I watched Warlock for the first time upwards of 20 years ago, and I remember liking it quite a lot. I just rewatched it last night, and I have some fresh thoughts on it. I've blocked out those thoughts in case they serve as spoilers for people who haven't seen the movie.
First off, it's very nicely directed and shot (in DeLuxe Color and CinemaScope), so it's almost always a pleasure to look at. So is Henry Fonda, who slots incredibly well into the western genre. I guess Fonda and his friend played by Anthony Quinn were meant to be a take of sorts on Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday, and they're both in fine form.
But I felt like the screenplay was a bit unfocused, and the relationships between the various characters relatively underdeveloped. I mean, I get that "character" is not always the focus of westerns, but something just felt lacking in the chemistry between the actors and/or the characters. Overall, the movie seemed more concerned with "theme" – and in a way that seemed like the movie wanted to be one of those movies with "something to say," a "statement" movie, if you will. But I'm just not quite sure what the movie was trying to say! Was is that the time of the "independent lawman" was coming to a close? (Richard Widmark's character assumes the role of town sheriff and insists on his role in dealing with the renegade "cowboys" or "regulators.") Or were we meant to admire the Wyatt Earp-type Clay Blaisedell? How was this especially relevant to viewers and why should we care? I guess I might have cared more if I felt more emotionally invested in the characters and their predicaments, but the movie came off as rather academic to me in the long run.
Overall, I really liked the direction, cinematography, and (much of) the set design, and Henry Fonda in particular is a strong and memorable presence, but I found the story, characters, and pacing rather disappointing. It's a movie I kind of want to like a lot, but for me, it's a 3 out of 5. (I even flirted with 2.5, but maybe there's just enough to like to push it up to a 3.)
So back to the question in my post title: What are your thoughts on the movie if you've seen it? Does it work for you?