effects. It essentially makes every single thing that's bad about being a vampire optional, to the point where I find it hysterical that White Wolf didn't like that people were making katana trenchcoat man when building that is basically effortless and building any character who actively suffers by being a monster, who experiences any of the downside of the embrace, requires legwork on behalf of both the player and the ST.

Update: I have definitely successfully been calmed down from saying that blood pool is BAD or less functional than hunger. I like the explanation someone gave that essentially boiled the choice of BP vs. Hunger to be between whether or not The Beast and all the unsavory aspects of vampiredom are in the Storyteller’s hands (BP) or in the hands of the dice (Hunger). And I, personally, like the latter, because it makes the beast and the thirst for blood literally less unscripted and therefore constantly hanging over your heads, as opposed to a conscious directorial choice where they yell “FRENZY!” when they think it would be interesting to do so. Neither is wrong, but I like the latter.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Jul 06 '23

WoD/CofD So, can we stop pretending that the Storyteller System is a narrative system?

0 Upvotes

I get it, in the 90s having that amount of fluff and depth in character creation was revolutionary, comparing to D&D. You could play whoever you wanted to play, not bounded by a class.

But really, the system doesn't lend itself to create a powerful narrative. There are no mechanics for the players to interfere in the story in a meaningful way, it's entirely up to the storyteller to write the book.

Comparing to modern systems like The One Ring or the PbtA games, which have distincts phases and rules for social encounters (unlike Storyteller, which only have extensive rules for combat), the game doesn't seem to hold up its "narrative" aspect.

In my experience playing Mage or Werewolf, the narrative aspect is entirely up to the players. If you want to roleplay is fine, but if don't want to it becomes a slog fest of throwing dice, and the system doesn't help you in moving the story forward. Might aswell play with any other system instead of this one.

I'm happy to hear your thoughts.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Aug 13 '24

WoD/CofD What is your unpopular opinion on world of darkness?

0 Upvotes

Ill go first, I think vampire is a Mary Sue, plot armor filled splat. And mage Power system sucks and should be a bit more simpler, while keeping the free-form spheres.

Edit: I think I should include by power system sucks I mean mechanics. Lover the power not the mechanics


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Jul 31 '26

WoD My final conclusion on the alpha material, great system.

3 Upvotes

I read all the new material, walked a long walk to absorb it.

Here is my take, when regarding the system one should realize that it’s a completely new system that has nothing to do with the old systems whatsoever, what they have in commonality, is the lore and the setting.

As for this new system, it’s a rule system, buildup by strict rules with modifiers, and actions, “feats” built into your class/clan and discipline, built-in currencies to push the narrative, solid options for skills powers. There is enough fun stuff for players to build upon a character in various ways in the form of skills, disciplines, clan traits, and merits.

The npc/monsters are split into three categories, minions, standard and elites, each with their own characteristics and how they respond to the PCs in mechanical terms.

Drama point to infuse a scene or NPC with additional options,

All in all, this is a solid Alpha test for a modern system.

For myself I would never use this for my world of darkness. As a storyteller, I don’t want my players to keep track of every little modifier coming either from their hunger. A discipline or what not. In world of darkness and the setting I feel like it slows the gameplay tremendously down. There are way too many mechanical aspects to this game that I would never want my PCs to keep track of. I especially do not like how the NPC’s are run by the GM and never rolling die. It can be fun in some systems, but not in world of darkness..

So great system, but not in Word of darkness.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Aug 31 '26

WTA Can Pentex be played as the good guys?

4 Upvotes

I mean "played" in the narrative sense; they would still be antagonists that the PCs fight. Though I'm also open to them being actually playable.

The Wyrm is a victim of the Weaver, right? So the banes got corrupted and went crazy along with the Wyrm because of the whole imprisonment thing. Perhaps Pentex is aware of this, and they seek to destroy the Weaver (and with that, civilization) to restore balance.

Okay, that doesn't exactly make them "good guys", and the PCs still have a very good reason to fight them, but it makes them a lot more sympathetic and aligned with the Garou Nation than we typically see.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Oct 10 '26

VTM I don't quite understand what stereotypes exactly inspired the clans.

3 Upvotes

I read somewhere that each clan embodies a vampire stereotype. It seems like the Toreador is Anne Rice's vampire. Nosferatu came from the film of the same name. These are obvious things.

But what about the rest?

Has anyone heard of the stereotype, that vampires are touched by fairies crazy seers, which the Malkavians embody? I know that in European past the mentally ill have been equated with vampires, but those legendary figures were definitely crazy members of the nobility.

The Ventrue are supposed to embody the vampire nobility. But in lore the Ventrue are just idiots, and story dislikes them so much, that anyone but them becomes a Prince. Or the Ventrue themselves aren't found in ruling circles as often as they should be.

What about the Tremere? They're obviously not liches. And I can't think of anything popular and iconic media about vampire-sorcerers.

I think the Gangrels originated from European and Central European myths. However, those vampires also possessed witchcraft, not just the ability to transform into animals and communicate with them. Control of the elements, various curses, communication with spirits. And they were closer to humans.

And the Brujah seem to have no identity at all. They're just punk vampires. Which are the personification of vampires from films and TV series of the 80s and 2000s. They are just aggressive and punks, they don't even have unique disciplines, just copy the powers of Toreador. It would even make sense if the Brujah were a bloodline of the Toreador. Also, their theme of scientist-philosophers is just a thing of the past. And in the modern world, the Brujah-punks are not even relevant. If this clan disappears, they will easily be replaced by Toreador and any vampires who want to be punks and bikers. This clan also fits well with the theme of the Sabbat, Caitiffs and thinbloods, rather than as a separate clan.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Feb 15 '25

If you aren't a werewolf, is life even worth living in WoD?

0 Upvotes

Like, seriously they are seemingly better than literally any other being in that universe, is it not better to just end your own life and reroll and hope for a better chance at it?


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Jul 20 '25

WTA How do people rectify some of the very triggering for some parts of Werewolf (W20)?

9 Upvotes

So, when it comes to the parts of Werewolf the Apocalypse I've read, I very much have a "curiosity-hate relationship" with it, mostly due to the "1990s inclusion and progressive stuff was actually racist and they didn't exactly realise due to a lack of research" stuff.

J.F. Sambrano talked about that in their patreon post I very much recommend reading if you haven't (link here, you don't have to pay to read: https://www.patreon.com/posts/werewolf-5th-and-86463964 ) and the treatment of the Older and Younger Brother tribes (using the names they used to refer to two of the tribes in the post for obvious reasons when you read it for yourself)

The way Kinfolk are treated by some tribes is another major issue

Most majorly for me individually is LGBTQ+ treatment, especially trans people (if you didn't notice via my pfp, I'm a trans woman and a lesbian) and the various offensive and incorrect language used in Changing Ways, especially, to quote: (TW: very transphobic wording and treatment) "To top things off, hormonal and surgical gender re-assignment are hopeless endeavors for a werewolf. His body rejects and repairs any alterations before they can have any real effect."and "Others slaughter the transgender individual as a mockery to Gaia."There is no reason for this beyond making the game needlessly cruel to trans people. Before anyone mentions the conservative society the Garou have, I think this should be entirely a social issue, but not as extreme as my second quote, rather than making the transformation part of werewolf affect the first quote.

There are other issues I've missed simply because they don't immediately come to my mind

So, I'm wondering two things

Firstly, how exactly did this happen, I'd guess for similar reasons as Sambrano's patreon post, especially when M20 (My favourite WoD gameline) didn't have this issue, being very kind, understanding, and accepting of trans people, if slightly ignorant but well meaning in a few lines, page 258 of the M20 rules has 4 paragraphs which are really nice and slightly heartwarming.

Secondly, how do people who take similar issues rectify this in their games?


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Feb 08 '23

MTAs mage and antisemitism?

0 Upvotes

I'll be the first to say I know very very very very little about Mage. Love VTM, just starting to dip my toes into learning about WTA lore, but I've almost never touched Mage outside of reading some of the posts that come up on this subreddit and clicking on the occasional link when there's an inter-splat connection on a White Wolf Wiki page.

All that being said - why are there so many terms used in MTA that are also used in Jewish terminology or antisemitic conspiracies? Outside of the whole NWO concept - which exists in a lot more media than just this, so I'm not singling it out - in the last few days I've also come across the "Pogrom" and a group called the "Cabal"? Have White Wolf ever explained this? Is it commonly accepted among Mage fans that the source material is flawed in this way, or is something flying over my head here?

(I'm not trying to ragebait anyone here it's a legitimate question. I don't know that much about Mage and I don't know if learning more about it makes all this stuff make more sense, or just makes it worse haha)

Edit: okay... some of you engaged in some good faith point-making, and some of you have just said "shut up racism isn't real when I don't personally see it." Some of you agreed with me, most of you disagreed, which I expected tbh. Thanks to everyone who was actually helpful in this discussion. To everyone that got so instantly butthurt - this is White Wolf. If you're scared of people pointing out the games haven't aged well in certain aspects, then you NEED to find new games to play, because it's all over WW's history lol.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • May 05 '24

VTM Does anyone else feel like some of the clans are just kinda goofy?

0 Upvotes

Idk if this is gonna be sacrilege or not, and I know you can just ignore things you don't like in a ttrpg, but I kinda don't like a lot of the clans lol. I just feel like somewhere along the line things got way off rails and they started adding things just to add them. There are so many clans that have very little to do with vampirism or are just "pop/real world culture thing but as vampires". The clans outside the original seven suffer from this the most, but honestly not even all the original 7 clans I feel make sense.

The Giovanni, Banu Haqim, and Ravnos are just mobsters/assassin's creed/Roma but as vampires, which is not only uninspired but can lead to insensitive depictions of irl cultures. I'm not entirely sure what vampire tropes the Tzimisce (excluding old clan Tzimisce, I actually really like old clan and wish that was just what the Tzimisce were) and Followers of Set are supposed to be filling. The Tzimisce I can kind of see as "vampires as inhuman monsters", but that's what the whole game is about and I don't think we need a clan where that's their schtick. They aren't terrble though and if I was only allowed to get rid of a certain number of clans they'd be low priority, but honestly I could do without them. The Followers of Set just feel like Conan villains, I don't really think they belong in the setting. The Lasombra and Tremere aren't terrible, but their justifications do feel kind of weak, "They control shadows and have blood magic because vampires live in darkness and drink blood"... ok. The Tremere especially are strange because the original seven clans were largely based off common depictions of vampires in media; but whenever I try to think of a reference for vampires practicing blood magic my mind always goes to VTM. Maybe I'm just not up on my vampire lore, but I feel like vampires being blood mages was popularized if not started by VTM. Then there's the Brujah, who also aren't terrible, but much like the Tremere the part of Vampire media they're representing feels like it was created by VTM. I'm not sure where the vampires as rebellious youth thing comes from, generally vampires are depicted as creatures of stasis, so idk what the inspiration for the Brujah was.

That leaves the Gangrel, Nosferatu, Toreador, and Ventrue. These are honestly the only clans I feel really fit the concept. They're all great representations of classic vampire tropes pulled into modern day. The Gangrel are the apex predator aspect of vampires who have a connection with animals similiar to Dracula in the novel (although honestly I feel like the animal connection is taken too far, but maybe I've just seen too many catboy Gangrel and am being cynical), the Nosferatu's inspiration is obvious, the Toreador are sexy Anne Rice vampires, and the Ventrue are aristocratic vampires. If I had my way, these would honestly be the only clans in the game.

Am I crazy or do you guys agree with me?


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Mar 12 '26

VTM5 What clan does she belong to? [v5]

Post image
0 Upvotes

Started drawing NPCs for a chronicle I'll be running in a while set in San Francisco and she's the first. What clan do you think she belongs to?


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • May 13 '23

MTAw Apparently Fate (sub-Archmastery) is so powerful it can move the forking moon. This is a badly written Spell description. No amount of Fate can change an event that is completely regular and perfectly predictable, Fate is supposed to only have dominion over uncertain things. Unless you're Ascending.

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Oct 03 '24

The Black Furies don't make sense.

25 Upvotes

First, I want to say that I am a proud feminist and supporter of women. Especially in this era as misogynists are increasingly crawling out into the open like cockroaches during a flood. That said, the Black Furies have a problem. They are nakedly hostile to men, as portrayed in the books. In the Umbra book, the Black Furies wanted to exterminate all of the men in their tribal homeland. Also, they used to kill their male children. However, with no males, they are more undermanned than most tribes. Also, it is a man's world, as they well know. So they must rely on their male kinfolk to do a LOT of their leg work, especially in the human world. Especially since they only have half the number of Garou that they should have.

Except their hostility to men would either drive the men away if they let them know about the Black Furies and the Garou, or at least make them ineffective and demoralized. And if they DIDN'T clue in the males about the supernatural aspects of the world, they would simply know there was an EXTREMELY hostile set of family members out there who seems to not like them very much, but they aren't exactly sure why.

It just seems that the Black Furies are built to self-sabotage themselves and to fail. But one way I would solve this problem is have the Black Furies merge their kinfolk network with the Children of Gaia. Work together as partners with them towards mutual goals, have their male kinfolk hang out with the CoG so they can identify with them, and make sure everyone remembers who they should be breeding with when it comes time to make babies. Anyone else have some thoughts on the matter?


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Sep 30 '26

WoD World of Darkness and The Problem With Playing a Monster

Thumbnail
therpggazette.wordpress.com
0 Upvotes

I think out of the, let's say more mainstream TTRPGs out there, those part of the World of Darkness are deceptively the hardest to properly play. For they ask of us something quite difficult: stop being human, be a monster. A supernatural kind, yes, but still.

Going with my beloved Vampire for example (although we also cover Werewolves in the article), yes I do enjoy playing it, yet I think I am not proficient enough at getting across the truly horror experience that is the life of a Kindred. No more warmth, no more sensation in your body, the inability to drink and eat, which as a foodie, truly horrible, the stuff of nightmares. You can't really trust anyone, there are so many rules and ways for you to die and good luck if you are a Nosferatu. No, most of the time, my games are a bit more lighthearted, the horror is dialed back a bit, as neither me, nor my players will necessarily be able to portray it in a believable manner constantly.

I did see games which managed to do so. A game run by Horia, Brasov by Night got a lot more closer to this portrayal of the actual horror of a newly embraced Kindred would find itself in. They recapped it in chapters and it was a pleasure reading through them. It kinda changed a bit the way I run and view my games, but I am not yet nearly as good as Horia.

With this piece I want to explore the challenges of this experience and to provide some ways in which you can improve this aspect, both as a player and ST. I hope you will enjoy it and find it useful!


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • May 10 '24

WTA5 "WWTO 5th is just Doomerism" Is a surface level take.

3 Upvotes

And a Bad one IMO

Yes ALOT of the book covers how the old guard failed and the new guard are up against impossible odds but....there's a lot of stuff that pin points how the players and story teller should change the conditions of victory/what it means to be garou and handle the fight. Opening the concept to a world that doesn't know itself anymore BECAUSE what it once was had failed, the horror that you cant save everyone...BUT the fight has changed the end may yet be survived, we are only on the BRINK but we can do SOMETHING we just have to redefine what that SOMETHING is.

I get not liking this approach but it's flat interpretation of the story the book wants to tell. We can argue how well that story/setting is portrayed don't get me wrong, but saying the book is JUST Doomerism is bad take.

Edit: THIS IS NOT MY OPINION OF THE BOOK. Also I'm never said this was the main criticism it was one of the criticisms that I feel falls flat is all.

Starting to get the vibe people think the doomer opinion is one I share when no, it was a take.on the books I really don't agree with. There is alot to criticize and research on w5 but I was saying the doomerism take over heard betwixt talks and podcasts was one of those takes I didn't agree with nut found rooted in the spaces I circles.

I have actually really appreciated people breaking down some stuff I didn't know about the making of the book that IS very worth criticizing and its nice to see some.people share my sentiments on what the final product is saying.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Oct 18 '22

WTA Pentex is stupid and I can't take werewolfs seriously because of it.

0 Upvotes

Seriously. Their greatest enemy is a corporation. Not a grand world conspiracy, not inquisition made by the union of national governments, not even ancient wizards of terrible power.

It's an "evil" public company. An enemy so mundane it will murder a fairy by being mentioned and so weak it is scared of the IRC and interest rates rise. It is also likely not even profitable since doing evil stuff for the sake of being evil doesn't pay.

Like, I get it, eco terrorism vs corporation greed, but can we not reduce the greatest enemy of the WARRIORS OF THE PLANET to that?

To me, a ventrue player, it destroys werewolfs as a concept. I just can't take them seriously.

Corporations are not enemies. They are assets. If the entirety of werewolf civilisation cant just hostile takeover/buy out a single Corp, werewolfs are not a threat to anyone. A single semi important ventrue elder has more power and reach than all of the werewolfs combined, which is silly.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Jul 29 '25

WTA5 I think I've realized why I like W5 so much, and why you should too

31 Upvotes

First off, I completely acknowledge a lot of the flaws with the mechanics, some the lore (and utter washing of it), ect. By no means is it perfect, in fact I completely agree it needs PLENTY of work. But I think W5 tries to grasp at some things that not only do a lotta people miss, but I personally think is fundamental to the concept of the game.

To me, W5 was made for new players just like V5. And with that, it pulls a lot more towards the initial werewolf fantasy than ever before, or at least in a more focused way. Cause to me, the core, classic werewolf fantasy is about a (usually good) person who becomes an unstoppable raging killing machine. And it's a metaphor for how even good people can hurt others when pushed to their limits.

Now, W5 forces you to spend WP to keep control of your crinos form every turn, and even then you're in a fugue state the whole time. Do I think this works? On its own yes, but not with how the gifts work, but that's a topic for a different day. The point is that this brings back that feeling of barely controlling the murder machine, and adds that deep personal horror to the game from the initial fantasy.

Beyond that, the whole spiritual aspect of WtA can be extremely daunting to new players, but I think W5 has done a good job of cutting off some of the overwhelming parts a bit while still keeping the idea for the most part. Fomori are focused on the more people aspect rather than murder fodder, and help lend to the narrative game experience. The umbra is harder to get to and it's talked about how and why that is, and I think that's good as, while I personally love the umbra, it is such a massive tone shift for new players. So having less focus overall and having it more as another narrative tool to use as necessary I think is not only a good thing, but necessary. And even the rites and such are made much more gnostic and free flow to allow many different interpretations.

And finally, W5, while still definitely having much more of a combat focus, does so in a way that very much tries to blend combat into narrative, and I think it does so pretty well. Turns and different kinds of actions are simple, combat focused and, let's be honest, inspired by D&D for familiarity, but have their own unique properties that lend towards the narrative style. Between the more loose timing of terms and actions, just the way attributes and skill rolls work as usual, and the 3 turns and out rule, combat still feels very cinematic and doesn't get dragged out for too long, but still let's you feel cool and badass.

I think W5, for all of its problems, deserves a lot more love. And in my opinion just some basic fixing to both stand on par with V5, and be something truly amazing in its own right. If you just rolled your eyes and ignored W5 at first, I get it. But if you like V5, or just are willing to try it out, I say fucking go for it. Not as a replacement for what came before, but as a new way to tell an old story.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • May 31 '23

WTA5 W5- Touchstones

9 Upvotes

Why.

No, really, why? Werewolf was never concerned with Garou necessarily having a relationship with anyone outside of the nation.

Forcing touchstones on them, in fact, completely 180° flips how Garou interacted with society in previous editions. We are going from a people whose monstrous Rage specifically seperated them from humanity, it was such a palpable force that humans, by and large, did not trust a Garou on instinct at best, and actively avoided them the higher their Rage was.

But now we have-

"uwu werewolves are super soft and cuddly creatures that all need a connection to their humans! A good gawou would never ever abandon their human ties! It would be totally unrealistic for a person to abandon their humans after discovering they are an out of control wolf-monster that could kill them at literally any moment!"

So does Rage just not affect humans any more? Is "The Nation" just fine with Garou associating with people that could threaten their existance when a slip-up occurs?

They just wanted to fit werewolf into whatever they did to V5 with seemingly no thought about whether or not it actually makes sense to who the Garou were. And you can pretend that it's fine because "it's not a continuation, it's a reboot", but that's precisely the problem. The majority of Werewolf's fans didn't want a reboot. You are presenting us not with Garou but with some basrardized Wolf-shifting people that are being called Garou.

This post isn't to beef with new editions. The 5ty editions are their own thing and people are free to enjoy what they like. But I still want the public to know what has been done to the Garou that makes OG fans so upset, so that when they see complaints in other threads they're not blindly down voting because they don't understand what it was that made WtA so great for so many of us in the first place.

Our criticisms and opinions deserve to be seen and acknowledged.


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Feb 05 '23

WoD Is vampire really a part of the WoD?

0 Upvotes

This is a strange question but I wonder why vampire is not linked to the WoD universe. Caïn is not a good fit for the trinity concept of kaos/weather/wyrm, and I cannot see any reason for the vampires to exists in this paradigm.

Do you think I've missed something important about the vampires?

What is your feeling about this?


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • 13d ago

WoD Hot take of the Day: V6 should have official guidelines for custom clan, antagonist, & Discipline creation for Storytellers to use!

Post image
0 Upvotes

(a page from the DCC corebook Royal Court edition)

I once brought up that it was sad that V20 did not include the systems for creating new bloodlines (outcasts a players guide to pariahs) or new disciplines (Time of Thin-Blood) in the core rule book or the supplements.

I was told that I shouldn't expect it because no corebook for any game would come out with such things, and including it in a supplement would decrease sales for future books.

I say this is a bunch of bologna, as the brand new ttrpg that I finally got my backers physical copy for (though I've had the PDFs for awhile has literally shipped with not only these rules which go on for several pages, but also more on different custom content guidelines.

So I once more shall say that we as Storytellers deserve up to date guidelines on custom content (clans, disciplines, etc) that will help us tailor such things to fit into the setting in a mostly balanced manner, such as what we had in "Time of Thin-Blood" for each gameline of WoD6, I don't care whether it comes as part of a supplement or core book, but it needs to be a thing.

Why does it need to be?

Because custom community made content is what breathes new life into a game, and keeps a community nice and healthy (see Skyrim mods, DnD, or even the Storytellers vault) they fix "bugs" add new ways to play and tell our tales. If not for Time of Thin-Blood I would never have been able to run my Antediluvian game the way I wished to. It's only because of that book that the disciplines I've made are even remotely balanced. While it is true that if I simply spent a couple months of study I probably could have connected the dots to do so on my own. The book not only sped the process, but gave me a framework to more properly judge whether or not a given power belongs with the rest of the disciplines.

So I will end off with this, PRETTY PLEASE WHITEWOLF GIVE US THESE RULES! I'LL NEVER SPEAK ILL OF YOU IF YOU DO!

What do y'all think?


r/WhiteWolfRPG • • Oct 08 '24

WoD5 What's manbearpig in the World of Darkness?

0 Upvotes

What would Manbearpig be in the world of darkness? Would it be a gangrel who has entered frenzy, a Chimera from the Dreaming, a Bygone or something even more strange?