r/WELS • • Apr 29 '25

Does anyone else feel that WELS is "Mid"?

5 Upvotes

Observation I've been having recently from an ELS perspective after attending about 20 WELS churches in my greater area. I'm of the opinion after being exposed to various WELS churches that the synod doesn't do anything great. It's just okay.

"Traditional" Worship

You're a traditional WELS church if your pastor wears robes and an organ is your primary instrument. You probably have a projector. You certainly have individual cups. You may even only have individual cups, and the idea of recommending a chalice is being heterodox. Most people probably kneel to receive. There's no adoration, and communion is offered twice a week most likely. It would be weird not to receive the host in the hand. Members look at you funny when you cross yourself, and bringing up the idea of confession gets you accused of being "too Catholic". You probably use the blue hymnal and don't think about it when you realize the psalms in that hymnal changes the actual biblical text to be more inclusive.

"Contemporary" Worship

You're a contemporary WELS church if your pastor doesn't wear robes and anything but the organ is your primary instrument. You certainly have a projector. You very likely only have individual cups, and probably don't know what a chalice is. Communion is probably once a month, but could be every other week. You don't know what adoration is, and you probably don't kneel when you receive. You've never heard of not receiving the host in your hand. You've never seen anyone cross themselves other than your pastor, and you don't know what private confession is. You've never seen a red hymnal before, and you didn't realize the blue hymnal changes the actual biblical text until you read the above paragraph.

In my quest to find a WELS church to attend I've pretty much failed at this point. It's been a disappointing journey that ultimately has led me to question why we're in fellowship with WELS. I've seen so many WELS connections at this point I find myself humming the tune, and I've just come to accept the WELS for what it is.

The WELS is bland Lutheranism that doesn't go anywhere beyond what would you expect from American protestantism. It's mid. You're not going to see actual traditional Worship, and you're not going to see full blown contemporary worship. It's reigned in by a liturgy that won't embrace traditional or contemporary worship in an attempt to make everyone happy.

Legitimate criticisms I can't get over:

The Blue hymnal is an atrocious book. Besides the intro of it proclaiming a hymnal for the "modern" world, I don't understand how the WELS justifies that book. You can see for yourself if you're curious. Just turn to Psalm 1 and compare it to the actual biblical text. The red one is cool though.

Clergy not vesting. What's up with this? Do you really not care about your office, your priestly office, that you can't be bothered to wear the garb? If you don't care about your called work, I can't be bothered to take you seriously, and if you want to wear a suit, you can sit in the pews.

The massive over reliance on the individual cup. It's ridiculous. Especially when you consider the actual words of the institution it's crazy to me that you can't be bothered to at least have a chalice. Nevermind the actual sacrilege that presents itself from the blood not being used in each of those cups, it just feels like you're fine disregarding scripture and tradition to appease misled people that would refrain from a chalice. Because drinking Christ's literal blood communally is gross or something? You might get sick? The God you have faith in will make you sick or something I don't know

Communion is never weekly. Nobody can give you a good reason as to why it isn't. It's always "we've always done it this way" or "it's less special weekly". Because human tradition trumps what our Catechism says about it, or we shouldn't do a sermon weekly because it's less special? I don't know. It feels dumb.

Projectors are lazy and it makes singing hymns worse because most people can't sing without seeing the melody. Your churches are also uglier for it.

What I actually like about the WELS

They don't practice female roles such as voting, and seem to be very strong in understanding of creation. I can confidently say that when the rest of American Lutheranism inevitably upholds female ordination, the WELS will probably never embrace it.

The WELS for better or for worse, time will tell, really prioritize education. They've done a phenomenal job with primary and secondary schooling and I don't doubt I'll send my children if one is nearby. I am noticing they often over extend this though so we'll see how successful it is.

Honestly that's about it. I can't point to much more that I actually enjoy about the WELS. If you read this far than thanks I guess? Thanks for coming to my Ted Talk

Lex orandi, lex credendi


r/WELS • • Sep 18 '25

Guys...we are NOT in fellowship with LCMS.

6 Upvotes

When I join a WELS online community, I expect it to be WELS. LCMS already has their own online communities; they don't need to be policing ours.

Sadly, it's increasingly difficult to find online communities where WELS and LCMS are not mixed together. This creates a false impression that we're in deep fellowship with one another, and some online LCMS posters even have mod authority over WELS believers in WELS communities.

This is absurd.

We. Are. NOT. In. Fellowship. With. LCMS.

There are a host of reasons why I'm not in the LCMS. One is leadership. Mark Schroeder is EXCELLENT about avoiding the culture wars plaguing most theologically conservative denominations today. Matthew Harrison is not. I'm not subject to Matthew Harrison's opinions on political figures. He's not the president of the synod I'm in.

And contrary to certain LCMS online caricatures, it's not that we don't believe there aren't Christians outside of our synod. Of course there are. But we're much more consistent about identifying who is properly Lutheran and who isn't, and more yet, we can be consistent about applying that standard to both laypeople and famous popular figures. That's another reason I'm in WELS and LCMS (among many others).

I cannot take LCMS seriously when a member insists my father is Satanic for having Pentecostal beliefs about hearing God's voice, while not holding a famous Pentecostal public figure to the same scrutiny. I'm not subject to this LCMS person's opinion. He has no authority over me as someone outside this synod.

I understand there are newer WELS members who may not be aware of the differences of this synod. But again, we are NOT in fellowship with LCMS. I don't need to be policed by an LCMS in my synod's own community. LCMS members should NOT be policing us over here. I do not go over into LCMS' subreddit and try to police their members and absorb them into WELS online communities. I would appreciate if LCMS did the same over here. LCMS already has their own online communities; they can have authority over their own members in their own online communities, but they should NOT have authority over us in OUR online communities.

We. Are. NOT. In. Fellowship. With. LCMS.


r/WELS • • May 01 '26

Why WELS?

0 Upvotes

I have great respect for all Lutheran denominations, for they all strive to preach God's word, but why WELS?

I also ask from a Theological standing point - being from the LCMS - how does the WELS differ Theologically?

Is it true you practice a closed prayer? Where you can only pray with other WELS members but you can still pray for non-members?​

Simply wondering on differences, why you're with WELS, and what you'd say to those not part of WELS.


r/WELS • • Feb 17 '25

As a conservative, I've earned things, so why can't I earn salvation?

0 Upvotes

Hi,

I struggle with the idea of not being able to earn salvation since being conservative is all about earning things through merit. Hence, the opposition to DEI: Didn't Earn It.

Wouldn't not earning salvation be an essentially leftist idea? We earn salvation by obeying laws like good conservatives, do we not?


r/WELS • • Oct 05 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Jun 14 '25

Asked to leave my church

4 Upvotes

What did I do wrong?

What sin am I unrepentant of?

Fair questions.

I wish I knew.

The issue seems to be me desiring to be treated with respect and dignity.

It’s not fair for a pastor to call me out the blue, when I am blocked from calling him, then when I say it’s not a good time to talk, to keep talking.

So I ask that he not call me.

Same on other boundaries he wants, because he’s overwhelmed right now. No WhatsApp, one email per week.

I’d agreed to his one sided boundaries, I assumed they were mutual, then earlier this week he sent me a really long message. It was really discouraging. It wasn’t information that needed sharing urgently. He tried to also provide some encouragement, but did it badly, in a way that came across as an accusation.

Fundamentally my suffering isn’t welcome. I was sexually assaulted, a bit over a year later, I was raped. I’m divorced and am a survivor of spousal abuse. I have c-PTSD.

I’ve had active flashbacks recently. That makes it like it was yesterday. I never refuse to acknowledge sin, if I was irritable and said something I shouldn’t, it doesn’t matter that irritability is a symptom. But it’s my feelings that haven’t gone down well. I said something felt fundamentally unsafe and dangerous, which is genuinely how it felt. Saying that got me asked to leave the church.


r/WELS • • Jul 21 '25

I think I got people really thinking at Bible study on Sunday. Curious on people's thoughts.

5 Upvotes

I go to a WELS church and in Bible study we've been doing a series on what it means to live our faith. This one talked a lot about turning tradition into law.

I don't remember what the discussion question was, but I remember I sort of deviated from what thoughts it was supposed to be prodding at and said, "We have a separation of church and state. It's kind of hard to separate our values and beliefs as a Christian versus a member of this country. Because our government is intended to be secular, I wonder if we need to at least tolerate that some laws exist instead of condemning them and the people who support them. We as citizens can accept that these things are legal, but we as Christians won't do them just because they're legal."

And then an old guy in his 70s piped up, "Like, should abortion be legal? We wouldn't do it, but I feel like we're oppressing those who aren't Christian by turning out beliefs into law for everyone."

Now, my mind hadn't gone to abortion, but it's probably one of the things he struggles with. Pretty much everything he said reflected my thoughts though.

I had been thinking things like outlawing gay marriage or being trans. I feel like outlawing it is persecution. I think they should be legal, whether it abides by my beliefs or not, because there's no secular reason why not. Why should I expect other people to abide by morals they don't believe in? I can teach others about what my morals and why I hold to them, and maybe they'll be persuaded to change perspectives.

It's kind of like the abolition. Just because you think alcohol should be legal doesn't mean you're promoting drunkenness.

Anyway, after 70 year old man piped up, things sort of awkwardly flip flopped until it turned to the thoughts the question was intending to prod, and I never got any other discussion or thoughts on it.


r/WELS • • Sep 03 '25

I am SO RELIEVED to be back at WELS!

13 Upvotes

Pretty much all the best times in my life have occurred while being at WELS.

I grew up in WELS until my parents left it when I was 8 and they unfortunately got caught up in Rapture theology and predicting the end of the world. Prior to those delusions they had, I had a great and happy childhood.

I rejoined WELS many years later when I was 35 not long after the start of Covid. I went to a quiet church where no one argued with each other about the masks and vaccines like so many other churches did at the time. I had my son while a member in 2022, baptized him, and had such nice and quiet and peaceful times from 2020 to July 2025.

Then I made a mistake back in July thinking the church was too elderly, that the pastor would never be able to retire (no one has taken the call yet in 2+ years), and that my 3 year old needed more Sunday School (there are seldom other kids in the local church). I thought a nearby Anglican church might work better - they are somewhat close to Lutherans theologically, so I thought, why not give it a try?

I was wrong.

The Anglican church seemed great at first - daily prayer meetings, fellowship, a large congregation, and a big Sunday School. I even liked all the high church elements, and I reconnected with some old Calvinist online friends there.

Then I found out people had been gossiping about my parenting style to the rector, and I was called in for questioning by him and some other high ranking person in the church yesterday. When I was first called in, I thought they were eager to ask how my catechism class was going, or how my son was doing in Sunday School - but no, instead there were some other church people who thought I was too hard on strongly correcting my son when he was pulling out the kneeling prayer benches and bruising people in the shins with them during service time, and they were there to lecture me about what they thought I should have done instead, which was apparently to hand him off to someone else and not actually TEACH him anything about not hurting people with heavy wooden benches.

Ugh.

That wasn't all. There are some real weaknesses to Anglicans having a big tent in their theology. People criticize us WELSers for having strict prayer fellowship, but when you are as lax as the Anglicans are, there is constant arguing about every theology topic under the sun. I was in some of their online communities, and every day it was a debate about whether or not Mary was a perpetual virgin and whether someone might be a heretic for denying this because such and such bishop from the 18th century thought it was part of the Nicene Creed or Ezekiel 44 or whatever, what to do about the dioceses that allow women's ordination (I was in one that didn't allow it, thankfully, but many do), and you name it - they argued about it.

I am so glad to be back at WELS! Thankfully, my local church has welcomed me back - I talked to the pastor today - and they're eager to see if they can get some Sunday School teaching going so my son can have that.

Yay WELS!


r/WELS • • Oct 29 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Sep 01 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Sep 04 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Oct 30 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Aug 10 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Apr 24 '24

Do I need to do anything with my life?

3 Upvotes

Hello!

I'm a WELS Lutheran! I attended a WELS school from Grades 1-12. And I'm starting to get back into Church going regularly (I don't know if that information is important or not but I figured I would add it :P )

  • So for my current situation

  • I'm a 24 year old male

  • Still living at home with my parents, I help out around the house with chores and what not but I don't have to pay rent

  • I pay for my own car insurance and car payments

  • I make $18.67 an hour, work 25 hours a week and have full benefits but I'm still under my parents health insurance for now

  • I have never been in a relationship and have no friends :P

  • I'm the youngest with two older brothers

  • I have a pretty severe learning disability and have been let go from a few jobs because of it :(

  • I'm on Escitalopram to keep my mental health good and I'll be in therapy soon

  • I like running

  • I currently am in pilot training to get my private pilot's license but I don't have any interest at all with a career in it

I have no idea if I need to add anything to my life, I don't really have any interests in anything career wise and I really struggled with school. My parents don't want me to move out and that's fine with me. I like helping out around the house with everything and the only thing I really have planned is to help out with my parents to the very end. I have prayed for years for answers if there is anything career wise I need to do but nothing stands out to me and if I'm supposed to look somewhere I genuinely have no idea where to look when I have no interests. I would say overall I think I'm happy where I am at in life and I'm posting here just because I think I'm finally getting the message that I'm probably fine where I'm at. I know that God has given some people life more simple lives than others and I think that just might be the case with me.


r/WELS • • Jan 06 '26

Verse of the day

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/WELS • • May 23 '25

WELS night at the Brewers.

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Aug 08 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Dec 10 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Dec 09 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Dec 16 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Sep 29 '25

When politics overrides doctrine

5 Upvotes

Hi all,

I have great concern for my older half brother, who is really diving deep into the LDS church and is getting baptized there on Sunday.

I think we have come to a point in our country where politics overrides doctrine for most, and as such, people like my older half brother, president Donald Trump, and even many in our synod think that Mormons are legitimate Christians and that we should be taking a greater role in politics rather than our synod's historic lesser one (such a topic has come up several times in recent WELS Discussion posts on Facebook).

But look what happens when we constantly tie ourselves up with Republican politics!

My older half brother is defending his conversion to LDS as valid because they're very Republican, respect the Bill of Rights and Constitution, and talk about Jesus.

As with my mother, he has no understanding of the trinity, how baptism works, or other important doctrines - but he knows the LDS is Republican, is against the gays and the Marxists, and so therefore they have to be Christians, right?

Undoubtedly we will see more of this, especially in light of the murders and fire of the Mormon church in the news this week. While I do not believe Mormons are saved, obviously that was a horrible tragedy and should have never happened. We should not murder our enemies. But now that sympathy with LDS will be even higher than before, I think we will continue to see our literal brothers, as well as other brothers and sisters of the faith, be led astray by conservative cults like LDS, all because we too often emphasize POLITICS over actual correct DOCTRINES of our faith!


r/WELS • • Sep 23 '25

Raising Son in Today's Society

5 Upvotes

Hi,

I'm a 40 year old WELS mom raising a 3 year old son. Today's society is so much different from how I grew up in the 1990s and 2000s, and I'd like some perspective based on the context of my own family.

I was baptized in the 1980s and my family was WELS from my birth until I was about 8. I remember my early childhood very fondly. However, my family left WELS before I was old enough for confirmation. They got caught up in the rapture stuff, like Left Behind, by the time of the mid 1990s, and completely left church, preferring to study the Bible on their own in their home, along with a lot of influence from TBN on TV. They thought the rapture would occur in 2008, so my older brother thought he had to hurry up and get married. When his girlfriend rejected him in 1997, he committed suicide. I was just short of 13 when that happened; he was almost 17.

During my adolescence, I had a lot of challenges with the faith as my family and I navigated the grief of losing a loved one. By the time I started college in 2002-03, I was pretty much agnostic. I met my future husband in 2004, who was (and remains) agnostic. My parents were never against our relationship or eventual marriage as my dad believed people can be saved after they die. I did come back to the faith in 2005, but it took a long time before any of us considered church. I eventually got my dad to start taking me to Calvary Chapel in 2013, and he attended as well (my mother had COPD at that point and couldn't travel). I eventually officially married my fiancé in 2016, and I left home so he and I could get our own place.

Since 2016, I've moved on from Calvary Chapel, tried IFB from 2017-18, LCMS from 2018-2020, and now back to my childhood WELS since 2020 (I also briefly attended an ACNA church to see what they were like, but WELS was much better).

My mom passed away in 2018, but my dad is still alive. His theology is still very heterodox, and he prefers a live-and-let-live kind of approach to life, so I can't really get a lot of advice from him. And with my husband being an unbeliever, obviously we have some very different perspectives. I have two older half-siblings, one of whom is attending a Mormon Latter Day Saints church, and my older half sister once attended ELCA, but she hasn't been in years.

Honestly, the only theological influences my son will have are me and the local WELS church.

With all that's going on in society, how can I guide him, especially given a family situation like this where there aren't a lot of clear theological influences?

Any help is appreciated.


r/WELS • • Aug 11 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Aug 21 '25

Verse of the day

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/WELS • • Apr 03 '24

St John’s Milwaukee (Urban Spelunking)

6 Upvotes