r/Watchmen • • Sep 12 '26

My Rorschach Fancast

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Watchmen • • Aug 07 '24

Rorschach is the hero for incels.

0 Upvotes

A buddy and I were talking about the new animated movie that’s almost out, and it came up that if you like Rorschach you’re most likely an incel. Anyone want to weigh in? 😂


r/Watchmen • • Jul 12 '25

Rorschach Cosplayer “doesn’t like politics”

Post image
0 Upvotes

My friend shared with me with these messages they shared with a guy they matched with on Bumble. He had a picture of himself cosplaying Rorschach at a con and decided to ask him about it. He says it’s because he likes watchmen, and especially Rorschach. His bio has political affiliation listed as “Moderate”…

We had a good laugh making fun of this guy. Because it’s absolutely crazy to Cosplay Rorschach and in the same vein say you don’t like politics. Plus him reciting the Pagliacci line was something lol.


r/Watchmen • • Nov 30 '23

People who says "If you like Rorschach you missed the point" are dumb af

Post image
73 Upvotes

For me people who think like that are absolutelly idiots, I know that Alan Moore created Rorschach to make fun of righ-wings and he himself hates the character but I don't understand why creating a character that is a total badass and kills scum like pedos, rapists and murderes is considered "making fun of the right"? So if liking him is "missing the point" so I really don't fucking care what the point is


r/Watchmen • • Jul 13 '25

Hooded Justice wasn’t “saving” Sally, he was beating up his younger lover for cheating

Thumbnail
gallery
55 Upvotes

To truly understand Watchmen, you have to understand it’s symmetrical storytelling.

Issue 5 goes crazy with the symmetry but it’s not just that issue. It’s the whole book.

In pictures 3 and 4, you will see a panel from issue 1 that depicts the dawn of the superhero. Hooded Justice catches two thieves in the act. Their placements match the placements of Detectives Bourquin and Fine in issue 12 after their deaths. The symmetry here is showing you both the dawn of the superhero and how it all ends up ultimately unfolding. It’s quite beautiful really.

Picture 5 is a mash up of issue 1 and 12. When Rorschach sees Manhattan for the first time, we see Manhattan doing something with his finger that creates some kind of blue circle. We see this same circle again in issue 12, only it’s pink when Manhattan is doing whatever he’s doing to Rorschach in issue 12. Again, symmetry. Hell, check out the second and third panels in issue 1, page 1. Rorschach is walking by the guy washing off the blood off the sidewalk, and you see a similar pink circle. Symmetry.

Anyway…

At first look, it appears that Hooded Justice is saving Sally. And he does, technically. But that’s not what he’s doing.

What he’s doing is attacking his younger lover who is attempting to cheat on him.

How do I know this? Symmetry.

The symmetrical opposite of issue 2, the second issue of a 12 issue series, would be what? The second to last issue of the series, issue 11.

What happens in that issue?

An older lesbian women has a fight with their younger lover.

The older one, Joey, makes comments that she’s very upset that her younger lover, Aline, would rather hang out with a bunch of doped up Knot Tops than hang out with her. From this, we know that Joey views Knot Tops as “less than”, she looks down on them. Then she proceeds to kick the shit out of Aline.

Now, regardless of who Hooded Justice is, hell let’s say it’s Rolf Muller for this exercise.

We know that Hooded Justice is a Nazi. We know this.

Do you know how Nazis view Polish people? As “less than”, subhuman even.

I posit that what happened was the following:

Hooded Justice walks in on Eddie and Sally…

He gets fucking pissed that his boy Eddie, his younger lover, is doing something with someone other than him. Not only that, but someone “less than”, someone subhuman.

“You sick little bastard…” HJ isn’t talking about Eddie trying to rape someone. He’s calling Eddie “sick” because Eddie’s trying to make it with someone ‘subhuman’ in his eyes.

How does Eddie know what Hooded Justice likes?

Sure, after a few years, everyone on the team seems to know that HJ is gay, but this happened in 1940, within a year of the team forming. So soon after they formed, it became instantly known that HJ was gay? And the 16 year old is privy to such information that HJ likes it rough?

I’m sure many will disagree. “Comedien isn’t gay.” I’m not even saying he is, but it’s possible he was groomed at an early age, and this may even play into why he sees the world as a big joke.

But yeah, the symmetry helps us understand what’s happening here.

It never sat right that after HJ saved Sally, he gives her shit afterwards by saying “For gods sakes cover yourself!” Like bro, she was just almost raped, what the fuck is your problem? You literally just saved her!

But from the perspective that he wasn’t saving her but rather just beating the shit out of his younger lover for cheating, then this line suddenly makes more sense.

whew

Alright, commence with the downvotes lmao


r/Watchmen • • Sep 24 '24

Comic Doomsday Clock went against everything that Watchmen stood for. How come no one is bothered by this???

Post image
0 Upvotes

RetconDoomsdayClock #Watchmen #DC_Comics #Superheroes #comicbooks #comics #graphicnovels #alanmoore #geoffjohns #garyfrank


r/Watchmen • • Feb 26 '26

TV Why do I not see anything that critiques HBO watchmen when the characters are nothing like themselves? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Finally decided to watch the series after many years and there were just so many plotholes yet im so surprised iv seen nothing on it, im guessing it is all just downvoted to hell because of all the people allergic to anyone who hates their political messaging but what about disliking it for legitimate reasons?

Some episodes were done very well like the one which portrays how Manhattan percieves time, that was done super well, same with looking glass backstory

But overall the characters were just not themselves...

John as always shown has been a massive asshole (he leaves his first gf and cheats on her because she is getting older) he is meant to be a flawed character, and now all of a sudden he is a great dude? Loving husband? And he didnt even say anything or acknowledge silk spectre when he finally saw her?

Ignoring the fact that he COULD obviously stop all that happened but just going along with "he wanted to die ect" i feel like that was just so shoehorned in... like they had nowhere to go with the plot. He would have also gone with the fact that he WONT stop them, not that he COULDN'T

Also ozymandias can STILL catch bullets but he cant beat looking glass and laurie? common ffs...

This is the first HBO show iv seen that is kindof... bad...

Most of it just FEELS like badly written fanfiction (although yes before anyone says, obviously i know its not cannon to either versions of watchmen)

Edit: i point out this is not actually a review, its me picking a few points to critique and wondering why i have barely seen any mention of this, funnily enough comments and upvotes have reflected exactly my point that any critique is for some reason met with massive downvotes and inability to accept the fact there are loop holes


r/Watchmen • • Jan 01 '26

The Silhouette: an alternate history

Post image
0 Upvotes

Born in Austria at the end of the First World War, Ursula Zandt came of age in the unstable ferment of interwar Europe. As a young woman in Berlin during the late 1920s, she moved within queer, socialist and anti-fascist circles.

The violent destruction of that world by the Nazi Party in 1933 left her with practical skills in secrecy, evasion, and underground logistics, and without any faith in law or permanence.

By the mid-1930s Zandt was active in resistance networks across Central Europe: courier work, smuggling, surveillance, sabotage, and targeted violence against informants and collaborators who operated beyond the reach (or protection) of the authorities. When her covert role was compromised she escaped to the United States.

In America, the emerging culture of costumed vigilantism provided both cover and utility. Under the name The Silhouette, she joined the Minutemen, participating selectively in public-facing operations while continuing far darker work alone. To the press she was an enigmatic and minor member of the team; to her teammates, an efficient specialist who asked few questions and offered fewer explanations. No-one shed a tear when child traffickers went missing or simply turned up dead.

Her career ended not with exposure of her activity as a serial killer on the side of the angels, but with exposure of her private life. In 1946, she was murdered alongside her lover in a killing dismissed as sordid and unworthy of investigation. With her death, the Minutemen quietly dissolved, and one of their most effective members vanished into footnotes, her outlines preserved but her mission deliberately forgotten.


r/Watchmen • • Apr 14 '23

The Comedian Needs his own Limited Series. Who’s with Me!!!!!

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Watchmen • • Sep 22 '24

I did not care for Watchmen (2009) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I know this isn't that unpopular of an opinion but the amount of hate I feel for this movie is so high and I needed to share my hate with other potential haters. If you liked the movie I'm glad you were able to enjoy it though, truly. I wasn't expecting much from Zack Snyder but even with my low expectations this movie couldn't meet any of them. My most basic complaint, I hate the color scheme I hate how grey everything is. I understand he was going for a grim vibe but look at the book, clearly it's an achievable vibe even with a candy coated color scheme. Another total nit pick, silk spectre ii's redesign; what purpose does this serve? I hate how much they changed in Rorschach's origin story. The reveal with the bone was about as subtle as an atom bomb. I hate that he beat the cartoonishly evil child killer with a bone saw. I hate that instead of any scenes with the new yorkers in the book we have a sex scene set to Leonard cohen's Hallelujah. I hate hate hate the change in ozymandias's plan. Snyder must have thought the plot too silly for his grim dark interests and instead we have Watchmen 2009. Any humor from the original novel is gone and what we are left with lacks substance, character, or an inkling of any theme from the original novel. Loathing is not a strong enough word for how I feel about this movie.


r/Watchmen • • Jul 08 '23

Movie If we get another Watchmen film adaptation at some point, I need Henry Cavill to play Dr. Manhattan.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Watchmen • • Sep 20 '25

Did Rorschach actually do anything evil? Like killing an innocent person or something?

14 Upvotes

Just a question, because I've seen a lot of people saying that Rorschach is an anti-hero or morally grey, but from what I've seen all of his non-heroic moments are pretty much just his inner thoughts. Did he actually do anything villainous on screen, or is his anti-heroism just lip service?


r/Watchmen • • Mar 09 '25

Who was right in watchmen?

0 Upvotes

You have the three different characters ozymandias, Rorschach and Dr Manhattan. All three of these men had an encounter with the comedian (who essentially represents life). They all had epiphany moments and came away with different philosophies. Rorschach came away as a pessimistic nihilist, Manhattan essentially lost all interest in life, and ozymandias became idealist. So who got it correct?


r/Watchmen • • Apr 21 '25

Did you know?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Watchmen • • Jul 20 '25

Is there a lore reason doctor Manhattan has a small penis? NSFW

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Watchmen • • Feb 09 '26

Opinion piece: Ozymandias is the greatest hero in comics

0 Upvotes

Ozymandias is one of the richest men in the world, and instead of greed and selfishness, he uses his wealth for the betterment of humanity. As the world is on the brink of self-annihilation/the end of humanity, he devises a plan to save humanity. By sacrificing 3 million people ( 0.06% of the population), he saved 5 billion people. It's basically a more severe version of the Trolley Problem. He single-handedly saved the planet, then had a plan on helping the now unified humanity into an utopian society.

Ozymandias did more than Batman could ever dream of. He even did more for humanity than Superman could ever do. Ozymandias actually saved the world and created world peace.

And that's the genius of this story, is the morality philosophical debate it creates. Some view Ozymandias as a villain who killed millions, I see him as the greatest hero in comics because he saw that that was the only way to create peace on earth and did what had to be done.

*I am basing this opinion on the Watchmen graphic novel as a singular story, not off of any addition cash-grab followups that undo things in the story. Based off of this story as it is, Ozymandias's plan would have worked.

Rorschach's journal found afterwards would have most likely been dismissed as the ravings of a murdering madman. As well as he sent it to a far-right, tabloid-style newspaper called the New Frontiersman, that people would most likely dismissed the story around Rorschach's journal claims as fake news. So there's no way his journal would have undone what Ozymandias accomplished.

So logically, within the confines of the singular Watchmen novel's world, Ozymandias's plan would have succeeded, and based off his intellect and ability to think many moves ahead, he would have succeeded in creating a unified utopian world.

Hence Ozymandias was able to do what no other superhero has been able to do, making him the greatest hero.


r/Watchmen • • Feb 20 '24

Why do we idolize Batman and The Question but despise Rorschach? What is the main reason?

0 Upvotes

Why are Batman and The Question so praised while Rorschach is highly despised by the readers?


r/Watchmen • • Nov 14 '25

Why did Alan Moore make Laurie as a 16-year-old when she was groomed by Dr. Manhattan?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

A few days ago, I read Watchmen for the first time and I really loved it. However, I do have some issues about it, and my question above is one of them.

I “understand” (narratively speaking, although obviously I don't agree with it on a personal level) that Dr. Manhattan would look for a girl younger than his current girlfriend Janey Slater; and also that she serves as a reflection of his father since, just as she was groomed when she was 16, the Comedian raped her mother when he was also 16.

Now, when Alan Moore was writing those plots, was it REALLY NECESSARY FOR HIM to write Laurie (and her father, as I explained earlier) as 16 years old? I mean, wasn't it enough to write them as 18 years old and that's it?

Moreover, he wrote Laurie, a 16-year-old, feeling "horny" about someone way older than her. Seriously, I've been thinking about it a lot and I don't see what it adds to the plot that both characters were 16 years old/minors when that happened, it just gives me the creeps.

At first, I thought that maybe Moore wanted to portray a cautionary tale (as with his mother Sally being in love with the Comedian even though he raped and beat her. In fact, I also had a hard time understanding this, but thanks to this post and Gibbons' frame composition and Moore's writing about Sally's toxic relationship with the Comedian, I came to the conclusion that it was a cautionary tale) but, of course, that argument falls apart on its own because, if she hadn't been groomed by Dr. Manhattan, then she couldn't have convinced him and he wouldn't have “saved the world".

So I'll ask again: did Alan Moore REALLY have to portray both Laurie and Blake as 16 years old when that happened instead of 18 years old? What does it add to the plot?


r/Watchmen • • Oct 02 '22

TV [TV] You can see the problem, right? Spoiler

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/Watchmen • • Nov 19 '25

Are Watchmen, Euphoria and Dune connected? Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

In Euphoria, Rue has omnipotence after taking drugs. This is like Dune. In Dune, taking that water gives you blue eyes and omnipotence. Is it possible that Dr. Manhattan gives his life force into a water, and causes dune events? All three things mentioned have a show on hbo, so it’s possible. also, in the moon issue, Jon mentions Paul.


r/Watchmen • • Dec 26 '24

TV I’ve never read the book. But I really enjoy both Snyder’s movie and the HBO show. EILI5 What the books politics are and what its messaging is and why some say Snyder “missed the point”

0 Upvotes

I’ve always been interested in the Watchmen story. I love all of Alan Moore’s other work but I’ve never actually got around to reading Watchmen but I know how important it is by reputation

I love the adaptations of Watchmen. I think the story is VERY intriguing and I’m not able to get my hands on the book atm but I wanna learn more

I’d love if you guys could explain to me like I’m 5 what exactly the BOOK’S politics and messaging is vs the movie and how Snyder “missed the point”


r/Watchmen • • Feb 15 '22

Movie Watchmen Movie: Improvement to the Opening Scene

8 Upvotes

NOTE: THESE SUGGESTED ADDITIONS AND ALTERATIONS ARE EXCLUSIVELY TO THE VERY FIRST SCENE OF THE FILM TAKING PLACE IN EDWARD BLAKE'S APARTMENT, NOT TO OR IN REPLACEMENT OF THE OPENING CREDIT MOVING-MONTAGE SEQUENCE THAT COMES IMMEDIATELY AFTER IT.

Let me preface this by stating that I saw the Watchmen movie upon its release knowing little to nothing about the franchise, then proceeded to read the original collected series.

The film suffers from some issues, but the very first scene, while informative and a solid fight sequence, could have really been improved with a take that would have nicely serviced the strong beginning credit sequence which followed it as well as the rest of the film, while also adding what I see as a great motion-picture-specific element that recalls some of the unadaptable elements of the book. Here's a way I've re-envisioned it:

The Comedian is watching the news and gets sick of it and starts channel-surfing, just as before, and stops on the “Unforgettable” commercial. As he watches, something dawns on him. He digs through an old cardboard box in his closet and pulls out a film can labeled “Minute Men ‘40.” Cut to him back on his couch, a rolling film projector behind him. On the screen is a 40s-era black & white news reel; an upbeat puff piece-style featurette on each of the Minute Men, one by one, showing them posing, smiling, fighting dopey criminals in clearly staged battles, all to classic cheesy newsreel-style narration. As he watches, the Comedian starts chuckling. His laughter grows with each new team member featured, until they reach his section, which causes him to start roaring. Finally, Silk Spectre’s section appears, and he stops, captivated by memories of Sally Jupiter, staring at her as she waves and smiles at the camera. His gaze drops as he releases a deep sigh if regret. Suddenly, the door bursts open and the assailant enters. The Comedian snaps out of it and rises to defend himself as the reel moves into a new sequence of the Minute Men in action, the narrator saying something like “Now let’s see what these heroes can really do!” or something. Barring the occasional cut juxtaposing the real fight with the canned news reel fight, the Comedian and the assailant proceed in combat all while the news reel runs and we hear the narration, almost as if the newsman is narrating the fight in the apartment. Eventually, the assailant throws the Comedian across the room, coincidentally through the projector, destroying it and ending the news reel. The scene finishes as it always has, with the Comedian being thrown out the window.

When I saw Watchmen for the first time, while I enjoyed the world and appreciated the beginning credit sequence, as someone unfamiliar with the work, I was completely overloaded by the striking but unfortunately difficult-to-track slow-mo shots I was seeing, as I'm sure the rest of the unfamiliar viewing audience was feeling. I know upfront exposition (crawls, news anchors at a desk spewing information, etc.) to establish a complicated and detailed world is beyond cliche and tiresome, but it can be tough to get engaged when the whole prologue timeline is unloaded on us without any context, and then drop the setup on us anyway (as Hollis Mason does shortly after). After reading the book, I realized how we could get some upfront exposition as well as other establishing elements of the story fit for the visual medium of film, but in a natural way.

Between chapters 9 & 10, we're treated to a handful of articles, letters, and interviews regarding Sally, the first of which is a complete 30s faux-dishy gossip column about Silk Spectre. While the article appears in the credit sequence, after reading it in its entirety, I realized the motion picture equivalent of such an article, the classic upbeat propaganda puff piece newsreel, would be a perfect was to not just introduce and set up her, but many if not ALL the Minute Men. This successfully establishes many helpful things for the audience… First, who the Minute Men are and how the world viewed them at the time, as these squeaky clean golden age heroes out to save America. Now the audience actually knows who these heroes are as they watch the credit sequence. Foreshadowing narration could also add even more context to the credit sequence, like subtle tongue-&-cheek hints at Mothman’s mental instability or Silloutte’s homosexuality. The narration would also contrast nicely with the grittiness of the credit sequence as well as the rest of the film. Second, the Comedian’s roaring laughter establishes his “it’s all a big joke” philosophy quite nicely, as the newsreel does indeed appear as a nostalgic, archaic joke in those modern, cynical times. This contrast is further pushed with the newsreel narration over the real fight, both contrasting and synchronizing with it. Finally, the Comedian being captivated and depressed by the young image of Silk Spectre hints at their past relationship right from the get-go, but still leaves it ambiguous as to its nature and letting its revelations unfold naturally as it does through the story.

Thoughts? Anyone agree or disagree that this would have improved the film?


r/Watchmen • • Dec 08 '19

Movie It’s bout time that everyone accepted the FACT that the movie was trash 🗑 and that the show is a million times better. Not sorry. 🤷🏾‍♂️

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/Watchmen • • Oct 19 '22

TV Was the fact that Jeremy Irons character is Ozymandias intended to be a surprise???

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes