Does anybody else find the grading for the first midterm absolutely ridiculous (specifically Question 4a,4b,4c)?
The questions are phrased so generically like "Give the result and clearly show each step," and "Explain why....," but then the answer key has some specific exact requirements that are necessary in order to achieve full marks. For anyone who hasn't taken the course, I can see how this may seem reasonable, but I assure you it is not. At one point (Q4a), you lose 0.5 marks for not converting your final binary answer into decimal form (even though the question only asks for the binary answer). How is this reasonable? The "Show the answer is correct, by converting it back to decimal" requirement in question 4a seems like the biggest indicator of this teaching team's inept expectations- you want me to read your mind? For real? Whenever a student highlights this on Piazza, we receive the same uncaring reply "From the post: "We will not answer any questions regarding the exam until the regrade request period is over." Why not? If you have such expectations from students, why can't the teaching team explain their reasoning? This isn't coming from some disgruntled student who failed, this is from someone who took the midterm seriously just to have gotten screwed over by the teaching team's ridiculousness.
4b is a simple "explain why" question, I felt like I blew it out of the water with a simple answer highlighting that the given arithmetic operation was outside the bounds of a positive signed binary representation, yet the rubric suggests explaining how 2's complement works which is literally the most basic concept we learned, it's like asking a grade 8 student to explain how to represent a base 10 number.... The question generically asked us to explain why, it didn't ask us to divulge into overflow or any of the above. If you wanted us to go over that, then include in the frickin question "Is there overflow/underflow/no error?" How can you include something in the rubric after asking students to just "explain why?" Even though we have full understanding of the material, we can't guess the exact answer you are looking for, especially when it's framed in a qualitative format. In response to complaints on Piazza, the professor responded with "The question already said that it is not possible to represent 32+32, so saying this is larger than 63 is not enough." But that's the exact reason... we weren't asked to dive deeper into "why that's the highest number," we were only asked to "explain why" 32+32 is not possible. If you wanted a more specific answer, then you should have included "If it's outside of the scope, why?"
Now I can understand the deductions if we were given grade weightings per question, but this 3 part question was just assigned an overall of 18 marks, so there was no way to determine the complexity of each of the individual sub-answers that they desired. 4a and 4b appeared so simple (simply because they WERE easy) but there wasn't any grade weight visibly attached to it (no "out of x"), so anyone who saw this would probably feel like it was a short answer and provide the basic solution- not explain how 2's complement works! They should have asked us if they wanted it. I finished 4a and 4b in 5 minutes flat, they were probably the easier questions on the exam for me and my fellow classmates, yet I ended up with 4/9 total. My answers were all correct.... and I got 4/9. Do you know how much that hurts after spending hours studying? I cannot express my anger enough. In anticipation, I know I'll get a response like "effort doesn't equal results" but I got the answer right, I just didn't "describe" exactly what they wanted. And no, these weren't fundamental things that I should have known to include- they were trivial and unnecessary additions. It's almost as if they completed creating the exam and decided it wasn't hard enough, so they just started throwing in grading requirements that were completely unwarranted.
Question 4C was not explained at all in Geoffrey's section (maybe 5 mins tops, and nowhere near the level of comprehension needed for that exam question), so why were we given this? Yes, it was on a slide, but we never dived into it, am I supposed to learn this on my own?
Idk man, I worked for days studying for this midterm. Tens and tens of hours. Walked out of the midterm feeling like I got 100. After receiving my midterm, and ignoring these arbitrary qualitative "incorrect answers," I should have received a 95- but with all of these stupid unclear grading components, I ended up just breaking 82 (I can't even imagine how students who performed worse must be feeling). This is ridiculous. They aren't even testing our knowledge at this point. They're testing how closely we can predict what they exactly want as a qualitative answer. Some of you may argue that this is the nature of a midterm but I disagree, we shouldn't have to guess what exact qualitative response you are looking for, especially if our answer is correct and there are no grade weighting attached to each question. This entire grading process is a slap in the face to any student that spent time studying for this midterm and actually got the questions correct (especially question 4a,4b, and 4c).
And what's with this whole "frivolous" regrade request thing? Be my guest to make further deductions if you find other mistakes that weren't accounted for the first time around, but to say any regrade that is frivolous will receive deductions.... ain't that your job?