Let me preface this by saying that I am well aware this post will not be very popular with this community, I am well aware of how the majority of the subreddit feels about this topic, however, it's not going to stop me from explaining why I and many other good players think that airfield AAA in its current state is absolutely broken and easy to exploit. I was inspired to make this post when I saw so many people defending airfield campers in this post and also suggesting the airfield AAA is not strong enough
What Is Wrong With Airfield AAA?
The main issue with Airfield AAA is that there is 0 counterplay to someone who abuses it, there is absolutely nothing you can do to someone who decides they will sit there and camp it. Airfield AAA has an effective range of around 4km and the second you are in range you will instantly be annihilated with no way to mitigate the damage.
But How Do I Defend Myself When Landing?
It's very simple, if you for whatever reason need to return to your base to rearm or refuel you should fully accept the fact that you are going to be defenceless with no way to avoid incoming enemy attacks, it makes no sense that the airfield AAA should just hold your hand while you sit there and prolong the game, you gave up your right to a fair fight by landing. With that said, you can avoid being strafed by reading the state of the game and realizing when you can and cannot attempt a risk-free RTB.
Let's look at some scenarios where it's YOUR fault if you need to land.
"I ran out of ammo and needed to land." Your fault and you should manage your ammo better, in most planes it’s entirely possible to get 7-8 kills without ever having to rearm, if you find yourself needing to land in something like an F4U-4B, you are not managing your ammo well or you just clapped their entire team, in which case you’ve won.
"I ran out of fuel and needed to land." Once again, it is your fault for not managing your fuel well, even planes like the Me-163/Ki-200/Bi with very limited fuel can last for a very long time if they are piloted by someone who understands how to manage their fuel. The Ki-200 can last for 12 minutes with proper throttle management, so why are you struggling with your fuel load in a Sabre? That's right, it's because you picked the minimum fuel option for extra performance at the drawback of having very little air time. Your two options are to either pick more fuel or simply manage it better. Managing a reduced fuel load can be accomplished by pulling back on the throttle in non-critical moments or gaining altitude as the game automatically adjusts the fuel mixture the higher you go which drastically reduces consumption above 3-4km. With both of these strategies combined, you can easily double your flight time.
"I got hit badly and needed to repair my plane" This is a case of user error. There is always a misplay behind every instance of damage you receive(except that of AAA, be it mid map or airfield based.) There are going to be games where you as the player are on the back foot. But before you cop out and say “There’s nothing I could have done”, why not reflect on your own performance in that game. Were you properly positioned to utilize your aircraft’s strengths? If you were, did you hit your shots and get the impactful frags your team needed to reverse a losing situation? In all likelihood, the answer to one or both of these questions is no. Because if you had hit your shots and gotten impactful kills that meaningfully altered the flow of the game, you would be winning. All this is a very roundabout way of saying that you put yourself in a bad situation and you got punished for it. This happens to everyone. With that said, that does not make you entitled to a free repair for a second chance. To better illustrate my point, let's imagine that you’re having the game of your life. You are the hypothetical situation previously mentioned. Perfect positioning and immaculate aim. By all accounts you are having an excellent game. Unfortunately, the final player on the enemy team is spared when RNGesus decides to load your autocannons with a reduced explosive yield and he gets a running start towards his base. The enemy team has a ticket advantage from ground pounders early in the game that used their air spawn to get risk-free ticket bleed. You now have a decision to make. Do you:
A) Abandon the initiative and return to base for the ordinance which allows the other player to repair and rearm and gain an altitude advantage over you
OR
B) chase him down and try for a strafe?
The answer to this question will depend on what plane you’re in. Many planes within the Russian and Japanese fighter trees have little or no ground strike options which makes an RTB ill-advised. Their only possible play is to attempt to run down the crit player before they can rearm and spam J out waiting for the game to end. The crit player can use his airfield AAA as a shield and force you to try for a strafe. With no ground attack options and a ticket advantage that belongs to the enemy team, it does not matter if you have 11/12 air kills in the match because you WILL lose in this situation. You’re forced to take the initiative against someone you already outplayed only for them to have a near-guaranteed free win in the bag. If you apply this logic to any other game it simply does not make sense. If I get hit for 99% of my health in an FPS, do I deserve to be able to run back to my spawn and sit there in an armoured bunker with Gatling guns to defend myself? Would it be fair for me to say "Oh if I come out I am going to die so I am not going to do that"? The answer should be clear but the unfortunate reality of this game’s player base is that many players would rather have an overturned AI defence system win the game for them as opposed to learning from their misplays and in turn using that prior knowledge to outplay future opponents.
"I am in a bomber and I can't defend myself/My repair cost is too high and I don't want to pay it"
Who sat there in their hangar and decided to fly a plane with a high repair cost? You did, and the burden of paying that cost is on you. How is it any different from when you are in the air away from your airfield? Do you expect to not be shot down if you fly directly over the area where the enemy is climbing? The answer is no, so why is it that you think you are entitled to repair and rearm without being in danger? If you are in something like an Arado 234 B2 you are (I hope) very aware that you are completely defenceless from any smart pilot, but you are the one that sat there and decided to play the plane, you understood that you had no defensive/offensive armament when you clicked the "To Battle" button. The enemy shouldn't have to pay for the fact you are in a useless/off-meta plane.
Now that I have addressed some common reasons as to why people need to return to their airfield, here’s a much more specific look at a matchup between a player in the advantageous posture vs a player with ticket advantage and airfield AAA. You are in a Yak-9U, a plane with limited ammo and 0 ordinance options, you get 4 or 5 kills with your Yak and there is one guy left alive on the enemy team. They are in a P-47 that has ground pounded for the entire match and they are on their airfield rearming, the P-47 sees you coming and is aware that he will most likely be shot down if he leaves his airfield, so he sits there and refuses to take off no matter how much space you give him. He has the ticket advantage and you are in a Yak with no teammates left alive, how are you going to equalize that ticket advantage? You have no bombs, you have no rockets, and you have a very limited amount of ammo to try and strike pillboxes with. This means that you will get around 2 or 3 pillboxes before you have to rearm. If we pretend the P-47 has a 1000 ticket advantage you would have to make 3-5 trips to the airfield and back to be able to get 10 pillboxes. This is simply not reasonable and you shouldn't be expected to do anything but clear the skies from fighters in a Yak, you were not built as a ground strike aircraft and as such you can't deal with ground targets effectively. So let's say you either
A) Try to be the hero and you attempt to strafe the ground targets, the P-47 sees this and climbs above you and kills you and you lost a match you didn't deserve to lose.
B) Linger around the airfield hoping the P-47 takes off, of course, he doesn't and you decide to go for a suicide strafe to hopefully win the match, but there is a very funny thing that prevents you from being able to kill the P-47. The P-47 can J in and out on the airfield whenever they please, they see you coming and they J out to avoid dying, once you are far enough they spawn back in and repeat the whole thing again. Once again, you lose.
How is this fair? You were denied a victory despite having completed your objective as a fighter and you still lost to someone exploiting a very poorly implemented game mechanic. Not every map has enemy AI to stop the ticket bleed (And sometimes the AI just crashes at the beginning of the match leaving you at a huge ticket disadvantage) and not every map has trucks that spawn at the end of the match that allow you to neutralize the ticket advantage.
Now imagine you are an actual competent pilot and you decide to play props, this situation happens almost every single match, it is such a miserable and predictable ending every single time and many good Air RB pilots simply do not touch props for this reason. Now of course after some incessant whining and constant complaining, Airfield SAMs were implemented to jets and it has gone about as well as you would expect, now instead of having a 4km dome of death, there is an 8km dome of death in the form of missiles + the proxy SPAA that will light you up if you manage to make it past the SAMs.
Let's examine another scenario, this time you are chasing a P-47 and they feel like they are in a disadvantageous position and they immediately B-line their way to the airfield, the P-47 doesn't even attempt to try and land, they just circle their airfield until either you feel angry enough to get baited into the AAA or they just win on tickets. This poorly implemented mechanic is abused in almost every match and if you don't experience it you probably die too quickly to have to deal with it or you are the one doing it, in which case, fuck you rethink your actions :).
In no other game would this kind of gameplay be supported by many, the only reason it is supported so heavily in this game is because a large portion of this community engages in it with no shame.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To conclude, I am not saying that you shouldn't be able to land and repair, I am saying you shouldn't be entitled to any sort of hand-holding while you attempt to land. The game is asymmetric and not every single plane can deal with ground targets efficiently enough, there is no way you are going to kill light pillboxes in an efficient manner when you are in a ticket disadvantage in a Russian prop with no ordinance, at that point you just lose, especially if the enemy is running away or camping their airfield.
Airfield camping has driven away so many good pilots from actually playing Air RB because this kind of shit happens every single match. You should not be entitled to complete immunity while you try and land since landing mid-match is the result of a misplay. If you want to see this type of miserable gameplay in action, here is a video showcasing how easily it can be abused