r/WarriorCats • u/catbeweird • 3h ago
Discussion (No Spoiler) WARRIOR SQUIRRELS REVIEW (Sentinels) - Fairly Spoiler-Free
What's up Warriors reddit!!
So, for context, about a week and a half ago I posted a photo of a book that kind of described itself as "warriors... but squirrels," I got while picking up Renegades 2 at the book store. And for some reason, y'all absolutely LOVED it and wanted a review. So here we go!! I will try to keep this as brief and spoiler free as possible.
This goes out to the 11 people who asked me to write a review!
-----------
Sentinels: Guardians of the Forest.
Overview;
The book is set primarily in a forest following a world building structure very similar to Warriors. In this forest, there are 5 individual clans of squirrels who control territory, similar to the Warrior clans. So, going in, I expected it to be similar to the Warriors books, but was pleasantly surprised. Is it similar? Yes. But it also differentiates itself enough that it definitely feels like its own individual world rather than Warriors fanfic. If anything, it reminded me of a healthy blend between the lightly mystical fantasy elements of Redwall and the clan battles of Warriors. And battles there are APLENTY. The book is one big mix between slice-of life, world building, and fighting. And although it did feel a bit rushed at times, this is something I could easily see perfected in the sequel, which it very clearly sets up.
So, to start, we have a young squirrel runt amply named "rum" (haha...), a member of Sky Clan, who was never really taken seriously for his size and broken leg. (and that's one thing I must say. This book does equal parts good and bad with disabled rep.) Rum is a very special squirrel who has visions and an odd gutteral "call" he must release on occasion, which builds up and boils inside him. Some kind of message from their Forest-God he learns. On heading away from camp to let out this "call" one day, he bumps into our co-protatonist, a bulky grey squirrel with an oddly white tail, named "Nearly." Also an outcast, the two quickly bond and develop a kind of friends turned "PLEASE KISS" relationship as the story progresses. (haha... Nearly. Get it. Cause she's NEARLY a grey sq... YES THERE'S MORE OF THIS.) As a whole, rum functions more as a brains type character, while Nearly is the brave fighter type. But this doesn't stop Rum from the great moment of course.
Eventually, the two squirrels learn that they are special and have unique powers. Harkening Heavily back to the second Warriors arc, it also turns out there are 3 more of them! One from each squirrel clan. (Woah, how odd.) So they set off on a quest to find the other, and save the forest from impending disaster!! Yay! (...which Warriors-like, also happens to be a fire.) I cannot say much else for fear of spoilers, but we end of meeting "Flightless" the flightless flying squirrel, "Rat-Tail" the.... hairless tailed squirrel, and "Frazey" the uh... Victim. And then fun ensues!!!
So where do I go from here? Well, the story itself has a surprisingly predictable but good message of bravery and anyone being capable of being special. But at the same time, I don't know if it goes in-depth into each of the characters "disabilities" as I would expect. Nearly, for example, barely gets any exposee on how her white tail made her feel. But it isn't exactly bad rep either. Rum for example is perfectly capable and learns to find himself perfectly capable despite his disability as the story progresses, which is great development. However, when I say that most of his clan and family go from outright hating him and relentlessly bullying him to LOVING him as soon as he is revealed to be MAGICAL, I mean it. It's kind of comical.
As for the world, it is full of the kind of description I would want. The author really manages to paint a vivid picture of what is happening to the characters and the world around them, although I do wish she went a little further into detail. For example, this is a forest FULL of all kinds of animals. In fact, there are other prominent non-squirrel characters. It really feels lively. But I do wish a little more was done to MAKE that "live-ness" shine. If the author somehow sees this, that is the ONE THING i would love to see expanded. The depictions of this great big world she has painted. Sadly, I think it ends way too soon and by the end of the book, the main characters are already on to somewhere new.
Now, I could spend all day on this, but quite frankly I'm not very good a reviewer. So I"ll move on to the fun parts. The good, the bad, and the ugly!! (ha...ha).
THE GOOD:
**-**Rather interesting premise about a group of animals trying to save their world from impending disaster. Despite being slightly stereotypical, the journey there is surprisingly endearing, and despite having special powers, none of them are seemingly anything that gives them a PHYSICAL advantage.
-Light Fantasy Warriors or Redwall esque plot. Picture "dnd party off to save the world."
-EXCELLENT FIGHTS. God, the fights in this book were plentiful and had me gripped. I only wish they were expanded and we get to see Rum join in more next time. But watching Nearly bite the CRAP out of Badgers and the group come up with hit and run tactics on the spot was so cool.
-Big world that seems Warriors Adjacent, but more than capable of being its own thing. It really makes the squirrels seem larger than they are.
-The badgers are evil.
-Surprisingly engaging characters. For instance, Frazey was only recruited forwards the end of the book and I already want to know more about her.
-Well written in terms of word usage, to the extent that I could easily see an adult loving it.
-Surprisingly good story that has issues, but hooks you in and makes you want for more.
-Absolutely BEAUTIFUL illustrations throughout. Worth flipping through for them alone.
-Massive potential. I know it's a bit pretentious to put this here as the last point, but this book OOZED potential of a massive overarching series, and I truly hope to see it.
Now, the BAD. Keep in mind, being critical tends to produce what seems to be a lot more serious than it actually is. So don't let me stop you if the idea of magic warrior squirrels teaming up with other animals like bears and cougers excites you. I REALLY enjoyed the book.
THE BAD:
**-**The badgers are evil. Like comically evil. With little to no motivation other than "WELL ... MR. UNTRISTWORTHY... HE UH... HE TOLD US TO!!!" And thats its major weakness. You have no idea how quickly they end up 180-ing on their plans.
-Disability rep that seems lovingly executed, but god. THOSE NAMES!
-The main character seems to have all their home-problems solved the MOMENT he turns out to be some mythical hero. Like, he goes from "useless weakling" to "WE LOVE YOU" In a flick of the wrist.
-World that feels equally developed and underdeveloped, especially as they travel during the middle of the book. It feels like they could have squeezed in a 2 book arc at least at some points. Despite that, the opposite kinda feels true as well. It's odd. Hence being mentioned on both sides.
And now my biggest issue...
-Frazey.
God, Frazey. When I say TRIGGER WARNING for everything in the brackets, I mean it. Mild spoilers ahead:
(So, here's my issue with Frazey. She spends 80% of the book getting relentlessly, and honestly slightly graphically at times, physically and psychologically tortured. It might not be as bad as I make it out to be, but it was enough to be a little jarring, at least me. And by the end, all it does is make you feel really sorry for this poor squirrel and feel absolutely no remorse for the main villain whatsoever. Honestly, by the end, it felt rather good for him to just have a slightly uneventful end, because it felt like all of his characterization was CRUELTY and nothing more. POOR FRAZEY)
OVERALL:
Sentinels has its issues, sure. But it was a very fun read! if you are looking for something that feels warriors-like in style, but are burnt out and looking for something new, this is your book! It's not perfect, sure. But I CANNOT WAIT for the sequel and hope the world and characters are expanded.
Thanks for reading.
7.8/10


