Superlative series! Spent maybe six hours a day reading it. Coulda done it faster if I didn't have a job/responsibilities. I stopped to read four other books and play Blood of the Dawnwalker, but otherwise, it was all Inn all the time.
Excited for another chapter on Saturday! May the series continue for another ten years, or until Paba gets tired of writing it.
Anyhow, thoughts.
The Good
Damn near everything. Paba nails a even mix of humor, mystery, tension, and weeping. Particularly big praise for all the worldbuilding exclamations. Ancestors! Dead gods! Tree rot! Eternal Throne!
Erin's a complete joy, of course—I even bought her plushie. Everything involving the witches is gold. Every Goblin and every Antinium is great. The Horns and Griffon Hunt and the Halfseekers. (Moore! T_T) Niers and his students. The Brothers! I hope we see more of Wilovan and Ratici with the forthcoming Rickel chapter. Normen and the Knights of Solstice. That one Drowned Folk song. The United Nations. Saliss! The Gnomes! Yelroan! The Agelum! Nawalishifra, who I hope we see more of. I was hoping she and Trey would become an item, but I guess not. Also, the Yoldenites! Can't wait to see them again.
And the villians are proper villians, too! Belavierr is terrifying, and so are the dead gods. Crelers! And Roshal—particularly big shoutout to that one Thatalocian chapter. It somehow doesn't seem like the current plot is heading toward another Summer Solstice event, but I kinda figure something will happen? Maybe?
Less good
The reader settings on the web reader. You can hide Apista, but I had to download uBlock Origin to block the little floating arrow she hides behind.
Volumes 8 and 10. This is purely because both have too little Erin. Now, Erin was dead for Volume 8, but that was OK because she came back. And then Volume 9 was a return to form...and now we're in Volume 10 and there's not enough Erin again. It was awful weird telling my only reader friend hey, check out this series, starring this great character you...see less of as the series progresses!.
Paba seems to find certain words and overuse them. For a while they used repast way too much. I was so happy when they quit. Right now it's screen as a synonym for block. Also, vouchsafe.
Some of the action scenes drag. Sometimes it's weird how many wounds nonwarriors can take and not die. But really, I'm thinking of the Strongest taking back Pomle when I say this.
Pisces doesn't talk fancy enough to get the amount of shit he gets for it. Like, he talks fancier than anyone else, but it's still not like...super fancy.
Flos is kinda boring. Everyone around Flos is compelling, but not Flos himself. Except when he broke that one Djinni slave spell, which was badass.
Ryoka kinda sucks. Erin's an even mix of levity and anxiety, but Ryoka's all anxiety, all the time. Like, Paba writes her well, but it's good writing that sucks to read.
Geneva's chapters started great, but weren't as good later. Medical drama? Great! Ken and Luan's brief stint as medics was top-tier. The later body-horror stuff...eh...not as compelling. Even if she got psyker powers out of it.
Bad
Later Mrsha and the Palace of Fates. It dragged and really soured me on Mrsha! PoF had some hype stuff like Arrema vs. Grimalkin and the Goblin King, but when Pawn stepped out from the dead-Erin future, I knew it'd result in a bunch of worlds opening and a bunch of people dying. Trillions dying is too much suffering! It's the only arc that made me stop and step away for like, two or three weeks.
Best parts/lines
The best string of text in the whole series is this one:
[Witches], you see, listened to thought and omen. They listened to the fates, and some wove threads, others looked into tea or the flights of birds. Some listened to the wind.
Especially when an [Emperor] told you that Erin Solstice was coming. That was a very useful trick [Witches] had picked up, listening to people.
Runner up is Pawn's monologue at Hectval.
Third is...I can't find the text for it, but the part where Mrsha excitedly shows Jelaqua a creler egg.