Bray Wyatt (2017)
My choice. Bray finally winning the WWE Championship after years of failed attempts should have meant something. Instead, his reign revolved around Randy Orton, the Wyatt Family betrayal and the rather bizarre House of Horrors match. The idea of Orton infiltrating the Wyatt Family and eventually turning on Bray was interesting, but the execution was disappointing. The WrestleMania match was especially underwhelming, and having Bray lose the championship after just 49 days made the whole thing feel rather pointless. There was so much more that could have been done with him as champion.
2. Jinder Mahal (2017)
I think Jinder's reign is interesting because I don't necessarily blame the idea of pushing him as much as I blame the way WWE went about it. His sudden transformation from a lower-card wrestler into WWE Champion was obviously difficult to take seriously, but I was willing to see where they would go with it. The problem was that his entire championship run became heavily dependent on the Singh Brothers interfering in matches and Jinder constantly finding ways to escape defeat. The Randy Orton feud dragged on for far too long, and by the time they moved on to Shinsuke Nakamura, things didn't get much better. I also think the decision to have Jinder lose the championship to AJ Styles on a random episode of SmackDown says quite a lot about how WWE eventually viewed that championship run.
3. Kofi(2019)
The problem with Kofi's reign is that WWE never really capitalized on the momentum of his WrestleMania victory. The Kevin Owens feud was rather forgettable, while the Randy Orton rivalry had plenty of history to work with, especially considering their 2009 feud, but never quite delivered. His title defenses were decent, but there was very little that made his reign feel particularly special. And then there's the Brock Lesnar squash on SmackDown, which was a terrible way to end a six-month championship run.
4. Dean Ambrose(2016)
Considering the circumstances of his title win, I expected much more from Dean. All three Shield members had finally become world champions, and expected this reign to kick off Dean's top guy status. His AJ Styles feud was good, but the James Ellsworth storyline took far too much attention away from the championship. The Dolph Ziggler feud was hardly memorable either. Dean finally had the opportunity to establish himself as WWE's top guy, but his reign never really felt important enough.
5. Big E(2021)
Big E's 110-day reign never really found its footing. After the excitement of his Money in the Bank cash-in, things became rather uneventful. The Bobby Lashley feud was decent, but the subsequent stuff with Seth Rollins and Kevin Owens felt increasingly directionless. Even his Survivor Series match against Roman Reigns, which could have been a much bigger deal, didn't lead to anything particularly memorable. One thing I keep thinking about is how WWE could have used Kofi and Xavier during this period. Looking back at their eventual heel turn in 2024, I think there was an interesting story to tell in 2021. Instead, Big E lost the championship in the five-way match at Day 1, being pinned by Brock Lesnar, and went back to midcard before retiring.