r/UVA • • Oct 19 '23

News It is Not Anti-Semitic to Criticize Israel - UVA Student Op-Ed

0 Upvotes

Hello r/UVA. We're The Jefferson Independent, a student-founded newspaper dedicated to free speech on the University of Virginia campus.

Last week we urged the condemnation of Hamas in response to the UVA chapter of Students for Justice In Palestine's tacit support for terrorist acts after stating their "unequivocal support for Palestinian liberation and the right of colonized people everywhere to resist occupation of their land by whatever means necessary."

As the conversation on Israel & Hamas developed, we decided to publish another Op-Ed.

TL;DR To conflate criticism of Israeli actions with antisemitism is absurd. No one seriously regards disapproval of Iran or Saudi Arabia's human rights records as Islamophobic. Israel has retaliated against Hamas with war crimes of its own. If we owe a moral responsibility to Israeli children, then we owe the same moral responsibility to Palestinian children.

Full Article:

After the horrors of WWII and the countless civilian atrocities, especially the Holocaust, the international community formed a coalition of nations and international institutions, all with the ostensible objective of promoting peace throughout the world and preventing an atrocity like the Holocaust from ever happening again. In 1945, the United Nations was formed; from 1948- 1950, the Nuremberg Trials were prosecuted, with Nazi and Japanese war criminals brought to justice under the first application of international law; 1950, the Geneva Conventions entered into force. During this time, this coalition of nations codified into law definitions of genocide, ethnic cleansing, crimes against humanity, and various war crimes, barring their use to prevent the total destruction of a civilian population or nation during the brutalities of war. It is clear within international law that the taking of Israeli hostages– including Holocaust survivors and activists for Palestinian rights living in Jewish communes, or Kibbutz– and the violence against civilians that Hamas perpetuated in the October 7th terror attack is illegal and condemnable. We heard many public figures, politicians, and mass media organizations condemn this violence against civilians, appropriately horrified by the massive loss of life and the sheer terror innocent children and non-combatants endured. However, we have seen almost no such condemnation of the indiscriminate bombings of civilians in Gaza, despite the rising death tolls and humanitarian crisis documented by the UN, the WHO, Amnesty International, and many more human rights organizations. See, under international law, Israel’s retaliation in response to the terror attacks is nothing short of a travesty, overstepping countless boundaries to commit crimes against humanity and repeated war crimes.

It is vital at this point to emphasize that to conflate criticism of Israeli actions with anti-semitism is an insidious usage of a straw man logical fallacy to obscure the humanitarian crisis people are protesting. To assert, as many have, that any criticism of Israel is anti-semitic is not just facially absurd, it is logically inconsistent. No one seriously refers to criticism of Iran or Saudi Arabia’s human rights records as Islamophobic, they rightly recognize that criticisms are geared towards state policy and behavior, regardless of their religious affiliation. Countless Jewish people throughout the world stand in support of Israel, and countless Jewish people have been on the streets advocating for an end to the bombings of Gaza. It is not as simplistic as a sectarian religious conflict, despite what the media would have you believe. In the past week, we’ve seen ‘reputable’ institutions like the BBC malign Pro-Palestinian protesters as “pro-Hamas,” and were subsequently forced to walk their comments back due to public pressure. Whichever stance you take as an individual, whichever stance our government officials make, all should recognize the importance and value of human life. If you are told a child has been killed, you should not need to know the religion or ethnicity of that child to feel heartbreak and despair. The absurdly sectarian rhetoric throughout the American political ecosystem since the October 7th attack has only served to accelerate hatred and ignore the humanitarian crisis Israel is creating in Gaza.

Since WWII, Israel has been the largest cumulative recipient of US foreign direct investment, with much of that aid dedicated to military purposes, comprising about 71% of Foreign Aid the State of Israel has ever received. The United States is not a neutral country in this dynamic. As significant funders of the Israeli military, our government has a moral and legal responsibility to ensure that American-made planes and bombs aren’t used by the Israeli government to commit war crimes.

Those who haven’t been exposed to constant influxes of information from reporters on the ground in Gaza and Israel likely are unaware of the extent of the war crimes Israel has engaged in in their retaliation, and may understandably see my referring to them as an overstatement. To alleviate those concerns, I’ll provide a documented list of the war crimes committed in the past week against Gazans, along with the specific law barring this behavior. At the conclusion of this list, I find it hard to believe that any objective reader would deny the severity of the crisis in Gaza or the necessity of a ceasefire, despite the fact that Congressional members of the ‘Squad’ were just excoriated for daring to propose an end to the violence. In response to these congresswomen, White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre responded by calling proposals for deescalation and peace “wrong,” “repugnant,” and “disgraceful.” This is not just a slip-up by the Press Secretary either. The Huffington Post obtained (and the Washington Post confirmed) email communiques throughout the State Department advising US diplomats about the use of three phrases in any rhetoric related to the violence: “de-escalation/ceasefire,” “end to violence/bloodshed,” and “restoring calm.” Peace is not what is repugnant. A ceasefire is not what is repugnant. What is repugnant is bombing mosques, UN safe houses, schools, hospitals, residences, and everything in between. See, the Gaza Strip is one of the most densely populated regions on earth, with over 2 million people living on a piece of land about twice the size of D.C. When Israel decided to pelt the Gaza Strip with bombs, they were fully aware of the fact that it would be impossible to not kill civilians, journalists, and even the very hostages they were ostensibly seeking the return of. Many have attempted to justify Israel’s carpet-bombing of the Gaza Strip with their right to defend themselves from terrorism under the UN Charter, and the necessity of retaliation to get the civilian hostages returned. But a ‘right to defend yourself’ does not justify verified targeting of UN safe houses, paramedics, civilian residences, schools, and more; you don’t get to engage in collective punishment because of a terror assault. And if the goal is to secure the return of the hostages, it’s probably not the smartest strategy to bomb the place they were all taken to smithereens– in fact, 22 of the hostages taken on October 7th have already been killed by Israeli airstrikes.

Here are the violations of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court as it defines genocide: Article 6(c) states that deliberately inflicting on a group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction, in whole or in part, is an act of genocide; the imposition of a complete siege of the Gaza Strip, entirely depriving Gazan residents of electricity, internet, food, and fuel meets this definition– what other objective is there in denying families, children, and hospitals water, food, medical supplies, electricity, and the internet? The Rome Statute also bars incitements to mass killing and genocide; many have argued that the statements of Israel’s Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, where he stated Israel was fighting “human animals, and [would] act accordingly,” meet this legal bar. However, if you are unconvinced by these examples, there are, unfortunately, plenty more. Article 8(2)(a)(iii) of the Geneva Convention bars ‘willfully causing great suffering and serious injury to body and health,’ deeming that behavior a war crime. Last Thursday, the IDF confirmed that they had dropped over 6,000 bombs on Gaza in 6 days, equivalent to the number of airstrikes conducted by the US in Afghanistan over the course of a year. Based on the most recent data from a Saturday update, at minimum 2,215 Palestinian civilians, including 724 children, have been killed since October 7th; even more have been injured with 8,714 civilians reporting injuries from the bombing campaigns.

Due to the severity of the constant airstrikes, over 400,000 Palestinians have been forced to flee their homes in Gaza, an example of forced deportation worsened still by Israel’s evacuation order of Friday the 13th, mandating over 1.1 million Gazans to leave their homes with just a 24 hour warning before their ground invasion. No matter your position on the Israel-Palestine conflict, you must recognize that this is a logistical impossibility. It is impossible for that many people to evacuate in that short of a time frame, especially for those who are wounded or sick, disabled, infants, or elderly. The WHO and other international institutions have repeatedly spoken out against the Israeli evacuation orders given to hospitals; in some instances, they were afforded less than 10 hours to evacuate patients, which is, again, a logistical impossibility. In a series of tweets on Sunday, human rights group Amnesty International verified that a convoy of about “30 people, 8 cars, and other nearby people, including women, children, and people with disabilities, was attacked.” In what’s known as a ‘double-tap’ operation, also a war crime, the first responders who arrived on the scene were immediately bombed upon arrival, killing a total of 70 civilian evacuees and medics. This was on one of the very paths of evacuation Israel recommended civilians fleeing Gaza take.

Additionally, a Human Rights Watch report published last week claims to have verified video of Israel’s use of White Phosphorus on civilian populations, a substance banned under international law which leaves serious burns on any skin it touches. 14 UN Officials have also been killed in the bombing. So have 12 journalists. And at least 22 of the approximately 150 hostages taken on the October 7th attack have now been killed by Israeli airstrikes.

I want to conclude by quoting Nicholas Kristof, a Pulitzer-winning American journalist: “If we owe a moral responsibility to Israeli children, then we owe the same moral responsibility to Palestinian children. Their lives have equal weight. If you care about human life only in Israel or only in Gaza, then you don’t actually care about human life.” I think this is an important note to end on because so many people seem to have lost their minds, uttering some of the most violent, genocidal rhetoric I’ve ever heard following politics. “Wipe them out.” “Flatten Gaza.” “They’re inhuman.” It is unacceptable to allow massacres of civilians on this scale to continue, and it’s disgusting to allow this dehumanizing rhetoric to exist without challenge or condemnation. It is unacceptable to use the killings of civilians and their family and nation’s collective grief to spur the mass killing of Palestinian civilians, subjecting them to torture by forcing people to starve to death, or die due to dehydration, lack of medical supplies, or indiscriminate bombing. The killing of civilians has never, and will never, justify the collective punishment and killing of other civilians. A right to defend yourself does not involve a right to commit Crimes against Humanity.

Note: Hours before publication, news broke that IDF airstrikes targeted a major hospital in Gaza, killing an estimated 500 wounded patients and doctors fighting to save them. This horrific atrocity has been denied by the IDF, claiming it was an errant Hamas missile aimed for Israel. It should be noted that Hamas is not known to have missiles of this capability, and that former misfired Hamas missiles, even in crowded areas, have not killed anywhere near as many people. Al Jazeera has also reported that the IDF gave the hospital an evacuation warning, indicating it was in fact an Israeli target.

https://jeffersonindependent.com/it-is-not-anti-semitic-to-criticize-israel/


r/UVA • • May 06 '24

On-Grounds Despicable journalism.

Post image
281 Upvotes

What exactly made the peaceful protest change?

Maybe the armed police, getting pepper sprayed maybe?


r/UVA • • Mar 09 '25

Student Life How is UVA for transgender students?

0 Upvotes

What kind of support is there for transgender students? Especially now with the political climate changing, are transgender students accepted and safe? Would UVA be considered a good choice for a transgender student?


r/UVA • • Oct 26 '21

General Question What do you realistically want the university to do about the fact it was built on Native American land, beyond just acknowledging it?

3 Upvotes

r/UVA • • Jan 12 '22

Student Life More COVID restrictions this semester are completely unnecessary and make no sense

16 Upvotes

I know UVA hasn’t come out and said anything about more restrictions this semester, but given the IFC’s recent announcement about rush, I wanted to share why imposing restrictions on students would be a horrible move by our administration:

  1. Every student is vaxed and boosted

  2. Omicron death rate is incredibly low, especially given our age group of ~18-22 years old

  3. Students aren’t being tested weekly anymore, so how is the administration going to justify imposing restrictions? To the same point, how will the administration deem it safe to reduce restrictions if they impose them?

  4. Bars and restaurants have little to no restrictions, so imposing gathering limits on grounds effectively does nothing

  5. We have in person classes, and while we have a mask mandate indoors, lots of students disregard it and no one is social distancing, again making restrictions meaningless

These points are in addition to the detrimental effect any restrictions would have on the mental health and well-being of UVA students. At a certain point, we just have to move on with our lives, and with our vaccine and booster requirements, I’d hope UVA does not impose any additional restrictions for students.


r/UVA • • Nov 16 '22

News I am so sorry. Maybe, Had charges not been reduced it looks like he would of been barred from owning firearms. We need to have laws inforced no deals.

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/UVA • • May 08 '24

Housing/Dining Where can I find Muslim roommates?

0 Upvotes

Is there a place where I could find Muslim roommates if I want to live off campus for UVA? I got in as a transfer student and was wondering if there’s a place for me to look!

I would appreciate it! Thank you!


r/UVA • • Mar 01 '24

Student Life I've been found [UVA 3]

0 Upvotes

As I write this I am still recovering from a concussion I received from a sparring match I had a few days ago (I found out that I don't protect my face very well).

I don't know if anyone will read this or remember me, but I'm still here and I'm still alive. In other news: I've been found! I ran into someone unexpected the other day and they mentioned my earlier posts. A pleasant surprise! (I now live in fear that they will reveal my identity (a joke (mostly))).

Naturally, since it's been two months since I've last written there has been too much that has happened for me to write here. I and my hazy mind will try my best, however:

I killed a chicken for the first time.

I joined a cult.

I drove to DC to buy some steamed crab but came back empty-handed after finding out they were too expensive.

Got pulled over by the cops for the first time (oops).

Left a cult.

Stumbled upon a company wide fraud ring.

Spoke at length with a very interesting man about Jesus Christ and the nature of human evil.

Hugged a tree.

Chased a squirrel.

Kissed my beautiful fiancée at a very fancy restaurant on valentine's day.

Nearly got knocked out cold on the floor of a basement gym.

And slept in a massive pile of banana peels.

There are far more stories than these I can tell, but I will have to omit them. I have found many unsettling and upsetting things in my trek through life so far, but I find that they are quite easily offset by the wonderful and the enlightening.

From my travels, advice (if you wish to read it):

Watch the trees! Wonder at the sky! Sing! Smile at the faces of the people going by - it might be the first and last time you come into each others' lives. Make friends of strangers and the strange (the estranged are the strangest). Say hello to a loner, they may just be a lone fellow. Keep your seatbelt on and eat your vegetables!

To all of my fellow students, happy break! I might see you around. (I hope to hear what you'll be up to)

To you who found me the other day, you owe me lunch.

P.S. No, I still have not partaken in substances - the strangeness throughout this post arises purely from severe lack of sleep, a shaken brain, and a lifelong love for reading.


r/UVA • • Jun 27 '23

Academics Do Not Listen to Dean Ozment

0 Upvotes

I've seen some posts about transfer students and their negative experiences. As a transfer who graduated the comm school with no issue and a high paying job - ignore Dean Ozment. She knows nothing and will encourage you to change your major to something easier because she's never accomplished anything herself. Type "dean ozment uva" and look at her photo and bio... is that really someone you want to take advice from?


r/UVA • • Feb 13 '20

Why should the racist student not be expelled? Isn't that standard policy for all universities that deal with a racist individual?

6 Upvotes

r/UVA • • Dec 17 '22

Academics CS 3100 - warnings from a fellow student

1 Upvotes

the final scores were released and piazza is a whole range of emotions right now. the grading is actually so unfair it's wild. i'm not saying this class is a total nightmare- a lot of people do well and it's nice that the mods are split up so you can split your studying- but the grading just makes it so intense and hard and the grading honestly depends on the TA and teacher and honestly just luck. like im sure some TA's are nicer than others and it's clearly reflected in the grading. like this last piazza post about "NO BOOSTS" is so intense and mean for what ?? like honestly if you were a student in this class you'd be acting the same way as us. im not asking for no kind of boost but like seriously why the attitude. honestly i wish floryan ethan and all the ta's nothing but the best over break and holiday season, but i hope they know i'm lowkey praying on their downfall.

all in all

if you need help when you take this class i will gladly help you out... but just bewarned. almost ended it for real but you can do it


r/UVA • • Feb 21 '23

Off-Grounds How to Walk In Charlottesville

10 Upvotes

Hi this is a bit of an informational rant.

I don't wake up wanting to hit people with my car, I promise. You don't use the crosswalk and maybe you don't know it but the entrance to the corner is a blind spot. Bikes count as cars! Yes we have lovely bike lanes, use them, yell at people who walk in them or decide to park in them, I am with you! but when you are in an area that doesn't have those, you aren't a runner, you count as a car, so when you clip across the front of my car and I hit you, I wont be at fault. Check this, my dad had a bicycle hit him in his car, it was on camera, when the guy sued for breaking his own leg, it showed he didn't follow right of way and was tossed out. I get it, this campus is walkable but oh my god is it a walk, but ya'll need to be proactive, use the lights at the crosswalk, WEAR BRIGHT OR REFLECTIVE COLORS,Don't Jaywalk, If it's dark, and you cant find a cross walk, I need you to stand under a street lamp or carry a flashlight! In my car, I can't see you if you're wearing all black running across the street when its dark out, I get it, it's slimming but you know what isn't slimming, a coffin. It honestly hurts my feelings when ya'll do this, not because I'm some entitled person in a car, but because we both got to work at it, you have to be seen, and if I didn't see you, where does that leave us?


r/UVA • • Oct 09 '26

News The story about the Cornell 7 is reminding me of the UVA Jackie saga

21 Upvotes

Almost 12 years ago. What a shit show.

To be perfectly honest, I see some parallels.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus

EDIT: Whatever people. I actually believe men in these situations have rights too. Like the right to not have your life ruined when the facts are murky (as they are here). You can call that a “horrible take” all you want. In my view it’s the correct take to afford all parties due process and in some cases (not all cases, but some) the benefit of the doubt.


r/UVA • • Sep 19 '26

Student Life petition

0 Upvotes

hi guys, I’m sure people have heard about the UVA football player who abused his dog and got charged on 3 counts of animal abuse. they kept him on the team. please sign the petition to stop paying this man! https://c.org/q8BnDQfnhr


r/UVA • • Apr 17 '12

Thinking about UVA... convince me.

0 Upvotes

I'm torn between UVA and Virginia Tech. I've heard they both have great Psychology programs, but I don't know that much about UVA's program. For any Psych majors, which program is better for someone who wants to go into clinical. What requirements do you have and what opportunities does UVA give you that VT can't? Thanks so much!


r/UVA • • Aug 29 '20

Student Life Unpopular opinion: UVA should bring students back for in-person classes

6 Upvotes

Everybody keeps comparing us to UNC, but our strategy is completely different. UNC had no official restriction on parties or gatherings. They changed their social distancing recommendations from 6ft to 3ft. They knew what they were doing.

People have already gotten suspended here for throwing parties. Ambassadors are walking around all night and would report a large party. Bars are open, but nothing close to packed. Block party was practically nothing. First-years deserve to experience UVA. If you can eat in a restaurant restaurant with your mask off, we should be able to sit 6ft apart in a lecture hall with masks on.

Obviously more could be done when you see other flagship publics testing everyone twice a week. But so far, things seem to be working out okay.

Is it crazy to think administration actually cares about us and isn’t only motivated by money?


r/UVA • • Jul 31 '22

General Question Monkeypox

2 Upvotes

Is anyone as freaked out about monkeypox as much as I am for this fall?


r/UVA • • Apr 07 '21

News A Medical Student Questioned Microaggressions. UVA Branded Him a Threat and Banished Him from Campus.

Thumbnail
reason.com
3 Upvotes

r/UVA • • Dec 22 '20

Student Life Almost everyone here is too liberal

0 Upvotes

r/UVA • • Aug 15 '25

News Sean Kingston (Wahoo Welcome August 2022) sentenced to 3.5 years in prison for $1 million fraud scheme

Thumbnail
apnews.com
14 Upvotes

r/UVA • • Apr 01 '21

Meme To All the Special ❄️ on UVA Twitter

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/UVA • • Feb 07 '21

Student Life Fraternity Rush

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/UVA • • Apr 24 '24

Off-Grounds What is the average opinion on occupying campus that are happening right now across the country?

0 Upvotes

Protest are happening right now at Columbia and all other universities across US, students are demanding their universities to divest from Israel.
Just curious, what is the average opinion among college student in US? Do most support what they are doing? Or don't support them because they disrupt classes and campus life? Or just don't care about it at all?


r/UVA • • Apr 26 '22

On-Grounds Plus Size Seating

5 Upvotes

UVA needs to add more accessible plus-size seating options specifically in lecture halls. The seats are small and uncomfortable and the plus out desks take up room in the chair for plus size students.