r/WWN • u/Any_Acanthaceae163 • 3d ago
Armour, Firearms, and the Armour Piercing Trait
I'm working on an industrial-fantasy setting, heavy on alchemy and steampunk elements and with an urban focus to start with. Something I keep going back and forth on is how I want armour and firearms to work...
The more I've looked into the history of bulletproof armour, the more obvious it's become that it's not actually THAT difficult to make armour that can stop a bullet - it's just really heavy. Thick layers of silk and cotton have been used for it, and if you put a thick enough armour plate on someone, they'll be fine. The tradeoff has always been mobility.
I started off wanting alchemically-derived bulletproof longcoats and maybe lighter vests or jackets to be an option (probably replacing the hauberk and the linothorax, respectively), but now I've gotten too deep into the weeds and I can't decide what armour options to make bulletproof and which ones to leave vulnerable. Great Armour should, by the sound of it, absolutely be bulletproof!
(There's also the mechanical question of whether I should make armour that bypasses Armour Piercing or if I should label armour as "Primitive", like other Without Number games... it feels a little strange if the armour is still contemporary!)
I really like the element of problem-solving that different armours having different strengths and weaknesses could introduce... heavy armour making someone dangerous in a close-up fight but leaving them vulnerable if you can pick them off from range, versus lighter bulletproof armours that make a shootout a risky proposal and encourage you to get in closer... it's a whole lot of extra work to decide what goes into what category or to write a whole new armour table, though.
Ultimately I'm left wondering if I should just strip the firearms of their Armour Piercing property and let armour apply as normal to them, or push through and figure out a modified or custom armour table.
(I've been looking at AWN and CWN for inspiration... I love the idea of CWN's ranged vs. melee values and the soak rules are interesting, but I think it's probably too much additional overhead for what I'm trying to do.)
Has anyone done something similar, and do you have any advice for the best way to handle it?

