I'm a 25F, and I've had a male best friend (25M) since 2022. We've been extremely close for four years. We've been there for each other through several ups and downs, and our friendship has always been platonic. We share a lot of common interests and can talk about almost anything, from family and careers to psychology, books and personal struggles.
In 2024, I made a female friend (let's call her A). My best friend found her cute and asked me to introduce them. I spoke to her, she was open to meeting him, and I introduced them.
At that point, A was going through a difficult phase. She had recently experienced heartbreak, moved to a new city for the first time, and came from a very financially struggling family. Her mother earned around ā¹10,000 a month doing basic labour work, her father wasn't financially supportive, and she also had a younger brother.
She was living in a cheap PG, struggling with the food and environment, and was generally very anxious and emotionally vulnerable. Even saying goodbye to people would sometimes make her cry because she was scared of being alone in a new city.
My best friend was also going to be moving away, and both of them wanted companionship.
When they first met, he genuinely put in a lot of effort. He planned the entire day around her interests, took her to a museum where the entry ticket itself was around ā¹1,000 per person, paid for everything and even brought her flowers. She was overwhelmed by the experience because she had never imagined experiencing something like that.
They clicked almost immediately. She fell for him, he started developing feelings for her, and eventually they became physically and emotionally involved.
They both understood that marriage wasn't a realistic possibility for them in the future, but decided to continue the relationship for a few years because neither wanted to be without the other at that point.
Initially, I was genuinely happy for them. But gradually, things started getting weird.
The jealousy and possessiveness
A became extremely possessive about him. She would get uncomfortable whenever he spoke to me, mentioned me, visited our hometown or exchanged birthday gifts with me.
For context, my best friend and I belong to the same hometown. Whenever he visits, we naturally catch up. We usually eat street food, have chai, discuss books and talk about life. Sometimes he pays, sometimes I do, although he mostly pays because he is earning and I'm currently unemployed. We don't go to expensive places or do anything extravagant.
But she would get upset even about these ordinary interactions.
Their relationship also had a strange financial dynamic. He paid for virtually everything. Whenever they went out, it usually involved eating at malls, shopping for clothes, buying groceries and other things she wanted. He paid for all of it. She never took out even a rupee. Sometimes she would ask him to order food or other things for her, and he would do that too.
He regularly spent thousands on her, including buying her birthday dresses and gifts. Yet she never reciprocated, not even with a small birthday gift for him.
Meanwhile, she would frequently go hot and cold with him. Sometimes she wouldn't talk to him for a week or two, but would meet him on weekends when they went shopping or spent time together.
What bothered me even more was how she spoke about him.
She made extremely hurtful comments about his appearance, height and physical intimacy. She would say things like she enjoyed talking to him online but felt uncomfortable when she saw him in person. She even made comments about his size and how she barely felt him during sex.
I eventually told him some of these things because I felt he deserved to know what was being said about him.
When our friendship became a problem
My best friend and I have always shared intellectual interests. We love books, discussing psychology, self-improvement, careers, family and life in general.
Whenever we meet, we naturally fall into these conversations. We are almost like productive buddies who genuinely enjoy each other's company.
A didn't seem to have that kind of connection with him. She struggled to listen to his problems, understand his perspective or offer suggestions. It often felt like conversations had to revolve around her.
She started getting irritated whenever he and I talked, laughed or discussed something together.
One incident that particularly stands out happened when they visited our hometown.
We went to a bookstore. My best friend and I have a ritual of visiting bookstores whenever we meet. We browse books, recommend them to each other and discuss things we've read.
A wasn't interested in books and was exploring the crafts section.
I noticed her discomfort and deliberately backed off. But my friend didn't notice and continued showing me books, just like he normally would.
Eventually, she became so upset that she sat down and started crying.
My friend told me she was overstimulated. I honestly didn't understand what had happened, but I didn't want to make things worse, so I maintained my distance.
Later, we went to the beach. I almost slipped near the water, and my friend instinctively held my hand to prevent me from falling.
A saw this and immediately ran towards us and came between us.
I understand that someone might feel insecure in certain situations, but these incidents made even ordinary interactions feel uncomfortable.
The things she said about me
She repeatedly made comments about me behind my back.
Once, she told him, "Doesn't she have her own man? Why does she need mine?"
I eventually messaged her directly and explained that I had absolutely no romantic interest in him. I told her we were just friends, that our friendship had existed long before their relationship, and apologised if anything I had done made her uncomfortable.
But the behaviour continued.
She also got jealous whenever he gave me small birthday gifts. For context, we exchange inexpensive gifts worth around ā¹300. It's something we've always done as friends.
He spends thousands on her, pays for everything and buys her whatever she wants, but even these small gestures between us bothered her.
She also became uncomfortable whenever he visited our hometown to meet me.
Eventually, he started hiding the fact that he met me because she would stop talking to him whenever she found out.
My problem gradually became bigger with him than with her.
At some point, I discovered that he was also talking badly about me to her. He apparently called me a psycho and said other hurtful things.
I also noticed something strange.
Whenever she insulted me or complained about me, he would sometimes join in. She would then become affectionate towards him.
It started feeling like he enjoyed the validation he received from her jealousy. He had never received much romantic attention before, and perhaps having someone act possessive over him made him feel wanted and important.
I don't know if that's actually what was happening, but that's how it looked from my perspective.
He also spoke badly about her to me, while speaking badly about me to her.
I felt like he was maintaining two separate narratives to keep both of us around.
And the worst part was that he rarely stood up for me when she disrespected me.
I repeatedly communicated how uncomfortable and hurt I was. He tried keeping both relationships separate by not discussing me with her and not discussing her with me.
But by then, I had already experienced too many incidents. I had lost the ability to feel comfortable around him.
Also, her possessiveness wasn't limited to me. My friend lives in a PG, and she would get irritated even when his roommates or other girls interacted with him. Once, when he was on speakerphone, she deliberately said something extremely hurtful to his roommate, even though she knew he could hear her.
Where things stand now
I eventually told my best friend that he needed to make a choice.
Either he maintains his relationship with her without involving me in this unhealthy dynamic, or he maintains our friendship without continuing to expose me to this situation.
I even told him that if their relationship eventually ended, we could potentially rebuild our friendship. But I didn't want to continue being part of this triangle.
He called me brutal for asking him to choose.
The thing is, I don't think he wants to lose either of us. He wants her as his girlfriend and wants me in his life as a friend
I just don't want to be constantly disrespected, discussed behind my back and treated like a threat for simply existing in his life.
I genuinely miss the friendship we had before all this happened. But I also feel like I've lost the ability to feel emotionally safe with someone who was once my closest friend.
My questions:
Am I wrong for asking him to choose between his girlfriend and me?
Is expecting him to stand up for me when his girlfriend repeatedly disrespects me an unreasonable expectation?
Should I have simply distanced myself without giving him an ultimatum?
I'm afraid, I'll never find a friend because all female friends left after getting boyfriends and would only come to rant about their lives. most male friends hit on me. he is the only guy who never did anything with me and always gave me my own space.
Why would someone continue maintaining a friendship while simultaneously badmouthing that friend to their partner just to gain validation?
I'd appreciate honest opinions, including if you think I'm wrong somewhere. I don't want people to blindly take my side. I genuinely want an outside perspective on this situation.