r/Trueobjectivism • • Jan 28 '25

R/objectivism is destroyed. Is this now the best objectivist subreddit?

32 Upvotes

One of the mods on r/objectivism unfortunately seems to have developed mental health problems (I say that objectively, not as an insult) This person seems to have taken over the sub as his or her person plaything, making it unusable.

This person doesn't allow any dissenting opinions which makes discussion impossible. He will call people on the subreddit names and even call Leonard Peikoff horrible things yet everyone else has to silently take it. Now there are also strict draconian rules and people who don't vote the way mod wants you to are forbidden to be there.

All these things happen completely erratically. He'll suddenly post some pronouncement out of nowhere, sometimes people object and he deletes it, but then some random other time he will post something else irrational. For example he briefly announed links to X were not allowed. Maybe he forgot to take his meds. If this mod is an objectivist then I am Santa Clause.

r/objectivism used to be a vibrant place to discuss and debate ideas, but now it's worse than useless. Hopefully this subreddit, r/trueobjectivism, will continue to live up to it's name and be a true objectivism subreddit. Hopefully everyone can just move over to here.


r/Trueobjectivism • • Feb 02 '25

R/objectivism downfall

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

The Redditors in this subreddit and r/aynrand were right about the destruction of the subreddit into a support of anarchism and gender war tribalism. Original newideal article and videos: The first ironically includes a former moderator of r/objectivism mike Mazza https://newideal.aynrand.org/evaluating-the-trans-movement-video/ And this article on Milei and anarchism https://newideal.aynrand.org/milei-should-build-not-just-tear-down/ It's clear that the subreddit is not longer about objectivism the philosophy of Ayn Rand, but instead focused on political tribalism, unfair smears of rand and peikoffs and a hijacking of the subreddit under the guise of not being discriminatory. https://www.reddit.com/r/aynrand/comments/1ifevv9/sadly_i_was_right_about_the_objectivist_sub/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button


r/Trueobjectivism • • Feb 20 '19

The Ayn Rand University app is here!

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/Trueobjectivism • • Feb 09 '25

Appointing A Better Top Mod for r/Objectivism

22 Upvotes

Would you share any evidence you have against the mods of r/Objectivism? I’m particularly looking for evidence of unjust mod bans or removal, but also evidence they oppose Objectivism.

r/Objectivism is a valuable subreddit. It’s the subreddit created for Objectivists. It has the ideal name for an Objectivist subreddit. It’s the biggest subreddit on Objectivism.

However, the top mod ParahSailin has been inactive since 2014. And the next most senior mod, Jamesshrugged, has recently become active and proven herself completely inappropriate as a mod, including breaking Reddit’s Moderator Code of Conduct. I believe there’s a chance of using Reddit’s mechanisms for reporting mods and replacing inactive top mods to appoint a better top mod.

The other two current mods aren’t great candidates.

RobinReborn hasn’t responded to my week-old message about Jamesshrugged. He seemingly tolerates her and seemingly didn’t seek top mod while she and ParahSailin were inactive. u/MikeMazza resigned as mod due to RobinReborn’s increasing hostility to Israel, examples here and here using posts from the awful https://ariwatch.com.

Asleep_Emotion7078 was added as a mod on Jan 28, 2025. His account was created on Dec 13, 2024, nine days after Jamesshrugged became active on Reddit. He believes in “growing and evolving the philosophy [Objectivism] and updating it to reflect modern society and values”. I contacted him about Jamesshrugged actions, but he didn’t address them in his response to me. He knows Jamesshrugged personally.

My top picks currently are u/MikeMazza and u/Sword_of_Apollo. Dr. Mike Mazza is an associate fellow at the Ayn Rand Institute, a current mod of r/aynrand and a past mod of r/Objectivism. u/Sword_of_Apollo is the top mod of r/Trueobjectivism and r/aynrand.

So, I’m asking you to share any evidence you have that Jamesshrugged is unsuitable to be a mod, particularly illegitimate moderator actions by her in banning and removing content. Old evidence is welcome as well to indicate a pattern. I‘m also asking you to share any evidence you have that RobinReborn is unsuitable to be a mod. Using those, I can demand Jamessrugged steps down voluntarily, persuade the other mods of r/Objectivism to support a better top mod, report her to Reddit and justify to Reddit that someone else should be appointed as the top mod.

Edit: I think success now is possible, but confronting the mods, reporting Jamesshrugged to Reddit and even attempting to appoint a better top mod are all valuable both in themselves and for the future.

Rules Jamesshrugged has broken

Respecting your community and co-moderators. Your community may evolve over time, but we expect that you will strive to keep it stable and usable.

Providing a clear and concise description of the topic(s) discussed by your community.

Creating rules that explicitly outline your expectations for members of your community.

Rule 4 of the Moderator Code of Conduct states that you should be active and engaged in moderating your community.

Evidence to oppose Jamesshrugged for top mod

I dont want people to be objectivists, I wanna troll the objectivists.

I should turn it into a trans porn subreddit :D

She temporarily changed the Icon and Banner of r/Objectivism to the Trans and Progress Pride Flag.

Jamesshrugged is the creator and current top moderator of r/AnarchObjectivism, which is exactly what it sounds like.

That’s ok. I made a couple of posts there asking ppls opinions of the racist comments Rand made about natives, her homophobic comments and Peikoffs transphobic rants and the opinion was very positive. So I don’t want to be associated with objectivism, even tho I do find value in her metaphysics, epistemology, and a derivative of her ethics by Nathaniel Branden 🤷🏻‍♀️ also I’m an anarchist 🤷🏻‍♀️

I have been :) I’m not right wing at all. I consider myself a left market anarchist. I just came up through Rand and am still mod of the subreddit. 🤷🏻‍♀️

This subreddit is officially anti-Trump. His supporters are not welcome.

Just leave.

She's not a neocon orthodox, that's for sure. Fuck your conservative conferences and nationalism, ARI. The new generation is creating our own objectivist culture that is fit for true radicals for capitalism, instead of a sloppy recreation of neocon values with Randian jargon.

What? I don't think that you understand that whoever creates a subreddit gets to decide what kind of community it will be. Parahsailin and I created this community to be a place for objectivists who are aligned more or less with the atlas society and David Kelley.

In response to Parahsailin putting r/Anarcho_Capitalism in the sidebar of r/Objectivism:

Parahsailin is doing a great job here, IMO.

In response to So you agree with having r/anarcho_capitalism in the sidebar? Let me guess, you are an "anarcho-capitalist"? This is just a blatant attempt by "ancaps" to control r/objectivism and misrepresent it. It's an insult to Ayn Rand and her legacy.

I also like that r/anarchobjectivism is on the side bar. Orthodox Objectivism is logically flawed and is systematically being corrected to be in line with reason, egoism, and individual rights. Minarchism is a contradiction to egoist ethics and flies in the face of rationality. It introduces statism into an otherwise perfect system.

Her description of the subreddit

Objectivism

  • Anti-Racism and anti-Sexism: Rejecting all forms of collectivism.

  • LGBTQ+ Rights: Supporting freedom of sexuality and gender expression.

  • Open Borders: Advocating free movement.

  • Pro-Choice: Defending bodily autonomy

  • Free Speech: Protecting expression against censorship

  • Anti-Prohibition: Supports legalizing all drugs

  • Anti-war: Non-Agression.

  • Anti-religion: Promotes Atheism and Science

  • Pro-Consent: Respects personal autonomy

Her two responses to the omission of Objectivism’s core positions in metaphysics, epistemology, ethics and politics:

Exactly. And these positions are 100% Objectivism. I think the old way of listing the 5 branches of philosophy don’t really inform a newcomer about what objectivism really advocates.

Of course it does in a very abstract way, but most people don’t make the connection immediately between a is an and open borders for example.

What omissions?

And I chose this method because I think it gives a more accurate picture of what objectivism advocates or opposes. I could just do the regular metaphysics epistemology ethics politics art thing, but I think it’s a bit to abstract for most people.

According to her profile, Jamesshrugged took a break from Reddit entirely in July 2019. She posted four times in August/September 2023. She didn’t become active again until December 4, 2024.

https://www.reddit.com/r/modnews/s/5lehB7ofdF

We know that having an inactive top mod on your subreddit can bring problems - for instance, a dormant top mod could return and upset the balance of both your modteam, and even of your community depending on the actions they take after a long time away.

Unfair moderator decisions

My post was removed and I was permanently banned for being racist. My ban was revoked by the mod who was removed.

u/younggamer67 was permanently banned for a post promoting the necessity of government for securing rights and opposing anarchy. He also had a post removed for being transphobic that referenced a video about the trans movement by the Ayn Rand Institute.

u/major_possibility335 was banned, perhaps permanently banned, for a post endorsing Trump according to him.


r/Trueobjectivism • • Sep 02 '19

Happy Atlas Shrugged Day!

20 Upvotes

It is your mind that they want you to surrender—all those who preach the creed of sacrifice, whatever their tags or their motives, whether they demand it for the sake of your soul or of your body, whether they promise you another life in heaven or a full stomach on this earth. Those who start by saying: “It is selfish to pursue your own wishes, you must sacrifice them to the wishes of others”—end up by saying: “It is selfish to uphold your convictions, you must sacrifice them to the convictions of others.”

--John Galt, Atlas Shrugged

The Objectivist ethics proudly advocates and upholds rational selfishness—which means: the values required for man’s survival qua man—which means: the values required for human survival—not the values produced by the desires, the emotions, the “aspirations,” the feelings, the whims or the needs of irrational brutes, who have never outgrown the primordial practice of human sacrifices, have never discovered an industrial society and can conceive of no self-interest but that of grabbing the loot of the moment.

The Objectivist ethics holds that human good does not require human sacrifices and cannot be achieved by the sacrifice of anyone to anyone. It holds that the rational interests of men do not clash—that there is no conflict of interests among men who do not desire the unearned, who do not make sacrifices nor accept them, who deal with one another as traders, giving value for value.

--Ayn Rand, The Virtue of Selfishness


r/Trueobjectivism • • Jan 29 '25

R/Objectivism has gone full communist

19 Upvotes

Was just banned for basically no reason other than disagreeing with the mentally ill mod who thinks THEY know exactly which positions objectivism requires. There is zero free speech there.


r/Trueobjectivism • • May 19 '17

The Conceptual Penis as a Social Construct - A devastating blow to the academic left and the most brilliantly beautiful thing I've read in years

Thumbnail
skeptic.com
18 Upvotes

r/Trueobjectivism • • Feb 02 '25

Happy Randsday!

17 Upvotes

February second is Randsday (or Ayn Rand's birthday), the only holiday on which you do something entirely for yourself. You could make a purchase you've had your eye on for a while, or perhaps complete a project that would make you feel a sense of efficacy. The point is to underline for yourself that your own happiness is your highest purpose.

If you decide to do something for Randsday, please post it in the comments so other people will be inspired. Thanks.


r/Trueobjectivism • • Feb 01 '25

Sadly, this user was was right about the Objectivist sub

Thumbnail gallery
17 Upvotes

r/Trueobjectivism • • Feb 02 '25

Ayn Rand's 120th birthday

16 Upvotes

Her last substantive interview with Raymond Newman in 1981 will be released at 2pm ET. https://www.youtube.com/live/fDR7AOgPBMI?si=MagKOCOQCT8kdt8u


r/Trueobjectivism • • May 07 '19

The feelz

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/Trueobjectivism • • Feb 27 '19

Objectivism on the Rubin Report

16 Upvotes

ARI has been busy. In addition to launching Ayn Rand University, we recently partnered with Dave Rubin for a special series of The Rubin Report, titled “Objectivism on Happiness.” The series explores the Objectivist perspective on happiness and how to achieve it. Show guests include John Allison, Harry Binswanger, Yaron Brook, Onkar Ghate, Gena Gorlin, Gregory Salmieri and Tara Smith. Watch the first four episodes here: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqsoWxJ-qmMtazmdDur38Fb9of1wpW2Sb

Twitter: https://twitter.com/RubinReport/status/1100806501319540738?s=19

Twitter: https://twitter.com/AynRandInst/status/1100806471254724611?s=19

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=10156619519984681&id=64676229680


r/Trueobjectivism • • Feb 02 '19

Happy Randsday!

Thumbnail
randsday.com
15 Upvotes

r/Trueobjectivism • • Feb 02 '25

Based on a real story btw

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/Trueobjectivism • • Feb 10 '20

Objectivism Versus Conservatism Briefly Explained

14 Upvotes

A comment I made in /r/Conservative about the difference between Ayn Rand's philosophy and conservatism:

I consider myself an Objectivist, rather than a conservative, because I agree with Ayn Rand's philosophy, overall, and I don't think it falls under the category of conservative thought. (Though her thought has clearly been an influence on many conservatives, and I think they should acknowledge this influence where it occurs.) The essence of conservatism is well expressed in the sidebar of this subreddit:

Conservatism (Latin: conservare, "to retain") is a political and social philosophy that promotes retaining traditional social institutions.

The essential, stated idea behind conservatism is a Burkean one: "Don't change things rapidly and be very cautious about such changes." Why? Well, this is essentially based on the authority of previous generations. We shouldn't change things radically, because we owe previous generations a duty of loyalty, and we don't know what's good for us as well as they did.

But note a couple of related things about this: 1) It's based on a lack of confidence in our own reason. 2) It doesn't distinguish between good old practices and bad old practices. (The second issue flows from the first: If we can't be confident in our reason, we can't distinguish good from bad practices.) So conservatism ultimately means cowering before the authority of previous generations and copying old practices, because they're old practices. This is definitely in conflict with a philosophy like Ayn Rand's that says that we should make independent judgments and go by our own reason.

It's a fair enough point that one shouldn't blindly abandon established institutions on a whim. That would be stupid and foolhardy. In fact, it would be irrational. But that's not what Rand's philosophy advocates. Rand's philosophy advocates rationality. It advocates taking a rational, objective look at established institutions and judging them according to how they contribute to or detract from human life. Those institutions that we judge to promote human life, like the republican government of the United States, should be retained. Those institutions that we judge to harm human life, like slavery, should be abandoned without hesitation.

But this is not what strict conservatism would council. Considering that slavery was long-established and that the Bible effectively endorses slavery at multiple points, [1] I would expect Jewish and Christian conservatism to retain slavery in the 19th Century. I would say that the Southern Democrats were the conservatives before the Civil War, while the abolitionists were the radicals.


[1] (Exodus 21, Ephesians 6:5, Colossians 3:22, 1 Timothy 6:1, 1 Peter 2:18)


r/Trueobjectivism • • Mar 19 '25

r/Objectivism has new moderation.

13 Upvotes

The subreddit r/Objectivism is now allegedly under new moderation. The new moderator is posting from an account that has been dormant for several years, and we don't know much of anything about them. He or she claims to be a supporter of the Atlas Society.

If you are currently banned from r/Objectivism, this is a good time to try to get your ban reversed. A number of formerly banned people have successfully appealed.

The r/Objectivism subreddit is usable again... for now.


r/Trueobjectivism • • Nov 06 '19

11000 'experts' agree on climate change

13 Upvotes

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-50302392

Saw this the other day and figured I would check out the 'experts' who have decided we need "deep and lasting changes" (i.e. statism) to save the world from global warming.

While the majority of these people have PHD's in a scientific subject, a large number of these are barely relevent to climate change, including doctors of physics, astronomy, neuroscience, gender studies (!), and gynaecology (!!). Even more of the PHD holders are simply listed as 'professors', or something similar. I googled one, a man called Lazarus Adua listed as a 'College Professor'; he has an almost non-existant presence online, and all I could discover was that he was actually an 'assistant professor' in the sociology department.

Also among the experts: a Zoo Keeper, numerous PHD students, a 'Manager director' of a company called ZaminrizkavanCo. Ltd. (which doesn't exist according to google), an UNDERGRADUATE student of biochemistry, and many other irrelevant or plain bizarre inclusions. None of the people I googled showed any recognition of being a part of this list of 'experts' - no links to the articles, no mentions of it on their LinkedIn profiles.

Feel free to have a look yourself, you can ctrl + f and find some more amusing examples.

Here's the link to the list.


r/Trueobjectivism • • Oct 14 '19

The Garden of Eden fantasy: The most destructive pursuit in history

13 Upvotes

The pursuit of the Garden of Eden fantasy is the most destructive phenomenon in all of human history. The Garden of Eden fantasy is the desire to live--or at least to exist--in the world without the need for any mental effort.

Nearly all of the religious wars of the past 2,000 years were fought with an eye toward a Garden of Eden in a heavenly afterlife. The obsession with reaching this state drove countless atrocities, including the medieval inquisitions.

Marxism holds that this Garden of Eden state can be achieved on Earth, in the form of a "true communism" where all goods are superabundant. Millions of people were slaughtered or starved in the 20th Century as a result of Communists' and socialists' obsession with reaching this enchanted Garden of Eden.

The fact is that human nature doesn't allow a Garden of Eden. Life for human beings is fundamentally about exerting productive effort to achieve values: growth, sustenance, happiness. Rest and relaxation is only satisfying when it's a rest from real effort. Without effort and change, life becomes stagnant, dull and emotionless. Also, without any effort at all, human life ceases to exist.

An essay of mine relevant to this point: "Wealth is Created by Action Based on Rational Thought."


r/Trueobjectivism • • Sep 10 '19

The Nature of Individual Rights

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/Trueobjectivism • • Oct 12 '18

u/JamesShrugged is at it again.

13 Upvotes

Is anyone else noticing this? He made u/ObjectivismBot which now shills libertarian and ancap articles 24/7. I got banned recently for expressing the same.

I must admit, I thought he had changed his ways.

I am forwarding this message to as many users of r/objectivism I can, i suggest you modify the first paragraph and do the same:


Hi, I comment frequently at r/objectivism. I was recently banned for reminding u/jamesshrugged of the shitfest he started five years ago on the same sub, which he is starting again. He'll start shilling Anarchism pretty soon and block anyone who says otherwise. This is because he is an Anarch-Objectivist (he made that up) and has been moderating with sockpuppets for a LONG time. u/ParahSailin is his own account. u/ObjectivismBot is also his account.

This is the reason why r/TrueObjectivism was created. We actually discuss objectivism there, and the mods aren't power-hungry creeps.

Please forward this message to any other user you see being misled - every user counts! Also, please unsubscribe from r/Objectivism. There's no way to remove u/JamesShrugged as a mod, and not using that sub is the only method of dissent.

The Details:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Trueobjectivism/comments/1psjku/major_update_on_rtrueobjectivism/

Relevant links:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Trueobjectivism/comments/1k0xgs/jamesshrugged_banned/

https://www.reddit.com/r/Trueobjectivism/comments/2oighc/the_automoderator_on_robjectivism_removes_links/

https://www.reddit.com/r/Trueobjectivism/comments/29vbbo/finally_got_banned_from_robjectivism/

https://www.reddit.com/r/Trueobjectivism/comments/25z5zo/new_member/

https://www.reddit.com/r/Trueobjectivism/comments/1jifjv/rtrueobjectivism_subreddit_rules_and_policies/

https://www.reddit.com/r/Trueobjectivism/comments/4f6eg3/im_wondering_whats_the_difference_between/

https://www.reddit.com/r/Trueobjectivism/comments/27fnfp/welcome_to_new_members/

https://www.reddit.com/r/Trueobjectivism/comments/2a574e/selfbanned_from_robjectivism_hello_everyone/

https://www.reddit.com/r/Trueobjectivism/comments/2cr2fg/new_to_objectivism_robjectivism_we_should_help/

EDIT

Objectivism discord server: https://discord.gg/T6MNV7H


r/Trueobjectivism • • Mar 13 '14

Only Rational Way to Read Atlas

Thumbnail
imgur.com
13 Upvotes

r/Trueobjectivism • • Oct 14 '18

Ayn Rand's essay "The Missing Link" depicting ancaps. From "Philosophy: Who needs it"

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/Trueobjectivism • • May 04 '18

Jordan Peterson Doesn't Understand Postmodernism, But Objectivist Intellectuals Should and Do

12 Upvotes

I just watched this YouTube video: "Jordan Peterson doesn't understand postmodernism"

The vlogger is right in one respect: Postmodernism is not "cultural Marxism." It is something much worse and more destructive than that: It is the rejection of the possibility of truth.* Marx was evil, but he at least thought there was such a thing as truth. With Postmodernists, there is no truth, only group-specific "narratives", "lenses", "gazes" or "discursive practices," along with supposed "power relations."

"Modernism" in philosophy was the post-Medieval attempt to use some form of reasoning--induction and/or deduction--to find universal, objective principles of existence, man and morality. Many Modern philosophers were misguided in how they went about it, but they can be defined as "Modern" by having that basic aim. "Postmodernism" is defined as the rejection of that aim as "outmoded."

As Ayn Rand basically indicated, the transitional figure between Modernism and Postmodernism was none other than Immanuel Kant. He "established the universal, objective principle" that there's no such thing as genuine objectivity--grasping what's really out there and mind-independent--but only the "inter-subjectivity of the human race." In full Postmodernism, this is merely Balkanized into the "inter-subjectivity" of subgroups of humans: race, class, gender, sexuality, etc.

Of course, Hegel and Marx were also intellectual heirs of Kant. The only reason Marx thought that there was such a thing as truth, is he didn't apply his theory of ideas as "superstructure of economic classes" to himself. If he had been consistent, he would have had to say that all of his ideas were merely the result of his economic circumstances, not "the truth." (It's quite difficult to say what economic class Marx would fit into in his own theory. He neither had to toil in a factory for a living, nor did he own substantial "means of production." He seems mostly to belong to the "parasitariat"--those who don't work for a living, but who leech off of sugar daddies like Friedrich Engels.)

I just came across a perfect example of the cultural influence of postmodernism on SJWs in a pair of YouTube comments** (question and reply):

Question: Does the author clarify the concept of whiteness? Or is that something we have to infer as the concept accepted in British/American society? I say this because there are different concepts of whiteness depending on the culture.

Reply: She speaks more about the concept of 'Whiteness' from the black perspective. Black people constantly have to view themselves through the white gaze so it is always funny to see the backlash when white people are made to view 'whiteness' through the gaze of the other.

---

*(Postmoderns sometimes speak of "truth," but they purport to mean "subjective truth": "my truth" or "your truth," or the "truth" of "my race"/"gender"/"group." This is a false and absurd view that destroys any meaning for "truth." So if I said "objective truth," it would be a redundancy: That is the only kind of truth there is.)

**Note that the comments I'm referring to are not on the video I link to in this post. So don't look for them there.