86
25
u/_spaderdabomb_ Aug 28 '24
lol I like how u just show the picture of the purple asset instead of showing the asset itself and all of the materials/textures that went into it. Big scammy vibes on that one. I would highly recommend showing the raw files it creates rather than just a likely externally generated ai image.
21
u/DannyWeinbaum Indie Aug 28 '24
None of these are real gamedev tasks. They're like... editor shortcuts to basic operations but slower since you have to type them out in english.
I'm imagining trying to build an actual feature or level like this and it seems excruciating. Even the meaningless task you made for it, which is randomly scattering prefabs, you had to tediously type the exact coordinates for. What if you wanted to cut a river through? What would you have to type? And then what if you needed the river to and end at a specific spot? And what if the resulting river looks terrible? What could you type to fix it? What if you wanted steeper banks? What if you wanted to clad props along the banks?
I have yet to see a single one of these AI text boxes do an actual gamedev task.
3
u/DaTruPro75 Aug 28 '24
For some boring tasks, it might be a bit faster. Instead of creating 5 cubes, if you wanted to create 20 all with a rigidbody and script it might be a bit quicker than just creating 1 and copy pasting it 19 more times.
11
u/DannyWeinbaum Indie Aug 28 '24
I mean i could just prefab it, copy it 4 times then copy those 5 4 times. But no matter how I do it it's taking me a few seconds. Ultimately stuff like that accounts for .00000001% of my production time, and 0% of my hard problems. Like we're talking about copying a few prefabs here! It seems a little silly to install energy hungry middleware to help me make that insignificant portion slightly faster.
And if it messes up even once I just undid all the time I saved.
5
u/PuffThePed Aug 28 '24
if you wanted to create 20
Then you really should make it a prefab and instantiate them in code.
99
3
3
u/puzzleheadbutbig Aug 29 '24
I'm not AI hater like some folks here, but hell, there is no way for me to pay 40-50 bucks for this. Plus, I have to pay for OpenAI? Hell no.
Also side note, linking google doc as "documentation" is a terrible idea and looks unprofessional af for an asset for such pricetag.
4
u/GamerObituary Aug 28 '24
Can I genuinely ask without getting any hate. Why do you guys hate so much AI tools like ChatGPT or this one?
Isn't it better to make things work easily for everyone, to boost creativity instead of hard worked codes?
I'm just a Game Dev Student, so I'm asking to understand lol
4
u/OggaBogga210 Aug 28 '24
Personally I don’t really hate it, i just think its a huge shame that unity wasted so much money and time on this gimmick (just because of the AI hype train + to increase their stock) They could have spent these resources on their 1000 uncooked released features
0
u/PuffThePed Aug 28 '24
Seriously, who even uses ML-Agents? The only usecase I've seen is to make gimmicky youtube videos
6
Aug 28 '24
Much of the hate is that the stuff is way overhyped. They are a great replacement from copy and pasting code from sample sample. For doing actual hard programming work? Not so much. But there is a lot of copy and paste level programming in the world. We have been trying to make it easier for like 60 year now. Code reuse (i.e. using unity ) was a big step forward. Autogenerating this code is just one more way of going.
8
u/MrMelonMatthew Aug 28 '24
AI tools like ChatGPT are language models, they are trained to provide expected responses and nothing more, they do not actually know how to program or really do anything that you ask of them
They have huge databases full of references to create what the machine believes to be a good response to what you said or asked. This means that a lot of what you get can be repetitive garbage or simply untrue, its why when asked to write a paper it can make up sources, its why you can ask it to do simple problems with fractions and it’ll mess it up. Its because all it cares about is giving a response that sounds good.
Even when it does work, results can often be over complicated or inefficient, which is probably why everyone here is so pessimistic about this tool, especially since they seem to purposefully not show us the code the AI wrote, just the result.
There are an infinite number of ways to not do something, a million ways to do something, and a handful of ways to do something well. All ChatGPT cares about is giving us something that looks like the second option
2
u/GamerObituary Aug 28 '24
I see, I agree with that. But what if the tool improves and starts to do better responses? What if ChatGPT (in this case) really starts to do a good job?
This tool would be hated too?
7
u/MrMelonMatthew Aug 28 '24
I mean, big if, but even if it did get to that point.. i don’t see the appeal. People like programming and modeling and sound design and just making games. I feel like the only setting in which getting an AI to code for you would be appealing is in a corporate setting where games are products first.
0
u/loliconest Aug 28 '24
What if someone love making games but hate programming?
5
u/MrMelonMatthew Aug 28 '24
“What if someone loves making books but hates writing”
Bestie thats an intrinsic part of making games lmao. If you get someone or something else to program your game then you didnt make your game.
It’s like getting a sandwich at subway and claiming you’re the one who made it.
0
-5
u/PuffThePed Aug 28 '24
It’s like getting a sandwich at subway and claiming you’re the one who made it.
Chefs can claim to have made a meal that they never actually touched.
5
u/MrMelonMatthew Aug 28 '24
Wow, maybe they shouldnt
-4
u/PuffThePed Aug 28 '24
Why not?
It's their design and creation. They just happen to have other people doing the chopping and frying.
What I'm trying to say is that the world is not as black and white as you think.
4
u/MrMelonMatthew Aug 28 '24
If you make a recipe then you made the recipe, congrats, that takes a lot of work and you should be recognized for it, but If someone makes a meal from that recipe then you are not the one who made the meal. You didn’t put the work into making it.
When i cook some salmon with some nice garnish and lemon juice, its not the fisherman who made that meal.
If i told a subway employee to give me a toasted 6inch meatball sub on white, im not the one who made that sandwich
4
u/MrMelonMatthew Aug 28 '24
Also i just realized, are you claiming to be a chef because you told the subway workers what sandwich to make?
-3
-1
u/TottalyNotInspired Aug 28 '24
I do not really agree with you here, I have been using claude 3.5 sonnet and gpt-4o a lot with game development and it really increases the speed and quality I can write code.
Sure sometimes it fails to solve a problem I give it, but I often am surprised how it manages to write code in seconds that would take me hours.
2
u/MrMelonMatthew Aug 28 '24
For your sake i hope its as good as you say. If there’s an issue tracing back to that ai generated code then debugging it is going to be a pain in the ass
6
u/DannyWeinbaum Indie Aug 28 '24
Because they don't do anything. They're all hype with no actual value in practice.
As an analogy, let's say developing a game is like moving a 2 ton pile of dirt from one place to another. These AI text boxes are offering to move a single teaspoon of dirt, on a table, two inches, as long as you tediously fill it's exact little teaspoon container, and with the right kind of dirt. Oh yeah and that teaspoon of dirt will go to a random location. And sometimes it will unexpectedly fling that teaspoon all over your carpet, and you will spend 20 minutes vacuuming it up.
And people who actually move dirt are having to hear all the tech bros and technologists (who have never actually moved dirt, and don't even know what the task looks like) scream "DIRT FLINGER IS THE FUTURE! DIRT FLINGER IS HERE! DIRT FLINGER WILL TAKE YOUR JOB!" So yeah the real dirt movers are gonna roll their eyes a little.
6
u/SkulGurl Aug 28 '24
Beyond the limitations of the algorithm itself, it’s massively wasteful. Like every prompt (not session, prompt) wastes about a bottle of water for coolant, it’s absurd.
2
u/Fawflopper Aug 28 '24
I want to assume two things :
-ChatGPT is ass at making code, most of the time it won't work and waste more time than anything
-If ChatGPT was to be working in a decent way, it would get hate the same way Artist hate generative AI that makes images, musics ect... Why hire a dev when you can generate a code that (kinda) work, without learning or paying anyone?
I think the best use case for ChagGPT right now, is just to use it for what it does best, generate conversations, and at best, call a function after it decides it is necessary to call it.
For example you have an NPC and you want it to talk and.. I don't know, end a conversation for example.
You will want to access Chatgpt API or have your own local gpt deployed in your game and have it generate responses like :
{ "speech" : "my shift is about to be over, hurry up", "func" :"[NULL] " }
{ "speech" : "I'm sorry but I have to go, tell me about that later", "func" :"leave" }
Those are just examples.
2
u/N-aNoNymity Aug 28 '24
ChatGPT made decent working code for me in early 2023, when I was learning python. Feels like its gotten progressively worse at everything, and now regurgitates the same answers that never work.
6
u/Fawflopper Aug 28 '24
Probably because it takes answers from itself overtime xD, its a clone of a clone of a clone that had sex with itself and all of its ancestor and that gives you the ass response you get now lmao.
-2
u/GamerObituary Aug 28 '24
That makes so much sense, thanks for the response. But still not agreeing entirely with you, cause Chat GPT can write a lot of code, but is up to you if you use and upgrade it or just copy paste into your work and make a lame work...
But again thanks, I now understand better ✨
4
u/Fawflopper Aug 28 '24
That's why I said it's an assumption, I don't use it to write my code, so I wrote two cases where one is, the code is ass, two the code is decent.
-2
u/GamerObituary Aug 28 '24
Yeah, but it helped a lot to understand anyways.
Instead of just downvote my comment like other people lmao
In my case I use it to code, but I don't like it to do all my work. I ask GPT about codes I don't remember or understand, ask for methods, functions and more specific things (for example, if it's better in performance do option A or option B, etc)
3
u/Fawflopper Aug 28 '24
Yeah don't worry, reddit be reddit lmao.
The way you use chatgpt, especially asking it why A is better than B is the best way in my opinion to learn with it.
2
u/GamerObituary Aug 28 '24
funny to see more downvotes in my coments lmao
Hope to see some posts from you in the future, mate!
Probably I'll be posting a bit later
1
2
-4
-31
u/Pampel-Games Aug 28 '24
After more than a year in beta, the first major release is here, which brings significant improvements to the core engine, along with other new features to further integrate AI into your workflow.
While AI is still in its very early days, the possibilities are incredibly exciting. Let's see what innovations await us 🧙♂️
If you want to use it, you can do so via the Unity Asset Store.
18
u/Ping-and-Pong Freelancer Aug 28 '24
£40 and then paying for the OpenAI integration on top of that - oof.
Like I'm assuming most of the features still have to be effectively hardcoded, since an AI still can't actually do things on the fly, unless you have it generating editor scripts? Then maybe that'd work, but that seems like it'd be full of issues anyway.
Most of these tasks look like something you can do reasonably quick with good experience / a good workflow, take the renaming objects for example, I am fast at that, I could do that in about the same time as typing out the prompt. Sure a prompt would probably be less mentally taxing, and if there's lots of objects that need renaming - maybe? But why wouldn't I just be doing that from a script at that point - seems like it'd be necessary if the object names are that important.
The text to speech is very cool I have to say, but currently AI like that is incredibly frowned upon (for good reason), so would I actually even be able to use it in a project?
As others have said £5 - maybe £10, sure I might go for it. But £40 for early features and I've got to pay the AI fees on top of that. It's a very hard sell, especially when I could likely implement the basic features myself in a weekend - although I'm sure you did spend a lot more time then that, it does look like a very clean interface, and likely lots of trial and error.
-12
u/Pampel-Games Aug 28 '24
It is not error free, sure, as public ChatGPT. 10 bucks is a bit cheap though, maybe we can meet in the middle at some point in the future...
4
Aug 28 '24
In the future yes, when the product is released. Roughly $50 for an unfinished AI is absurd though
29
u/PuffThePed Aug 28 '24 edited Aug 28 '24
My personal take on this:
It looks really interesting, but I'm not paying almost $50 to play with "early days" AI that I have no idea if it actually works well enough to be useful.
If this was $5 or $10 I would probably buy it just for the hell of it, but $50 with no easy way to refund, no way.
-19
u/Pampel-Games Aug 28 '24
There’s a ridiculous amount of development time invested in it. But okay, the end-user only pays for what they think is valuable to them. So, I tend to agree with you. You can wait a year or two; the price will probably come down over time...
7
Aug 28 '24
But okay, the end-user only pays for what they think is valuable to them
Yeah, no one cares how long it took you, or how hard it was. What they care about is the value for the price. I feel like any game dev that has been in the industry long enough should know this.
4
u/Techie4evr Aug 28 '24
I think you're going about this bass ackwards ... You should start with a lower price, gets more people in the door, gives you more feedback, and thus you'd probably progress quicker to the point where you can justify raising the price. Putting in ridiculous amounts of Development time and charging cheap prices is all a part of the Developers game.
-3
u/DaleGribbleBluGrass Aug 28 '24 edited Aug 28 '24
So I'm not advanced as many of you here. I do udon and C# for VRchat to make worlds or avatars, this would be nice to speed things up for simple scripts especially if it can do udon. I wonder if it will be able to tell the difference for simple scripts with player sync vs local only. Might have to give this a try on a test project to see if it can help speed up things up or how advanced it can get with some things I've seen but don't know how to do. Would be a good way to learn in my opinion if it can do scripts you don't know how to do but can then open up and see how it did it.(If it actually works haha) Edit ah one of those groups that just down vote people for speaking, good to know goodbye.
31
Aug 28 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/PuffThePed Aug 28 '24
On r/Unity3D, yes. On the store? I don't if this sub is an accurate representation of of the asset store demographics.
6
u/PuffThePed Aug 28 '24
Can I ask it to find stuff?
Like, find where this function is being referenced in the scene.