This documentary holds up even better on rewatch. Never felt such intense paranoia while watching a film. The whole thing is an epistemic crisis. You can slip into infinite skepticism so easily that it feels like your sense of reality is breaking. It's jarring.
As you watch the film, you form different interpretations about each character and who they are. But as you keep watching, you start questioning each interpretation because of how the film reveals information. You soon realize that each interpretation is being undermined and proves to be unreliable.
Elizabeth could be a genuine woman who has unknowingly wronged and defrauded people because of her naïveté and social awkwardness. Or she could be a master manipulator who is putting on a carefully curated act delegating the dirty work to her partner so she's not personally liable.
She says it's hard for her to cry in front of others but she does it all the time when she knows millions will be watching. Which of her tears are genuine? Which of her glances and smiles are authentic? Is she deceiving us or is she deceiving herself?
There's no way to know.
Is Billy a genuinely devoted partner who believes in Elizabeth's innocence? Or is he a willing accomplice trying to rehabilitate her reputation?
Is he a controlling partner that controls her image, communications, and business dealings? Or is he just the convenient scapegoat that Elizabeth can use to do her dirty work and maintain her image as an altruistic idealist?
Who controls whom? Or are we being controlled?
Thereâs no way to know.
Is Billy an opportunist that cleverly maneuvered himself in this position of dating an extraordinarily intelligent and significant person? Or has Elizabeth staked out and made Billy into a loyal dog who defends her vehemently and is a puppet for her future projects?
Is he genuinely a terrible person or is he playing a character so that the blame shifts from Elizabeth to him? And as an extension the blame for Theranos's failure shifts to Sunny?
Is he being manipulated or are we?
There's no way to know.
She seems to not care about money. But she's deeply intertwined with someone who cares a lot about it.
Is their relationship an informal business arrangement concealed behind the language of love? Or is their love genuine?
Can we really trust what they're showing us about themselves and their relationship? Which parts should we trust and which parts should we not?
There's no way to know.
It isn't just the fact that there are contradictory interpretations and we don't know which ones are correct. It's deeper than that. They could all be correct to various degrees and there is just no way to know what's true and how true it is.
If this wasn't confusing and cryptic enough, we get even more ways that the truth could be getting obfuscated.
Elizabeth carefully chooses her words. She uses vague language and seems completely oblivious to its lack of clarity. When caught off guard by a question, she stutters and stammers. You can see this clear as day when Amanda asks "Did you know I was gonna be here?" and she stammers and replies "I don't know if I knew."
Is all this a farce? Does a billionaire inventor really not understand the meaning of the word "can"? Or is she just socially awkward and doesn't understand how to be clear in her language?
Are we getting manipulated by language? Were the investors manipulated by the same language?
There's no way to know.
Elizabeth and Billy use vague language that is often contradictory. Billy says that "Her desires and my desires are one and the same." He has access to her accounts and power of attorney. But when money is discussed she says "Billy has his own way of doing things."
She says that "I'm tired of having other people speak for me." Yet she allows Billy to manage her public image however he sees fit.
He talks about her love for him as "monuments of love" to him. But is their love hiding a complicated arrangement involving money, power, and reputation?
There's no way to know.
Another possible layer of obfuscation is memory.
When Nathan wants to portray a scene that they weren't allowed to film or write about, he has to rely on his memory of the events. This causes massive problems.
For example, when Nathan asks Amanda to reenact the scene where he asked Elizabeth about the financial compensation for the film, Amanda says "Well, I knew he was talking to you about it." But then he changes the word it to something because he isn't sure whether that's what she said. So, the new line becomes "Well, I knew he was talking to you about something."
Changing this one word to another changes the entire interpretation of the scene. Her motive changes completely. The way we see it changes completely. It becomes unreliable.
Nathan manipulates us by changing a single word in a single scene. How much are we being manipulated over the course of three hours and thousands of words?
There's no way to know.
And this brings us to yet another layer of obfuscation: filmmaking and performance.
In the above example, Amanda's reenactment of the scene is how we perceive things to have happened. But she's interpreting the lines and the scene in her own specific way through her own biases and then portraying what she believes will best capture the essence of what happened.
Are those performances accurate or are they just a dramatized version of what happened? Is she making Elizabeth look more innocent than she actually is or is she making her look more guilty than she actually is?
There's no way to know.
The same can be said for Nathan. Did he genuinely correct a faulty memory or did he allow his biases to get in the way?
Is he accurately representing the conversation they had in the prison? Or is he deceiving us by framing Elizabeth in a specific way?
If so, is he even aware that he is deceiving us or is he deceiving himself through his biases and his fondness for Elizabeth?
There's no way to know.
Amanda isn't just reproducing the conversation but she is interpreting it as an actor. Nathan is directing that performance and deciding what belongs in the script. The filmmakers select which parts of that performance we see.
But what actually happened? Where does actual conversation end and the scripted reconstruction begin?
There's no way to know.
How much of Lance and Nathan's visual style affects how we see and interpret events? Are they framing things to make Billy seem like the bad guy? Or are they trying to show that Elizabeth cannot be trusted no matter what?
Is Nathan performing when he asks questions to different people? Is his deadpan delivery part of his performance to get certain kinds of responses? Do his extended, awkward silences serve the same effect?
Is he trying to entrap his interviewees or is he trying to capture their essence by leaving them suspended with their own thoughts?
There's no way to know.
Both Amanda and Nathan initially, instinctively, believe Elizabeth. Despite knowing that she is guilty of all these crimes. Are they being manipulated? And by watching them come to these conclusions, are we being manipulated?
Is Nathan becoming emotionally attached to Elizabeth? Is he consciously or unconsciously protecting her? Is he painting Billy as the bad guy to protect Elizabeth? Does he want to blame Billy for things that are also Elizabeth's responsibility? Or is he accurately documenting Billy's problematic behavior?
Is Nathan being sincere in his process? Or is he muddying the waters?
There's no way to know.
Amanda brings up the notion of Stockholm syndrome when talking about Elizabeth and Billy's relationship while Nathan interprets their love as genuine. Nathan seems more sympathetic to the relationship than Amanda.
Is Amanda seeing Billy for who he really is? Is Nathan overlooking things because of his biases? Or is Amanda clouding her judgement because of her own biases?
How do we know which one of their perspectives is true? Or are they both true to various degrees?
There's no way to know.
When Nathan and Amanda are talking, which of their lines, reactions, judgements, are their own and which are scripted lines?
When Nathan asks Amanda to repeat a line or tweak it in some way, is this part of a performance?
When Amanda is smiling at Nathan or when she accuses Nathan of being protective of Elizabeth, is that part of the performance?
Are all these instances genuine conversations happening naturally and being captured as they are? Or are they carefully rehearsed sequences that make us perceive the reality of the situation in a certain way? Are they manipulating each other? Or are we being manipulated?
There's no way to know.
Even the shot selection, editing, and narrative structure is deliberately designed. We aren't shown the swimming scene with Nathan and Elizabeth till the end. And when it is shown, we are forced to question Nathan's accounts of events. Withholding that footage shapes our understanding of events. Is the whole process of filmmaking trying to manipulate us into seeing things in a specific way?
There's no way to know.
Elizabeth talks about how she's treated worse because of how Amanda portrayed her in The Dropout. She believes those people treat the show as if it's a documentary. But we know that just like this documentary, there were hundreds of different decisions that went into how that story was shown and how she was portrayed.
Which of those decisions led the audience to accurate insights and which led to distortions? What was omitted and what was invented? How much of the show is accurate? And how much of it is there for dramatic effect?
When Amanda reenacts this part, she has a reaction: "I didn't do that to her. She did that to herself." How much of her "worse" treatment is due to Amanda's portrayal and how much of it is the result of her own actions?
There's no way to know.
And the mind-blowing part is that Amanda is reinterpreting and reenacting the events yet again in this documentary. And this documentary will further shape how we understand the original events.
There's a loop going on. Each piece of media about her shapes her public perception which then inspires more media attention and dramatizations. How many layers has the truth been through to get to us? And just how much has it changed in the process?
There's no way to know.
And that brings us to our final layer of obfuscation: ourselves.
If we knew who Elizabeth was before watching this documentary then we came in with our preconceived notions about who she is. We have an idea of her before even watching the documentary. And that influences how we see everything.
We know she is convicted of some serious crimes. We may already be suspicious of what she says and does before she says or does anything. When she stutters, hesitates, or uses vague language, we might be interpreting it as lying or being disingenuous. When she cries, we might interpret that as a performance. When she appears naive, we might interpret that as deliberate manipulation.
How many of these things are we seeing as they actually are? And how much are we letting our biases and beliefs cloud our perception?
There's no way to know.
Billy's constant defense of Elizabeth makes him seem excessively loyal. His cryptic language and controlling behavior make him seem suspicious. His interest in money makes him seem opportunistic. Him trying to walk back his angry, blurted statements make him appear fake and dishonest.
But are we interpreting his loyalty as manipulation because we already dislike him? And do we actually dislike him or is the film showing Billy in an excessively negative light in order to manipulate us into disliking him?
There's no way to know.
Nathan's awkwardness and his confrontational questioning make him appear skeptical and trustworthy. He is open and transparent about what he's thinking and his methods. He becomes our lens of Elizabeth. He is asking the questions that we want to know the answers to. He is showing us what we want to see about her.
But is his awkward and self-critical persona a constructed facade trying to influence our judgement? Or is he presenting himself authentically and letting us see the truth as it is?
There's no way to know.
Amanda recognizes this and confronts him about his biases. Does this make her seem more objective? Are we accepting her interpretation more because she goes through this line of questioning?
There's no way to know.
Nathan and Amanda both talk about how they believe Elizabeth. Why is this included in the film? Are they showing their authentic, sincere reactions? Or are these reactions supposed to influence our reactions?
Are they a reflection of who we are and what we are doing behind the screen? Are we getting convinced and manipulated just like they are?
There's no way to know.
Elizabeth seems innocent. Maybe she's consciously manipulating everyone.
Billy seems controlling. Maybe the film has edited the film to make him look that way.
Nathan appears self-aware. Maybe that self-awareness is a performance.
Amanda challenges Nathan's biases. Maybe she does this because of her own biases.
The reenactments expose the unreliability of memory. Maybe that exposure itself is carefully scripted.
Every explanation generates another explanation about how we could possibly be getting manipulated.
Is it healthy skepticism or paranoia?
There's no way to know.
Elizabeth might be a deliberate liar while genuinely believing some of her own explanations. She may manipulate certain people while being manipulated by others. Her helplessness might be partly genuine and partly strategic.
Billy might genuinely love Elizabeth while also being excessively controlling. He may be acting in her interests while also pursuing his own. He may be manipulating her while simultaneously being manipulated by her. His devotion to her might be partly sincere and partly self-serving.
Nathan might genuinely be trying to establish the truth while also letting his unconscious biases influence his filmmaking. He might just be being himself when interviewing while also intentionally manipulating certain social situations to get people to reveal information. He might want us to see everything while also shaping what we see through his filmmaking.
Amanda might be biased against Billy while recognizing his problematic behavior. She might recognize Nathan's biases but not recognize her own. Her portrayal of Elizabeth might provide insight while simultaneously conveying misleading ideas about who she actually is.
Most of these interpretations aren't mutually exclusive. The issue is how true is each interpretation?
How much of Billy's behavior is influenced by love versus control?
How much of Elizabeth's presentation involved conscious deception versus self-deception?
How much of Nathan's filmmaking reflects sincere investigation versus intentional narrative construction?
How much of Amanda's skepticism reflects accurate perception versus prejudice?
There's no way to know.
We recognize that a lot of what we are seeing is being clouded by performance and biases. Yet we still interpret everything through our own biases. They influence which interpretations seem convincing to us. We are drawn to interpretations that fit what we already believe about who these people are. We can recognize other's biases without recognizing our own.
How do we separate interpretation from observation? Can we even make judgements knowing that no judgement we make can ever be objective?
We can see everything. But we can't know everything. Can we even know anything?
We observe words, actions, expressions, interactions, and emotions but we can't reliably tell which are authentic and which are not.
Seeing doesn't mean knowing. Knowing doesn't mean understanding.
Our understanding of reality travels through four layers of filters. First is human presentation. Second is language and memory. Third is filmmaking. Last is our own interpretations.
Each layer can reveal or obscure aspects of reality. Not all of these are intentional. But it doesn't change the fact that we are manipulated at the end of the chain. The processes it goes through to get to us are unreliable.
Just how much are we seeing of reality as it is? And how much are we seeing the transformations that reality went through?
There's no way to know.
The final conversation before the film closes is about how Nathan is trying to portray events accurately. Amanda questions whether his feelings for Elizabeth are affecting his account. He seems genuinely convinced that Elizabeth and Billy's love is authentic. Amanda finds the relationship problematic. Which one is it?
There's no way to know.
The film ends with "It's very complicated." This couldn't be more fitting. Some people come out of the film convinced that they know the truth. Perhaps someone's manipulations worked. The rest of us come out with more questions than we came in with. And that's the beauty of the film. It truly is an epistemic crisis.
The final thing that is shown on the screen before the lights go out is the New York Times quotation and how Nathan and Lance contacted the journalist about it but it remains unresolved. Suddenly the context around it fades out and only the quote remains:
They're not playing me. They're playing a character I created.
The film informs us that the quotation is contested and not independently verified. But then it visually strips away the contextual information explaining why we should question the quotation.
We know that it is not confirmed that Elizabeth said the words, yet the film gives these particular words the final, most memorable position in the film.
The film is trying to show how an uncertain account can become an accepted narrative when the context is stripped out.
This quote becomes a microcosm of what the whole film has been doing so far.
Reality exists. Different accounts of said reality say contradictory things. These accounts are filtered through the four layers of obfuscation. And we are left with a narrative at the end. Without the context and the nuance.
We know that the quote is unreliable yet we are tempted to believe it because it is reductionist and emotionally satisfying. It shows how we might not actually want the truth. We might want something that satisfies us and our preconceived notions and biases.
If we look at this through a meta angle, we can see that Nathan and Lance are using filmmaking techniques to shape our understanding of reality. Even though the quote is disputed, showing it in this manner gives it an extraordinary narrative weight despite its contentious nature.
We literally see the context disappear. What will we remember: the uncertainty or just the quotation?
By showing this quote as the final thing before ending the film, theyâre deliberately showing us how uncertainty and context disappear as stories become simplified into memorable narratives.
Theyâre explicitly showing us how their own documentary is distorting the truth through its own filmmaking.
Itâs mind-blowing when you really think about it. Itâs the central theme of this documentary and it references itself to show us how it is happening in one final effort in its final stroke.
This self-reflexivity shows how it, and as extension, how we are engaging in the exact process that it shows is unreliable. It asks you to question yourself and what your takeaway of the film is. It exposes how we might be warping the truth to fit our own sense of reality.
Was this the point of the film? Was Elizabethâs case a device to show you that the truth is unreliable? Or was it to show you everything about Elizabeth as it is so you can see everything?
I guess weâll never know.