r/Ubuntu • • Dec 25 '20

Linux Alternative

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

200 comments sorted by

226

u/EternityForest Dec 25 '20

OpenSCAD is not an AutoCAD alternative! It's a programming language that specifies geometry through code!

The Linux CAD most people want is probably Realthunder's assembly3 fork of FreeCAD: https://github.com/realthunder/FreeCAD_assembly3 which fixes a lot of issues like topological naming, and it's a real CAD as you would expect, not just a programming language.

26

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Neat, thanks I might check it out. But as a whole...

I'm gonna stick with the standard CAD programs. Those are not something I want to be dealing with extra issues in.

9

u/Wrench_Scar Dec 25 '20

FreeCad is powerful but workflow is painful and constraints choke you everywhere. You have to fully define the geometry, which is cumbersome if you don't know all dimensions like say two circles whose centers are know and you make a common tangent to make a curve like shape "S"

And when you trim the rest good luck with defining that.

Otherwise it's pretty good also offers some other workbenches, I like the CAM of it plus obviously if you want you can just code or copypaste to add various strategies

I feel like I should mention Onshape here, if you really don't want to use windows or wine. Onshape is great can even use on my phone browser they have free version and recently they went under PTC

2

u/gnosys_ Dec 25 '20

Solidworks and Fusion360 are also constraint based CAD programs, FreeCAD is not different or harder to use from that perspective.

1

u/elliptic_hyperboloid Dec 26 '20

Onshape is my go to for personal stuff, especially since I don't have a Windows computer. Coming from a solidworks background the learning curve isn't too bad and it can do everything a hobby user needs to do.

1

u/gnosys_ Dec 25 '20

FreeCAD is, for the most part, excellent. The areas where its capabilities are under heavy development, dragons definitely, but a lot of the fundamentals are very good and performant. 100% can not do everything that Fusion360 (nevermind Solidworks) can do, but it can do a lot with some professional architects and engineers sincerely using it for their professional work.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

What about an InDesign alternative?

7

u/reven80 Dec 25 '20

Maybe Scribus?

4

u/gnosys_ Dec 25 '20

people keep saying this, and i wish they would stop.

1

u/stueytheboy Dec 26 '20

Is it not? I've only used InDesign a few times, but Scribus seemed similar, though I've also only used it a couple of times.

1

u/gnosys_ Dec 26 '20

it's not even remotely close at all. we're not talking the difference between inkscape and illustrator, like they are just worlds apart.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '20

Really? I gotta agree with stueytheboy here. I used Scribus for a project that required InDesign and it did the job. I don't know. Maybe there's something I'm missing.

2

u/gnosys_ Dec 25 '20

does not exist.

1

u/EpsomHorse Dec 25 '20

Sort of, kind of... LaTeX. It is nothing at all like InDesign to use, but its output is the same thing ID puts out.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '20

I think LaTeX suffers from exactly the same problem as scribus... It is possible to create something comparable to the product of inDesign, but the route getting there just isn't what people are after.

I mean you could, in theory, typeset a document perfectly well using open office. It would be a hellish process and there would be a high proportion of jank... But the resulting PDF might be close enough. Doesn't mean it's a real alternative.

LaTeX is powerful and useful, particularly with academic subjects, mathematics and such... But the average user wanting to make something shouldn't have to deal with it. It's specialised, not generalised.

InDesign works particularly well because, even with a small bit of knowledge the process of creating a document in it guides the user. It helps create good documents. The workflow is also solid enough and deep enough for professional use too. I mean, I've spent a lot of time with all of these platforms and trying to get optical character alignment in anything else is a very difficult. InDesign has a checkbox for it.

Tldr: it isn't what the program is capable of, it is what the experience of creating is like that drives how well an alternative works.

1

u/EpsomHorse Dec 26 '20

Agree completely.

0

u/EpsomHorse Dec 26 '20

One thing... in LaTeX getting OCA is as easy as loading the microtype package.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '20

Easy? Not sure that's the right word, especially for gui-focussed users. Compare the following to the checkbox that comes with InDesign by default:

Installation

To install the package, use one of the following methods (in decreasing order of simplicity):

Use the package manager of your TEX system (TEXLive: tlmgr install microtype; MiKTEX: MiKTEX Package Manager).

Download microtype.tds.zip from CTAN, extract it in the root of one of your TDS trees, and update the filename database.

Get the source (microtype.zip) from CTAN and extract it, run latex on microtype.ins to generate the package and configuration files, and move all generated files into a directory where LATEX will find them, e.g., TEXMF/tex/latex/microtype/.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/AcostaJA Dec 25 '20

Absolutely right, but speaking of AutoCAD alternative (in general) it's a bit pretentious as even with freecad the learning curve for someone coming from AutoCAD simple don't pay, it's the big issue with professional software, users use to end running AutoCAD on a VM if they can't have a native version.

Same for blender (while it's very popular in windows too)

1

u/EternityForest Dec 25 '20

Yeah, if you come from the paid software there seems to be some issues when learning the FOSS ones.

But for low budget types like me without a degree, nothing I run into at work is particularly hard with FOSS, all the modern tools are easy if that's where you started.

The exception is PCB design until really recently, now that we have LibrePCB. KiCAD is one of the only open source programs I've ever tried, and immediately went back to proprietary.

Blender took a long while to have a good UI, but it's fantastic now.

1

u/Joedang100 Dec 26 '20

For a lot of engineering, stuff like AutoCAD is also at least a decade in the past. In mechanical/aerospace engineering, pretty much everything is done in parametric* CAD these days -- stuff like SolidWorks, Fusion 360, and NX. As much as I absolutely loathe those softwares... they are really the right tool to use, and are leaps and bounds ahead of anything available in the open-source world.

when I tried FreeCAD, it wasn't very good. I found it to be significantly worse than AutoCAD, TBH. I haven't tried that branch of FreeCAD, but I think it's kind of moot anyways. For at least the last decade, anything that isn't parametric is pretty much not worth using for mechanical assembly/component design.

* For context, in parametric design, you essentially write a script that describes how your geometry is constructed. Each step of that procedure takes in some parameters (and usually some pointer to an abstract representation of geometry) and spits out some new abstract representation of geometry. It's very different from something like AutoCAD or OpenSCAD, which -- if I recall -- tend to only represent geometry in terms of lines, arc segments, and triangles and don't strictly keep track of topology.

1

u/EternityForest Dec 26 '20

FreeCAD considers itself to be parametric, but I've never used anything else so I don't exactly know the difference. It's definitely not a direct drawing app like blender, everything is done with constraints, which can be expressions that use values from a spreadsheet.

Under the hood, I'm not exactly sure how it understands geometry. You can draw 2D arcs and splines that are real curves, and you can put a fillet on a corner, and it's a real abstract feature you can edit later.

But you do run into topological naming issues unless you use the Realthunder fork, the standard version isn't happy if you go back and edit prior things that have future dependancies. I stick with the Realthunder assembly3 variant.

And sometimes tools like fillet can't quite figure out what to do, so the underlying geometry libraries might not be as good as paid software, but I can't really compare.

1

u/Street_Platypus_4410 Feb 17 '23

Hey, that's quite good. I use some CAD app on the highschool and we make a pattern using code

0

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

[deleted]

1

u/gnosys_ Dec 25 '20

i tried out BricsCAD and although it's probably a very good program, it is a professional (complex) piece of software that has a specific niche which is BIM (architecture).

in my opinion basically requires professional training materials, not something you can just pick up and play with. it's also the price of professional software which makes it less accessible.

47

u/-ShutterPunk- Dec 25 '20

Darktable and kdenlive all day! Resolve if you want to get serious.

6

u/shrodingercat5 Dec 25 '20

kdenlive is amazing

56

u/UncleComrade Dec 25 '20

I'd rather say Darktable is a Lightroom alternative tho...

0

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Lightroom is also a photo catalogue. DT s too limited for that.

4

u/abelom Dec 25 '20

Digikam would be a better fit I'd say.

1

u/stueytheboy Dec 26 '20

Heard good things regarding cataloguing. I like Rapid Photo Downloader on Ubuntu, but I also have a Mac for which it is not available.

46

u/Catlover790 Dec 25 '20

kdenlive > lightworks IMO

15

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Or even DaVinci Resolve

4

u/vs8 Dec 26 '20

Kdenlive is good but it can only do basic edits. Resolve can handle much more and it uses hardware acceleration. Sadly it's not open source but it's the only real video editor that runs on Linux.

4

u/fejorca Dec 25 '20

Openshot is good also

2

u/Avamander Dec 25 '20

Blender > kdenlive for sure

21

u/Maoschanz Dec 25 '20

Why do people keep reposting this? Why do people keep upvoting this? Don't we all know it's fake outdated bullshit by now?

6

u/mogoh Dec 25 '20

I wish. This is such a bad list and people keep upvoating it.

28

u/5HT-Serotonin Dec 25 '20

To be honest Gimp lacks alot of features that Photoshop provides. I still wish Photoshop for Linux so I can finally remove Windows.

35

u/xwp-michael Dec 25 '20

Most of these alternatives lists come from people who've never had to use the "original" software for anything above entry or hobbyist level.

No professional would use Gimp over Photoshop in the industry. And that AutoCad alternative is even worse.

-12

u/bman123457 Dec 25 '20

What professional in any field is using linux for anything? Linux users are mostly computer hobbyists and as such are only really going to use these at a hobbyist level or maybe a "productive at home" work use.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Most dev work happens in Linux.

-8

u/bman123457 Dec 25 '20

Dev work isn't something that you are needing alternative software for. My point is that their aren't professionals out there using linux and struggling for windows alternative software. Professionals just use whatever the standard in their field is.

11

u/Grammar-Bot-Elite Dec 25 '20

/u/bman123457, I have found an error in your comment:

“point is that their [there] aren't professionals”

I consider the post by you, bman123457, invalid; it should say “point is that their [there] aren't professionals” instead. ‘Their’ is possessive; ‘there’ is a pronoun or an adverb.

This is an automated bot. I do not intend to shame your mistakes. If you think the errors which I found are incorrect, please contact me through DMs or contact my owner EliteDaMyth!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '20

What professional in any field is using linux for anything? Linux users are mostly computer hobbyists and as such are only really going to use these at a hobbyist level or maybe a "productive at home" work use.

That post above, and this post below

Dev work isn't something that you are needing alternative software for. My point is that their aren't professionals out there using linux and struggling for windows alternative software. Professionals just use whatever the standard in their field is.

are saying two very different things. Make up your mind instead of shifting goal posts. Or take the time to write a complete thought the first time.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

LMFAO

1

u/semitones Dec 25 '20

Lightworks for example is a professional-level software; some AAA movies have been made with it. IDK about the others.

2

u/ckydes Dec 25 '20

You should try Krita, has a lot more features imo and come closer to photoshop although it wouldnt replace photoshop completely.

26

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

I love Linux, but anyone who says FreeCAD is an actual alternative to AutoCAD has never used either. OpenSCAD isn't the software itself, it's the programming language that's used in FreeCAD. AutoCAD isn't even good, but still miles ahead of any FreeCAD fork.

5

u/gnosys_ Dec 25 '20

OpenSCAD is not the lanugage FreeCAD is written in, it is a different CAD program which is console-based (you use objects and methods to syntactically describe the object you're modelling).

FreeCAD is an alternative to Solidworks or Fusion360, as a constraint based modeller, but it is of course much more limited. FreeCAD is still a very good program. i'm also not aware of any forks of FreeCAD

also weird that your judgment of what is and isn't a good piece of software puts an extremely expensive and widely used program in the "not good" category i'm curious what you think would be good

0

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

There is no CAD software that's actually good, but some are slightly less bad than others. For CAD software you 100% get what you pay for, so CATIA is the least terrible option. The constraint tool is a pain to use, but at least it has a decent assembly module and actually working ISO 6983 geometry export.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20 edited Jan 15 '24

imminent pen engine payment price sink march foolish longing kiss

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

It's always best to use the same CAD software everybody else at your school also uses. The older versions of AutoCAD seem to run decently with Wine, but newer versions (~2010-ish and later) are actual shit. Virtualization isn't a good idea either. If your version doesn't run with Wine, just do a minimal Windows install with like 20 GB allocated space that literally just runs AutoCAD and nothing else.

6

u/Step1Mark Dec 25 '20

I forgot about Lightworks.

Why not use DaVinci Resolve? It's one of the most popular video editors, free up to 4K timelines, and basically the industry standard for color grading.

19

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Thanks. If I ever have to use windows I'll have a look at this list.

4

u/semitones Dec 25 '20

The thing is, a lot of the ones on the "linux" side you can also use on windows!

5

u/canceralp Dec 25 '20

Slightly irrelevant but, is there a way to work with Natron, Kdenlive and Audacity "together", just like Adobe products do by transferring projects only, without exporting the whole thing?

5

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

You might want to look at blender if integration is important for you.

Edit video and audio, node based compositing, and of course the 3d package.

5

u/canceralp Dec 25 '20

I tried making a video with Blender before. It took me more than 3 days to search for a simple sharpening effect -which can be done in 5 seconds in any NLE- and than gave up. I'm using it for 3D modeling, but for video editing: no..

3

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

I have not edited for a while, but I hear there are some advancements made, also some plugins

But still effects like that are probably better done in the compositor.

I totally get it though, it's not on the level of a dedicated editor.

On the other hand integration is really well done, and for the right kind of project, it can be really powerful with the video editor combined.

I hear great things about the video editor combined with real time 3d scenes being used as storyboard and scene planning.

There are definitely workflows to use the video editor effectively, but its different from the normal video editing workflow, and admittedly a bit counter intuitive.

5

u/NJG86 Dec 25 '20

Any tip for an Adobe pro PDF editor (or whatever the name is/was) alternative?

3

u/zaimond Dec 25 '20

The closest I've been able to find is Master PDF Editor, but it's not open source. If anyone has a open source alternative I would love to hear it.

There are loads of command line utilities that combined do most of the stuff I need (OCR, rearranging pages etc), but I haven't found any open source GUI application that comes close to Adobe Acrobat Pro.

5

u/KiloGex Dec 25 '20

I would not consider GIMP a Photoshop alternative. It's good for graphic layout, but horrible at actual digital art.

I'd suggest Krita instead. Still free and open source, but more better for art.

4

u/HothFirstTrumpet Dec 25 '20

I worked in Lightworks for a while. It's really good. DaVinci Resolve is crazy good now. Beyond the coloring, It has a compositor built in, as well as most of the features that you'd get in an audio DAW. I'm a professional musician and audio engineer, so that's pretty huge to me. I can do most of the audio editing I need to do for videos now without having to necessarily go to any of my audio software, and it finds and works with all of my audio plugins as well. Some of the more advanced features like the image stabilization actually look to be worth the price tag after trying them and seeing them watermarked. Like I said- have a lot of love for Lightworks, but resolve is just ridiculous.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

I'd also add the Da Vinci resolve works really well for editing, grading and compositing video on Linux.

It's not open source, but it easily goes toe to toe with Adobe Premiere.

I really do wish there was a similar alternative for inDesign. Scribus just isn't in the same league. It's like using MS Paint when you are used to Photoshop... You can get the job done, but it's very much the long way.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Please tell me that no one uses dream weaver anymore.

10

u/Tyl0 Dec 25 '20

Also, many of these Linux alternative softwares are also available on Windows. So if someone is deciding to switch over to Linux, you can try many of these on Windows rn

11

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

That's how I switched to Linux. All the software I was using was open source, so I figured I'd get an open-source operating system to run it all.

15

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Yeah... Gimp isn't Photoshop alternative either

6

u/Nurgus Dec 25 '20

To Photoshop purists, nothing is a Photoshop alternative unless it's a feature complete clone.

6

u/petepete Dec 25 '20

The only real alternative is Affinity Photo. Not 100% feature complete but more than enough for most people.

I'd love it if Serif released a Linux version.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

[deleted]

3

u/Nurgus Dec 25 '20

You can say something similar for every single "alternative". It's missing the point. None of them are feature perfect clones.

1

u/reddittookmyuser Dec 25 '20

Hope they didn't make this in Gimp. Terrible job on the Linux alternatives side.

3

u/theorem_llama Dec 25 '20

For a Lightroom alternative I also highly recommend Darktable. I can't understand why people continue to pay the exorbitant fees for Lightroom.

1

u/AxisFlip Dec 25 '20

I really want to like darktable, but I just can't get warm to it.

1

u/theorem_llama Dec 26 '20

To be fair, sometimes I feel there's too much choice in it. There are many ways of achieving the same thing, and if you're a bit of a perfectionist you can find yourself looking for guides on how best to do a certain thing. With a change of mindset though (if the photo looks good it's good) and getting down a good workflow, I really like it. I also like that it saves the sidecar files in the same folders as the photos, which some people don't. I find this makes baking up your raws and sidecars more logical.

3

u/joshpetit Dec 25 '20

Blender isn't really an alternative per say, I think it's most people's first choice now which is awesome!

9

u/thatgreatdragon2000 Dec 25 '20

Libre Office sucks for its poor formatting and compatibility with MS office. It's really frustrating when I download the file ,opened it in Libre and the formatting is all wrong.OnlyOffice or FreeOffice is better

13

u/vancity- Dec 25 '20

This might be considered corpo-blasphemy, but Google Drive is probably the best Office Alternative available.

3

u/dataispower Dec 25 '20

Agreed. I have moved entirely to the Google cloud office services. I don't love using them, but LibreOffice is so hard to use and the Google services sync across devices which is really nice for me.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

I might have lucked out but I never had any compatibility issues since the new formats (like docx) have been introduced.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '20

Bad compatibility? Microsoft is in the consortium that develops the odf format, and the literal first thing Ms office asks when you install is if you want to use its openxml format or odf format.

I have never had any issues whatsoever - which makes sense, it's their own format!

Remember, Microsoft pretty well supports Linux these days, like, I can and have installed Skype and edge on lubuntu and I have installed Ubuntu in my windows 10 ( I dual boot) from the Microsoft store!

1

u/adasiko Dec 29 '20

It’s not about who is format owner. There are two very different and complicated formats. It’s not possible create good converter from one to another.

2

u/secur3gamer Jan 04 '21

Libre Office sucks for its poor formatting and compatibility with MS office. It's really frustrating when I download the file ,opened it in Libre and the formatting is all wrong.OnlyOffice or FreeOffice is better

If you don't know how to use it, sure. The formatting issues are caused by not having mscorefonts installed. Install them with:

sudo apt install ttf-mscorefonts-installer

I found this out because I had to work with people in uni who used Windows and I could never figure out why the formatting was always off. It's because when they use Times New Roman (or any other Windows font) it defaults to Liberation Serif when opening in Libre Office.

4

u/cediddi Dec 25 '20

As a developer, bluefish feels like it's the windows movie maker, Dreamweaver feels like imovie.

11

u/dontc9 Dec 25 '20

It's 2020, wysiwyg is dead.

1

u/cediddi Dec 26 '20

Except it didn't, wysiwyg lives with qt designer, xcode, android studio, they all have wysiwyg interfaces, plus there's bootstrap studio. Writing html, rendering it realtime, plus inspecting it is split now. Writing is on text editors, real time rendering is usually a plugin, and inspection is done on the fully fledged browsers. Ftp client is usually still embedded or plugged to the editors.

What I'm saying is, wysiwyg is a very good concept, Dreamweaver is archaic relative to modern technologies.

2

u/dontc9 Dec 26 '20

True, I was talking about web development thought.

2

u/roelofjanelsinga Dec 25 '20

As an alternative to Raw Therapee, try Darktable. It's a little less technical and aligns better with Lightroom. I've really enjoyed using it for the past year!

2

u/lucifer955 Dec 25 '20

Lightworks!!! Is that good enough to do a basic video editing stuff?

2

u/GeneralDumbtomics Dec 25 '20

Some of these "replacments" are doing some mighty heavy lifting. Looking at you OpenSCAD.

2

u/larsjoo Dec 25 '20

Adobe Illustrator - Inkscape

Corel Draw - Krita

2

u/1337HxC Dec 25 '20

Can I get an Illustrator alternative?

We've been using Inkscape... anything better around?

2

u/AltitudinousOne Dec 25 '20

Not for Linux, unfortunately. They have been trying for yonks to get affinity designer to work in wine, but nothing concrete so far. It's definitely a gap. Inkscape is not a bad app, but some aspects of its design are quite counter intuitive. I use it regularly but I would be lying if I didn't say it frustrates me.

1

u/HounddogGray Dec 26 '20

No CMYK in Inkscape is an instant deal breaker for me.

1

u/HounddogGray Dec 26 '20

Look for Gravit Designer Pro, it looks quite interesting. They have a free version as well, but IIRC, it's pretty limited.

3

u/GLVic Dec 25 '20

I'm using google office suit in browser as an alternative to ms office.

Libre office is still not great after all those years, but I understand why someone would prefer it over google product.

3

u/ColdFireBreath Dec 25 '20

I prefer Krita over Inkscape

4

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Krita is primarily a raster graphics editing tool (editing changes the value of pixels), inkscape is a vector graphics editing tool (uses math to describe a shape so it never loses quality)

krita is used for digital art while inkscape is used for logos, vector art, web graphics and stuff like that

2

u/ColdFireBreath Dec 25 '20

Krita is also capable of creating vectorial graphics, I prefer krita because I think it's easier to use.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

yes you can but the two apps are used for different stuff, i use both of them for different use cases

4

u/RepostSleuthBot Dec 25 '20

Looks like a repost. I've seen this image 1 time.

First seen Here on 2020-04-13 87.5% match.

Searched Images: 183,693,197 | Indexed Posts: 687,296,101 | Search Time: 5.89891s

Feedback? Hate? Visit r/repostsleuthbot - I'm not perfect, but you can help. Report [ False Positive ]

View Search On repostsleuth.com

2

u/firewolf8385 Dec 25 '20

A lot of those are more-so just free alternatives. I use Gimp, Blender, and LibreOffice all on Windows

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Open source for ever <3

1

u/allinwonderornot Dec 25 '20

Matlab: Octave

SPSS/Stata/SAS: R

0

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

[deleted]

1

u/thornstriff Dec 25 '20

I replaced Lightroom with Darktable. Never heard about raw therapee. Is it better?

1

u/Nightquaker Dec 25 '20

Any Adobe XD alternative?

1

u/ldshn Dec 25 '20

Is Natron as powerful as AE

2

u/ParanoidFactoid Dec 25 '20

Another insane comment.

Natron is great. No maintainer right now though. And Natron is not comparable to Ae, it's more comparable to a 2d version of Nuke 3d.

And no shape vectors, wiggle function, or roughen edges.

Blender with Animation Nodes is where you want to go if you're looking for wiggle and roughen edges on FOSS. With layers, since you can use the z axis for occlusion layers.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

I wish Adobe had good alternatives, but for better or worse, they’ve built an amazing product.

1

u/Se7enLC Dec 25 '20

Raw Therapee and not Dark Table?

1

u/ParanoidFactoid Dec 25 '20

Natron is no longer maintained. Awesome software needs a maintainer!

1

u/Ozamatheus Dec 25 '20

i love gimp but my tablet pen don't :C

1

u/ianj001 Dec 26 '20

!remindme 1 day

1

u/ronweasleysl Dec 26 '20

I would switch Raw Therapee with Darktable since the latter is going to be more familiar to Lightroom users. Also switch Lightworks with Kdenlive, Shotcut or Olive. Libre Office is good but it also doesn't have full compatibility with MS Office, I'd recommend installing OnlyOffice as well for those moments when you absolutely have to open a docx file that someone sent you. Lastly Blender can replace Adobe After Effects and Premiere as well if you put the time to learn it.

1

u/wamred Dec 26 '20

I might have to save this post for reasons of Google.

1

u/Markus_K09 Dec 26 '20

I heard most of the Linux apps like Blender and Inkspace weren't as good as their Windows counterparts.

1

u/Susan-Thapa Dec 26 '20

can someone explain me more about lightworks?

1

u/D_sagarChoureHembrom Dec 26 '20

Add 'Da-Vinci Resolve', 'PhotoGimp' & 'Krita'.

1

u/mrgodhimself Dec 26 '20

GIMP is nowhere close to being a Photoshop alternative, Krita is much better than it.

1

u/Junabled Apr 03 '21

what about music production

1

u/Soul_M93 Nov 26 '21

No Adobe Dimension alternatives 😭

I need that so much

1

u/ElSafanawy Apr 21 '23

all of these r horrible

1

u/tehlegend1937 Dec 25 '20

Cheers for Gimp for being free, but it's workflow is trash compared to Photoshop. It's impractical for a professional environment.

2

u/gnosys_ Dec 25 '20

i first switched to linux to use gimp professionally, on purpose, because for my photo editing tasks it was and remains superior to photoshop.

2

u/ParanoidFactoid Dec 25 '20

You're insane.

No. Adjustment. Layers.

1

u/gnosys_ Dec 26 '20

the trick is right-click on the layer stack and "New From Visible" to iterate adjustments in the same way as making new adjustment layers and blending modes. with the 32-bit float pixel depth you can also iterate "destructively" on a single layer pushing and pulling it around to an extreme amount without meaningful quantization. but, in my case i never twiddle knobs back and forth after setting in an adjustment so i've never missed them.

main reasons for my switch was the 32-bit float colors, different color look, and until PS copied it gimp had a better heal brush.

1

u/ParanoidFactoid Dec 26 '20

These adjustments are destructive and cannot be recombined into different orderings without recreating the entire adjustment stack.

Not. The. Same.

1

u/gnosys_ Dec 26 '20

regarding ordering, grouping, blending they absolutely can they work the same, it's also easy to insert ones in the middle. it is honestly no obstacle at all. as well the destructiveness is greatly reduced because the bit depth preserves the relative difference between the pixel values to such an extent you can crush the life out of the layer and put it back and hardly tell the difference. but again, as i say, the so-called destructiveness doesn't actually matter for me because i never go back and fiddle with things like that, really pretty pointless.

1

u/ParanoidFactoid Dec 26 '20

You are deluded.

1

u/gnosys_ Dec 26 '20 edited Dec 26 '20

yeah i guess my eight years of professional technical assistance for contemporary art photographers doesn't mean shit

like i have and do still use PS for some things, like had to help someone with this weird multi image salon-style hanging, so composed it entirely with smart objects for the layout file to be able to iterate easily. absolutely not possible with gimp, totally. but stuff like doing color correction, exposure, healing/cloning stuff, even for compositing and masking? gimp is better.

1

u/ParanoidFactoid Dec 26 '20

yeah i guess my eight years of professional technical assistance for contemporary art photographers doesn't mean shit

Not given what you're arguing.

  • No multi-select for layers. Chain tool is a ridiculous time waster. K

  • No layer styles or other nondestructive way to manipulate text and layer elements. Everything must be rasterized before applying an effect!

  • No nondestructive adjustment layers. No way to reorder effects in an effect chain. Must rasterize each effect and set in stone the chain ordering. NUTS!

  • And a photography studio that uses a tool without CMYK support for print?

Whatever, dude.

And I don't hate GIMP. I want GIMP to succeed. But it has serious workflow problems. You're insane to be arguing otherwise.

1

u/TheHeksiiii Dec 25 '20

Visual Studio - Paid Rider just doesnt cut it and made me switch back to Windows

1

u/crazyfreak316 Dec 25 '20

❤️ Inkscape

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Not gonna lie, libre office is a bit crap. Microsoft office is the best of its kind by far.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

It can do all basic editing tasks.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

In my opinion krita is a better alternative to photoshop than Gimp

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20 edited Dec 25 '20

Comparing Dreamweaver with Blue Fish is a retard move.

(Funny how kids cry and downvote. Dreamweaver ftw!

0

u/Gaspuch62 Dec 25 '20

Scribus as an alternative to InDesign

0

u/darkwyrm42 Dec 25 '20

Although I've never used ID, I'm pretty sure that Scribus can match most of what it does, but I'm pretty sure the workflow is VERY different

0

u/Gaspuch62 Dec 25 '20

I haven't used ID since High school, but a different work flow is to be expected with alternative software.

0

u/Pierma Dec 25 '20

It's pretty cool to see more alternatives but linux alternatives lack the most useful feature of all combined, a working ecosystem.
The dobe suite is not just a bunch of programs threw together, sadly

-1

u/AcostaJA Dec 25 '20

I see a lot of bias with this post, beyond "naive" suggestions as Opens and over AutoCAD (seems never actually delivered a project, even FreeCAD it's just up for hobbyist not for Pro-workflow), it's also seems to favor the political issue, as to ignore better non-gpl Linux alternatives.

-1

u/fall0ut Dec 25 '20

Calling these programs an alternative is very misleading. I do not have experience with all the alternatives, but the ones I have used pale in comparison to their inspiration programs.

-6

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

WPS office is a better alternative than libreoffice

0

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

[deleted]

55

u/EternityForest Dec 25 '20

Krita

5

u/Gaspuch62 Dec 25 '20

I love Krita.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

I totally forgot about this. Thank you!

2

u/vancity- Dec 25 '20

Me too, love me some Krita

13

u/lordkabab Dec 25 '20

My favourite is photopea.com the online Photoshop clone.

32

u/SquirrelBlind Dec 25 '20

Glimpse.

Krita is not photo editing tool, it’s more like drawing tool.

Glimpse is a fork of GIMP, but less bloated and without all the politics.

13

u/oz1sej Dec 25 '20

Politics?

4

u/BirchTree1 Dec 25 '20

Gimp is a derogatory term for people with physical disabilities.

13

u/vancity- Dec 25 '20

It's also a non-derogatory name for someone with a specific sexual kink.

7

u/BirchTree1 Dec 25 '20

Yeah. It's honestly kinda stretching, and anyone who takes offense at it can just understand it stands for the pretty generic sounding GNU Image Manipulation Program. Many instances of people getting offended can be resolved with a little communication.

2

u/d1ngal1ng Dec 26 '20

Except in those cases where they want to be offended.

1

u/BirchTree1 Dec 26 '20

True. I wish people acted genuinely and didn't get offended on the behalf of others. Let them speak for themselves.

4

u/TheMrDrB Dec 25 '20

I mean he's not wrong

1

u/doge_lady Oct 17 '21

"Bring out the gimp"

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Fix the association, nothing wrong with the animal name.

0

u/semitones Dec 25 '20 edited Feb 18 '24

Since reddit has changed the site to value selling user data higher than reading and commenting, I've decided to move elsewhere to a site that prioritizes community over profit. I never signed up for this, but that's the circle of life

10

u/Striped_Monkey Dec 25 '20

I've yet to see a significant contribution that they've made code wise, perhaps you could elaborate?

4

u/DStellati Dec 25 '20

For now they've just rebranded gimp, they are working on changes but it's still a somewhat recent project (and with gimp 3.0 around the corner they'll probably start applying changes after that release to avoid the last days of gtk2)

4

u/Striped_Monkey Dec 25 '20

So what I'm hearing is it's not less bloated or without the politics. (Hell, it adds more politics by virtue of the only thing it changes) It's just a re-brand. You're advertising it as something it's not based on the promise they'll do something other than find-and-replace "gimp" with "glimpse" (oh and changing the art).

The reason why I asked was that glimpse has been around for a not insignificant amount of time, and I've not heard a single actual piece of development work of any significance come out of it in the 3 (?) years it's been around. As far as I'm concerned it's vaporware and just exists because a few community members didn't like the name.

8

u/Igor_Grey Dec 25 '20

I think it's not critical change. It's only replace words master, slave. Bullshit

5

u/slnbl5U2VCLkuSl8Tzl Dec 25 '20

If they don't like gimp, why would they like glimpse? Isn't it merely a rename at this point?

1

u/SquirrelBlind Dec 25 '20

My bad, I thought that there was done some major refactoring.

12

u/klieber Dec 25 '20

Glimpse is a fork of GIMP, but less bloated and without all the politics.

No, "glimpse" is a fork of GIMP, where their number one "primary objective" is to "fix the problematic name".

Others are, obviously, free to use whatever they want. I have no interest in using any product where their primary goal is to be politically correct.

1

u/semitones Dec 25 '20

I don't think there's anything wrong with using it either; that's the beauty of open source

4

u/async2 Dec 26 '20

I'd say the gimp source will be more up to date and critical bugs will be fixed faster. So it's too big of a compromise for just the name

1

u/semitones Dec 26 '20

Those are good reasons to use GIMP, yes. However not everybody needs the cutting edge, especially if you are chilling on a stable version or long term release. So I think it is a reasonable choice for people who do care about it.

2

u/gnarlin Dec 26 '20

Uh, no. It's the reverse. It's Glimpse that has all the politics. Their sense of political correctness that makes them change the name because Gimp offends their delicate sensibilities.

-8

u/Igor_Grey Dec 25 '20

Politics is in someone's heads only. Software can't be political 🤦‍♂️

5

u/klieber Dec 25 '20

Software can't be political

Debian project: hold my beer

3

u/AcostaJA Dec 25 '20

Say that to Python SF about "master-slave" ban, and all languages eliminating Politically "incorrect" wordings 🤷‍♂️

1

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '20

You hear that? That's Stallman crying so hard his sobs have become recursive.

4

u/JakeDoubleyoo Dec 25 '20

Try Photopea or Pixlr. They're both browser based and free, and pretty darn good.

4

u/darkwyrm42 Dec 25 '20

Krita is as deep as Photoshop, which is great if you need that. If you want something lighter, Pinta is really nice -- think Paint.NET for Linux.

2

u/qeomash Dec 25 '20

Paint.net, though I'm not sure it works on anything but Windows

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

Should work fine on Linux with WINE (I think you need to install the Mono libraries as well though)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

The newest versions don't work but 3.5 somewhat does

2

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

There's always the option, of using a vm. Not pretty, but if you have the horsepower for it, go for it.

2

u/andrewfenn Dec 25 '20

I prefer photopea in the web browser. Maybe not everyone's cup of tea but when all you're doing in some simple things it's much easier to open quickly and work with. Also opens photoshop files and other formats gimp can't.

2

u/Plankton_Plus Dec 25 '20

GIMP is not a viable Photoshop alternative and claiming that it is really isn't doing Linux any favors. Nobody seems to be trying to create a real Photoshop alternative because of the GIMP dishonesty.

Krita is closely matches Photoshop in terms of quality, but it isn't designed to solve the same problem (Krita is for simulating physical media).

The only actual Photoshop alternative I have ever come across is Affinity, a one-time payment of $50, but it doesn't work under WINE. I have a Windows 10 VM for it.

Linux does not have a Photoshop equivalent.

1

u/xerker Dec 25 '20

+1 for photopea.

I never learned Photoshop or gimp but photopea has nice guides and can be installed as a chrome app

0

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

it has the same problem as Lightworks, though: you have to register to use their stuff, even if you stick to the freebies.

1

u/semitones Dec 25 '20

I use lightworks; it is somewhat annoying to register every so often, but is there any actual downside?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20

It's capped out at 720p with a free license. Back on Ubuntu 14.04 it was the only advanced video editor that worked so I was kinda forced to use it. Now I'm on kdenlive.

1

u/semitones Dec 25 '20

Thanks for the tip. I used it on windows since I didn't need to use anything more then 720 at the time, but these days it's more limiting than it was then