r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Jun 07 '15

Total Biscuit - Violence and video game narritives

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Feb 13 '23

Why Most AAA Games Have No Soul by Going Indie

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Apr 17 '19

Marvel's Spider-Man Didn't Make Me FEEL Like Spider-Man (and other nitpicks) Spoiler

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Dec 03 '19

Paradox Interactive is Not Immune to Propaganda: Leftist Politics in Grand Strategy

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Jan 23 '18

Trans and Other Non-Binary Representation in Video Games- An Analysis of Troupes.

5 Upvotes

So I'm in this class right now, where we are talking about feminist representation in Video Gaming, and it made me think a lot about the non-binary representation in the same games.

In class we had to watch a lot of Anita Sarkeesian videos, and in one of them (Ms. Male Characters) she talks about feminine identifiers in video games (such as the color pink, bows in the hair, extensive makeup, ect) and goes on about how these breed an air of sexism and a negative look at female representation in video games. She also goes on and talks about how, when these identifiers are placed onto a male figure it can appear trans or homophobic.

In a response to this, Youtuber Caranraug says that a joke cannot be inherently transphobic. I took a personal opposition to this, we don't ever say that a racist joke can't be inherently racist, it's just racist to joke about certain things regarding people of color. Caranraug also talks about how the trans issues aren't addressed in Sarkessian's videos. Which is very true, however it got me thinking....Sarkessian talks a lot about troupes of women in video games, do non-binary individuals experience any troupes of their own.

Below are my personal thoughts, feel free to add more ideas I really want to expand on this more. Let's have a discussion ya'll!


So there are some troupes I've really come across when studying the "vast quantity" of non-binary characters in video games. 

"The Inattentive Developer" 
Definition: When a developer doesn't take a stance (or acknowledge)  on the identity of a character, forcing the community to draw conclusions about a specific character's identity. Or similarly, a developer takes out  any mention of the identity, or overwriting it entirley. 
Examples of this: Leo in Tekkan 6 (a supposedly gender neutral character, where the developers have never out right spoken about identifying them as a gender neutral character). Birdo from the Mario Series also is a victim of this troupe. In the initial release of Super Mario 2, she is described as followed: "He thinks he is a girl" (the wording is a different issue altogether) after this, there is no indication that she is a trans character. Yes, this game is marketed towards children, but there are characters later down the list are actually in the exact same franchise that address trans issues. 
Why is this bad: It basically either erases or never clarifies their identity. 

"Misgendering" 
Definition: I think we all know what this is. one of the most common tropes regarding trans and non-binary characters in almost all forms of media. 
Examples:  Vivian in Paper Mario Series, Erika in Catherine, as well as many others. But there is one character in particular that I want to touch on: Naoto in Persona 4. Naoto is the Detective Prince of Inaba, and for the first two-thirds of the game he identifies as a male and dresses as a male. During a section in the game where he is the main focus (and also fulfills a Damsel in Distress role) it is revealed that Naoto was born female. Immediately after this moment the masculine pronouns are dropped, and Naoto is referred fully as "she" for the remainder of the game. Naoto is even forced into competing in a beauty contest so another character can come to terms with his homosexuality. And also there is a scene where Naoto and some of the women of the cast are sitting in a bath together, and Naoto is clearly uncomfortable with their body, and yet is further oversexualized. 
Why is this Bad?: Misgendering anyone is never okay, when it is intentional and not a reference to the characters past (like a flashback) it drives a difference between the genders, and is generally considered an act of "not accepting their preferred gender."  And this can be explained further in the next troupe. 

"The Trans-Joke Trope" 
Definition: Next to misgendering this is one of the most common troupes for non-binary individuals in games. 
Examples: Erika (Catherine)- When she is revealed to be trans (as a "shocking reveal") another character panics and exclaims that he "want's his V-Card back" refusing to accept that he lost his virginity to a trans woman. This is then played off as a joke from Erika, and for the rest of the game a lot of characters Misgender her and say "I can't see Erika as a woman anymore". Vivian (Paper Mario) several characters misgender Vivian in her time during Super Mario, and several make jokes about her as a trans woman. There is even a time in Grand Theft Auto IV where the player character says "hey man-girl-whatever (or some variant of this) in regards to a trans woman. 
Why is this bad?: Well it begs the question what makes a joke transphobic? And for me it is the fact that these characters are joking about a person's identity. When someone makes fun of a Person of Color for being black or hispanic, or makes a joke about asian sterotypes, we in hearintly think these are rascit, and I believe the same goes for trans and homophobic jokes. 

"Trans Villan Troupe" 
Defenition: "It's okay to hit her, she's a man"
Example: the primary example I want to pull from for this is Poison in the Street Fighter series. The developers literally came out to say that this is why they included Poison in the North American release of the title, providing the excuse to hit her. 
Why is this bad?: Why do we need to put a label on someone for the sake of violence? In a game grounded on violence, why does this matter?

Now there are some really positive representations of Trans and Non-binary characters, but for the sake of length I can save that for a comment thread, unless you want me to rant about how much I appreciate Krem in Dragon Age Inquisition. 

Let me know your thoughts, was there anything I should add? Anything I should fix? My goal here is to make this into a video or academic paper or something to get published. Any and all comments are welcomed!  

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Jun 13 '18

Fallout 76 Isn't Fallout 5, and That's Ok

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Sep 13 '21

Is Fromsoftware Becoming outdated ?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Apr 06 '16

The Philosophy of Dark Souls

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Sep 07 '22

why was Mass Effect 3's writing so GOOD? by Michelle Zhuli

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Jan 07 '16

IS THE OCULUS RIFT TOO EXPENSIVE?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Nov 11 '20

Games Aren't Art - YiiK

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Feb 25 '26

video games written by men vs women

3 Upvotes

so i’m doing some research for a project about the potential differences between video games written by women and video games written by men. do you guys ever think about this? if you do, do you notice a difference? for example, TLOU (2013) was written only by Neil Druckman, but TLOU2 (2020) was co written by Neil and Hailey Gross. both are violent games with a rich story and strong female characters, but is there a difference in the story or character quality? obviously don’t take the TLOU example and run with it lol, i know it’s a bit of a controversial game to some. just looking for opinions from people who game + think about the creatives behind it! would love any other examples and discussion! mostly looking to discuss story driven games.


r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Nov 15 '15

Evan Narcisse - The New Tomb Raider Made Me Think About Going Back to Church

Thumbnail
kotaku.com
2 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Apr 11 '21

Why BIOSHOCK is not a Masterpiece by Masked Vale

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Mar 02 '19

Euphoria: A Feminist Analysis – Sadistic Torture Porn, Or Brutal Allegory? (NSFW) NSFW Spoiler

Thumbnail
guardianacorn.com
5 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • May 31 '22

I am Error - Elden Ring is MORE than a 10/10

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Apr 17 '26

Which one would you click on Steam?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’m currently working on the capsule art for my psychological horror game The Infected Soul.

The game is about a neural implant that distorts reality… you can’t trust what you see.

Which one draws you in the most?
1, 2, 3, 4, or 5?

If it interests you, you can add it to your Steam wishlist — it would really help me a lot 🙏

The Infected Soul – Steam Page


r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Dec 24 '17

Rocket League is comparable to Chess in how it creates an expressive game experience

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Dec 12 '18

Speedrunners breaking the game | what do you think?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Jun 16 '26

The Rusted Demo is Available Now

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hello everyone, we have attanded steam next fest and published our demo. If you like 2D puzzle platform games, you can give it a try. The Rusted is introducing an AI dominated post apocalyptic world and you can play as a robot dog for searching for his human family.


r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Dec 06 '20

The Witcher 3 Rekindled My Love for Gaming (video essay!)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Mar 30 '22

Shin Megami Tensei V is Really Bad by Simply Dad

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Oct 09 '20

My analysis of why fall guys hype has decreased (roughly) 95% in 4 weeks.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Jun 24 '26

GTA VI physical disc petition launched

Post image
0 Upvotes

We just launched a petition about the physical edition of GTA VI.

Rockstar is reportedly selling the physical version of GTA VI with only a download code inside the box, meaning there is no real disc.

For many of us, physical games are not just about playing. They are about ownership, collecting, midnight releases, sharing games, and preserving gaming history.

A box with a code inside is not a physical game. It is just a digital license in packaging.

We are not against digital games. We are against calling something “physical” when it contains no physical game.

This is not only about people who prefer physical copies. It is also about everyone who cares about gaming history, memories, and not letting an important part of gaming culture disappear.

If you believe games are more than just digital licenses, you should sign this petition.

We also encourage people to share this, create posts, videos, discussions, and help spread awareness across social media. Every voice matters.

If you are creating content about this topic, feel free to use the ideas, arguments, and slogans from this campaign in your videos, posts, and discussions. You can use phrases like:

Code is cold, disc is gold
A box with a code inside is not a physical game
When something is sold as physical, it must be physical
A download code is not a physical game
Physical means physical
Save physical gaming
Disc or nothing

Use the hashtag: #discisgold

Petition link:
https://change.org/discisgold

Code is cold, disc is gold.

Stay loud. Stay together. Make it matter.


r/VideoGameAnalysis • • Feb 17 '16

Why Aren't There Science Fiction Games? - Extra Credits

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes