UPDATE 2: I did not receive the J&J - instead, I received the Novavax vaccine which I have been waiting nearly a year for. I will have to deal with some personal and career related repercussions as a result, but I will be able to sleep easy knowing my concerns and the outstanding questions I have aren’t relevant to this type of vaccine. Best of luck to all.
UPDATE: u/827753 was able to alleviate my concerns through rational respectful discussion. Risks of negative effects due to spike proteins entering the nucleus is likely irrelevant, as the immune system destroys the factory cells. The follow up concern of the vaccine entering brain cells and leading to destruction of those brain cells is minimized by the difficulty of both the LNPs and adenovirus passing through the blood brain barrier, and their viability after passing through the heart. They acknowledged that there are uncertainties and non zero possibilities of negative effects, but reduced those risks to negligible through evidence and logic.
I have booked my J&J shot for Thursday.
To those who simply dismissed my concerns using ad hominem attacks, red herrings, and non-sequiturs - you will never help anyone with a bad attitude like that. People who are unvaccinated against COVID19 are not all irrational, unintelligent people, or even anti-vaccination.
Arriving at the right conclusion through faulty logic and/or blind trust doesn’t make you intelligent - it makes you lucky.
Let me please preface this by saying I am not anti-vaccination. I studied micro-biology and biochemistry for 2.5 years before transitioning to engineering, so while I’m by no means an expert in the field, I understand the basic science and know vaccines are effective.
I have a concern, that quite frankly, nobody has been able to quell and I’m hoping there are some much more knowledgeable people on the matter that could put my mind at ease.
I am a skeptic by nature and while I know the people working on these mRNA vaccines are brilliant, I also know they are human. I also understand the scope of the problem and know that people had to work quickly to implement a solution to a novel virus. There exists room for unintended consequences.
My preference has been to delay taking the mRNA vaccines and holding out until Novavax is available in my location, as my concerns do not hold true with Novavax. However, due to personal and job related reasons, it would be extremely beneficial for me to take the J&J vaccine this week. Novavax is supposed to be available on Tuesday, but I will not be fully vaccinated in time taking Novavax.
My primary concern at the moment is the findings of this study:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8538446/
Essentially, full length spike protein was found to inhibit DNA repair mechanism in-vitro. The primary concern is negative impact on the immune system, but also, the inherent elevated risk of cancer in mucking with these mechanisms.
I understand this is in-vitro. I understand that the spike protein coded for in the mRNA based vaccines is a modified version. But it is still the full length spike protein - it’s simply been modified to have a trans membrane domain added to keep it from exiting the cell completely and wandering through the human body (correct me if I’m wrong).
So, the reality is, normal full length spike protein enters the cell nucleus and inhibits DNA repair mechanisms in-vitro. This has not been confirmed yet by any published work in-vivo, but given the in-vitro results, an in-vivo study would be warranted. While the spike protein in the vaccines is modified from the original, they are both identical in that they contain the full length spike. It’s quite possible that the expressed modified spike proteins are similar enough to affect these mechanisms as well. It certainly warrants further study.
Like I said, the people who developed these mRNA vaccines are brilliant, but there’s still lots we don’t know and we are learning. If these modified spike proteins did enter the nucleus and affect DNA repair, that would concerning. Or have we studied this? Can someone find evidence that this is not a concern?
Like I said, I would like to overcome this hesitancy for a number of reasons. But unless I’m sure, I can’t justify injecting myself with a potentially carcinogenic (if the results of this study are reproduced in-vivo with the modified spike) immune dis regulating vaccine when an option that I have no concerns about is right around the corner.
So, if someone could put my mind at ease and convince me to get the J&J this week, it would save me a lot of trouble.