At least under Plan 2 (less so Plan 5, it’s harder to defend but you heard these opinions before plan 5 was even a thing), UK student loans should not be thought of as “debt” in any sense at all. You should be sectioned if you remotely suggest it is.
You don’t repay a fixed amount.
You don’t repay it if you’re unemployed.
You don’t repay it if you earn below a threshold.
It gets wiped after \~30 years.
Name me the bank that will give me a loan like that.
That’s not a loan. It’s a graduate tax with branding so bad it terrifies people who don’t understand basic maths.
Example:
If you earn £37k, you pay roughly £80/month. That’s it.
For a job you almost certainly would not have without the degree.
And yet we endlessly hear:
“Student loans are bad”
“Uni isn’t worth it”
“I don’t want debt hanging over me forever”
This only makes sense if you:
Don’t understand marginal tax, or
Think in scary big numbers rather than actual cash flow, or
Were never suited to higher education anyway
For STEM or genuinely useful degrees, the ROI is obvious. Especially for those of us who studied in the era with maintenance loans and grants that literally let you live while studying.
Honestly, sometimes I wonder if understanding student loans should be an entrance requirement for university.
If you’re too thick to work out that this system overwhelmingly advantages you — particularly under Plan 2 — then no amount of education is going to help you.
Yes, Plan 5 is worse. Yes, the system could be better.
But pretending UK student loans are equivalent to US-style debt is just wrong, and the fear-mongering is actively pushing capable people away from education. But more importantly it’s shifting focus away from things that actually matter - the erosion of quality of universities in the uk - one of our final actually meaningfully worthwhile institutions, and the lowering of quality of life and social mobility for each and every successive generation, all for the purposes of funnelling money to the top.
This isn’t controversial. It’s just maths.