r/whoop • • May 09 '25

Discussion Upvote this if you cancelled your Whoop subscription!

Post image
3.0k Upvotes

r/whoop • • May 08 '25

Media Whoopgate — The receipts

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/whoop • • May 12 '25 This Bravo Popcorn Bless Up I'll Drink to That

Discussion Thoughts on 5.0 Upgrade from Ben Foster, former Chief Product Officer at Whoop

1.9k Upvotes

I am the former CPO at Whoop (2020-2022). I'm writing this as an independent Whoop member -- one who has a lot of familiarity with the inner workings of Whoop from product features to pricing to business strategy. I have not spoken to any Whoop employees before posting this. They will be just as surprised to read this as you. Note that none of my commentary is in any way representative of or even endorsed by the company. This may not be what a lot of people want to hear, but I think the community should hear it anyway.

Whoop isn't the evil corporation a lot of people are claiming. The company was founded from a true vision and desire to improve human performance and that has now extended to healthspan, which I applaud. They care as much about helping each of you improve your health and fitness as much as they do about making money. I can personally attest to that, having sat in all the highest level executive meetings and product design reviews. However, in order to influence health and fitness long term, the company needs to be sustainable, and that means each subscription needs to be profitable. Keep in mind it's that profit which funds the next round of R&D investments so they can continue delivering app features and new hardware capabilities to you. No profit means no product improvements, and ultimately no Whoop.

If you were intending to pay for your Whoop subscription indefinitely and you continue to, then you will literally pay $0 more than you would have while getting upgraded form 4.0 to 5.0. That is the definition of free. Yes, just like a cell phone plan, you need to have a long enough COMMITMENT so that Whoop can upgrade your hardware while doing so profitably. For the 3.0 to 4.0 upgrade, that required a 6 month commitment (which I stated in an interview while referring to that hardware upgrade specifically). For 4.0 to 5.0 it seems the company is now asking for an incremental 12 month commitment instead, which is what has been required of new members for some time now. While it's a different length of time, the upgrade structure is consistent. I think there are two reasons 12 months is being required: (1) there are only annual subscriptions now, so other lengths of time don't make sense, and (2) the new bells and whistles of the (very positively reviewed) 5.0 aren't cheap to design, test or manufacture and Whoop does need to have assurance that they won't send a very expensive device out to people only to have them bag their subscription when it comes up for renewal. That simply doesn't make business sense.

If you're invested enough in the Whoop experience, as I am, to feel a lifelong commitment to your subscription, then extending the commitment length shouldn't matter. The only people for whom it matters are those who had an intention of canceling their subscription, anyway. Show me the company that proactively upgrades relatively expensive hardware for no incremental cost AND requires no increase in subscription commitment length. If they're in business, they won't be for long.

On top of this, the same subscription cost of $239/year they were paying for 4.0 now gets members Whoop Peak where they could have just offered Whoop One at that price point. If all you care about is the new hardware and not the new features of Peak, then you actually get to continue on Whoop for an even LOWER price than you've been paying before. That's better than free.

Now let's talk about Life/MG. These hardware and software capabilities are even more expensive to develop and manufacture and the only way to provide sustainably is to charge accordingly. You don't have to buy it, and if you don't you still get upgraded. But, if you think the premium features of Life/MG are worth a premium price, it's available. For anyone who thinks they should get that for free as well, consider that you're painting the company into a corner by giving them only two options: (a) provide this new hardware and operate at a loss, thus running the company into the ground eventually ending your Whoop subscription, or (b) have them constrain their innovation efforts by ignoring new opportunities to improve your health and fitness that require more expensive hardware. No one should want either of these outcomes (an unsustainable business or "upgrades" that are focused on cheap manufacturing costs over high-value features). With MG, the company is staying on the bleeding edge of innovation and simply providing options so that members can decide whether they want new upgraded 5.0 hardware (for $0 incremental cost) or they want INSANELY upgraded MG hardware that comes a premium price point.

Similarly, Whoop has offered that members can OPTIONALLY pay an upgrade fee if they are not willing to increase their commitment length. No one has to pay it, everyone can get 5.0 without paying any more per month than they ever had. Personally, I think it was a mistake for the company to even offer this because while optional, members just have an allergic reaction to combining the words "Whoop" and "upgrade" and "fee", even if it is purely optional. Regardless, it's there. If you don't like it, just ignore it.

Expecting Whoop to demonstrate their commitment to you by shipping you a very expensive device while being unwilling to demonstrate your commitment back in the form of extending your commitment length is unfair. Telling them they cannot innovate outside the bounds of your current subscription level is both unreasonable and self-sabotaging. Be careful what you wish for: projecting unreasonable expectations on Whoop the company will just come back to bite Whoop the community. A lot of great people at Whoop have been working tirelessly for years to innovate on members' behalf, to give them a new range of subscription options, and to keep subscription prices to a minimum. They'll continue to do so because they remain loyal to the mission to unlock human performance and now healthspan, too. But they need your support to do so.

I saw another post asking for upvotes from people who canceled their subscriptions in protest. I'd love to see upvotes on this post from people who love their Whoop, can appreciate the dynamics I explained, and look forward to continuing their subscription with their new hardware.


r/whoop • • Mar 27 '24

Discussion I worked harder than my wife giving birth.

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

r/whoop • • Jan 10 '21 Take My Silver

If you really want to increase HRV, let me show you how.

1.6k Upvotes

When someone asks how to increase HRV, I follow up with the question:

Why do you want to increase HRV?

The question is often ignored, but the few times it hasn’t been, I’ve received answers that usually revolve around the following two ideas:

  1. It’s suggestive of increased athleticism

  2. Because elite athletes have high HRVs

I’d like to dispel that immediately and suggest that neither of the two above scenarios are definitive. There is research that suggests high HRV is associated with some endurance athletes, but it’s very loosely correlated. I am going to propose that the idea that athletes have a higher HRV is due to how they manage their lifestyle and recovery, as opposed to their individual athleticism. I know of many well known athletes who publicize their Whoop data and their metrics aren’t as impressive as you might think.

I’d like to encourage you to think about Whoop differently. Instead of attempting to find quick ways to increase HRV, focus on building a consistent, narrow baseline with HRV and RHR metrics. What this means is getting your HRV reading between a 10-15% margin and RHR within 1-2 BPM. For example, if you have an baseline HRV of 100, work within the margin of 80-120 HRV. If you have a 40 RHR, work within 39-41 BPM.

In order to manipulate this physiological data within your control, we must first understand what HRV represents and how Whoop uses it.

Through the brilliant marketing team that is Whoop, they quote:

Heart rate variability, or HRV for short, is a measure of your autonomic nervous system that is widely considered one of the best objective metrics for physical fitness and determining your body’s readiness to perform.

This isn’t necessarily a false statement, because this statement is true for many athletes (or individuals with consistent baseline metrics), but it is not true for the majority of consumers, because the majority of consumers experience much “HRV noise” (you’ll know what this is after reading this) for it to be a reliable indicator of any physiological training adaptations or the ability to perform.

Beyond Whoop’s marketing jargon, HRV is the measurement of time intervals in between each heartbeat, and with this measurement provides us insights into our autonomic nervous system (ANS). There are two branches of our ANS: sympathetic and parasympathetic, and within the context of Whoop, it is a fairly reliable metric for determining the parasympathetic branch of our nervous system, and with the parasympathetic branch Whoop can derive some assumptions following the sympathetic activity.

Sympathetic activity has been popularized by the phrase “Fight or Flight" and parasympathetic activity has been popularized by the phrase “Rest and Digest”. What happens during sympathetic activity? Some common symptoms are elevated heart-rate, suppressed appetite, digestion is inhibited, blood rushes to our extremities, and we’re ready to roll. What happens during parasympathetic activity? Almost the opposite: Heart rate slows, digestion becomes stimulated, and blood begins to flow to our internals. Have you noticed the pattern in the journal yet?

  • Drank alcohol (sympathetic activity)

  • Breath work (parasympathetic activity

  • Caffeine (sympathetic activity)

  • Meditation (parasympathetic activity)

  • Stress (sympathetic activity)

  • Stretching (parasympathetic activity)

The journal attempts to associate your sympathetic or parasympathetic lifestyle behaviors with recovery, which as we know is heavily influenced by HRV. Why is this important to know? Who cares about this, right? It’s important because it’s a representation of how our nervous system manages stress, either from training, overeating, fasting, the grief from the death of someone close, and so on, and utilizing the knowledge of stress we expose ourselves to daily in conjunction with the data that Whoop provides can allow us to build correlations with your lifestyle and training.

As an example, if I’m dealing with a plethora of stress from work and inadequate nutrition and I happen to fail my squat PR, I could have very well still have gotten stronger, but the allostatic load was far too great from other lifestyle stressors that I may potentially be hindering my recovery from my squat resulting in poor recovery or never achieving homeostasis. This can result in depleted resources to recover, or manifest itself in a huge parasympathetic shift, swinging your recovery well above baseline in an attempt to divert all resources to recovery at the cost of supporting other unconcious functions of our body.

Let’s utilize our previous example of an individual and build a profile:

Jane

  • She’s a powerlifter

  • Baseline HRV of 100

  • Narrow baseline margin of 15%

  • She is Mrs. Consistent HRV and outperforms Mr. High HRV in nearly all activities

Joe

  • Strength athlete

  • Baseline HRV of 180

  • Wide baseline margin of 40%

  • Enjoys alcohol on the weekend with the bros, likes In-n-Out, brags about his 99% recovery score on Reddit (also his 1% after his night out with the bros), but doesn’t think Whoop is useful for him because HRV is too inconsistent and unreliable (is this you?)

They both attend the same gym and it’s deadlift day. Jane hits her deadlift PR, quietly texts her boyfriend in celebration, and moves onto accessory moves. Joe hits a huge PR, grunts loudly, and posts on instagram. They both celebrate with some post-training sushi and spend the rest of the day in recovery. The following morning Jane has a depressed HRV of 90 and Joe has an HRV around 160. Joe is really proud of his high HRV but since it was 140 the day before (due to having a wide baseline margin), he considers himself further recovered and thinks Whoop is useless for strength athletes. Jane, on the hand, is always around 100 following rest days and following her deadlift PR she noticed a drop in 10% HRV.

Jane can associate the drop in HRV as sympathetic activity associated with conditions in which her nervous system had to adapt due to PRing her deadlift. We call this “allostasis”, it is a condition in which our nervous system experiences an external stressor that triggers sympathetic activity, and her ability to manage allostasis (recovering successfully) by an implement of parasympathetic activities within her daily routine, which all contributed to her developing a narrow baseline.

Joe also experienced allostasis, but to which degree, he will never know and will never be able to correlate allostatic conditions with his ability to recover, and in turn Whoop will not be able to provide him with insightful data to reflect his training. Regardless of this, they were both able to overload successfully and regain homeostasis. They will both be stronger by the time they recover, but Jane will have data that she can use in future programming and training blocks and her recovery score will have meaning to her. She likes Whoop and just signed up for another year. Joe is waiting for his subscription to end so he can start counting his steps in Fitbit again.

Joe and Jane live their lifestyles very differently, but the reason why Joe wasn’t able to make correlations in training and recovery is due to a concept I briefly mentioned: HRV noise. Or, “lifestyle noise”. This is due to inconsistent lifestyle behavior, as a result of not understanding how HRV is affected.

Having a widely fluctuating HRV is indicative that the individual is having HRV noise. It’s the idea of exposing a variety of different stimuli and inconsistent times and forcing our nervous systems to react to it. You might think that eating that late night snack impaired your recovery because Whoop said so. In reality, resources were just diverted to manage digestion because of the late night snack, you may actually even be more recovered because of the snack, but you won’t be able to make this correlation because it’s not consistent.

Now here’s the meat of the guide. I am constantly playing with HRV. I’ve learned how to manipulate it at will, through lifestyle, and even a variety of training methodologies. As a “recreational strength athlete”, I’ve been able to manipulate and determine correlations just liike hypothetical Jane. Here is my HRV manipulation data this year:

/preview/pre/9dlbbol70ga61.png?width=1219&format=png&auto=webp&s=1787158e47d9f3bbf70d1ae5e03308288c89a67f

My baseline this week is 180 and averaging half of my week above 200.

This is a long-term suggestion. The majority of you won’t be able to implement all of this at once. I’m a single guy who deeply cares about my training, performance, health, and recovery. I have the time to devote myself to recovery and have often been called robotic in my lifestyle. I don’t know a lot about this subject, but I’m passionate about all things nutrition and training, and I believe I can offer some help.

Sleep:

Whoop puts an emphasis on sleep in an attempt to give you stronger recovery suggestions. Whoop is always bothering you about your sleep needs and sleep consistency. The truth is, Whoop is doing this because Whoop wants you to build a consistent circadian rhythm. A circadian rhythm is one of the most major contributors to developing a consistent baseline. When sleep consistency is built, merely going to sleep an hour later than you normally do can result in an impaired HRV.

The individual stats, such as Awake, Light, REM, and SWS don’t really matter all that much. The idea here is to introduce some consistency within your circadian rhythm and see how these metrics might react. If you get a 10% improvement in REM and SWS, that’s great. Does it mean you’re getting 50% REM and SWS like Whoop says? It definitely doesn’t, but it does tell you that your consistent habits are contributing to the overall objective of Whoop.

Nutrition:

Meal timing is important to managing your baseline as well. Find blocks of time in which you eat daily. Eating at consistent times helps regulate your appetite hormones and digestion, all which influences your parasympathetic nervous system, and because it influences your parasympathetic nervous system it will inevitably affect your HRV (remember, Whoop specifically attempts to measure parasympathetic activity).

Here’s an example of my eating windows, with no snacking in between:

  • Meal 1, 7:30 am

  • Meal 2: 12:00 pm

  • Meal 3: 3:30 pm

  • Meal 4: 6:00 pm

  • Meal 5: 8:00 pm

What are your performance goals? Weight loss goals? Weight gain goals? Caloric intake also greatly affects HRV. Our bodies love maintenance, and a caloric surplus and deficit are stressors the body has to manage and again can influence HRV. This is because resources will be diverted to support digestion in the event that you overate, thus showing an impaired HRV score, which affects the Recovery score. In reality, you might be recovered just fine.

How much does alcohol mean to you? If alcohol must be a regular practice in your lifestyle, I am sorry, but the effects of alcohol last way too long for HRV to be helpful for you. If you just drink once per week, by the time your HRV has recovered its baseline, it will be derailed once again. A few drinks can affect your HRV by up to five consecutive days.

Do you follow a fad diet? What are the implications of your diet?

Composition of food matters. HRV has a very close relationship with inflammation. If you eat high-inflammatory foods, you will definitely see this affect HRV. Do you eat foods with a high-thermic effect? Are you a vegetarian? Are there vital nutrients that you might be missing? What is your macronutrient ratio and how much protein do you eat? What is your protein:energy ratio? Building consistency around nutrition around your goals will contribute greatly to removing HRV noise.

Hydration:

Hydration should probably be individualized, but I wouldn’t overthink it. It will differ depending on gender, age, body weight, etc. Just aim for 3-4 liters of water per day and try to limit diuretics like soft drinks, coffee, stimulants, etc. Be weary of drinks like La Croix or other sparkling beverages that offer minimal or no hydration due to lack of electrolytes. Avoid sugary drinks, and if you want fruit juice, try eating actual fruit as it contains a fair bit of water and many salts.

Hydrate appropriately for your athletic endeavors, but don’t overhydrate. Pee color isn't the most reliable, but it can provide some suggestions on where you sit with hydration. Avoid dark and avoid clear. Light green/yellow is where you want to be.

Supplementation:

Be weary about supplementation that claims to boost your HRV or recovery scores by your fellow Redditors. Taking an anti-inflammatory can reduce inflammation and in turn increase HRV, giving you a very weak correlation to whatever stressors you experienced the day before. If you take NSAIDS because training is painful, hire a coach and dedicate six months to technique and form. Anti-inflammatories and pain meditation do not belong in a gym bag.

Use common sense when you utilize a supplement. If you need to take 3mg of Melatonin to sleep, why do you have to take a hormone that you are already capable of producing endogenously? If your circadian rhythm is wacky, melatonin may be used to help regulate it, but do you still need it once it’s regulated?

How do you feel the morning after you take 600mg of Magnesium? Are you groggy or ready to hit the ground running? Why do you need that much? Do you need to dial back?

If you have to take 4g of Glycine before bed to prevent blood sugar spikes, what does that tell you about your nutrition?

The goal here is to improve yourself, not get the best possible scores in Whoop. Think objectively when implementing your supplementation stack. Know what you are taking, why you are taking it, and how much.

Mindset:

The last thing I want to cover is mindset. Yup, yelling at your dog for barking at your kid-sister can affect your HRV, and if your dog is capable of stressing you out, you can also ensure that any training correlations will be weakened. Learn to manage life’s ups and downs, our perceptions contribute to the state of our ANS greatly.

We are our own enemy. We can’t really choose the outcome of every event in life that occurs, but we can choose to frame our mindset in light of those events. This is an important tool to hone that I do not have the credits to discuss, as I need to vastly improve my mindset as well.

In case this wasn’t all clear, removing HRV noise will increase your HRV. It isn’t that you weren’t capable of having that HRV before, it’s just that you’re managing your HRV so you can have clean data for Whoop to analyze. When you have a lifestyle that contributes to regulating many of the unconscious functions of our body and nervous system, you may be able to utilize Whoop for training. But if you cannot, do not be discouraged, as it can still expose other lifestyle stressors and give you an opportunity to improve in other areas of your life.

You may not be able to increase HRV. It could be genetic, or it might not even be worth the cost of lifestyle rigidity, the truth is that all of us have the ability to manage allostatic conditions, and in order to continue building this, we must continue exposing additional stressors to our nervous system. What’s that mean for an endurance athlete? Maybe reducing his 100-meter sprint by a second. What’s that mean for a strength athlete? That might mean throwing 5 lbs. on the bar every week. The data provided by Whoop will never be definitive, but it can suggest many things, and the more consistent you are with your lifestyle, those suggestions can become very strong correlations enough to influence training decisions.

tldr:

  • Focus on building a consistent baseline, not a higher HRV

  • A higher HRV will come as the result of reducing HRV noise to build a consistent baseline

  • Use Whoop to help build that baseline, by implementing circadian rhythm, introducing parasympathetic activity, and developing a recovery routine

  • This isn't easy. If you think this will take a few weeks to implement, you're not right. If you are starting at zero, it can take months to years to get to Whoop's level.

  • Don't be like Joe; Be like Jane.

The big writing between-the-lines in this essay is to focus on building a consistent baseline, not focus on a higher HRV score. I hope I’ve partly convinced some of you.

--

EDIT: THANK YOU ALL FOR THE SHINEY MEDALS!


r/whoop • • Feb 26 '24

Ordered replacement 4.0 unit, received someone’s personalized engraving

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

I’m so glad Dr Maryam is loved, but what’s going in with customer service and order fulfillment at Whoop?

Are replacement units refurbs or is this just a random mistake?


r/whoop • • May 08 '25 Helpful Bless Up

Discussion This MG thing feels like such a slap in the face as a user for the last 4 years.

1.3k Upvotes

The standard 5.0 appears to be the same except a better battery and now it'll have a feature like Garmin where it tells you your fitness age compared to your real age. But for $120 more a year, we can access the actual 5.0, the mg. 🙄 What is the point of this subscription based model if you don't get to reap the benefits of the new devices. I've dumped so much money into this company and this is what we get in return? They're pissing down our backs and telling us it's raining.

I couldn't roll my eyes harder about this. This is likely going to be what pushes me to cancel my membership. Happy 5.0 day!

Edit: Seeing a lot of people feel the same as I do. We should review bomb them on Google.

Edit #2: I cancelled my membership and ordered a Garmin.


r/whoop • • May 08 '25 Bless Up Helpful

Discussion What the hell WHOOP?

1.1k Upvotes

So the 5.0 is up for pre-order now and… what the hell?

I’ve been a big fan of Whoop for a while. Yeah, it was always on the expensive side, but things like the free hardware upgrades and the screenless design with all the features made it feel worth it.

But ??? All the new features are locked behind a yearly price tag that’s basically the cost of an Apple Watch? For what—an ECG that might be accurate?

Maybe it’s just me, but this feels like a turning point—and not in a good way. As much as I love the brand and the concept, this pricing model just doesn’t sit right with me anymore.

Edit: Glad to see I’m not the only one feeling this way. If we can collectively give Whoop this kind of feedback, maybe there’s a chance they’ll reconsider. After all, we’re all here because we do like the idea behind Whoop!


r/whoop • • Apr 23 '26 Bravo

Personal Achievement 1 Year Life Transformation

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

Well, here’s to hoping WHOOP might be the one subreddit that doesn’t ban me for supposed steroid use…. I just want to share this somewhere as this is a very meaningful day for me. Anyway, here goes:

365 days ago to the day, I looked in the mirror and hated who I saw. I made a promise to myself to change.

I did not believe I could come back from all the damage I had done to myself. But continuing down the road I was on was slowly killing me.

I wanted to become someone I could be proud of. I wanted to become strong. I wanted to be able to live a long life. And I wanted to become healthy enough to capitalize on any opportunities that life might bring my way.

I didn’t want to blink and wind up on my death bed, realizing that I had never truly lived. I finally saw that there are no do-overs. I finally accepted that life is not a joke.

April 23 will be the day I celebrate for the rest of my life as the moment where I became an adult. It will forever mark the day where I started treating my life and my potential with the respect it deserved.

This post is not intended to be a victory lap, or to preach, but rather, to serve as a reminder to myself and anyone else, that you can accomplish absolutely anything you set your mind to. If there’s something you’ve been wanting to do in your career, in your relationships, or in your personal life, take the first step today. It will be hard, but it will also be worth it. I wholeheartedly believe we can achieve all our dreams in this life as long as we stay consistent, patient, and disciplined. We are all capable of greatness.

Pursue goals that challenge and scare you. Fail or succeed - try again, and again, and again. Never give up. And watch who you become.

I am grateful to everyone in my life who supported me through this metamorphosis ❤️ Here’s to another year! 🍻

#NeverAFinishedProduct #DoItHard #Again #KeepTrying #NoGoingBack #DareToDream

Edit: Thank you so much for the positive comments. Some of you are really awesome for what you’ve said. I hope everyone can have a fantastic rest of 2026 and a very happy life!

Edit 2: For those who want more detail. This is a 30 page fitness plan with full logic I wrote for a friend. It’s geared towards someone who wants to build muscle but also maximize cardio adaptations - I.e. hybrid athlete. But the concepts can apply to any goal if properly understood - https://smallpdf.com/file#s=252b4dec-d358-4e54-9af2-1988d30b288c


r/whoop • • May 30 '26 Diamonds are Forever Bravo Mindblown Popcorn

Discussion I reverse-engineered my WHOOP 4.0, rebuilt the whole app + backend in a weekend, and open-sourced it

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

For context - I had the WHOOP 4.0 about two years ago, I did the subscription for a year and overall really liked the product. I was impressed by the hardware, the clean look and the always-on charging. Didn't like the subscription aspect - and also didn't like that the data visibility was limited - I couldn't just see raw metrics the device was putting out. After looking into breaking out of the subscription for my Eight Sleep Pod, I dug into my drawer and found the WHOOP strap.

Last weekend I used Opus 4.7 to fully reverse engineer the BLE protocol the WHOOP 4.0 band uses, as well as create an app for surfacing the data it produces, and a server for backup / storage and for running analysis. Decoding built on prior work, which I've linked in the repo - I extended these projects with the full BLE command set, a hardened strap->phone->server sync, a native iOS app, and a server with storage and analysis. There's some fine tuning to be done - the algorithms are approximations - but for now I have a fully functioning WHOOP strap with no subscription - and the data, processing pipeline, and UI elements are all my own.

I saw the Fitbit Air was coming out about half a day into this, and I thought at first this was kind of trivial because that product has a base tier that has no subscription - but by fully owning the data flow with this work, I'm not locked into using the app, Google doesn't have my biometric data, and I can tweak the app / data pipeline however I want.

That was a big unlock I noticed after implementing this - if I want a new view, a new derived metric, I can just have Claude running on my machine at home, with access to the server and to build scripts and it can make those changes - imagine I'm doing a workout and ask it to add to the app the ability to see strain vs. sleep time, something like that. Within a managed ecosystem, that's behind feature requests, bug reports, etc. By owning the stack, I can make those modifications independently.

I have a technical background, but the time and effort it took to do this makes me think we will see these companies fall out of this app-reliant subscription model. I think owning your own data, your own app, and your own stack is going to become the norm pretty quick.

Repo - https://github.com/johnmiddleton12/my-whoop


r/whoop • • May 09 '25

Discussion BLOOMBERG NEWS - WHOOP FACES BACKLASH!!!!

1.1k Upvotes

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-05-09/whoop-faces-backlash-after-charging-existing-users-upgrade-fee-for-new-models

It’s official — Whoop is trending for all the wrong reasons. Major outlets like Bloomberg are reporting how the company is facing backlash after charging loyal users an upgrade fee for the new models, despite their previous public promise to offer free hardware upgrades for members of 6+ months.

They literally had a blog post (now deleted) saying, “members receive the next-generation device for free…” and that “new and regular updates would come without requiring a new device.” Now with the Whoop 5.0 and MG, they’re asking us to extend our subscription or pay $49 just to access new features like ECG and better sleep tracking.

It’s frustrating to see a company build trust with promises — then backpedal as soon as it suits them. I’ve been a supporter of Whoop for a while, but this move feels like a straight-up cash grab.

Anyone else feeling burned by this?


r/whoop • • May 08 '26 Bravo Popcorn

Discussion For those wondering about the size difference between WHOOP and Fitbit Air

Post image
925 Upvotes

r/whoop • • Nov 08 '24 Bravo Bravo Take My Silver

WHOOP + Huel changed my life

859 Upvotes

After 2 years I am NOT leaving WHOOP. In contrast to the neverending stream of negative comments, I will be keeping mine.

All my adult life I wanted to be on a before->after poster.

I knew I had it in me, but it took years to actually get sht together and just do it.

I started my own healthspan (or longevity) mini protocol in August 2023, following a simple habit building framework. There were 3 rules:

  • Small but continuous changes for the better

    • Just 1.4% improvement every week leads to >100% improvement year over year

  • No more than two failed days (habit non-completion) in a row (duolingo streak freeze style).

  • Keeping >80% habit adherence over 30 day rolling period

My goals for healthspan improvement:

  1. Total body fat <17%

  2. Fat Free Mass (FFM) >85%

  3. Metabolic age well below calendar age

  4. All blood markers in green zones

  5. Look good / feel good

The Daily Protocol:

  1. Calorie restricted, healthy diet - deficit ~200kcal/day (2000kcal total)

    1. Breakfast - Huel Black- 400 kcal

    2. Lunch - Huel pot - 400 kcal

    3. Snack Fruit - 180-200 kcal

    4. Early dinner - Huel Black - 400 kcal

    5. Supper - Varied highly nutritional food - ~600 kcal (ie. Every foods)

  2. 1.5g of proteins per kg of target body mass (~110g for me)

    1. Breakfast - Huel Black for breakfast - 40 g

    2. Lunch - Huel meal for lunch - 20 g

    3. Early dinner- Huel Black - 40 g

    4. Supper - Varied highly nutritional food - ~20 g

  3. Activity and exercise

    1. Increase by 2% every week until >11 WHOOP strain avg then keep stable

  4. No more than two consecutive failed days

Tech stack:

  • WHOOP

  • Huel

  • fitIQ (added much later in the year)

Was it all thanks to WHOOP - no. Was it all thanks to Huel - no. Was it easy - also no.

But, it worked for me, and that is what counts.

My overnight success over the last year:

Achieved everything that I wanted.

I have now reached a stage, where exercies and movement is a default for me. If I skip gym or running, I feel physically uncomfortable. A reverse to what I felt starting out.

Increased 90d average Strain to >13 from <8. On WHOOP’s logarithmic scale this means around 2.5x increase in effort.

My body composition is fantastic. Metabolic age estimated at 20 (15 years under calendar age).

My cholesterol is finally in the green zone -> haven't gotten yet to transcribe the results to a table.

And I finally got my before/after:

What next:

I am continuing my routine, with avg strain >13 at the moment and keeping >10 strain streak for the last 3 months.

With my transformation, I wanted to get involved in the healthy habit forming movement. I have now joined Nick (@paynedigital) at fitIQ.io - Advanced Analytics for WHOOP, for datafreaks like us.

Stay tuned for my 100 day 10+ strain update.

I will be keeping my WHOOP :) Is WHOOP ideal? No, but it works for me.


r/whoop • • Nov 25 '25 WOW Hooray Bravo

Whoop Age Just wanted to share my little victory

Post image
826 Upvotes

Still have a very long ways to go in terms of health. And I don’t know how much the whoop age really means anything but it’s nice to know I’m making good improvements. My VO2 max when I first got my whoop was 15, now it’s 38 and still working on improving.


r/whoop • • May 19 '25

Advice Alcohol is literally Poison

Post image
793 Upvotes

On Friday I drank 3 Beers. My recovery dropped to 7%. Completely killed me. I needed two days to get to a green level again. I'm a male 21 years about 80kg and 1,88m tall. I rarely drink so. I think it's understandable why my recovery dropped so low. But this is crazy wasted an entire weekend of rest


r/whoop • • May 28 '25

Other You asked for it – so I made it happen. The Whoop 4.0 Band to 5.0 Device Adapter is now available!

Post image
787 Upvotes

I was honestly blown away by the response to my Reddit post about the 3D printed adapter that lets you use your Whoop 4.0 bands on the new 5.0 device.

Since then, I’ve improved the design for more durability and produced a small batch to make it available to everyone. The price is intentionally low – with this adapter, you can save two old bands and avoid spending at least 2 × $39 on new ones. A 2-pack is just €10.49. I don’t want to rip anyone off, I just want to help everyone keeping their Bands, they paid 50$ for…

What the adapter offers:

  • Seamlessly fits Whoop 4.0 bands on your Whoop 5.0 device

  • Available in black, light gray, toxic green, navy blue, and red (black looks the best)

  • Full compatibility with Whoop’s charging system

  • Made with durable PETG, UV- and water-resistant

  • 3D printed: the connectors are highly accurate, the top of the buckle has a clean finish, while the underside and sides show typical minor 3D-printing imperfections. I recommend applying very minor pressure while inserting the band.

Let me know what you think – and thanks to everyone who asked for this and supported the project!


r/whoop • • Oct 11 '26

Question - Answered! Whoop users when they discover alcohol is bad for their health

Post image
769 Upvotes

r/whoop • • May 25 '23

I did it. I beat Whoop.

Post image
750 Upvotes

r/whoop • • Jul 31 '25

Discussion HRV improved (almost 3x), much lower RHR. Some important changes in lifestyle.

Thumbnail
gallery
729 Upvotes

First of all, I want to say I decided to try whoop back in 2024 to improve my sleep, then I ended up changing my lifestyle completely.

I was not starting from a good place. M38, depressed and obese (125kg x 180cm), sedentary, high alcool consumption. Had my lowest point in February 2025, then I decided to actively do something for my health, at least to try.

First step was in march/april, when I reduced a lot my alcool intake. Started eating better, more fiber, less saturated fats, no processed foods. Started doing some very low intensity cardio, zone 1, it was already a lot for me.

In May I had a complete visit to a cardiologist, bloodworks, some other check ups to check my health status before doing anything. I had the OK to start exercising at higher intensity, some directions on what to do.. and started losing weight.

In June, you can see a big "leap" in improvements, both rhr and hrv (VO2max in a lesser way). That is exactly when I decided to stop alcool almost completely. Lost a lot of weight. Excercised 4 days/week, at a higher intensity (not much, zone 2, but still a big improvement for me).

As of today, I lost 17kg. Now i am 108kg (started at 125). My highest registered HRV is 116, my lowest registered RHR is 46. VO2max is 33 (started at 29, in february).

I am still obese, I still have a lot to do. I plan to slowly increase my activity, still going for cardio for now at least until I go below 100kg. Planning to increase intensity, and over time try to stay in zone 2-3. Then to add some strenght excercises, to reinforce my muscles maybe. Then idk, advices are appreciated!

I want to improve my vo2max, but I guess it is too early, I should be happy of the little and slow improvements I already had maybe. But as I said, advices are welcome!

Wanted to share this "journey" (or at least, the START of this journey, still a lot to do) because I had a terrible moment in my life where depression was hitting hard and moving me to self destructing behaviours. It is so easy to go down, unfortunately. Maybe this can help other people who are struggling. I am still not ok, but I hope I am in the right direction at least. Whoop made me more aware of what I was doing to my body. I don't want to be an athlete, I just want to be healthy, at least healtier than now. I hope I can succeed.

Be safe everyone, be happy, and be healthy. Love you all.


r/whoop • • Jul 24 '26

Discussion I ate an entire Costco supreme pizza before bed

Post image
728 Upvotes

What’s a weird thing you thought would have gave you a low recovery but didn’t? Honestly I feel great today


r/whoop • • May 12 '25

Other Healthspan - aint pretty

Post image
719 Upvotes

Not sure what I was expecting when I tried out Whoop Healthspan, but it definitely gave me a wake-up call. Turns out sitting at a desk all day and grinding CoD into the early hours doesn’t exactly scream "peak health." Time to rethink a few habits and figure out how to be a bit more active.


r/whoop • • May 08 '26 Bravo

Advice For Others Whoop screwed us a year ago. Fitbit Air just launched. I'm out this month.

695 Upvotes

Quick reminder for anyone who forgot.

Last May, when the 5.0 came out, Whoop quietly deleted the blog post that promised free upgrades for existing members. The exact thing most of us signed up for. Then they tried to charge us $49 to upgrade, slapped on a bunch of new pricing tiers, and locked the good features behind the expensive one. They only backed off after Reddit and Bloomberg dragged them for it, and even then only for people with a year+ left on their sub. The rest of us got nothing.

Now Google's Fitbit Air is here. 100 bucks, no subscription, does basically everything Whoop does. My sub ends this month and I'm not renewing.


r/whoop • • May 10 '25

Discussion It was in the FAQ too

Post image
682 Upvotes

The promise of free upgrades wasn’t just in that blog post - it was in the FAQ too. Not only that but the wording in the FAQ was even stronger. How is the MG not the “latest and greatest technology”? According to this, we should get it for free, full stop. This is an incredible bait and switch.

Source: https://web.archive.org/web/20250321095745/https://www.whoop.com/us/en/thelocker/your-top-questions-answered/


r/whoop • • May 24 '25

Other I built a 4.0 Band to 5.0 Device Adapter – because WHOOP’s greed pushed me to

Post image
680 Upvotes

I’ve been a loyal WHOOP user for a while now, but the switch from 4.0 to 5.0 really rubbed me the wrong way.

First, finding out that the 5.0 is a paid upgrade was already disappointing. But when I discovered that none of my 4.0 bands fit the 5.0 device? I nearly lost it. It’s the kind of needlessly greedy, user-hostile move that just feels like a cash grab.

What really pushed me over the edge was holding the 5.0 in my hand for the first time and realizing that the incompatibility is purely due to tiny design changes — we’re talking millimeters here. It’s clearly intentional. That was the moment I decided: screw this, I’m making an adapter.

So, I started working on a 4.0 band to 5.0 device adapter — and after a whole bunch of failed prototypes, I finally got one that works.

Right now it’s a 3D printing project, so it’s far from perfect and still a bit rough around the edges. But it works — and that’s the whole point. With just a few smart adjustments (a guiding rail in the design being the key), the 5.0 can be made to accept 4.0 bands with no functional downside.

The kicker? During the design process, I got even more frustrated. The differences between the 4.0 and 5.0 aren’t technological necessities — they’re deliberate obstacles. WHOOP redesigned things by mere millimeters just to lock us out of using old accessories.

I’d love to make a version out of metal like WHOOP’s official bands, but I only have experience with 3D printing. If anyone knows how to take a design like this and turn it into something more durable, I’d really appreciate the advice.