THE BATTLE OF FIVE FORKS
By David Cardwell
Confederate Veteran
Volume 22 #3
March 1914
Page 117
So much has been said about the morale of the Army of
Northern Virginia after the battle of Gettysburg that I
cannot refrain, as a humble private in that army, from describing
as best I can the battle of Five Forks.
To say nothing of the splendid fighting of A. P. Hill's men
and the cavalry at Reams's Station in August, 1864, and the
almost daily fights that W. II. F. Lee's Cavalry had along the
Boydton plank road and the Weldon Railroad at Reams's Station,
we swept Hancock's celebrated 2d Corps away from
our front like a whirlwind. Nothing stopped us. and our
force was far inferior to theirs. Col. Robert Aldrich says that
Gen. A. P. Hill sent to General Hampton (or Butler) for a
mounted man who was familiar with the country, and he
(Lieutenant Aldrich) was sent. When he reported to General
Hill, the General said : "Lieutenant, how many men have you
with the cavalry?" Lieutenant Aldrich told him that he had
about two thousand and then asked: "General Hill, how many
men have you?" The response was: "About eight thousand,
1 think." Then the General said: "How many men do you
think are in front of us. Lieutenant?" To which the Lieutenant
replied: "All of Hancock's troops. I should say about
twenty thousand men." Lieutenant Aldrich then insinuated
that the General was attempting a big job with the force he
had. General Hill then said: "Lieutenant, if we can't whip
them with this proportion, we'd better stop the war right
now."
History shows how well he figured. General Hancock,
when he returned from the hospital, testified to the completi
ness of the defeat and told his corps that the Confederate
army could not be beaten, but must be worn out. So youi see
that up to August, 1864. the army had a good deal of fight in
it, and so on till the spring of 1865. I was with the cavalry and
on the right of General Lee's Petersburg line. After leaving
the breastworks, the cavalrj patrolled the line and fought
almost daily, and fought with spirit, too.
On the 31st of March the cavalry found itself way down
the line toward Dinwiddie Courthouse, and they put their
artillery into position on the south bank of a stream called
Chamberlain's Run. I was No. 4 at one of these guns. In
a few minutes Barringer’s Brigade, the 1st North Carolina
Cavalry (a splendid regiment under Col. Cowles in the lead, came up. At once a heavy fire was opened on
them from the other side of the run. We opened with our
guns, using short fuses. As the brigade of General Barringer
charged across the run, which was three or four feet deep,
our gun was in position on a little knoll on the right of the
ford by which the cavalry charged, and I had a splendid opportunity
to see the whole fight. In all my experience (and
I had been in over sixty fights, great and small) I never saw
a more splendid charge. They simply swept everything out
of their way. Every field officer of Barringer's Brigade was
shot, yet on pushed these soldiers. The splendid cavalry of
Sheridan fled before them until they almost reached Dinwiddie
Courthouse, where their infantry was in large force.
Now, this was long alter the battle of Gettysburg. Colonel
Cowles was shot through the head and fell into the creek,
supposedly dead; but I met him after the war pretty much
alive. One of our men, a splendid soldier, Ashton Chichester,
was shot through a thigh. It was a pitiful sight to see the
dead and wounded dragged from the creek. General Barringer,
when writing a history of the North Carolina Cavalry years ago,
asked me to write him an account of this fight, of which he was justly proud.
The soldiers covered themselves with glory.
But now we must come to our story, the battle of Five
Forks. This is, I believe, said to be one of the decisive battles
in all history. At any rate, to my mind it was the turning
point in the fighting in the immediate defense of Peters
burg and Richmond. After the Chamberlain's Run fight we
lay down on the red clay of Dinwiddie County and thought
we could whip anything alive. We had taken care of our
wounded, buried our dead, and were ready to go to sleep.
We went to sleep and slept as only soldiers can. The matter
of bedclothes did not concern us. We "traveled light." and
when the reveille sounded at dawn on April 1 it was soon
followed by "Boots and saddles!"
We were up and in the saddle after a hasty breakfast of
grapefruit, eggs ,au gratin, hot rolls, beefsteak. German fried
potatoes, and coffee— 1 reckon not! B What we had was corn
pone cooked three days before, raw Nassau pork (some
times called "mule" by the boys, who worshiped it and got so
little of it. 1 was hungry -"hungry" is not strong enough. I
was so hungry that I thanked God that I had a backbone for
my stomach to lean up against.
Well, as 1 said, we were up and in the saddle. We sat in
the saddle for hours waiting— for what. 1 didn't know. What
ever it was, we were ready for it tor anything, and nothing
would have surprised us. We were past all such emotions
We found later that we were on the extreme left of a line
that was forming, and we found this out by being ordered to
the extreme right at a gallop. As we galloped down the line
we recognized among the infantry Pickett's men. Bushrod
Johnson's men, and the foot artillery that belonged to those
commands. We passed just in the rear of them all. They
were behind very light earthworks, just enough to insure
them a wound above the knee.
We recognized many men in the infantry and artillery,
many who never left that field alive. One man particularly
I noticed, sitting on his horse just at the forks of the road
(Five Forks). He hail on a brand-new uniform of gray,
with a red collar, and on the collar were three gold stars.
He was a young man—O so young he seems to us old soldiers
now! To my boyish eye (1 was nineteen) he was simply
grand. Think of it! A full colonel of artillery! Could anything
be more exalted than that? He had on gold spectacles
and looked like the god of war. It was Col. Willie Pegiam.
of old Virginia. He was one of the gallant men who gave
up their lives there. Before the day was done he was shot
through the breast of his beautiful gray coat; and I was
told that he died that night in the arms of his friend, Capt.
Gordon McCabe, in Ford's Depot. the pity of it! He had
great and good company there
We galloped down the entire line, and on the right we
found our division (W. H. i. Lee's) already dismounted
and in position. They too were behind breastworks just
high enough to insure them a death wound. The works were
about three feet high. Space was made for us at once and
our four guns went into position. "On the left fourteen
yards; close intervals; forward into battery!" was about the
command our captain (Wilmer Brown) gave, and we unlimbered
for one of the history-making battles of the world.
Little did we think of this; we were simply doing what we
were used to. If anybody said anything, it was about this:
"Well, boys, it looks like we are going to have a good-sized
scrimmage."
Page 118
We dismounted, gave our horses to the horse holder, and
proceeded to rest ourselves and to make remarks. One said:
"No fight to-day, boys; only an April fool." Our commissary
rode down the line on a good fat horse with such cries as:
"No fight to-day. Company Q is at the front." Another fellow
cried out : "Look at that horse. How fat he is ! That's
where the feed goes." The careless, jolly humor of the
men almost in the presence of death is hard to understand in
these piping times of peace.
we l< ninged about these works till about three o'clock.
At one time one of the boys went back to the limber chest
and got out of it a plug of tobacco so musty that no one
could use it—such as our government issued to the troops.
He suggested that we ram it into the gun and said : "If anything
will kill them, this will."
I have read much history since the war, and of course I
write now with that light before me. I know now (I did not
then why Sheridan kept Us waiting so long. He was waiting
for Warren to come up on our left and rear. Since then
war history says that Warren, who was relieved of his command
at Five Forks by General Sheridan, was court-martialed,
or there was a congressional investigation as to his
tardiness. I don't know- what the outcome was, but I do
know that until Warren came up W. H. F. Lee took care of
Sheridan's immense force of cavalry ; and Sheridan's success
at Five Forks was due to General Warren's coming up
in the rear and left of our infantry.
Well, be that as it may, about two-thirty, or possibly later,
some one said : "I see some movement in the peach orchard
back of Mrs. Gillam's house." As I could not see it (being a
short man I. I went back and got my horse; and as I rode up
Major McGregor, who was formerly our captain, handed me
his field glasses, and I beheld a sight as I saw squadron after
squadron of splendidly mounted and equipped cavalry wheel
into line in the orchard back of the Gillam house. They were
at "carry saber" and were forming by the right flank. The
sun shone brightly, and the glint from their burnished arms
was blinding. On they came, forming on the right, in front
of our position. Well, I watched them until I was sure
that there was more cavalry than I ever saw even on the
plains of Brandy Station.
I saw an ambulance drawn by four horses drive up to the
Gillam house. An officer in charge (I don't know whether
he was a Yankee or a Confederate) assisted the ladies of the
Gillam family in and drove off. I thought by this time that
I had better get to my post ; so I gave up my horse and went
to my post, No. 4, at the gun.
Our cavalry had thrown out a skirmish line, "a thin gray
line," and they had brought out some fence rails, piling these
rails up in front of them in a sort of angle with the point toward
the enemy. Then we waited and waited and wondered
why Gen. Phil Sheridan did not commence his movement to
ride over us. Many a thought passed through a man's mind
in such waiting.
We were slill in good shape. Gen. W. H. F. Lee rode
up and down the line, talking in a quiet tone to officers
as he passed. He was ready to fight, and so were we. We
had fought big odds before. "Brace up, old boy; it is no new
thing to you." "Well, why in the thunder don't they come
along?"
After a while out in front we saw a small white puff
of smoke, then another, and so on till it sounded like a pack
of firecrackers. Then the men in the little rail pens began
to come in on a run, turning and firing as they ran.
crambled over the works they said: "Boys, we are going to
catch hell. The whole earth is covered with cavalry." Raising
our eyes, we saw them coming, first at a walk, then at
a trot march, and next at a gallop, and then bugles blew the
charge. Did you ever hear the charge sounded? Great
Caasar ! It is a blare that goes to the bone, and it would make
a rabbit fight a bulldog. On, on they came. We threw short
fuse shells into them as fast as we could pull the lanyard, and
then canister. On they came. We thought that they would ride
over us ; but when the canister got in its work they wavered,
swayed, and turned back. O, can you imagine yourself standing
behind those light earthworks waiting for five thousand
mounted men to ride over you? There are many things I
would prefer. Our men did not move. Nobody fell back but
the men out in the rail fence. But we drew a long breath
when the cavalry wavered and turned. What a relief!
We looked out over that great field as the smoke cleared
away and saw the bodies of the dead. The slightly wounded
crawled off, afraid to raise their heads. The poor horses!
Some were still in death, some struggling to get up. This
charge was repeated four times, as I remember, and when
they came the fourth time we heard the spattering of bullets
in our rear, to the left. In a few minutes we saw the
infantry moving toward us—at first just one or two, then
three or four, and so on till there was a big movement
through our command, and then a stampede. I had never
seen our troops stampeded.
It should not be inferred from the foregoing that the infantry
and artillery to the left of us did not take a large part
in this battle. I am telling of what I saw in front of the
cavalry and horse artillery where I was. All I know of what
took place on the left of the cavalry is what I heard, and I
heard a continuous roar of artillery and a strong rattle of
small arms. So far as I have heard since, the divisions of
George E. Pickett and Bushrod Johnson did not "lay down"
on their job, and gave way only when the 5th Corps of General
Warren enveloped their left and rear.
The records of these two divisions were about made up,
and they were glorious. I have seen many narratives by
privates that told of things which were impossible for them to
know anything about. I have tried to avoid this. Does it
not seem strange that General Warren, the man who saw to
it at Gettysburg that the key to the situation (Little Round
Top) was occupied by the Federal forces when it had been
overlooked, the man who was the real hero of Five Forks,
should have had a court-martial for his reward and is not
lauded as one of the great men, as is the noisy Sheridan?
Sheridan never did anything when he did not have every
advantage.
Our division kept its line and never wavered, though the
infantry crowded them. They met the charges and moved
out under orders. It was an awful mixture. General W. H.
F. Lee took a flag and rode among them, begging them to
rally. But no, sir; they would not. They went their way.
We limbered up under order to do so and moved out toward
the right, down the road. As I attempted to follow with two
other comrades we were stopped by Col. L. Tiernan Brien,
of Maryland. I recall his splendid figure. He was in the fulldress
Confederate uniform of his rank, and any one who has
seen the full-dress uniform of a Confederate colonel of cavalry
or of the staff has seen something gorgeous. He told us to
pull down a fence in front of the 2d North Carolina Cavalry,
"squadron front," and we did it. By so doing we got terribly
mixed up, after mounting, in a charge 01 that regiment. We
were pressed back to the road. I was looking for a way
out, and I was looking hard, too.
I looked west, and there was a line of fire clear across the
road. I knew I could not go east (the enemy were there) nor
south. So northwest I went, jumping my horse over a fence.
Poor old Dick Chamberlaine, of Norfolk, who was No. 2 at
my gun, had all of his eyebrows, mustache, and hair on the
right side of his head burned off. Half of his jacket was
also burned off by his being too slow to clear the front of the
gun when the order to fire was given. Poor old Dick rode
close behind me and jumped the fence into the swamp, also.
Dick was a sight. You could not tell which army he belonged
to. His face was black with powder.
The 2d North Carolina Cavalry had checked Custer's mad
charge, which enabled the artillery and most of the cavalry to
get away. In the mclcc of the charge of the 2d North Carolina
Cavalry sabers and pistols were used before Custer's nan
recoiled. We were at very close quarters, and such lights do
not last long.
Henry L. Moore, of our battery, Owen O'Brien, and myself
were close together. In the mix-up a color bearer was cut
from his horse, and as the flag fell it was seized by Moore,
A great big man made a swipe at Moore with his saber, but
missed his head and struck the flagstaff. Moore struck him
Over the head with his pistol and brought the flag out. I Ins
about closed the battle o\\\\\\\\ Five Forks. Night had come on
before we got through, and the line of tight could easily be
traced by the line of lire.
Soon after we got in the swamp we encountered the numerous
wounded men who either had been taken out of the
light and laid behind sheltering trees or had crawled out
there. As we rode along in the dark woods they begged
piteously to be taken up. We talked about it, but could nol
see that we could do them any good. We knew that an
ambulance corps of one army or the other would look after
them the next morning.
When I jumped the fence I had a saber hanging to my
wrist by a strap and a pistol in my hand. With Dick riding
by m\\\\\\\\ side. 1 looked much like a man will] a prisoner. Soon
some one said to me : "Great God, man, how did you get a
prisoner?" 1 put up my saber and pistol and looked more
peaceable. Dick and I floundered about in that swamp, and
soon we were out of sight and sound of the wounded and
all sound of strife.
We kept on in a northwesterly direction, and just as the
roosters began to crow we emerged into an open field, We
halted. In a few minules we discovered the figure of a man
Btanding upright, holding a gun. He looked like "one in
authority." In fact, he looked "on guard." So we contemplated
him with interest. Dick said: "Davy, you ride forward
and challenge him." I said: "Dick, suppose you amble up and
ask him his name and command." We did not know where
we were nor who he was. After some debate we both rode
forward, and tile figure promptly presented his gun and
said, "Halt I" in a cross tone of voice, and we halted as soon
as we could. We found that he was on guard and belonged
to our division. We asked him where our battery was, and
be said thai it was "away over beyond that big white house."
And for "over beyond that big white house" we started
I'" fore we had gone far. however, we came upon a group
of mounted men, and in their midst we soon made oul Maj.
Gen, William Henry Fitzhugh I.ee. It was now broad daylight,
and we could see things plainly. But I must say that
in the darkest part of that forest at the darkest period of the
night we could have made out General Lee. He was six feet
three or four and weighed not an ounce less than three hundred
pounds. He was mounted on his brown war horse, "Frantic,"
a horse he always had his saddle changed to before going
into a fight. The two together, man and horse, made one of
the largest establishments I ever saw.
We halted here. Meantime Moore and O'Brien had joined
us, Moore still carrying the battle flag. We found General
Lee trying to collect and get into some shape his scattered
division. We three boys sat on our horses near by, feeling
very much at home with our division commander. The
General would call out, for instance : "Is there any officer
here from the 1st North Carolina Regiment. Is Colonel
Cowles here?" No reply. "Is Lieut. Col. So and So here?''
No reply. "Is there any officer of this regiment here?" Some
captain or lieutenant would ride up and say: "I am here. General.
I am Captain So and So, of Troop B." "Well, Captain,
form the 1st Regiment out there and take command." And
so he went through the whole list of his regiments and
formed what was left of that once splendid division.
Now our turn had come. The General turned in his saddle
and in a sweet, soft, eourleous voice Said: "Well, young
gentlemen of the artillery, what is your battery?" We answered,
as we always did with great pride, "McGregor's."
"Well, permit me to inquire why you are not with your battery."
We thought we had a splendid excuse. In fact, we
felt that we had done even more than our duty. Think of
that mix-up with Custer at the forks, etc. Henry Moore
rode up and, expecting to be complimented, showed General
I ee 'be rescued flag. We told him of Colonel Bricn and the
line of fire to the west, across the road. As our battery retired
that way, we thought it was captured, lie answered with
more harshness than I thought him capable of : "Go to your
battery. It is not captured; it is over there in that held.
You should never allow yourselves to be separated from your
battery." We rode off in no good humor and said about
ili~ "lie is an ungrateful old fellow, and I don't like him
anyway. He isn't much of a general." A courier rode up and
told General Lee that he was wanted at the big white house
10 attend a council of war. We rejoined our battery in the
big field, and were received with great rejoicing. The boys
in the battery did not know what had befallen us. We felt
very much set up by having so much fuss made over us.
As we traveled the road that night, about midnight an incident
occurred that shows the rigors and severities of war.
General Lee called for a nun who knew the country and
asked for a man from t he 13th Regiment. No one coming
forward, the General said to a courier: "Go up to that house,
rouse them, and say that I want a man that can guide me to
such and such a place." The man of the house, and also the
lady, appeared at the window, and both protested against the
man's going; hut General Lee ordered the man to come out
at once and guide the command. The poor man came, and
the woman wept bitterly. General Lee made the man mount
a led horse and ride out into the darkness to guide him as
he directed.
The affection of one comrade for another is second only
to the affection for one's own family, and it lasts through life.
I see my comrades in the silent watches of the night. I hear
t heir voices. I know their ways and sayings. I can see
them mounted and dismounted. I know their horses. I have
slept, eaten, and nearly starved with them.
Now begins the stop,- of the retreat of General Lee's army.