r/VCAndrews • u/Capital-Study6436 • 13h ago
Which characters do you wish to see get in trouble on-screen?
Dr. Pervert.
Malcolm.
Sissy Towers.
Yolanda.
Julian.
Melodie.
Joel.
Arden.
Logan.
Tony.
Jillian.
r/VCAndrews • u/Capital-Study6436 • 13h ago
Dr. Pervert.
Malcolm.
Sissy Towers.
Yolanda.
Julian.
Melodie.
Joel.
Arden.
Logan.
Tony.
Jillian.
r/VCAndrews • u/Infamous-Thought-765 • 18h ago
What are your thoughts on “My Wedding Party”?
________________________________
At her wedding party, Olivia feels tall and awkward. The guests wear clothes that are white or pastel colored, so apparently that tells you all you need to know about them.
These women gossip about Olivia and how homely she is.
Malcolm flirts with all the pretty ladies, and this surprises Olivia because she thought he found flighty women to be a turn off. Apparently, she took him at his word. Imagine that.
So we learn that the only reason Malcolm married Olivia is because she has the body for bearing the many babies he demands. She suspects this is not the way making babies works. You don’t just appear n a k e y in your wife’s room, demand a son and, voila, 9 mos later, baby Malcolm arrives into the world. But this is Malcolm Foxworth we’re dealing with, so 9 mos later, voila, baby Malcolm makes his grand entrance. We’ll learn about him in the next chapter.
r/VCAndrews • u/nina_ballerina • 1d ago
Corinne said that he stopped breathing on the way to the hospital and she threw his body in a ravine. I think she was lying because of the way she snapped when Cathy told her about a smell in the attic. She probably left the dirty work to John Amos and never asked what he did with the body.
r/VCAndrews • u/strawbbghost • 1d ago
hello, new to the sub, not new to the book.
what i’m going to say has probably been discussed, and debated and discussed again for years and years but i’ve never had anyone to soundboard any of these thoughts and theories with.
i’m listening to the audiobook of FITA as i’ve decided to revise the series as an adult rather than a teenager, and.. wow. what in the fresh hell is happening here?
first of all, i’m convinced chris knew more than he let on. the way he constantly defended his mother even though the neglect was so clear; starving them, pretending that she didn’t know they’d been whipped, ignoring the twins time and time again, telling cathy about menstrual cycles only because chris prompted, bringing them gifts that were no longer appropriate for them as they aged, the doughnuts etc etc. he HAD to have known more and to have been in cahoots with corrine.
second, how on earth did no one wake up whilst cathy had tar poured on her head? how did carrie not wake up and scream from seeing the grandma?
third, how on EARTH did corrine just IGNORE the fact that the twins just were NOT growing?? and how did she not feel any type of way about it??
i’d love a perspective of FITA from corrine’s point of view, i’d LOVE to know what was going through her head
(bare in mind, i’ve only ever read up to ITBT but i’m determined to get through the entire series)
i hate chris more and more as time goes on, how tf was he just living in fantasy land peeping at his SISTER as she gets older because he had some weird oedipus complex that was never investigated
edit to add: WHAT WAS WITH THE NAMES ON THE DESKS IN THE ATTIC?? HOW BIG WAS THIS ATTIC!? the way it’s described, in my head it’s so HUGE it’s like its own house with different rooms etc
PLEASE let me know your thoughts, theories and discussions - i don’t worry about spoilers please spoil away i’m so excited to discuss these books with people
r/VCAndrews • u/Infamous-Thought-765 • 1d ago
What are your thoughts on "The Ghosts of the Past'?
____________________________________
Olivia finds a little room in the north wing with a stairwell that leads to the attic. It occurs to her that this is probably a room that was created with the very specific purpose of locking annoying family members away.
In Flowers in the Attic, it is made known that she is afraid of attic spaces because she used to be locked in closets by her parents as a child. But she seems to have no trouble going up into the attic on this particular occasion. Up there, she finds creepy furniture draped in white cloth, pantaloons and bird cages. The bird cages give her the idea to collect birds all of a sudden. Malcolm will later nix that idea.
Suddenly, she recovers the memory of being held captive in a closet by her mother as a child and can’t tolerate being up there any longer.
So down the stairs she goes.
After talking to Malcolm about this secret room, she finds out that there were indeed some black sheep cousins who were kept there in the past. Maybe Olivia is psychic.
r/VCAndrews • u/MrsPhuckHughson • 2d ago
This is a running theme for many characters in VCA universe. What are ya’lls thoughts on this?
Paul (not Dr Pervert)
Phillip
Tony
Jillian
Pierre
Alicia during her imprisonment
Georgia
r/VCAndrews • u/Infamous-Thought-765 • 2d ago
What are your thoughts on “The Ugly Duckling and the Swan”?
________________
Olivia is bitter over the fact that it’s morning, and Malcolm never came to her room for a post-wedding cuddle. In fact, he’s already left the house without saying good day. She responds by taking her frustrations out on the staff.
She makes plans to fix up her work area and make it pretty with plants and paintings. Would you look at that? She’s just like the little Dollanganger children who will one day decorate a dreary attic to make it cheerier. Who would have ever thought the mean old grandmother had it in her?
Since she’s on a roll here, she decides to be naughty and trespass in her mother-in-law’s abandoned quarters. She is impressed by the magnificent swan bed. Everyone who sets eyes on it can’t seem to shut up about it.
Malcolm is immensely vexed when he finds her hanging out in there like she’s Goldilocks. This leads to him telling her the truth about his mother. I can’t help but wonder if his father killed his first wife and only pretended she ran away. That would be a secret befitting of a Foxworth man. Or maybe Malcolm accidentally pushed his mom down a flight of stairs and his father covered it up. The possibilities are endless.
But as far as the book says, she ran off with some faceless lover. Who is also now a suspect in her possible murder. We’re going down the rabbit hole here.
Talk about his hated mother always gets Malcolm’s libido fired up.
r/VCAndrews • u/Infamous-Thought-765 • 2d ago
Chris Sr.
And then years later, Chris Jr. follows in his father's footsteps.
r/VCAndrews • u/Infamous-Thought-765 • 3d ago
What are your thoughts on “My Wedding”?
________________
So now it’s time for their rushed wedding. How romantic! No one will be showing up on Malcolm’s side because his father is traveling, and apparently, there’s no one else for him to invite. Not suspicious at all! Olivia invites her maternal aunt and her cousin John Amos. John is 18, and I'll bet he looks like a younger version of the creepy bald butler he will one day become.
Malcolm and Olivia’s first kiss as a married couple is disappointing.
Olivia’s father tells her to be good to Malcolm from here on out. Funny, he doesn’t demand that Malcolm be good to his daughter!
Malcolm tells Olivia a little more about Foxworth Hall and how rich he is. He wants to be even more rich and have even more status, not just in Virginia but in the entire U.S. Good to know he has sensible dreams. Malcolm says his mansion has about 30-40 rooms. And he’s cut back on the help, but it’s no problem because he has Olivia now. So there you go. He didn’t want a wife. He wanted a maid without having to justify the expense. He’s practical, if nothing else.
So they arrive at Foxworth Hall, and Olivia soon learns that, with all the spare rooms available to them, they will be retiring to their separate quarters.
I wish I lived in Foxworth Hall. Having a nice toasty fire set for me in my own cozy room?
Then again, Foxworth Hall does eventually burn to the ground, like, 40 years later. So maybe we foresaw that coming.
r/VCAndrews • u/Capital-Study6436 • 3d ago
r/VCAndrews • u/Infamous-Thought-765 • 4d ago
What are your thoughts on “The First Bud of Spring"?
__________________________
So we open with an addendum to Olivia Foxworth’s Last Will and Testament. She says that it’s time for us to hear her side of the story. When you’ve been painted as a torturer and murderer of small children, it’s only natural to want to give your version of the facts. If only every dead person prepared themselves for a stain on their family name in this way. I want to point out that this must have been written up well before Cathy crashed the Christmas party, for that was the same night the grandmother died. So yes, Grandma Olivia planned ahead, knowing that when you do evil things to helpless children who can’t fight back, one day, when they are older, they might just muster up the nerve to tell everyone your dirty little secrets.
So here are the facts, per the evil grandmother.
It all began when Olivia Winfield – an awkward spinster who still lived at home into adulthood – met a handsome blond man named Malcolm Foxworth one night when her father invited him over to the house for dinner. If you’ve read the other books in the series, you know that Malcom is the filthy rich grandfather who ruled his family with an iron fist. Olivia is shocked when she realizes that he has taken an interest in her. This whole courtship reminds me of my grandparents a little. My grandmother met my grandfather when her father invited him over to the house for dinner. And they also went to church together. That’s about where the similarities end, thankfully.
Malcolm proposes to Olivia after a total of about two dates in rapid succession.
Olivia sees no red flags, though she announces right off that she was very naive because apparently, despite Malcolm’s eagerness to marry her, he had said nothing about loving her. Surprise surprise, this businessman seems to be treating their proposed marriage as little more than a business transaction.
r/VCAndrews • u/Capital-Study6436 • 4d ago
r/VCAndrews • u/More-Raspberry-3784 • 4d ago
Love this community, I trust your recommendations :p
r/VCAndrews • u/Capital-Study6436 • 5d ago
Chris Sr/Corinne.
Cathy/Anyone.
Audrina/Arden.
Heaven/Logan.
Dawn/Michael.
r/VCAndrews • u/Infamous-Thought-765 • 5d ago
So I'm thinking we start discussing Garden of Shadows tomorrow? Olivia needs to tell her side of the story. I was thinking we could discuss a couple chapters a day with maybe the weekends to get caught up.
How do you rank the original five?
r/VCAndrews • u/lzardonaleash • 6d ago
For me, the least is Lillian Cutler. She had a terrible childhood and tons of tragedies poured on her and so of course she’s not going to be able to form healthy attachments, but I just feel like ‘dead inside’ would be more realistic than ‘vindictive witch.’ She doesn’t even love her ‘won me in a poker game’ husband so why would she even care if he’s sleeping around? And as someone who WAS the pretty girl who was raped, she should have more sympathy for Laura. Would have felt more realistic had she taken Dawn to raise instead.
The most, I feel like has to be Luke Casteel. That generational poverty is no joke, especially at that place and time. He thought he was gonna make it out and then fate struck him. In spite of his heavy depression, he DID do his best to try and make sure the kids were cared for. I believe he knew Jane needed a doctor badly. And I also think he expected Fanny to get some discipline and never considered she would be abused.
r/VCAndrews • u/purplekat76 • 7d ago
I’m old enough that I was sneaking the Flowers in the Attic, Heaven, and Audrina books from my older sister as they were being released. I want to reread and also read the books I missed, but I know that there are so many other series now from the ghost writer and also additions to FITA.
I know I definitely want to read all of FITA, Heaven, and Dawn. What are the other series that are also worth reading that you would recommend?
r/VCAndrews • u/Infamous-Thought-765 • 7d ago
All the VCA characters are in a Friday the 13th movie. Who's going first? Who makes it to the end? Who's the bad guy?
Malcolm is the one in the mask. A camp was created on Foxworth Lake, and he haunts the premises. Philip goes first while pestering Dawn. Dawn is in the wrong place at the wrong time and unfortunately goes next. Audrina makes it to the end, starts the car but the movie ends with someone popping out of the backseat and grabbing her as she's distracted by her sister in the window.
r/VCAndrews • u/Capital-Study6436 • 7d ago
r/VCAndrews • u/Infamous-Thought-765 • 7d ago
Bart: Who's this random man taking our picture?
John: Only men can take a good family portrait.
Corrine: Oh, you...
Jory: Who gave Bart a bowl cut? Doesn't seem like something Mom would bother to do. I thought he was growing it out!
r/VCAndrews • u/Infamous-Thought-765 • 8d ago
So does it sound good to start a Garden of Shadows book chat on Monday?
In the meantime, what songs would you add to a Dollanganger playlist? My additions are below.
"Only You" by Yazoo (Every man to Cathy)
"Woke Up This Morning" by Alabama 3 (The Sopranos Theme) for Cathy in Petals on the Wind but maybe some others like Malcolm
"I Go To Extremes" by Billy Joel (Cathy and Baby Bart)
"Money (That's What I Want)" by Barrett Strong (Corrine and Bart Jr.)
"Notorious" by Duran Duran (Malcolm)
"Footloose" by Kenny Loggins (Jory)
"I'm Alright" by Kenny Loggins from Caddyshack (Chris Sr.)
"Axel F" (Beverly Hills Cop theme) by Harold Faltermeyer (Jory in ITBT)
"Father Figure" by George Michael (😬)
"Cold As Ice" by Foreigner (Olivia)
Honorable Mention: " U Can't Touch This" by MC Hammer (Olivia)
r/VCAndrews • u/MrsPhuckHughson • 9d ago
How did we all feel about Ruby marrying him and then having the role play night with the Confederate soldier fantasy? Because it made me want to scrub my brain.
r/VCAndrews • u/Capital-Study6436 • 9d ago
r/VCAndrews • u/Infamous-Thought-765 • 9d ago
What are your final thoughts on the first four books? Any headcanons?