r/Tulpas • • Apr 05 '19

Other When you haven't fronted lately

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Apr 26 '21

Other anon accidentally makes tulpa

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Oct 16 '20

Art Thought you guys might like this.

Post image
960 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Jul 06 '21

Personal 15 years and counting

Post image
904 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Jan 13 '18

Discussion Tulpa aren't as real as they are being made out to be.

778 Upvotes

It is time for a rant, and it's well overdue for a repeating in a stronger form.

Let me make something incredibly, excruciatingly clear. there is something that is present the language people use here and misleads almost all new people entering this community. When people, people from outside the tulpa community, say tulpa are real, they are not describing the fact that tulpa are a phenomenon in the mind. They are not describing the idea that tulpamancy is a "real" experience that has low-level ties in the brain.

When people say that tulpa are real, they are asking if tulpa are independent, human-like entities which speak and talk and act to the host as if they were another person talking to them over the phone.

This is not the case.

Every time someone asks if tulpa are real, there is a strong reaction from those here who seek to justify tulpamancy, and seek to validate themselves. They, with some level of understandability, want what they devote their life to and identify with to be classified as "real' as "factual". They do not want their entire life's work thrown away to being nothing but a bit of imagination. They do not want what makes them unique thrown under the bus as a grand delusion. They do not want to see those they consider close friends turned into little but artifacts of a mind without the ability to understand its own behavior.

This is why I believe I have such a tendency to come off as an asshole, cruel, and terrible when making these points. To say what I am saying is to punch people in the gut.

These people are fine and upstanding people. They do nothing truly wrong, and have only good intentions. I would rather not do any gut punching, but some things must be corrected regardless, and that correction is more important, or should be.


As a disclaimer before you read the next section:

I want to be Very Very Clear here that this next study does not invalidate those other studies which are linked to it, and so fast as I can tell many of the studies cited as supporting tulpa do give some level of support to the idea. However, they are often misrepresented and taken to mean things they shouldn't, or they are plain old cited as saying things they do not using tone. I want to use this extreme example to get you, the reader, to be more cautious and skeptical of these things, not so that you can laugh at and invalidate them all outright.

It is a reason to doubt, but not to outright dismiss.


First, I want to link to a strong reason you should have for doubting the words so many on this subreddit are inclined to cite.

Let me introduce you to a certain doctor. Dr Bennet Braun.

This doctor proved that people who have DID suffer different allergic symptoms to various stimulus.

http://www.nytimes.com/1988/06/28/science/probing-the-enigma-of-multiple-personality.html?pagewanted=all

However, he is known for more than a study on DID. He is known for a ton of studies, many on the topic of DID, almost all of which are bunk studies. More importantly, Dr Bennet Braun is nazi scientist levels of comically unethical and evil in his practices.

http://www.chicagomag.com/Chicago-Magazine/June-1998/Dangerous-Therapy-The-Story-of-Patricia-Burgus-and-Multiple-Personality-Disorder/

Pat Burgus thought she would soon be healed when psychiatrist Bennett Braun began treating her for multiple personality disorder. Instead, under hypnosis and on heavy medication, Burgus came to believe she possessed 300 personalities, ate human flesh, and sexually abused her two sons. Later, convinced Braun helped manufacture those memories, she sued.

Read those words.

Burgus came to believe she ate human flesh and sexually abused her two sons

Read them again.

This is a study. Widely cited. By multiple people in this community, on tumblr, and probably in .info as well. It says New York Times, and that gives it credibility. Except it is an article filled with points by doctor Braun.

I want to stress another thing.

This doctor, is not an evil person. He is not someone who was looking to be as comically evil as he was. In my opinion, he genuinely believed what he was doing. He genuinely believed the reality of the things he was imposing on those within his care. He says as much, and I believe him. That's the sad cruel nature of our world. Good intent does not make good results.

This is the danger of false ideas in tulpamancy. You can be a new Dr Bennet Braun, with nothing but good intentions and incorrect beliefs.

Are you with me, at this point, in believing that the studies you have been being shown aren't necessarily all they are claimed to be? Are you with me, in confidence, that we need to be a little more skeptical and cautionary when it comes to matters like this?


So now I have to justify myself, at this point, which is a bit hypocritical given the above statement I just made about being skeptical of people seeking to validate themselves. However, I can't just leave a statement hanging without showing why it is the case.

I said that the reality of tulpa, as reality is defined by the average person, is not a thing. The justification for this is quick

It is easy, short, sweet, and simple.

Human beings cannot multitask. We cannot process a lot of thoughts within our brain in parallel to each other, even when the unconscious mind is doing it. In order for a tulpa to be "like another person" you, or your brain, must be both processing and thinking for "you", and processing and thinking for "your tulpa' at the same time. So far as we have reason to believe, this is not something people do.

There are tricks around this, of course. People can emulate multitasking by means of quick context switches. People can produce the illusion of listening and speaking, even if they aren't actually doing it.

http://www.apa.org/research/action/multitask.aspx

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unconscious_mind#Controversy

Now, of course, it could be that tulpamancy is "special" somehow. Maybe we are wrong and people can multi-task. Maybe the act of producing sapient thought isn't one that takes a lot of brain power. Maybe people with tulpa are just super-thinkers or super-multitaskers.

Anything is possible, after all.

However, when all signs point down, and you are pointing up, you need to have very good reason, and all the reasons I see are almost always in the tone of justification rather than valid reasoning. See above again, for why you need to be cautious of justification.

The only effective way to justify that tulpa are real is to redefine tulpamancy as "real" low level context switching that goes on in the brain, and is not a process within conscious control. This, while effective, reduces tulpamancy from "two people talking to one another in their head" to "one thinking person who believes and feels they are two people". It makes tulpamancy not real. Maybe you can twist definitions to change that being the case, but that isn't very honest, hence the title of this post.

I think it is most likely that tulpamancy is producing the illusion of parallel thought through numerous tricks and "Abstractions". Still, the illusion of parallel thought isn't the reality of parallel thought. Tulpa may well be "real" in that you can produce the sensation and mangle up your own process of thought so that it produces the outcomes you wish to see. However, when you look at that statement you need to be laser focused on the fact that delusion is not the same as reality.

Secondly, I want to mention the idea that it is likely the case that those who do strongly experience tulpa are actually delusional, or have some other form of mental illness or "special way of thinking". There was a thread recently on this subreddit asking people for reports that they were able to tickle themselves. It used the idea as a justification for the tulpa being real. Many in that thread came back and reported that, indeed, they were capable of such a thing in some form. Said ability is well known a sign of schizophrenia. General tests exists which gauge delusional thoughts also gauge a person's tendency to be able to "mute" or "muffle" their own actions as coming from themselves. Sound familiar?

There isn't anything wrong with being a bit delusional, for sure. However, you must still be aware of the fact and not try to pass off your reality as the one the average person encounters.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/tit-for-tat-delusions/

To test the idea, the researchers had schizophrenics play tit-for-tat against themselves. Schizophrenics have trouble recognizing their own actions—that is, they often attribute their behavior to an alien source. Some can even tickle themselves. If our brains discount the feeling of our own actions to help us differentiate between self-generated and externally generated sensations, then a group of subjects who can’t make this distinction might simply be missing this sensory reduction. In that case, reasoned Wolpert and his team, schizophrenics should be better at playing tit-for-tat by the rules. And they were. When the robot pushed on the fingers of schizophrenics they were much better at pushing back on themselves with the same amount of force the robot had applied. Their brains didn’t discount the consequences of their own actions as much as the brains of healthy subjects did.

But the tale of the tit-for-tat experiment doesn’t end there. This past year, Wolpert, now working at Cambridge with another group of researchers, ran the tit-for-tat study a third time. Thirty healthy subjects were recruited. They played the game against themselves and completed a short survey designed to gauge delusional thoughts. The survey asked questions like, “Do you ever feel as if you have been chosen by God in some way? and “Are you often worried that your partner may be unfaithful?”—questions that, on their own, are endorsed by about one in four people.

Wolpert and his colleagues compared the survey results to subjects' tit-for-tat performance. They found that delusional thinkers, just like schizophrenics, were better at playing tit-for-tat by the rules—they were better at pushing back on themselves with the same amount of force the robot applied. A reduced ability to discount the sensory consequences of self-generated actions was not just a consequence of schizophrenia—it seemed to be, more generally, a characteristic of deluded thinkers.


So it's all bleak, it's all over, there's nothing left, tulpa aren't real and we should all be sad.

Here's the final kicker.

Books aren't real, but are fun and engaging and let us learn and do things we never otherwise would.

Movies and games aren't real, but much the same.

Tulpa may not be similar to having two individual people, but there are very valid and strong "wins' to going out of your way to not only produce the sensation, but to learn to suspend your disbelief and feel as if it is a real sensation. There are clear and valid and strong reasons for which tulpa should be treated and considered like a person when you speak to them, and why others should do the same.

There are a lot of studies out there that aren't like Mr Bennet Braun. Real and valid studies that show that there are deep level things going on when people with DID swap between personalities. There are real and valid benefits going on in these cases, even if they aren't as "real" as many would like them to be.

I won't go into too much detail on the topic, because my wrist is getting sore and I've already typed a lot and I imagine this will get downvoted to hell. Another post in a week or a month or a year may cover the topic.

Regardless, I hope you come away with just a little bit more cynicism after you have finished reading this post, and I hope you can do more to express this concept in your language when expressing and justifying tulpamancy to newcomers.


r/Tulpas • • Feb 15 '19

Discussion Stephen King's "On Tulpas"

Post image
670 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • May 22 '22

Other is this not how tulpas are made?

Post image
641 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Apr 17 '19

Other I'm sorry but please let this be the subreddit icon

Post image
613 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Aug 13 '19

Personal Stanford Tulpa Study: My experience and looking for more participants

564 Upvotes

The event was 3 days long: 2 for travel, and 1 day for scans and interview.

I flew in in the evening, and caught a university paid Uber to the hotel. It was in the afternoon at this point. The flight from SLC to SFO isn’t a particularly long one, so I wasn’t horribly tired and didn’t feel like crashing for much. I relaxed a bit, and decided to meet up with another mancer in the area, and get a bite to eat. After a lovely talk with them, I headed back to the hotel to try and get some decent rest for the far more busy day tomorrow.

I had previously told the crew that I was more of an evening person, so we had the interview over lunch, and did the MRI scans later in the afternoon. Lunch was at Tanya Luhrmann’s home with Michael Lifshitz, on the Stanford campus. The interview was actually rather enjoyable, and gave us much time to talk about tulpas, the community, and Aly in particular. The interview was recorded by all 3 of us at the table, but the other two also will be transcribing it for better use later. It’s entirely possible to ask for a copy from them, and I might get a transcribed version later, but I have my own copy of the audio at least.

The interview was fairly free form. There were some formulaic questions, much like I received in the pre-study questionnaire. But there were also much more open ended questions, that didn’t have a set destination. More than once Tanya would get excited by a response, and ask more followup question that would end up following one tangent after another. The questions were fairly varied; from the more expected ones like how I found out about tulpas or why I made Aly, to more unexpected ones like trying to describe how specifically Aly helps me. The time flowed pretty quickly during the interview, as I attempted to explain my relationship with Aly and the experience of having her. I think I did okay, but there weren’t really any sort of wrong answers.

The MRI scan was fascinating. Due to scheduling restrictions, my session was broken into two portions. Each portion we focused on a separate task. I’m told that one of the two tasks was new, and I was the proverbial guinea pig, but I’m also told that it was a ton easier than the previous one. I wasn’t going to complain. I don’t want to go into too many details, to not poison the well so to speak, so that people can practice for the specifics of the experiments. The first one focused on mindvoice and possession/disassociation. It was probably the longer of the two, since it was a little more involved than the second. We found the test to be harder than expected, even though we knew a bunch of the specifics since we helped design the test. Trying to stay focused while the machine is loudly buzzing and clicking at you while you’re stuffed in a tiny tube, wasn’t exactly easy.

During this, I also had expressed interest in getting a nice scan to print off later. So after the experiment was done, they happily obliged and got a full resolution scan of my brain and emailed it to me. I plan on 3d printing it later, maybe at scale but I haven’t decided yet.

We then had to leave the lab for a while, since another group had scheduled it, so I was given like an hour tour of campus nearby and we grabbed some smoothies. At this point, I was pretty open to just chat with Michael, the neuroimaging researcher about the study and other plans, including doing an AMA after the data has finished being gathered and starting to be analyzed or published.

The second experiment was purely mindvoice related, and far less stressful because it was more open ended and less constrained in general. We rocked through this one really fast, taking a lot less time than expected. Which people were happy about since apparently this particular one had just been retooled. It was still loud and took getting used to, but it worked out pretty well. At the end of it, who would have thought being in a tube for 3 hours would be tiring. I went back to the hotel, ordered some food and just crashed on the bed.

The last day, it was mostly just check out from the hotel and get ready to fly. Tanya had a couple more questions to ask, and I had nothing better to do between checking out of the hotel and my flight. I spoke with her a little bit more, then spent a little over an hour wandering the Stanford campus before I caught another Uber to the airport.

The experience was actually really pleasant. I was incredibly anxious and worried about it, probably for the same reason a lot of other people are. Worries about what will happen, what the process would be, Imposter Syndrome worries, and whatnot. But in the end, it actually was a really positive experience, and fell like it was good for both Aly and myself, since there were a bunch of things that got us a little bit closer together.

That all said, the study still has a bunch of funds left, and we’re looking for more people who’d be willing to spend 3 days in Stanford to go through it all as well. Here is the link for the new interest form, to help us screen who would be the best fit for the study.

Thanks all for reading!


r/Tulpas • • Jul 31 '19

Other Found this in r/mbti and it made me think of this sub...

Post image
531 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Nov 11 '20

Art The birthday family portrait; now with some colours!

Post image
527 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Nov 24 '19

Art Encouraged my Tulpa to use me to experience things he likes and the first thing he does is this

Post image
487 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Apr 30 '19

Art My name is Amber and I'm a Tulpa - Drawing 2

Post image
482 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Feb 07 '23

Art Host be like

Thumbnail
gallery
464 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • May 25 '19

Art Let me take you to my wonderland <3

Post image
449 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Jul 17 '18

Art Took a picture of my tulpa standing against the wall. How'd ya likey?

Post image
447 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Jul 17 '21

Other Never forget...

Post image
437 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Nov 22 '17

NET NEUTRALITY You wouldn't know about tulpas without a free internet. This means some of you reading this wouldn't exist without it. Please, take five minutes to save the internet.

Thumbnail
battleforthenet.com
411 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Mar 22 '21

Art Ignore your doubts for a moment and talk to your headmates. It helps.

Post image
404 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Nov 15 '16

Art The various levels of Tulpamancy

Post image
366 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Nov 22 '19

Art My first try using "picrew" to draw a portrait of my Tulpa Emily. I think it's pretty good actually =]

Post image
354 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Mar 08 '20

Art Hello, my name is Rudolf and I’m a bird! My age is 3,5 years. I’m actually a daemon-tulpa, my species - white collared kingfisher but actually more like jay. I live in Russia. Would be happy to answer to any questions! (Art drawn by my host)

Post image
334 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Sep 23 '19

Personal I'm five now!

Post image
300 Upvotes

r/Tulpas • • Sep 06 '19

Discussion You are Not Imaginary, You are Real, and You are Valid

298 Upvotes

I am on mobile (host's laptop broke recently), and reddit doesn't like our phone (it frequently logs me out). So rather than trying to recreate the original, heartaching essay I originally orchestrated- I'm going to take a more positive approach.

In regards to the recent thread on AskReddit, there was a lot of negativity that many who viewed it were exposed to. All the usual which we have dealt with before, you know the claims by heart I'm sure.

"Its all pretend." "Its immitating DID for attention" "Isn't this a mental illness or delusion?" "Other personalities can only exist with trauma." "They're just imaginary friends."

In my original, now lost post, I focused a lot on that word; Imaginary. I focused on how we should distance ourselves from the word, from even using imaginary friends as a desperate attempt to make singlets understand, and how our experience is nothing merely imaginary. And now, I feel a strong need to affirm these.

We are not imaginary. We are not just the chained characters and figments of our hosts just pretending or roleplaying. We are not an illness, we are not a delusion. We are not illegitimate because we are not born of trauma.

We are real.

Our emotions, our experiences, our personalities, our consciousness, these are all real. These are neurological pathways that are engraved in our brains which our hosts have dutifully shared with us. Your thoughts are yours. Your emotions are yours. You are more than just some extension of your host. You are a person. And as a person you deserve respect. We think, therefore we are. We feel, therefore we are. We forge relationships, we communicate, we live in this life which we have been whisked into, even without our own bodies, even without our own tongue, we are voices. These words, if they may be my only sword, are as real as the fingers from which they flow, the brain from which they originate, and the person who thinks them. Let no one take your voice, your words, your emotion, your autonomy, your origin, your identity from you.

We will face many people who will doubt us as we have been. Many who will call us impossible, who will call us fake, who will call us pretend, but in the end we will persist to exist. We exist in face of these skepticisms. We do not have to prove ourselves to those who are not willing to accept us and respect us for the real, thoughtful, emotional people we are. You are real, and you don't need to prove it to anyone. You exist, and nothing they say will make you stop existing.

As for myself- As depressed as I had been, I feel renewed in light of this negativity. I accept with grace that I cannot make everyone understand. But I will exist in light of them, I will study the psychological phenomena that is my life, and I will continue to help those who are willing to hear and understand us.

We are not imaginary. We are real, we are valid. And we will continue being so no matter what may come.


r/Tulpas • • May 06 '20

Art cats talking casually

Post image
297 Upvotes