r/VioletEvergarden • • Mar 22 '24

Question why is violet so OP?

0 Upvotes

i just finished the show and it was everything i expected and more , but it had some major flaws (like the big tiddy woman).The biggest flaw imo is the fact that violet is so fkin op , like no way a 10yo girl can beat up an average man no matter how much she is trained let alone soldiers. i dont mind unrealism in anime but this show is an exception because its primary purpose is to portray real emotions. so is there any explanation in the LN as to why is this the case ? also, how much better is LN compared to the anime and if i want to read it , should i read from the start or where the anime left off

edit: i thought people here were nice . damn you guys , people can have opinions.


r/VioletEvergarden • • Jan 11 '26

VIOLET EVERGARDEN THE MOVIE SPOILERS. I would have been okay if Violet fell in love with another person instead. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Prefacing this with: Look I know everyone, and their mothers has talked about their divisive opinions about the final movie already, but I never got that chance so it's my turn on the trolley. (That, and none of my friends watch any animes.)

I've some qualms with resurrecting Major, but that's not going to be the point of this short thread. I fucking LOVE this series, and I thought the final movie was pretty great up until that final 20 minutes where the Major, and Violet got together, and lived happily ever after.

I've no problems with Violet getting a happy ending. Falling in love, and all that, but did it really have to be the Major? I would have been okay if it were with someone else. I don't care who exactly.. Just not the person who literally named her and raised her from a child. He gave her a name, he taught her how to speak, and he gave her a reason to exist when she was a feral child soldier who didn’t know what a "heart" even was. In the series, that dynamic was beautiful because it felt like a father-daughter or mentor-student bond. It was about a man trying to save a girl’s soul and give her a future. When he said "I love you" at the end of the war, it felt like the desperate final wish of a guardian who wanted his "child" to live a full, emotional life. It was a broad, world-opening kind of love. But the movie? The movie pulls this absolute bait-and-switch where suddenly it’s "Oh, actually, I want to marry the girl I raised."

It's fucken gross, and it astounds me that some people defend this shit. It completely recontextualizes every tender moment they had in the flashbacks. Instead of seeing a man trying to protect a vulnerable child, you’re forced to look at it through the lens of a "brewing romance," which makes the age gap and the power dynamic feel predatory rather than protective. Gilbert was a grown-ass man in his late 20s when he took in a 10-year-old girl.

The show was about Violet outgrowing her dependence on him. It was about her becoming her own person and realizing that "I love you" can mean a million things. By making the ending a romantic reunion, the writers basically said, "Actually, the only 'love' that matters is the one where she goes back to the guy who raised her."

I wanted her to find someone on her own, someone who didn't know her when she was a traumatized kid with no social skills.

I'm just saying... By tethering her to Gilbert, the story denies her the chance to experience a relationship that isn't colored by her own history of subservience. It robs her of the ultimate growth: the ability to choose someone who has no claim on her past, only a place in her future.

I know I'm throwing out a lot of negativity here, and this has already been voiced a thousands and more by different people, but I just wanted to throw my opinion out there. I genuinely love this series, and I think it's a masterpiece. Not just in the anime genre, but from storytelling as a whole. It's just the final movie that just completely soured me. It doesn't ruin the entire series or anything... I just wish it was different. I might even just headcanon this as noncanon.


r/VioletEvergarden • • Mar 21 '25

Meme You can’t tell me that you wouldn’t smell her hair given the chance, I know it’s good

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/VioletEvergarden • • Jun 07 '22

Question Does Violet have high functioning autism?

0 Upvotes

she shows some symptoms


r/VioletEvergarden • • Nov 20 '24

VIOLET EVERGARDEN THE MOVIE Please tell me I'm not the only person that absolutely hated this movie. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I'm going to make a longer post when I have more time tomorrow. I just finished this movie and by God, it was so bad.


r/VioletEvergarden • • Dec 28 '24

LIGHT NOVEL I don’t understand why people try to justify the Gilbert and Violet romance, especially in the novel

30 Upvotes

What could possible be the reason why Gilbert raised Violet when she was 10 years old, cared and loved for her like a father and then falls in love with her and even propose. It’s crazy why people justify it. We can all ignore the age gap (which we should honestly not) but it’s just purely on a moral perspective. Like what if your Uncle would marry you, it’s just weird. Please make some good arguments and not just the usual culture, it was a different time or whatever. I want a purely moral perspective on how it is okay. Yes they are happy and Gilbert doest seem to do bad things with her but I could write a story about a guy pushing a massive rock upp a cliff for all eternity but just i decide as the writer that he is happy and the dude that forced him to push upp the boulder is actually a really nice guy.


r/VioletEvergarden • • May 28 '23

Question Will it get a bit... less slow paced and better? (spoilers for 6 episode) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Importent, I have diagnosed ADHD type combined and I might be on autism spectrum + english isn't my first language, im sorry.
Im freshly after watching 6 episode, Im enjoying series.. tho, whole ending with Leon really killed my mood, because of my dislike to romantic tropes (episode 5 already made me hella uncomfortable, but I somehow liked it because of how relatable Violet was in it). It just felt very rushed to me, but I also don't understend such interactions and relationships, it simply made me feel annoyed a bit.
My irritation also caused me to realize how much is ahead of me, and, while im enjoying style, music and im finding Violet to be huge mood, fact how slow things are going (apart from this love part) are just making me feel tired, I feel understimulated.

Like I said, im really enjoying this anime so far, I don't want to end watching it only halfly, but please, will it get a bit faster, and will there be less scenes like this ending (speaking only about Leon's crush)


r/VioletEvergarden • • Oct 02 '24

Miscellaneous Violet Evergarden Bunny Girl Violet by Old-timer’s Joy Studio it will be release in 2025 but the design kinda disgusting 🤢 they lewding violet hard NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/VioletEvergarden • • Jul 16 '25

VIOLET EVERGARDEN THE MOVIE Does anyone else also felt unsatisfied with the ending of violet evergarden?

0 Upvotes

The show was on my watchlist from like 2 to 3 years but I didn't watched it. Recently I tried and this was good, my eyes got watery throughout the season but the last movie was felt like something was missing they sure did bad to violet wbu guys?


r/VioletEvergarden • • Dec 31 '22

VIOLET EVERGARDEN THE MOVIE [MOVIE SPOILERS AHEAD] I finished the whole series, i was really disappointed with the movie ending Spoiler

0 Upvotes

If you haven't watched the movie i suggest you don't read any further

First off I've always been bad with words, and im not all that confident in my English, so i apologize in advance.

After all these years, after Violet has gone through so much character growth, befriending people and taking small but important steps to moving on to a normal life, the major turns out to be alive, chilling on an island with a half-assed excuse to not go and visit Violet and/or his relatives

And yet after all that, in the end, Violet jumps off the boat, swims back to shore, they cry for a couple minutes and they supposedly live together happily ever after on the island. Violet abandons everything she has achieved on the mainland just for a "happy ending"

Everything else from the movie was great, even the part where we find out Gilbert is alive. I only wish that Gilbert read the letter that Violet wrote while she was back on the mainland, finally moving on, even leading a normal life.

I'd like to hear other opinions as well, im aware that i might be missing the point, so id love to discuss the ending with other people.

thank you for reading my 4a.m rant, and i apologize if what i said makes no sense whatsoever


r/VioletEvergarden • • Jan 06 '26

VIOLET EVERGARDEN THE MOVIE It's stating the obvious, but I want to talk about that ending.

0 Upvotes

Look, the entire series builds a very clear journey. Violet learns little by little what words mean, and thus understands what feelings are, and what those feelings cause in others. Each episode is a different emotional mirror: grief, farewell, unrequited love, late love, impossible love. And the turning point is exactly that episode where she faces the Major's death. There, it's not just sadness, it's denial, guilt, anger, emptiness, it's the beginning of real grief. An entire episode dedicated to Violet discovering and overcoming the Major's death, but then, suddenly and for no reason, he comes back? If that was the path to follow, wouldn't it have been better to leave his situation more open, never touching on the subject and making this ending "the inevitable issue"? And when Violet finally decides to talk about it, and ends up going after him after receiving a letter that gives the small possibility that the Major is alive? Call me picky, but it seems like a more coherent decision.

But that's not what happened. In the end, we have him alive out of nowhere and for no reason, on some island somewhere. I wish it was because he was traumatized by the war, but not even that. It was because "I used her as a weapon." That would be a good discussion and even a good justification if it weren't abandoned halfway through and brought back later just to cause a fight with Hodgins. If it were a deep war trauma, a guilt that prevented him from returning, we could have a discussion about forgiveness and self-flagellation, but the execution is shallow. He disappears, lives like a hermit, and only comes back because Violet insists. It's weak and even forced, almost 2 hours of film where the first half is focused on the subplot of the sick boy, which is good, but still a subplot, and the other half focused on Violet and Hodgins wandering around the island with the depressed Major, stuck at school or at home.

Giving MY suggestion for how the ending could have been. I would have Violet fall in love with someone else and remember the Major's actions while he was with her, so she would finally understand what he felt for her, since she would be going through the same situation, and perhaps even taking the same actions, and thus not only would it give meaning to this adventure, but it would also close the cycle of her overcoming. Violet spent the series deciphering the "I love you" of others, she needed to experience the feeling for herself to truly understand what Gilbert felt, loving someone new would be the last stage of her emotional growth, not erasing Gilbert, but honoring her feelings by moving on.


r/VioletEvergarden • • May 25 '23

Discussion Am i the only one who was disappointed by the ending? Spoiler

6 Upvotes

2 years have passed since i watched the show and all the movies.A few days ago i decided to refresh my memory about the ending and now that i remembered it i cannot but feel disappointed.

First of all, i understand it's fiction.My problem though is not solely their age gap but also how gilbert had treated her up to that point.He seemed to regard her as a daughter so for him to end up in s romantic relationship with her struck me as really weird.

Besides that,Violet's attachment to Gilbert should not be rewarded.I think most would agree that if an 18 year old exhibited so much attachment for a person much less someone 10 years older than her we would not applaud that.

The reason i take this so seriously is because when i watched the series i was 15 in a very weird phase and Violet's themes resonated with me.Personally, for me a much more impactful ending woulf be if Gilbert helped her realise that her romantic attachment to him was not normal and instead guided her to become completely free.


r/VioletEvergarden • • May 13 '26

VIOLET EVERGARDEN THE MOVIE Hot take: the Major should have stayed dead Spoiler

27 Upvotes

It felt like the major coming back to life and being alive all this time ruined one of the core messaging of the show and movies. Originally they had the themes of morning. Someone you don't truly know is dead, Loving someone who has died before you understood what love was, And moving on and continuing with.

I think the major being alive all this time ruined those. By having him come back to life it feels like a fake out And it diminishes the impact of those themes. It also had Violet essentially throw away her job and social life to live with him on an island.

Alternative ending: I think it would have been better to have her fall in love with someone else. I think it would have improved the story by showing how much she developed as a character by having her realize what love is and experience it in someone new! I think the only problem with this is they didn't introduce a character that fit this role unless they wanted to give her a bi arc


r/VioletEvergarden • • Jul 23 '25

Question Can I still enjoy Violet Evergarden if I dislike the pedophilia stuff?

5 Upvotes

So I wanted to start watching Violet Evergarden again because I love Kyoani and sad stuff (plus I've heard great things about it). I watched the first three episodes a few years back, and loved the first episode, but I remember the third one being very off-putting to me due to some teenager being arranged to marry a man far older than her (something which was treated as a good thing iirc).

I have heard many things about the romance between Violet and her father-figure-mentor (?) Including him raising her and having feelings for her when she was around 14 years old. This honestly really disgusted me, and put me off from watching this anime many deem a masterpiece.

Could I still enjoy this anime even with the pedophile/agegap stuff? This anime is so widely regarded as incredible despite the fact most people probably wouldn't be okay wth the romantic relationship portrayed. in it, so it made me wonder if I was crazy or missing something. I appreciate any response and I'm not trying to offend anyone. Thanks!


r/VioletEvergarden • • Aug 19 '22

VIOLET EVERGARDEN THE MOVIE I just watched the movie and I thought it was terrible. Spoiler

2 Upvotes

So before anyone yells at me in the comments, I really loved the anime, and I was all too eager to watch the movie right afterwards. And seeing as it had 100% on rotten tomatoes and very high reviews overall, I went in with high expectations. But the main plot points made pretty much zero sense to me. Like I was under the impression that the major was dead, and the anime had a lot of time spent coming to terms with that, and understanding how to move on afterwards. But then in the movie, just out of the blue, he's suddenly alive again? I feel like this completely ruined and devalued like half of the anime, and left no real space for any more story to be told. Also since Violets relationship with the major always came across to me as paternal, it seemed super strange when it was revealed to be more romantic, despite the several DECADE age gap between the two. So I'm really just left wondering whether I missed something, like a different movie or a second season of the anime that I somehow completely ignored? Because being someone that is usually quite generous with film ratings, I just can't understand how everyone loves it so much, if I didn't miss something completely massive.


r/VioletEvergarden • • Sep 01 '25

VIOLET EVERGARDEN THE MOVIE My Take on the second Film (VE the movie)

0 Upvotes

Is it only me or is the movie pretty shitty. Like i hated it. It goes against everything in the series. Its about letting Go and starting a new Life and the second the mayor is somehow alive she Just says fuck it all and leaves to live with the Guy who caused to much Trauma, pain and the loss of 2 Arms in a shitty little island. Like If the Part where she leaves His doorstep in the movie and then left the Island Just, that would have been good aswell... I personally never watch it when rewatching the series and the movies and for me its Just Not Canon. Call me crazy but i hated it. Thanks


r/VioletEvergarden • • May 12 '24

Question are gilbert and violet married??

0 Upvotes

[potential spoilers] someone please explain cuz i might just hate the story and gilbert if they are (context: i saw a comment saying they got married in the light novel)


r/VioletEvergarden • • Aug 10 '25

Question Why is Violet Evergarden considered "romance"? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Idk if this is a spoiler, so I just tagged it as one, dont assault me idk 🤷‍♂️

I can confidently say this is my favorite anime. The colors, the writing, the character design, the aesthetic, all of it. I haven't watched too many animes because I have a pretty short attention span, but this anime kept me focused 100% of the time, and I for the first time in my life actually felt a little dispointed when I had to do something and pause where I was. But something strikes me as a bit odd? Before I say this (which you and I both know what I'm gonna say cus of the title), don't call me an idiot for just not really understanding genres. I find romance to be quite boring and therefore not really having much experience actually knowing what it is as a genre. But with that out of the way, why is this labeled as "romance"? I understand that maybe the letters always being about a loved one might label it as such, but you usually think about "romance" talking about girlfriends/boyfriends/husbands/wives, not people who are blood-related like grandparents, sons, daughters, dads, moms etc etc. And I get that the letters are the main focus, but Violet wouldn't be writing the letters if it werent for Gilbert. And while I was watching, I had always thought that Gilbert was more of a father figure than a love interest? It would just be odd if he was a love interest for Violet. Violet is "around 14" as she tells the princess, Gilbert is the one that shields Violet from others who only see her as a tool, Gilbert legit even gave Violet her name. So why is this considered "romance" if Gilbert is supposed to be more of a parental figure to her than a lover? Is Violet in love and theres just something I don't understand, or was I right all the time and it was just because of the letters that label it such, and Gilbert is supposed to be her father-figure?


r/VioletEvergarden • • Oct 29 '23

VIOLET EVERGARDEN (TV) Just watch this instead of Episode 5 and avoid the romanticized child marriage

57 Upvotes

r/VioletEvergarden • • May 25 '25

Discussion Just a little shower thought I had recently

0 Upvotes

If you have ever used ChatGPT or are a frequent user of it, you should realize that they are the modern day equivalent of auto memory dolls in the world of Violet Evergarden. I mean, look, they help write touching letters for people who don't know what words to use. Furthermore, they don't only write letters but also short stories, articles, transcripts, etc. This actually also applies to other chat based AIs like Deepseek for example.


r/VioletEvergarden • • Apr 25 '26

VIOLET EVERGARDEN (TV) If auto memory dolls are underage, is it illegal to hire one to write a sexually explicit letter?

0 Upvotes

r/VioletEvergarden • • Oct 08 '26

Meme (Movie) I just wanna say ahead of time that I am sorry for making this.

4 Upvotes

r/VioletEvergarden • • Jan 20 '25

VIOLET EVERGARDEN (TV) Is Frieren Overrated?

2 Upvotes

So I was just thinking after finishing Frieren the very strong similarities both anime has. Two emotionally blunt girl trying to learn emotions and understand humans they are both cold yet fragile in the beginning however throughout the anime they grow as a person and start to realise they had feelings and start ro reflect into the past and the realisation of death of a loved one hurts more than they thought. I think Frieren struggled with the storytelling it was stretched out and not much happened I understand the pacing was meant to be slow but that's not what I'm referring to there is a different between the quantity of the story progression and how slow they implement it. Violet is way more dense in good way. You wish it was longer because it's so well written. I think are the visuals clear they go to Violet its one of the best animated and drawn anime all time. The soundtrack is super subjective both made by the same person however frieren is way more popular yet violets soundtrack has more streams on Spotify.

In conclusion i love Frieren but it makes me sad that people rated it the best anime, gotten so popular, even though i think is Violet a better version of that anime and just makes me feel bad for Kyoto studio not getting the praise they deserve especially after the things that happened. Maybe it's just me but Violet Evergarden is my favourite anime of all time and it's so underrated and I know it's quite popular but I think should be even more known, what do think, feel like?

71 votes, Jan 22 '25
37 I agree, Violet is a better anime, deserves more recognition.
34 I disagree I think Frieren is better and properly rated.

r/VioletEvergarden • • Jan 31 '26

VIOLET EVERGARDEN THE MOVIE I finished the whole series... I didn't like the movie. Spoiler

18 Upvotes

The tv series and the special episodes were one of the greatest pieces of media ever made. The movie, however, I kind of hated. Maybe I'm just interpreting it wrong, but I feel like the movie backtracked the messaging of the rest of the series. Violet spent the entire storyline of the series learning how to feel, understand not just "I love you" but everything. Part of that growth, while she probably could never let the major go completely, was accepting that he's gone and moving forward. But then in the movie it turns out the major is alive, and Violet has a character regression, abandoning a dying child who hired her to write letters for his family and rushes off to go see the major on the isolated island he's been hiding on. I say "hiding" rather than living because that's more accurate. He falls into one of my most hated clichés, which is the self-loathing coward who runs from their past and decrees for everybody else in their former life what THEY think is best for all of them. He refuses to even face Violet, which breaks her heart, and so after receiving a telegram that the child she should have been writing that letter for died, she understands she has to move on and go back to helping others put their feelings to words... THEN the major realizes he's being a piece of shit, and charges down to the pier to apologize, Violet jumps OFF OF THE SHIP and swims to shore so they can reunite, and he asks her to stay with him, on that secluded island, forever. Like, just forget all of the friends you have made, leave the life you've built, isolate yourself here. I get that they love each other, but it came off as manipulative to me. You ran off to hide on this island, you should be the one going to her. He makes unilateral decisions “for Violet’s sake”, avoids accountability by isolating himself, refuses to face her, and frames his disappearance as moral penance. For him to then 180 and ask her to abandon her entire life and stay with him, on his terms, in his exile, just feels antithetical to everything else I watched.

I also don't like what it did to the rest of the series' world. Shortly after Violet gets her unrealistic fairytale ending, accessibility of telephones and higher education or whatever made auto memories dolls obsolete and so all of the rest of them lost their jobs. Take Iris, for example. Her dream was to become the world's best auto memories doll, and she ends up a museum curator, or something like that, somewhat conveying she was never able to move on from the forced obsolescence of her dream. It doesn't even hint at what happened to Cattleya or the others, but the whole postage company went out of business. Like yeah, I get sometimes that happens in real life, but it feels wrong that Violet gets her dream, and everybody else gets fucked. And the fact that in the 'present' time of the movie, Violet is referred to in the past tense, heavily implies she is dead. That's just more of a knife twist. I don't think the book needed to be shut THAT hard.


r/VioletEvergarden • • Dec 25 '24

VIOLET EVERGARDEN THE MOVIE My thoughts on Gilbert at the end of the movie, and the relationship dynamic. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Gilbert angered me because they could have stayed platonic, I mean, HES 15 YEARS OLDER THAN HER! And he successfully groomed her into staying with his miserable self to that darn island, keeping her for himself selfishly, remember when he said "I want you to stay with me, Violet." He felt sad and regretted using her as a tool and blamed himself for that and by causing her to lose her arms. But in the end, he still used her as a tool, used her to fill that hole in his heart/life. As they met, I saw Violet struggling with so much mixed emotions, he's basically taking away her freedom and life by telling her that he wanted her to stay with him, yeah he did say that he wasn't his superior officer anymore, or the man that she thought he was, but HE SHOULD KNOW BETTER. Violet had Stockholm syndrome, and she's a very complicated person who doesn't know any better. But yeah, she did have feelings, but I really didn't want them to be together, because he's an old man and Violet is a MARVEL!

My best wish is that hopefully they stayed platonic and had a father/daughter relationship, be cause you know, 15 years age gap is CRAZY and he's prolly a pedophile ngl. And yeah, just met her as she was on his door and just had her moment with him, happy to know that he's alive, and GO BACK with the PRESIDENT, and let her live her life.

I truly wished tho that Leon was endgame, because they both looked good together and the fact that they are both the same age, not with an old man..

But sadly no; Whatever, I still love Violet and am still waiting for a sequel and more content...

Still waiting..

(Changed the title, because Im new to reddit.)