First, a disclaimer: I'm a woman and a feminist. I believe in women's independence and capabilities, but there's something that's been weighing on my mind lately, and I'm curious whether other women have similar concerns.
I worry about not having enough men in my immediate family/social circle, especially because I'm single.
I'm not particularly concerned about this in the context of natural disasters, power outages, or other relatively short-term emergencies. I'm thinking more about scenarios involving war, widespread civil unrest, societal breakdown, or situations where we might need to flee or defend ourselves.
The reality is that the average man is physically stronger than the average woman, and I think that difference can become particularly relevant in high-conflict survival situations.
For context, my immediate family consists of:
- Me (30F)
- My mother (50s)
- My grandmother (70s)
- My two brothers (early 20s)
- My uncle (40s)
My father is somewhat of a question mark because my parents are divorcing, so I'm not sure whether he would be part of our group in an emergency.
Excluding him, that's technically an equal number of men and women. But there are two things about this arrangement that concern me.
I'm single, and I don't have a romantic partner whose primary commitment would be to me.
I love my family, and I know my brothers and uncle love me. But I also recognize that as my brothers get older and enter serious relationships, their priorities may change.
If either of my brothers had a girlfriend or wife, I don't think it would be unreasonable for him to prioritize her safety over mine. Depending on the circumstances, he might even choose to separate from our family group to stay with her.
That's not necessarily something I would resent. It's a natural part of building a life with someone. But as a single woman, it makes me wonder where that leaves me.
There's a difference between having male relatives who love and care about you and having a committed romantic partner who considers you his immediate family and primary responsibility.
Obviously, a husband isn't a guarantee of safety or protection, and I'm certainly not suggesting that I should marry just anyone as an insurance policy against societal collapse. That would be an absurdly high premium to pay for such a niche insurance policy!
Still, I can't help thinking about it.
2. Our group has limited physical capacity relative to its size.
Of the six of us, my two brothers are young and physically fit, and my uncle is reasonably fit and capable of defending himself. I'm moderately fit for a woman, while my mother and grandmother are older and not physically fit.
That means one-third of our group consists of older women who may struggle more with physically demanding survival situations.
I'm not suggesting that my mother or grandmother would be useless or incapable. They absolutely have valuable skills and could contribute in many ways. But I'm trying to be realistic about physical limitations.
If we needed to evacuate on foot, move heavy supplies, transport an injured person, or physically defend ourselves, how much additional burden could the more physically capable members realistically take on?
And what happens if one of my brothers is injured, unavailable, or separated from the group?
We don't have much wiggle room.
This also becomes more complicated if we ever need to split into smaller groups. With only three men, two older women, and myself, how do we divide ourselves in a way that doesn't leave one group particularly vulnerable?
3. I think having men present can be a form of protection in itself.
This is probably the part that feels most uncomfortable to say, but I think it's worth discussing.
Unfortunately, simply having a man accompanying you can sometimes deter harassment, intimidation, or physical aggression before a confrontation even begins.
Of course, firearms can be a great equalizer, but ideally, you'd want to avoid having to use one at all. Preventing or deterring a confrontation is preferable to having to defend yourself during one.
And if a physical confrontation does become unavoidable, strength differences can matter significantly.
I recognize that not all men are strong, capable, or willing to protect others, just as not all women are physically weak or incapable of defending themselves. A well-trained woman could certainly be more useful in an emergency than an unprepared man.
But speaking in generalities, I do think having more physically capable men in a survival group offers certain advantages, both in deterring conflict and responding to it.
I also recognize that physical strength is far from the only valuable survival skill. Medical knowledge, resourcefulness, planning, situational awareness, emotional resilience, and countless other abilities are equally important in different circumstances.
I guess my underlying concern is that my family's age and gender composition leaves us with less flexibility than I'd like, and being single adds another layer of uncertainty about my own protection and support.
I'm grateful that our group doesn't currently include young children who would need constant supervision or assistance. I imagine the calculations become even more complicated for families with several children, elderly relatives, or other dependents.
I'm not trying to suggest that women need men to survive, nor am I looking to debate whether women are capable of being independent. I just think there are practical considerations regarding physical strength, group composition, and personal relationships that can become especially relevant in extreme survival situations.
So I'm curious:
Do any other women think about the gender, age, and physical capabilities of their potential survival groups?
If you're single, live alone, or have a predominantly female family or social circle, does that influence how you prepare for high-conflict emergencies?
And if you have elderly relatives, young children, or other dependents, how do you account for those additional responsibilities?
I'd genuinely love to hear different perspectives, including from women who disagree with me or have found ways to address these concerns. This has been on my mind for a while, and I'm curious whether anyone else thinks about it.