r/WarCollege • • Jan 31 '25

Have modern militaries ever used magic?

0 Upvotes

There are volumes about magic being used for offensive purposes in antiquity.

And there there is also information about the CIA working with remote viewing, and astral protection, etc.

Has a modern or relatively modern state ever tried to use sorcery or magic or astral protection like the CIA was doing for military purposes?


r/WarCollege • • Feb 08 '25

Question How common or useful is dual wielding in real-life firefights with guns? What are the weapons that can or have been dual wielded?

1 Upvotes

r/WarCollege • • Dec 17 '24

why somany modern guns still use old school straight grip?

0 Upvotes

Straight grips are commonly used on blackpowder muskets and old bolt-action rifles. soldiers have to hold their wrists at an extremely uncomfortable angle when aiming and firing.

Yes, one benefit is that it makes it easier for soldiers to use them like spears when fighting with bayonets, but that seems to be the end.

even so, many modern firearms, especially civilian shotguns, still use straight grips.

Maybe it has some unique advantages that pistol grips don't have?


r/WarCollege • • Jan 03 '24

Why is it that infantry is the only type of unit which can get into cover and clear it.

0 Upvotes

For example a trench line, a building, a dense forrest. Why isn’t that other small units such as armed drones can’t do the job or at least be able to provide recon in such enviorments, to my knowledge the hornet microdrone should be able to get into such places and since they are so cheap once one runs out of battery you can send another And keep cycling them.


r/WarCollege • • Apr 29 '24

Question What's the current doctrine for fighting indigenous or uncontacted societies, if it exists?

0 Upvotes

I imagine a conventional battle would be no issue, if they can even organize that kind of resistance, but what about guerilla warfare and civil resistance? Is the plan extermination, assimilation, conflict resolution with settler groups? Are there plans to deal with disease or to take over local resources?


r/WarCollege • • Jul 30 '26

How did the German/British artillery design became so bad and Soviet Russian artillery design became so good after WW1?

0 Upvotes

Before 1918, Germany had the best artillery designers in the world in Krupp whose guns were massive success and upon entering the Great War their heavy piece such as the 100, 135, and 150mm dominated the French who lacked a decent response. Similarly, the British artillery park went from being outperformed by the Boers and had to repurpose naval artillery for land use in the Second Boer War to designing some excellent design such as the 18 lb, the 4.5 inches, the 6 inches, the 7.2 inches, and the 8 inches with famous brands like Vicker-Armstrong producing magnificent piece. Meanwhile, the Russian had no major artillery production and had to rely to inferior French companies such as Schneider to produce very lackluster pieces.

Fast forward 25 years later, and the table turned. Both Germany and Britain had to repurpose a lot of their WW1 guns with lackluster result and were unable to develop excellent artillery piece. For example, in the 100-130mm caliber range, the Soviet were able to develop the 122mm A-19 which outranged both the British 4.5 Inches and the German 10.5 cm Sk18/40 and delivered a much heavier shell at greater accuracy. At over 130mm, the Russian had the 152mm ML-20 that, again, could outrange both the German 150mm sFH 18 and the British BL 5.5 inches while firing a larger shell. In fact, many Soviet artillery pieces of the era such as the 100mm BS-3, 122mm M-30, 152mm D-1, and 152mm ML-20 were deemed competent enough to be used into the modern era, performing well against American artillery in Korea/Vietnam while British design of the era was quickly deemed obsolete and removed. And it wasn't because people were desperate: American guns of WW2 design (and Americans were also newcomers) proved effective enough to be used well into this day.

Given that both Germany and Britain had the industrial know-how with massive firms capable of producing excellent artillery pieces with proven combat track record and both nations invested heavily in weapons development in the 30s, why was it that they could not develop good artillery and let their lead in designs slip into the Russian and American hands?


r/WarCollege • • Jun 22 '25

Why does army no longer provide brothels for soldiers?

0 Upvotes

It's a matter of fact that you can hardly find a being who is more horny than a soldier, and provided with a hole - any hole - your average GI will stick his D in it. Army has realized this needs and prostitutes have been staple for army, with many military going so far as to set up dedicated brothels like the French BMC or the American RAA and later KMCW in the aftermath of WW2 and during the Korean war. The idea is to provide soldiers a way to relieve stress without a/getting STD and b/them committing rape and sour relations with locals.

And yet army gradually removes their military brothel system, the last of whom being the French who removed theirs in 2003. Why so? Why did army no longer run brothels?


r/WarCollege • • Jun 03 '24

Should tanks be ‘stealth’ the way fighters are ?

1 Upvotes

With optical, infrared, and radar sensors getting so good, plus precision guided missles, it seems nearly impossible for a tank to camouflage itself from an aerial adversary in the absence of either air supremacy or air defense. That’s my premise, but is that accurate? Some nations will be in a position where they don’t have either, yet don’t want the loss of all armored vehicles to be a fait accompli. So why hasn’t there been effort to design the tank version of an f35 for environments without air superiority/defense?


r/WarCollege • • Jul 14 '22

What makes Islamism attractive in Africa?

0 Upvotes

What makes Islamism attractive in Africa? Why is it so difficult to root out?


r/WarCollege • • Feb 14 '26

Question February 14, 2025 Drone strike on Chernobyl - can this considered a war crime/violation of the Geneva Convention?

0 Upvotes

I believe that we can talk about this now because it's over a year old now.

I'm not going to ask about Article 5 because the Feb 14th attack did not breach the tomb structure I believe.

Edit: or is it just war?


r/WarCollege • • Feb 01 '26

Did Israel attempt to win hearts and minds in Gaza and if so why did it fail?

10 Upvotes

From the outside looking in it looks like they just did search and destroy missions and did the bare minimum(if even that) to take care of the populace not even trying to win their support. I thought it would be common knowledge in militaries that clear, hold and build missions trying to win over the populace is way more effective than just trying to just kill the insurgents.


r/WarCollege • • Jan 08 '26

Question War of 1812

0 Upvotes

In honor of the anniversary of the Battle of New Orleans, I have a question regarding the War of 1812. Specifically, what factors led to the US somehow winning the war against Britain?


r/WarCollege • • Mar 12 '25

Question Why do aristocrats like member of the royal families join their nation’s national armies

0 Upvotes

Sometime these royals join in real battle. I am amazed since they could sit out of the war like a certain president in the new world.

What make them join the military?


r/WarCollege • • Aug 08 '24

Question Did USSR plan to attack first?

9 Upvotes

How credible are theories of Stalin planning to invade Western Europe, and Hitler forestalling him? And arguments like Soviet troops deployed in offensive formation, having million of paratroopers which doesn't make sense if you plan to defend, etc.


r/WarCollege • • Aug 01 '24

Question When does war become a rational decision?

0 Upvotes

War doesn’t quite make sense to me, I find it quite irrational. Going off to another country to literally kill and demolish them en masse over matters that are often rather boring bureaucratic things like land disputes.

It’s the equivalent of having a dispute over a fence with a neighbour and after heated discussions deciding to get a gun and spraying their house with bullets, setting their house of fire, etc. It’s just a frickin fence, yah it sucks but going to war with your neighbour is a disproportionate escalation that’s highly irrational.

Like a cartel running a protection racket, like yeah it sucks but it’s just the cost of business, just pay up and try live your life or move. It wouldn’t make sense to send your sons and nephews to go butcher the cartel and come back in body bags, just pay up.

Countries are far apart enough that it takes hours to reach from one to another, there’s so much land in between, what could they possibly do that affects you so much that you choose such a drastic option as war (savagely killing en masse). Spending private jet levels of money (as an analogy of personal consumption) to ship off young men thousands of km away to literally kill and burn and destroy.

None of it makes any sense to me. Especially when it is over things like trade or whose name is on a piece of land, etc.

So could someone explain what circumstances can war be a rational and proportionate response, a duty or compulsion to engage in? I’m talking about large scale wars, not counter terrorism.


r/WarCollege • • Dec 08 '24

Question Homoerotic trench love

0 Upvotes

I read some source on this sub that talked of British soldiers in ww1 having some kind of romantic love that didn't exist elsewhere in their culture. But I can't remember a source. Can anyone tell me what this is from?

I am also curious generally why this hasn't occurred elsewhere. WW1 was hell, yes, but not only ww1 and not only for the British. How widespread was this phenomenon that being trench buddies brings men to love?


r/WarCollege • • Aug 24 '24

Why does it seen like no countries other than Russia and Ukraine are procuring large numbers of FPV/Kamikaze drones for their armed forces?

1 Upvotes

FPV drones have proven to be a vital weapon to both sides in the Russo-Ukrainian war. However, it seems like no other countries are putting anywhere near as much effort into procuring these drones as Russia and Ukraine are. The countries which are doing something (e.g. US Replicator program) seem to be focusing on much more expensive kamikaze drones that will cost tens of thousands of dollars each, rather than the sub-$1000 COTS drones we see in Ukraine. Long-range drones like the Shahed-136 also don't seem to be being procured by very many countries despite their extensive use in Ukraine (and now against Israel).

Why exactly is this? These drones seem to be pretty much where airplanes or artillery were in WWI. Not investing in stockpiles of them seems like a huge missed opportunity. Are countries actually doing this and just not talking about it?

Thanks for any information.


r/WarCollege • • Aug 03 '22

How does Chinese military hardware compare to that os the US?

0 Upvotes

I have heard people say that high quality products can only be produced by the Chinese if there are quality controls put in place by American or other foreign companies. How true is this and how does this reflect in their military hardware?


r/WarCollege • • Jul 20 '24

Are there any military units above tier 1 units

8 Upvotes

My understanding is that the (expired) designation basically goes like this.

Tier 3 - regular infantry and regular soldiers

Tier 2 - special operations soldiers. Picked from the best tier 3 soldiers. In the US this would be green berets, 75th rangers, navy SEALs, marine recon

Tier 1 - the elite special operations soldiers. Perform counterterrorism, hostage rescue, targeted assassinations, etc. They are pulled from the ranks of the best tier 2 soldiers. DEVGRU pulls from the other navy SEAL teams. Delta force pulls from the 75th rangers and the green berets.

Are there any units above tier 1?

My impression is that by the time you are an expert in a tier 1 unit, you are about 40 years old. You need the health of a professional athlete to function as a tier 1 specialist. You may join the military at 20, spend a few years in regular infantry, then join a tier 2 unit and spend several years training and performing operations. By the time you join a tier 1 unit and complete the 1-2 years of training you are close to 30.

There are very few professional athletes who are 40 years old for a reason.

Having said that, I get the impression there is something akin to a level above tier 1.

CIA SAD/SAC and the intelligence Intelligence support activity (ISA). These groups perform very dangerous paramilitary missions and intelligence gathering operations. They may not have units on a higher tier than delta force or DEVGRU, but they like hand pick the very best operators across various classes of tier 1 units to perform missions.

The mission to kill Bin Laden. It is my understanding that there are roughly 200 members of DEVGRU, but when the assassination of Bin Laden was organized, they hand picked the best operators from all the different squadrons of DEVGRU. They didn't just send red squadron or gold squadron to perform the mission. They hand selected the most experienced and most talented members from across all the squadrons and formed them into a team of ~20. This would be another example of a unit above tier 1.

Another example would be intelligence gathering squadrons within tier one units.

Of the squadrons of DEVGRU, black squadron is the intelligence gathering squadron. In Delta force, it is G squadron. Supposedly these are the most elite members of DEVGRU and Delta force, and supposedly these are the ones who get pulled to work with the ISA. These are the ones that go undercover into very dangerous areas and perform intelligence gathering. I would not be surprised if DEVGRUs black squadron, Delta forces G squadron and the ISA are all inside the Gaza strip right now gathering intelligence to give to Israel's military and units like sayeret matkal so they can perform raids to kill Hamas militant and rescue hostages.

But as far as groups like the CIA SAD/SAC, do they hand pick the best members of assault squadrons of Delta and DEVGRU and organize them into teams to perform paramilitary missions?

My impression is that its not possible to have units above tier 1 because by the time you finish your career in tier 1 your body is broken down due to 20 years of military service and being middle aged at that point.

But the examples I listed above seem to provide situations where the best members of tier 1 units are hand selected to perform special missions, making them arguably groups who are more elite than tier 1.


r/WarCollege • • 28d ago

What's stopping Ukraine from copying Patriot?

10 Upvotes

Ukraine's big woe has been the lack of Patriot missiles. But Ukraine is a big country with a decent industrial and engineering base and an industrial-military complex that has progressed immensely and delivered some impressive innovations at scale. Meanwhile they have had access to the Patriot system for a long time. They would not even need to invent a whole lot, just copy it. Where is the catch?


r/WarCollege • • Oct 01 '24

Why did the US send ground troops into Vietnam despite knowing how tough the Korean War was?

9 Upvotes

Was it a case of sunk-cost fallacy by the US?


r/WarCollege • • Aug 06 '25

Did the British actually conquer India?

0 Upvotes

Did the British actually conquer India? Like in the same sense Genghis Khan conquered his empire. I'm not convinced the British actually held most of India but acted more like mercenaries to Indian princes who called themselves under the British crown.


r/WarCollege • • Aug 30 '24

why is US navy so good at PR comparing to other services?

0 Upvotes

ask any American on the street these questions, chances are answer is somewhere related to US department of Navy:

  1. most badass pilot? probably blue angel or marvick (for the less informed one)

  2. most badass special forces? of course navy seals

  3. most badass people fighting conventional land wars? USMC and many people with zero military knowledge know the whole "once a marine, always a marine" thing

  4. ship stuff, it's bread and butter so no argument here

5, even nukes, you see movies entirely about nuclear sub, but not much about land based silos or even strategic bombers.

is this something inherently cultural? Or do Army and air force just not care enough about PR and the myriad of benefits a good PR get?


r/WarCollege • • Oct 07 '24

The Russians and Chinese have a reputation for irresponsible or badly executed air interceptions, did the USSR have the same reputation?

1 Upvotes

The Russians and Chinese have a rather long history of dangerous and unprofessional conduct while intercepting western aircraft doing surveillance or freedom of navigation flights, occasionally resulting in collisions. Did the Soviet Union have a similar reputation?


r/WarCollege • • Sep 01 '23

Question Will super heavy tanks make a comeback?

5 Upvotes

The recent war in Ukraine suggests tanks are easily destroyed by ATGMs, mines and drones. This vulnerability is not due to technological or command issues because both Russian armored vehicles and western armored vehicles have suffered significant amounts of loses. To make matters worse, infantry can no longer support tanks effectively because ATGMs and drones are fired at kilometer ranges and at those ranges, infantry cannot do anything. Advanced anti-air measures also ensure that aircrafts cannot support tanks or destroy tanks reliably.

For tanks to remain viable, they must go heavier i.e, they must get heavy enough that they can easily take ATGMs, mines and drones. The beauty of this is that, since the tanks get super heavy, ATGMs, mines and drones are forced to be bigger, slower and heavier. Larger ATGMs means infantry will struggle with moving around the battlefield making them much less effective. Larger mines mean they can only cover a relatively smaller area and the bigger size means they will be much more easily demined. Currently used anti-tank drones are a headache because they are small and thus they are difficult to shoot down. If drones are forced to go bigger and heavier, it will be easier to take them down.

So, I would like to ask if we will see the comeback of super heavy tanks. If not, then why?