r/TrueReddit • u/yourmotherisawhore • Apr 15 '13
Gitmo Is Killing Me
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/15/opinion/hunger-striking-at-guantanamo-bay.html?_r=088
u/chupacabrando Apr 15 '13 edited Apr 15 '13
Letter written. Anybody else out there, feel free to copy/paste my letter and send it to your respective representative. Don't know who this is? They make it RIDICULOUS EASY to contact your representative. Go to http://www.house.gov/representatives/find/, enter your zip code, and BAM! Click the little email button. Please do this. This needs to be addressed.
"Dear Congressperson _______,
I recently came across the article in the New York Times, "Gitmo Is Killing Me" (http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/15/opinion/hunger-striking-at-guantanamo-bay.html?_r=0), written by a prisoner still being detained in Guantanamo Bay. I think the situation has become dire. I do not know how long abuse like this has gone on, but I fear it may be longer than I expect. There is absolutely no reason for prisoners to still be detained in Guantanamo Bay. We, as a civilized nation, MUST clear out the remaining prisoners. This is a crime against humanity, and not representative of American interests at large. This, unfortunately, is a case where apathy cuts deeper than malice, and should we continue to sweep such an infringement of basic human rights (as defined by the Bill of Rights) under the rug, the remaining innocent prisoners in Guantanamo will die unfulfilled and untried. This is not the American way.
Sincerely,
__________"
10
u/mattkatzbaby Apr 15 '13
I've upvoted this because this is the absolutely most useful comment in this thread. THIS makes a difference.
I will be sending a letter based on yours and I thank you for your effort.
Congress people get letters and the letters matter more than anyone here in internetland thinks. If you don't have tons of donation money, this is the most important thing you can do. I suspect, but do not know for certain, that this is more important than making a phone call to their office.
7
Apr 15 '13
Get this comment to the top, please.
Finding senators is just as easy.
Don't let history say you did nothing.
(Also -- I've heard faxing is the most attention-getting thing you can do to a leader. It hogs their machine and depletes their resources. Just another idea. The only wrong idea here is to do nothing.)
4
u/hrtattx Apr 15 '13
upvoted. emailed my rep. i encourage everyone else to do the same, it's extremely easy. this is how democracy works. our representatives are supposed to do our bidding. we have to let them know how we feel about the issues.
2
u/nas Apr 15 '13
Thank you for this response. American citizens, this is your government and if you don't like it, do something about it. To those who are okay with this, I have two simple questions. Do you believe the right to a fair trial? If so, why do the prisoners not qualify to this basic human right? Do you think that calling someone a terrorist gives you the right to treat someone as sub-human. I have no doubt that future generations will look at this behavior (started by Bush, continued by Obama) as shameful.
2
u/mmhawyeah Apr 15 '13
I'm sure your email will be appropriately filed in the correct
trashbin and acted uponneverin a timely fashion.1
Apr 15 '13
I just messaged my congressman. I feel like I made a difference today, even if it was small.
→ More replies (1)1
49
u/pth Apr 15 '13
I hope my grandchildren will look back on the Guantanamo Bay prison and drone strike assassinations the way we currently view World War 2 Japanese American internment camps -- with shame and confusion on how it was allowed to happen.
That said I do not know how to get there from here. I tell my friends, most of them either say, "the government must know something you don't" or that I am blowing it out of proportion. I write my congress people and the White House, rarely a response and never more than boilerplate.
I want to live in world of free people, not a nation that worships freedom like an idol, but barely knows the meaning of the word. I am not some student radical, I am a dad, husband, suburban living guy who is ashamed of how his country and the people I have voted for are letting us down.
7
u/courageousrobot Apr 15 '13
I agree with you to an extent. However, there are differences between Guantanamo Bay and the internment camps.
The Japanese in the internment camps were placed there due to suspicion because of their nationality. I can't speak for numbers, because what the hell do I know, but in theory, Guantanamo Bay is a place for terrorists. Maybe many of them are innocent. Maybe they were in the wrong place, at the wrong time, but the fact is, at least some of those men there are terrorists.
So the difference is: one was founded on intolerance and racism, the other on... an unconstitutional foundation. The motivations, intentions, and causes ARE different.
10
u/notsofst Apr 15 '13
I don't see the difference you're trying to make. The Japanese internment camps were created because of the possibility that some Japanese might be foreign agents working against the U.S. during the war.
Guantanamo is the same deal, except the people were collected internationally and the size of the camp is much smaller and its implementation much more cruel, and our war now is much less defined.
Both were founded on an "unconstitutional foundation" as you put it, and in my opinion, Guantanamo is a far greater crime. I mean, at least the Japanese Internment camps didn't have institutionalized torture.
Guantanamo Bay is a scar on our history and its creation is one of the most shameful and terrible acts ever perpetrated by our government.
1
u/courageousrobot Apr 15 '13
The difference is, as far as I know, no Japanese-Americans (and we were talking about American citizens here) were ever caught planning sabotage against the United States.
In theory (again, because what do any of us really know), there are actual legitimate terrorists in Gitmo.
Guantanamo Bay is shameful. Due process should be practiced and respected... but how is it a far greater crime to incarcerate terrorists and potential terrorists than to incarcerate your own country's citizens based on nothing but race alone?
5
u/coooolbeans Apr 15 '13
See: Niihau Incident
The Niʻihau Incident (or Battle of Niʻihau) occurred on December 7, 1941, when Imperial Japanese Navy Air Service pilot Shigenori Nishikaichi crash-landed his Zero on the Hawaiian island of Niʻihau after participating in the attack on Pearl Harbor.
The island's Native Hawaiian residents were initially unaware of the attack, but apprehended Nishikaichi when the gravity of the situation became apparent. Nishikaichi then sought and received the assistance of three locals of Japanese descent in overcoming his captors, finding weapons, and taking several hostages. In the end Nishikaichi was killed by the wife of Niʻihauan Ben Kanahele, (he was wounded in the process), and one of Nishikaichi's confederates, Yoshio Harada, committed suicide.
The incident and the actions of Nishikaichi's abettors contributed to a sense in the American military that every Japanese, even those who were American citizens or otherwise thought loyal to the United States, might aid Japan, and ultimately may have influenced the decision to intern Japanese Americans through World War II. The actions of the Niʻihauans were widely celebrated in the United States; Ben Kanahele was decorated for his part in stopping the incident.
2
u/notsofst Apr 15 '13 edited Apr 15 '13
Whether they caught anyone or not is kind of besides the point. They were concerned that some Japanese Americans might be spies and/or operate as insurgents on the mainland. Their response was to round up the whole population of Japanese, ~100,000 or so, and intern them.
So, the scale of the deprivation of liberty is much larger, that's for sure, since Guantanamo is only ~1,000 strong. But we're definitely making up for the size of it with the quality of injustice that we're dispensing now. Just because they used race as a criteria in WW2 doesn't really matter at all, IMO, what about race makes it any better and/or worse than any other prejudice?
In both cases it's the government using wartime privileges to subvert human rights. Now it's even more of a joke because we're at "war" with "terror", which means we have a defacto perpetual war that we can use to incarcerate anyone, anywhere, at any time, regardless of race and/or nationality.
Really the only difference between WW2's internment and now is that in WW2 at least we had some criteria for who gets interned, and we interned a much larger section of the population, but treated them better.
Maybe it was worse in WW2 because the internment was of U.S. citizens, not foreign nationals like it is today, but I'm not 100% sure we can say with certainty that U.S. nationals haven't been caught up in all this. I mean, we've hit at least one or two with drone missiles, so who's to say that there aren't a few U.S. Nationals in one of the CIA camps located around the world.
In theory (again, because what do any of us really know), there are actual legitimate terrorists in Gitmo.
That's kind of the problem. Anyone has a right to a public trial, a defense, and to be made aware of the charges that have been brought against them. They have a right to have these things done within a reasonable amount of time.
Terrorist or not, you have a right to all these things. So the guilt of the detained parties is completely irrelevant, since that guilt has not been found through proper and public processes.
2
u/reasonably_plausible Apr 15 '13
since Guantanamo is only ~1,000 strong
Source for this number? Not that it makes it all that much better, but current number of detainees at Guantanamo should be at 166.
1
u/notsofst Apr 16 '13 edited Apr 16 '13
Says 779 on the wikipedia article, for total number of prisoners moved through.
If anything that number under-represents the issue, since Guantanamo isn't the only site.
And it's likely that the CIA is under-reporting the number of detainees slightly.
So Guantanamo is at 779, but there are likely hundreds more caught up in similar situations in sites run by the CIA all over the world.
Abu Ghraib was one such site. What a wonderful discovery that place was. Imagine the "Guantanamo" sites that we have which have absolutely no oversight and/or public awareness of.
3
u/canadianbakn Apr 15 '13
the fact is, at least some of those men there are terrorists
Do some more research. The vast majority of those men are now believed to be innocent, some have even been pardoned, and the families of those turning in "terrorists" were given food and money by the US. If you were starving, you'd tell lies too.
6
u/pth Apr 15 '13
But the net result is the same, we are holding and sometimes torturing innocent people without trial. In other cases we assassinate them and anyone unlucky enough to be near, with drones again without due process.
Ends justifying means, ignoring common humanity out of fear some of the worst attributes of humanity masquerading as strength and morals.
6
u/courageousrobot Apr 15 '13
I can't argue with your premise.
I'm not saying you're wrong, but what do you do with those terrorists who are guilty, but the evidence against them is invalid due the the legality of how it was obtained?
Let's assume that funding is cleared up, prisoners are allowed to face trial, most of those that were in the 'wrong place at the wrong time' are let free, sent back to Yemen or wherever, but a handful are kept at whatever Supermax they're moved to. Is that an acceptable compromise? Is it ever okay to detain your enemies in such a way?
6
u/pth Apr 15 '13
You can have a military trial, with relaxed rules of evidence discovery as long as it is a trial with reasonable rules and a chance for the defendant to "have their day in court" then yes. Once a real and at least semi-public (the record could even be "held in escrow" for x years due the sensitive nature of acquisition, etc). It would be best if it could be done by a close ally rather than us, but regardless it should have been done a decade ago. And people who are found innocent deserve significant reparations their lives have been destroyed out of our fear.
Once someone is found guilty basically of murder/war crimes/crimes against humanity -- lock them up and throw away the key and if they want to hunger strike, then let them.
We can't hide behind our previous mistakes and continue to act the bully. Our actions are breeding another generation of terrorists, because there are few other ways assault the United States or unfortunately even get the attention of most of its population.
3
4
u/Neebat Apr 15 '13
"It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer"
That version is from Sir William Blackstone, 1765, but the idea is much older.
Let them go. Stand up and demand that every single prisoner at Gitmo be prosecuted or released NOW, this year. We don't have to detain them just because they're guilty. We've failed as a society by contaminating the evidence so they can't be tried, but that's no excuse for punishing the innocent along with the guilty.
4
176
Apr 15 '13
I can't, off the top of my head, think of any cartoonish villain who would kidnap someone in his mid-20s and then torture him in a dungeon for 11 years. I mean, this transcends the limits of your normal, run-of-the-mill cheesy exaggerated villainy.
39
u/adremeaux Apr 15 '13
There is no single villain. It is distributed, and it's more attributed to negligence and ignorance than anything. Each member involved is only aware of a small part of the whole. And then employees come and go. The only person (or people) you can truly attribute this to are congress, who refuse to shut it down despite repeated attempts by the executive branch to close it. But even then, those congress members don't truly know the whole story, either, and the only reason they vote against it is for political reasoning. The whole thing is a farce.
-3
u/NoMoreNicksLeft Apr 15 '13
who refuse to shut it down despite repeated attempts by the executive branch to close it.
[chuckle] Sure. Whatever you want to tell yourself so you can feel good for voting for him?
Do you know what non-sociopaths do? They'd shut it down anyway, and then take the punishment for doing it against Congress's say-so. Impeachment, whatever. (Though truth told, had he done this, even I would be a fan, and we'd punish Congress in turn).
But he doesn't give a shit. Truly.
7
u/adremeaux Apr 15 '13
They'd shut it down anyway, and then take the punishment for doing it against Congress's say-so.
You can't do that... like, not, he'd do it and then get impeached. He literally cannot do it. Please learn something about politics before you continue posting on it.
→ More replies (3)0
17
u/ValiantPie Apr 15 '13
Have you ever seen Oldboy? Do so, because it's a wonderful movie. It takes the premise you just stated and gets even crazier and more interesting from there.
7
u/randomb0y Apr 15 '13
Only without the torture. He's just imprisoned. There's no beatings, force-feeding, etc.
0
6
Apr 15 '13
Is that the one where some guy eats a whole octopus? If so, that's the only part I've seen, I think...
5
121
u/Cacafuego Apr 15 '13 edited Apr 15 '13
Apparently the US is willing to release all or almost all of the remaining Yemeni detainees, but the Yemeni government is demanding $200 million (yes, they want $200 million before they will accept their own citizens back) and we are only willing to pay $20 million. Wikipedia
I can't believe that this is the only roadblock. Surely it would be worth $200 million to get that much closer to closing this shameful chapter.
Edit: okay, so Obama suspended repatriation of Yemenis in 2010 due to concerns about the "current security situation", a reference to the terrorist network(s) in Yemen that allegedly had ties to Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab (the underwear bomber). It's not clear to me whether this is still the primary issue.
64
u/kog Apr 15 '13
I can't believe that this is the only roadblock.
The responsibility lies not so much with the White House but with Congress, which has thwarted President Barack Obama’s plans to close the detention center, which the Bush administration opened on Jan. 11, 2002, with 20 captives.
Congress has used its spending oversight authority both to forbid the White House from financing trials of Guantánamo captives on U.S. soil and to block the acquisition of a state prison in Illinois to hold captives currently held in Cuba who would not be put on trial — a sort of Guantánamo North.
This was a part of that year's NDAA, the omnibus bill that funds the entire US Military for the year. It's the same way Congress strong-armed him into signing the one everyone on reddit hates so much, with the indefinite detention provisions.
11
u/Cacafuego Apr 15 '13
Interesting article!
I would like to know more about the roadblocks mentioned here:
But Congress has made it nearly impossible to transfer captives anywhere. Legislation passed since Obama took office has created a series of roadblocks that mean that only a federal court order or a national security waiver issued by Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta could trump Congress and permit the release of a detainee to another country.
This sounds like more than just a funding issue.
4
Apr 15 '13
permit the release of a detainee to another country.
This sounds like more than just a funding issue.
You are right it is finding a country that actually wants these guys.
→ More replies (2)4
u/kog Apr 15 '13
You're absolutely right. As you can tell from the article, it's a pretty damn complicated situation, and I'm far from an expert.
1
u/bigDean636 Apr 16 '13
This actually makes a lot of sense, at least politically. It's a very good position to take, for political maneuvering, to say "I'm not going to vote for AMERICAN money to be paid to countries to take back their own prisoners that we detained for possible terrorist ties!"
And it's really not all that unreasonable of a position, but it certainly sucks for the Gitmo prisoners sitting in limbo.
→ More replies (2)0
u/NoMoreNicksLeft Apr 15 '13
Obama's a millionaire. He could, if he wanted to, ask the Cubans to let him drive them to the Havana airport, and buy them all commercial tickets.
Problem solved.
16
u/randomb0y Apr 15 '13
This should be higher up on the page.
I still think that the US should pay this plus reparations to everyone who was never found guilty of a crime.
14
Apr 15 '13
exactly, what the fuck is the plan? just keeping them until they die, and then you solved the problem?
4
u/CandethMartine Apr 15 '13
Yes - the US is looking into long term medical care for these people, which hints very strongly at this.
3
→ More replies (1)0
45
Apr 15 '13
"Do anything to me!" he yelled. "You've been starving me for weeks. Finish it off and let me die. Shoot me. Hang me. Sentence me to twenty-five years. Is there somebody else you want me to give away? Just say who it is and I'll tell you anything you want. I don't care who it is or what you do to them. I've got a wife and three children. The biggest of them isn't six years old. You can take the whole lot of them and cut their throats in front of my eyes, and I'll stand by and watch it. But not Room 101!"
"Room 101," said the officer.
0
Apr 15 '13
[deleted]
5
u/snoharm Apr 15 '13
Why is this a reply to a 1984 quote?
1
Apr 16 '13
Because he's replying in response to the content of the quote, not the notion of it merely being a quote. Don't worry though, we all know you have read 1984 now.
I believe ehsany is saying if we could show, straightforward, what these tortures are like and spread it (much like how affecting the the quote from 1984 is in written form), then perhaps more attention would be paid to the situation at hand.
→ More replies (3)
203
u/Addyct Apr 15 '13
America does this. I want to say "still does this", but that makes it seem like it was acceptable at some point.
We are doing this You and I are doing this. It's our government. We are responsible.
100
Apr 15 '13
Point me in the right direction. I'm a dreamer, an idealist, I imagine I'd be an activist given a cause I believed in strongly enough. How do I, on a personal level, affect change in this?
43
Apr 15 '13
Write to your congressperson. It's more than nothing.
14
u/rustajb Apr 15 '13
It's something, but with little weight. My wife writes her congresspeople on occasion and always gets back boilerplate letters that basically say "I do what I want. I do it for you." She's never received any meaningful discourse or response. I always hear this as a means to an end, but I can't help but feel it's terribly misguided and uses energy that could be put to better use.
5
u/ghjm Apr 15 '13
It only matters in quantity - just like voting. Go door to door and get 100 people to write letters, and you might see something happen.
7
u/mattkatzbaby Apr 15 '13
Listen to this guy. Nerd-fatalism is such a depressing thing. An action, like signing a petition or writing your congressperson, has an effect. Every politician or staffer will tell you the same thing:
Letters work. They are direct evidence. Get a stamp and a piece of paper and write a god damned letter.
20
u/whyso Apr 15 '13
Sounds like nothing, have some lobbyist money though...
46
u/cdigioia Apr 15 '13 edited Apr 16 '13
A large # of letters on the same topic is something. It's easy to be cynical but...a member of one of the most democratic governments in all of history and..."Oh i can't write a letter...it's too le hard, and probably doesn't matter much".
You're not a serf, slave, or other non-voting-member tied to the land - this is unusual in human history, regardless of your cynicism you learned in AP US History (so back off 17 year olds!). It might be worth it to express your opinion!
1
u/whyso Apr 16 '13
A large number might, but my writing one would not be or cause this. Also there are probably other concerns that would override any amount of letters.
→ More replies (6)0
Apr 15 '13
[deleted]
16
u/WorkSux456 Apr 15 '13
This mentality of if I write my representative I will be be put on some list is why shit doesn't get done. These are our elected officials in government. At worst your letters will be a nuisance and get put in File 13. At best you along with many other people's letters will help put this on their radar as something important to their constituents.
→ More replies (1)7
u/bobtheterminator Apr 15 '13
Lobbyist money is not the problem here, nobody lobbies to keep Guantanamo open. It's purely public opinion. Everyone in Washington thinks closing the prison will look bad, and it will. Especially if Obama tried to shove it through without the approval of Congress. If public opinion changes, government opinion will change.
10
u/rustajb Apr 15 '13
That's not it. Releasing those prisoners means we have to respond legally. They were detained unlawfully. If they are found to not be insurgents or criminals, there are potential national and global legal repercussions for what we have done. Until they can think of a way to release them and get off scott free, it just isn't going to happen.
6
u/bobtheterminator Apr 15 '13
I'm not sure that's true. Has any significant country even called us out on this? I think I remember maybe China did, but anyone else? We've already released hundreds of prisoners without any charges, and if I remember right many of the current detainees have been cleared for release, they just haven't actually been released for whatever reason. If there are going to be global consequences, they will happen whether or not we shut down the prison.
Obama wrote a nice executive order a few years ago that told the defense department to figure out where to transfer or release all the prisoners within a year and then shut the place down. Congress blocked funding for that and then I guess he gave up. I really think the only obstacles here are a) closing it would be pretty unpopular at the moment, and b) there are probably plenty of prisoners the DoD doesn't want to release but can't formally charge for whatever reason. There's really nothing we can do about point b unless Congress or the international community wants to step up and point out how illegal this stuff is, but point a is definitely changeable.
3
u/rustajb Apr 15 '13
You're looking at now and extrapolating. When 800+ people are released there is going to be a percentage that seeks justice or revenge or both. That percentage will be the loudest and will want to draw attention to the crimes committed on them. The situation will be very different if the right person says the right words to the right people. It could become quite a large stink. That's the potential. As long as it stays open and the prisoners remain there, there is no potential for them to cause us retributive harm.
3
u/bobtheterminator Apr 15 '13
800+? There's 169 there right now. We've already released 600 though. Now I'm sure some of the ones still there are the most vocal and dangerous and I'm sure that's one of the concerns of the DoD, but with so many we've already released, I don't think that's a huge hurdle. Some of those 600 must have spoken out publicly, and so far they haven't made an impact. Some of them are probably working for terrorist groups at the moment. I totally agree that keeping the prison open is the safest option for those in charge, but I think you overestimate the potential impact of released prisoners. We've had former (and current) presidents speak out against this place. If they couldn't stir up enough controversy then what are these guys going to do. Who could they even find to talk to that doesn't already know about this and hate us for it?
Also, closing Guantanamo doesn't mean sending all the prisoners home. The idea is to transfer many of them inside the US and actually charge them with something.
2
u/ancaptain Apr 15 '13
Disagreed. Similar to how homeopathy can do damage by giving the illusion of a cure and preventing the individual from finding an actual cure, thinking that writing your politician can produce change lacks empirical evidence to support such claims, quite the opposite actually.
→ More replies (27)3
u/Stillbornchild Apr 15 '13
I'm a dreamer
Bless your soul
How do I, on a personal level, affect change in this?
You work logistics for someone willing to get their hands dirty.
10
u/Eskapismus Apr 15 '13
Well it's actually even worse. I'm not American but I am a "member of the West" and like we westerners are talking about the "Muslim world" as if it were one entity the rest of the world is talking about the West as if it was one entity.
I am living in Russia and every time I mention some human rights abuses by some Russian authorities to a Russian co-worker or friend I get an immediate "well you westerners aren't any better - look at the Gulag in Guantanamo" come back.
We are undermining everything the western culture once stood for. Guantanamo is an amazing propaganda tool for guys like Putin to proof to their people how hypocritical "the west" is.
Seriously, fucking stop it already its been too long.
46
Apr 15 '13
This is why they hate America. Not because of 'freedoms' or whatever bullshit.
→ More replies (8)18
u/Bitterfish Apr 15 '13
Not really, though. I mean, it's horrible, but fewer than a 800 people have ever been detained there, and there were only 169 left by June 2012. The problem is that they've basically fallen through the cracks -- the government hasn't decided to release them, and there's few enough of them that it doesn't present a really massive problem for the military.
My point is just that it's not like everybody in Yemen (or whatever, any middle eastern country) knows somebody who went to Guantanamo. Basically none of them do. Maybe they've heard about it, but I imagine it's fairly abstract, like it is to most Americans. This is definitely not why they (those who do) hate America.
45
Apr 15 '13
In the UK a similar amount of IRA suspects were imprisoned, and the effect of their interment still resonates today, and they were almost universally hated. It's not directly comparable, but it shows how just a handful of people can act as lightning rods for angst and upset.
2
Apr 15 '13
Internment has been introduced a lot of times in Irish history, and every time it has only incited violence.
Do people not study history, or what?
18
u/nowonmai666 Apr 15 '13
If only 169 Americans were being held for no good reason in some random country, do you think that the American people would stand by and say "meh, they just fell through the cracks" and not care? Or would there be demonstrations of hatred against that country?
7
u/fieryseraph Apr 15 '13 edited Feb 26 '26
This post was taken down by its author. Redact was used for the removal, which may have been motivated by privacy, security, or other personal reasons.
unwritten cable dinosaurs teeny cooperative square ripe gaze tart handle
26
Apr 15 '13
And yet as a country you still feel the need to lecture the rest of the world on matters of liberty and freedom.
64
u/GloriousDawn Apr 15 '13
As a european myself, i think you got it wrong. Isn't the purpose of the "liberty and freedom" rhetoric to convince americans they're still living in a free and democratic country ?
4
10
u/bifmil Apr 15 '13
Isn't the purpose of your rhetoric to convince Europeans they're superior?
8
u/HellonStilts Apr 15 '13
Europe mostly outgrew concentration camps seventy years ago. So yeah, we kind of are in this respect.
9
Apr 15 '13
That fact that you can legitimately compare extermination camps of the Nazis to the internment camps at Guantanamo is laughable. I wonder how many Jews got kosher meals or PlayStations in Nazi Germany.
You want to blame someone? Blame Congress who passed a law specifically saying we cannot put these guys in a federal prison.
Saudi Arabia does't want these guys back, Pakistan doesn't want these guys back. Nobody wants these guys back. Maybe whatever county you live in can take them.
→ More replies (2)5
u/ecib Apr 15 '13
Europe mostly outgrew concentration camps seventy years ago. So yeah, we kind of are in this respect.
Lol, what?
You guys house a bunch of our CIA black-sites. European and American Intelligence Services, -Buddiez4Lyfe <3 The actual torture happens on your soil.
4
u/HellonStilts Apr 15 '13
The actual torture happens wherever the CIA has its black claws, it seems. This really seems to be a result of the pressure of the massive US intelligence agency. Further, most European governments seem to be against all this, what with the big-ass investigations being pursued against corrupt former Warsaw-pact intelligence services and all that. So considering that the black sites are initiated by the US, and Guantanamo is run by the US without any outside pressure, you're not really selling me.
9
u/ecib Apr 15 '13
This really seems to be a result of the pressure of the massive US intelligence agency.
Nice try. It's the result of the consent of the European Union countries that opted to participate just as much. To even hint otherwise is a joke. The shit they're doing on EU soil is so bad that they couldn't get away with it under US law, -that's why they're performing the rendition. All they need are countries willing to participate and let them do what they want. In exchange for cash or weapons or whatever else.
Further, most European governments seem to be against all this,
Except, ya know, the multiple ones involved. And due to the nature of the secret renditions, we can't even be sure of the exact number of EU countries involved, or to what extent. We do know it is multiple.
But keep your head right there in the sand where it's comfortable. Just like in Hitler's Germany, these American and European governments need a critical mass of people to look away.
→ More replies (4)3
Apr 15 '13
We have kinda outgrown the perpetual state of war the oh-so-good US find themselves in.
3
0
2
u/Metallio Apr 15 '13
Listen, hypocrisy bugs me as much as the next guy, and I recognize the political utility in convincing the populace that we're the "good guys"...but I can't see striving for those ideals without that rhetoric. If I wish to retain some optimism and believe that there really is a "better" way to live, inclusive of liberty and freedom and justice for all...how do I push for it, fight for it, without discussing it? Without short phrases to encapsulate the concept? Long panel discussions are necessary but so is inclusion of those who will never read anything long enough to need a TLDR.
I'd far rather live in a world where the starry eyed can be misled because they truly believe in these things than one where we've given up on them, and that means we're stuck with "liberty and freedom". I can think of worse things to fill up cheesy speeches with.
3
17
u/wafflesareforever Apr 15 '13
No I don't. I'm an American, but please don't confuse me with America. I don't even know that guy anymore.
2
3
3
u/NoMoreNicksLeft Apr 15 '13
You and I are doing this.
Speak for yourself. I am not doing it. You may want to pretend that you have the necessary influence in government to stop it but for some reason are failing to do so...
I see no reason to pretend just so I can feel guilty.
3
Apr 15 '13
If you are an American citizen, you are paying taxes that keep this institution open. If you are not American and simply living in America, purchasing American products from American companies, you are paying taxes that keep this institution open. If you voted for Barack Obama or John McCain or Mitt Romney, you voted for politicians that keep this institution open. If you know this is going on and you do nothing about it, you help keep this institution open.
Complacency is one thing, denial is horse shit. Deal with it.
→ More replies (1)1
u/PeevishPanda Apr 16 '13
Unfortunately, I did more. I was there when the first plane and many others were loaded with detainees and sent to Gitmo, I probably saw the guy who wrote the article. It's a shame they are still being held with no effort at due process, It's deplorable.
55
u/fearofcorners Apr 15 '13
That is horrifying and shameful.
-10
u/rmandraque Apr 15 '13
If its true. Just being honest here.
19
u/rattleandhum Apr 15 '13
the truth is often more horrifying than what gets published in the New York Times.
→ More replies (1)4
u/Khatib Apr 15 '13
Apparently you don't try too hard to find actual news, i.e. not the pop drama the 24/7 networks are pushing as news. The hunger strike and force feedings have been talked about in several venues, albeit not getting as much attention as they should be getting, for at least two months.
→ More replies (3)
13
u/nicponim Apr 15 '13
I don't understand; Can somebody answer me why did the Guantanamo administration allowed anyone to spill the beans? If this was due to public pressure, why didn't they fake it?
(Not that I don't want this hell closed, just baffled)
11
u/Letterbocks Apr 15 '13
The hunger strike?
The news has been relayed by detainees' legal representatives, AFAIK.
It is discussed in this article http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/apr/14/guantanamo-bay-last-uk-detainee
14
u/Magnora Apr 15 '13
Yeah I think the force-feeding is what finally is making this story get traction. They're force feeding people to keep them alive to torture more info out of them. It is beyond fucked up, it's like some government sponsored live-action "Saw" movie, just absolutely reprehensible. Americans are tired of this camp and how soulless it makes our country appear to the rest of the world. Everyone wants this thing shut down except the people who run it, and apparently those people are beyond scrutiny and above the law.
1
u/nicponim Apr 15 '13
Why would they allow legal representatives in illegal/(secret?) prison?
4
u/Letterbocks Apr 15 '13
Well Shaker Aamer is a UK citizen and was cleared for release in 2007, so the UK government have been lobbying for his release since then on top of pressure from human rights groups. I'm not sure if the families/governments of other inmates have acquired counsel.
Guantanamo certainly isn't a 'secret' prison, never was.
-8
16
u/Kaluthir Apr 15 '13
Maybe Obama should, you know, keep his fucking promise to close the place.
25
u/eamus_catuli Apr 15 '13
The most prolific myth on Reddit: "Obama tried to close down Guantanamo".
Well, no. What he tried to do was move it to a SuperMax prison in Thomson, IL.
Those detainees whom the Administration knew they could successfully prosecute in court would receive civilian trials. Those against whom they knew they couldn't obtain guilty verdicts, or weren't positive, would be held, on U.S. soil, indefinitely. "Prolonged detention" was the phrase Obama used when he presented the plan in May, 2009.
10
u/Kaluthir Apr 15 '13
What I (and presumably most others) mean by "close down Guantanamo" is 'move the detainees currently at Camp X-Ray to places in CONUS so they will receive certain rights (and to not put future GWOT detainees in similar conditions)'. I don't expect him to cede the Guantanamo naval base back to Cuba or anything. That "prolonged detention" crap is just as much of a betrayal.
7
u/eamus_catuli Apr 15 '13
Right. And my point is that Obama planned to just move them, without giving them more rights. He claimed a power which not even Bush claimed: the power to detain indefinitely, without trial or charge, on U.S. soil.
6
49
u/lowey2002 Apr 15 '13
I’ve been detained at Guantánamo for 11 years and three months. I have never been charged with any crime. I have never received a trial.
Disgusting!
59
u/Pyroteknik Apr 15 '13
Not just disgusting, but criminal and counter to the authority our government alleges to uphold, the constitution, which was specifically amended to prohibit exactly this.
→ More replies (3)22
Apr 15 '13
Don't take this the wrong way but you sound a bit surprised. It's common knowledge that detainees aren't charged with anything or given a trial.
I'm not saying that it's acceptable, I'm just worried that there are people out there who still don't know what the US is doing.
21
u/lowey2002 Apr 15 '13
No I've been aware of this for quiet a while. Time doesn't diminish the way I feel about it.
20
Apr 15 '13
Hi. I downvoted you because you are in TrueReddit and your comment does not add anything to the discussion. Please remember which subreddit you are in!
7
u/lowey2002 Apr 15 '13
All my upvotes to you, friend. This is exactly why I love this subreddit. You downvote me not because you disagree with my opinion but because it lacks content.
Truth be told I originally wrote out a whole essay about how I am Australian and despite not being an American citizen the behavior of the US government using loops-holes around the constitution and using foreign soil as a quasi-legal excuse to imprisoning people without due course is both upsetting and alarming.
See, the thing is that whenever I write out my opinions in depth I take a breather before posting and revise what I have written down. My aim is to make my post both as succinct and high impact as possible (since few people bother reading a great wall of text). So I revise what I had written and attempted to make the exact same point but with greater brevity.
Hence my post. Despite the policies, the logic or the potentially life saving information this individual could have given to further national security in the United States I find it disgusting that an individual can be imprisoned without charges, trial or appeal. As far as I am concerned the rest of OP's article is questionable since preventing somebody from committing suicide is a basic responsibility to someone who is in charge of another human being. But those three sentences made me sick to my stomach;
I’ve been detained at Guantánamo for 11 years and three months. I have never been charged with any crime. I have never received a trial.
As such my essay could be summed up with a single word that I chose to put in bold.
Therefore I think my comment has a place in this subreddit. It's not a snide remark or a invitation for pun circlejerk. It is neither poorly thought out nor indented to antagonize people with differing opinions. My comment is the condensed version of a well thought out essay on the injustice that is Guantanamo bay.
The simple fact is; I thought the United States of America was better than this. There is a man, right now, who has been in imprisoned by the USA for 11 years and three months. He has not been charged with any crimes. He has not received a trial.
Disgusting
-3
u/hivoltage815 Apr 15 '13 edited Apr 15 '13
Thanks for your valuable input to the thread.
Edit: Just pointing out that if /r/TrueReddit is supposed to be for "insightful" content, why does this, a one word reaction to the article, get upvotes? Hell, this wouldn't even be good content for the rest of Reddit. If I popped into a /r/funny thread and says "Hilarious" I certainly wouldn't be one of the top comments. I feel like I'm taking crazy pills.
11
u/Epistaxis Apr 15 '13
Does anyone remember this guy? I wish we'd elected him. He would have shut that thing down.
5
u/bifmil Apr 15 '13
Does anyone remember that the President cannot unilaterally override Congress?
6
u/ContentWithOurDecay Apr 15 '13
Does anyone remember you can reintroduce an idea to Congress?
4
u/tehbored Apr 15 '13
And have it sure in committee repeatedly without ever even reaching the floor.
→ More replies (1)2
u/ferrarisnowday Apr 15 '13
Could you elaboriate? The President is the Chief Executive of the military. He could shut it down in a day if he wanted to.
5
u/tomeoftom Apr 15 '13
This is the saddest thing. Any America reading this, please write to your Congressman immediately.
11
u/Metallio Apr 15 '13
Look, it's been done. It's been done over and over. Lots of us grew old writing them. It's been over a decade and the effect has been essentially nil. There was a moment of 'hope' when Obama signed the order to close the place, but that's passed.
They know what we think and it's not completely tinfoil-hat territory to think that we've put ourselves on a list somewhere for speaking up and I can't blame others for refusing to be marked for something that does no good.
7
2
Apr 15 '13
There are a lot of people here that are suggesting writing to your congressman. That is a good start. I also suggest you get like minded people together and start talking to those who have some inkling but aren't really that well informed.
Nothing will change unless this develops into a movement with massive protests. Not to mention lobbying the right politicians and making this the issue for liberals the way abortion is for the right.
2
u/woahmanchillout Apr 15 '13
I had a nurse fuck up once and stick a tube into my stomach through my nose without any sort of pain suppressant. It was the most painful thing I have ever experienced.
2
Apr 15 '13
This article was released at a very unfortunate time, especially if al-Qaeda does claim responsibility for the bombs in Boston.
4
Apr 15 '13
Isn't this the exact opposite of the kind of article that belongs in this subreddit? It's heavy on emotion and light on facts. What does the US government have to say about why these people are being detained? What about the Yemeni government? Or the detainees' lawyers? Or impartial experts? We all get to be outraged for a few minutes, but since we've learned basically nothing we are no more able to do anything, or even form an opinion, than we were before.
5
u/cran Apr 15 '13
Yes, I'm certain this guy is a complete bystander who found himself simply away from home when the big, bad United States grabbed him and began torturing him. After all, people are vomiting blood. And he just wants to go home. I mean, say no more ... that's all the evidence I need as a person with no real insight into his case. The situation is desperate. Poor displaced Yemeni.
Yeah. This is so sad. Except for this:
http://projects.nytimes.com/guantanamo/detainees/43-samir-naji-al-hasan-moqbel
Read that document. Stop knee-jerking into thinking the US is inherently evil and these guys are innocents. Get some fucking backbone and think for yourselves.
11
u/tracerbulletnpi Apr 15 '13
Those who oppose Guantanamo on principled grounds are clearly thinking for themselves. They oppose the government pushed consensus you seem to support.
Whether you believe the 'intelligence' you linked to, which admittedly in many cases had been acquired by methods generally regarded as torture, the fact remains that it's diametrically opposed to the principals this country was founded on to hold anyone without trial. Maybe he's lying in the NYT post. But if he's a terrorist and committed a crime, prosecute him. If he's a terrorist and he hasn't committed a crime, your hands are bound by american principals, there is nothing to hold him on. If he's not a terrorist and he hasn't committed a crime, again your hands are bound, there is nothing to hold him on. These are the only principled options available.
Pre-crime has yet to be considered a prosecutable crime. Even when the FBI has arrested the guys in their entrapment operations they wait for them to actually do something substantially illegal to arrest them (there the only question is whether they would have done anything absent the FBI informant)...
5
u/mattkatzbaby Apr 15 '13
If there is enough evidence to believe he is guilty, then we can try him. If there is not enough evidence to try him, we should free him.
I don't often see things in black and white - but how do we know it's true unless we test it?
→ More replies (10)14
u/SavvyStereo Apr 15 '13
So, he fought against the US? So what, he's a soldier. Doesn't he deserve certain rights as a prisoner of war or something? I don't know much about this so I'm not having a go at your point of view but I don't see any way that his treatment is justified. I would love to hear a reasonable explanation as to why this is happening.
15
Apr 15 '13 edited Apr 15 '13
So what, he's a soldier.
This is exactly the crux of the argument. Actually he isn't a "soldier", or at least, not one for Afghanistan, because he doesn't fight for that government, wearing their "uniform". Rogue military like this are explicitly not protected by the Geneva convention.
Consider this: the point of the Geneva convention, as abhorrent as it may sound, is to "civilize" warfare. Combat, though brutal, should (as much as possible) limit civilian casualties, allow combatants to surrender safely, limit the use of assassination and hostage-taking, and so on. As you point out, it also covers the humane treatment of soldiers in time of war.
But over all this, governments who sign this convention recognize that at some point there will be an end to the fighting, and that there needs to be dialogue between the governments to allow the possibility of peaceful resolution. You can't have this kind of thing with a group like Al-Qaeda, because they are not a government. As "insurgents" (or whatever you want to call them) they don't have an formal diplomatic channels with the US or other governments. They aren't beholden to any established government or claim to represent the people of any nation. Their "soldiers" can't be ordered to surrender by anyone in recognized authority.
As such, they are not really soldiers. They are, essentially, criminals. They only care about their own interests. This makes it difficult to have any diplomacy with them. If the US were to "negotiate" with them, that would legitimize their actions and their right to speak for the people of that country, and by extension, all such groups.
Explicitly, this guy is not covered by the Geneva Convention because he is a citizen of Yemen, a neutral third-party country with which the US has separate relations. Implicitly, he's a member of a rogue group that has ties to no country and is protected under no international law, and has been made an example of how the US will prosecute those who join these groups to fight against us.
Now, all that being said, I don't agree with this kind of treatment. At the very least, all prisoners should be treated humanely. They should be kept on US soil and tried, in whatever way possible, in the appropriate courts and under the provisions of the Constitution, even if they are not US citizens.
Why? Because we want to be the "good guys". It costs little and gains much to show the world that we actually believe all men should be endowed with certain rights.
12
u/usrname42 Apr 15 '13
If they are common criminals and are not covered by the Geneva convention, then the only principled way to deal with them is to put them on trial and arrest them, not lock them up without trial or murder them.
7
Apr 15 '13
Agreed. There are two things standing in the way of this.
First, pigheaded conservatives who believe we are being ethical in treating these prisoners this way, and their obstruction of any legislation to allow them to be released. And the pigheaded conservative voters who elect them.
Second, the lack of any appropriate legal structure under which to try them. But this is more an academic problem for which there are many solutions -- The Hague, for example. Only if we did that we'd probably have to release classified documents, which might reveal how the information was obtained, which would then very likely implicated many US citizens as criminals under international law.
But I'm sure we can offer redacted evidence if needed. It's just a question of how decent we want to be.
5
u/SavvyStereo Apr 15 '13
Wow, thanks, that's a great explanation. So, if he's a criminal and not a soldier, he should be able to be tried, like you said. So why does he remain without trial if the US know that he has been fighting for a criminal organisation? Lack of evidence? I guess in that case, it's a human rights issue and as you mentioned the US should be dealing with it differently.
1
Apr 16 '13
Since he is a citizen of Yemen, the US has likely contacted that country to see what they want to do about him. From what others have said, apparently Yemen wants $200 million to take back him and all the other Yemenese detainees at Gitmo, which seems an unusual request, and the US is not willing to pay.
2
u/mikelj Apr 15 '13
Why? Because we want to be the "good guys". It costs little and gains much to show the world that we actually believe all men should be endowed with certain rights.
Well said.
Since you seem to know about this stuff, is this the same way that the International Brigades should have been treated if they were caught by Nationalist forces during the Spanish Civil War? For example, since George Orwell was a British citizen whose government was not a belligerent in the war, would he be outside the jurisdiction of the Geneva Convention and considered a "criminal"?
2
Apr 15 '13
Well, I believe the convention allows the British government to take responsibility for him. I'm not sure what that would have meant.
1
2
u/gigitrix Apr 15 '13
The thing is, the US is at "war" with these factions when it suits them, yet they are demoted to the rank of criminal whenever it suits them too. They are cherrypicking legality and creating a new nebulous classification of "terrorist", which is poorly defined and has no legal protections whatsoever.
2
Apr 15 '13
We call it a "war" but only because the word has a certain marketability. Legally, just calling something a "war" doesn't automatically invoke the Geneva Convention.
Consider the difference with the 63,000 or so Iraqi army prisoners captured during Desert Storm. Desert Storm POWs were treated humanely and released as part of the cease-fire agreement, in exchange for Coalition POWs and Kuwaiti citizens held prisoner. Note that this kind of cease-fire and prisoner exchange can only happen when you are fighting against an established government willing to abide by certain common rules.
When fighting against nebulous organizations, there are no rules.
2
u/gprime312 Apr 15 '13
I'm sure the government didn't make any mistakes and held a fair and balanced trial to incarcerate him for his crimes. Oh wait, he was illegally detained without trial? Well I'm sure he was a terrorist anyway. The government told me so!
2
u/gigitrix Apr 15 '13
IF ONLY WE HAD A WAY OF DECIDING IF HE'S FUCKING GUILTY OR INNOCENT.
I don't have to think for myself, that's the role of judge and jury. A fundamental right that has been denied.
Have some "fucking backbone" and realise that regardless of this person's criminal status, the US is complicit in crimes against everything humanity and justice stands for.
0
3
u/meatpuppet79 Apr 15 '13
The fact that he is still being held without trial I won't comment on now but the fact he is complaining about being intubated and catheterized because he refused to eat seems a little rich. The military cannot allow him to die because if that were to happen, the outcry would extreme, so they do as their duty of care requires. If he doesn't like being fed through a nasal pharyngeal tube and having a tube put up his dick to help him piss, then he should not participate in hunger strikes.
0
Apr 15 '13
[deleted]
3
u/meatpuppet79 Apr 15 '13
Should they let him kill himself? Will that garner a less handwringing response from reddit?
0
Apr 15 '13
[deleted]
2
u/meatpuppet79 Apr 15 '13
I'm not American either, but I do get what is happening and I agree, they really need to charge him and the others with something or cut them loose, enough is enough. But if I understand correctly, the military is responsible for holding them, not deciding their fate. The fact they are keeping the prisoners alive with forced feeding during hunger strikes is not an indictment upon the personnel doing the job nor the organization who authorizes it.
1
u/Archteryx Apr 15 '13
How come these nytimes articles require you to login? Do all other reddit users have credentials? Is there a secret I don't know ?
3
Apr 15 '13
No login needed for me. I wonder if it's where you're read it from?
2
u/Archteryx Apr 15 '13
New York!! Go figure
1
Apr 15 '13
That might be why, since it's a NYC publication they want you to buy a print copy from a newsie.
You still got newsies in New Yawk, doncha?
1
Apr 16 '13
Do you think the people quibbling over what to do with these guys have any actual idea of what it is like for them?
Without a doubt many of them are completely innocent of anything, simply wrong place, wrong time. Accused for vengeance, accused on basis of location, accused on basis of age and appearance, but in reality completely innocent. Imagine what that ordeal must be like psychologically if you have no cause, no reason to be be enduring it?
Is everyone just so far removed that they don't even think of them as people any more?
-1
u/principalsofharm Apr 15 '13
Um why was he talking about Obama in 2002?
1
u/borahorzagobuchol Apr 15 '13
He wasn't. The interview took place this year. The man has been detained for 11 years, since 2002.
1
-1
u/Nordstadt Apr 15 '13
You guys are too nice for words. Yesterday I would have agreed with all of you about calling representatives and such. I don't think that you will get more than 10 or 15 people together in the street to protest his treatment without them looking around for a bomber. Today I watched the video of the Boston Marathon bombing. Now I would support sending a million more Al Queda soldiers to Gitmo. Not so sure I would send food. Love you all, but this looks like a lost cause.
-19
-9
u/mikepoulin Apr 15 '13
Maybe they should've thought of this before they became terrorists.
1
0
u/principalsofharm Apr 15 '13
They didn't choose to be terrorists. We chose to label them terrorists.
52
u/amaizebawls Apr 15 '13
Can someone help me understand why prisoners like this man are not being tried? What are the barriers to justice in these cases?