For five years, the Washington State Human Rights Commission treated Olympus Spa's women-only policy as a clear violation of state law. It found the Lynnwood spa in violation on the complaint of a patron the spa had no record of, then gave the Korean Christian family that runs it ten days to settle or face referral to the Attorney General for prosecution. When the family sued, the state fought them in federal district court and won dismissal. It fought them again at the Ninth Circuit and won, and it kept that win when the full court declined to rehear the case in March. At every stage, the state's position was that the law was clear and the spa had no case.
That confidence lasted until the spa asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take the case. The state requested two extensions on its response, now due December 4. On October 22, with Washington's Solicitor General, two deputy solicitors general, and three assistant attorneys general on the call, the commissioners spent nearly an hour in closed session being briefed on the litigation. They came back out and adopted, without objection, an emergency rule letting businesses where nudity is central restrict entry "based on genital characteristics." That is the policy the Commission spent five years punishing. Commissioner Han Tran gave the reason in one line: "We're making a narrow change to address pending litigation." The same motion directed the executive director to work with the Attorney General's office, which is defending the Commission at the Supreme Court, to file the rule effective immediately.
The Washington Law Against Discrimination reads the same today as it did in 2021. The only new fact is the prospect of nine justices ruling against the state. Worse, the rule contradicts the state's own victory. The Ninth Circuit majority, at the state's urging, held that the statute unambiguously bars entry rules based on a person's appearance and that the statute overrides the Commission's regulations. By that reasoning the Commission had no authority to adopt this rule. It is preparing to tell the Supreme Court the case is over, relying on a rule its own winning precedent says is invalid.
The emergency label does not hold up either. Washington law lets an agency skip public comment only when immediate action is necessary to protect public health, safety, or general welfare, and when the normal process would be contrary to the public interest. Press accounts say the motion invoked that standard. The meeting's draft minutes record only a motion to adopt the rule "as presented," passed with no discussion, and no commissioner identified any threat to the public. Nude spas have operated in Washington for decades. A Supreme Court filing deadline is a problem for the agency's lawyers, and the emergency statute says nothing about shielding agencies from review. Nobody with a stake in the question got a formal comment period, from patrons whose privacy or access the rule changes to the businesses that must enforce it. The rule lasts 120 days, about long enough to carry the state through the Court's review.
I would welcome this rule on its merits. The problem starts with the WLAD itself, whose definition of gender identity drove the Commission's original enforcement, and no emergency rule can override that statute. A lasting fix has to come from the Legislature or from the Supreme Court, and the Commission is working to keep the second from happening.
The Supreme Court has seen governments drop a policy mid-case to escape review, and it requires them to show the conduct cannot reasonably be expected to recur. In FBI v. Fikre in 2024, the justices unanimously refused to accept a change of position made during litigation as that proof. A temporary rule, adopted because of the lawsuit, contradicted by the state's own precedent, and useless against private discrimination suits should not satisfy it either. If the Commission now believes the spa was right, it should say so on the record and open the rule to public comment. Until it does, the justices should take the case.
Sources:
Just the News: https://justthenews.com/government/state-houses/washington-state-disavows-policy-allowing-naked-males-womens-spa-scotus
Draft minutes, Oct. 22, 2026 Commission meeting: https://www.hum.wa.gov/sites/default/files/public/meeting-minutes/minutes/REVISED%2010.22.2026_Commission%20Meeting%20Minutes_Draft.pdf
Ninth Circuit amended opinion: https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/us-9th-circuit/118226828.html
Supreme Court docket No. 26-286: https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/26-286.html