First of all I wanna say that I like this series, I really do. But some scenes that I can tell were intended to be deep/meaningful have made me cringe a little bit.
Vince Vaughn's monologue in Ep2 is an example of such a scene. It just felt very contrived, and his wife's reactions seemed unnatural as well.
Ani talking to the creepy psychiatrist dude is another case. When she said "...she became a detective" I half expected her to put on her shades and start puffing on that e-cig, and then walk off into the night as My Least Favourite Life played softly in the background.
But the worst, imo, are the bar scenes between Ray and Frank. It's quite interesting to watch them interact with each other, and gain some insight into the nature of their relationship, but why do they keep having to cut to that woman playing the guitar? It completely kills the tension between them and ruins the immersion. In this episode alone they showed her three different times, I think it was even more in the previous episode. The only reason I can think of is that she's going to play an important part in the series at some point, which is why they keep showing her. Nonetheless, it just feels so unnatural to keep cutting in close up shots of her for seemingly no reason other than "art".
In the first season, Rust was a little bit pretentious and " edgy", however Marty calls him out on it pretty much straight away, when he says "Stop saying odd shit" in Ep1. I thought that was really well done, because it allowed the show to get a bit "pretentious" (for lack of a better word) through the character of Rust, however, it showed that Rust wasn't the norm. Everyone thought he was a weirdo, which he was.
Season 1 showed us that Marty's personal life was ideal (or so it appeared to be at first). It's why Rust was so pessimistic and dark, because he wanted that perfect life that everyone around him seemed to have, but he couldn't because of the death of his daughter. You could sympathise with his character because he was a weirdo that didn't fit in.
In season 2, everyone feels like a bad version of Rust. They all share his intensity, but when all of the main characters are dark and "edgy" it feels as if that's the norm. I mean, who's "normal" in this season? Who can we compare any of the main four to in order to show how tragic their lives are? There's no Marty with the beautiful wife, two loving daughters, nice home.
Basically what I'm trying to say is that when the first episode establishes that everyone's life is complete shit, then nobody's life is complete shit. Why should we feel sorry for any of these people, this is apparently normal in the world of True Detective Season 2.
Seriously, who has it worse?
The man whose father locked him in the basement for days at a time as a young boy, without any food/water, who literally beat rats to death with his bare hands to survive?
The woman who had to raise herself because her mother committed suicide and her father refused to take responsibility for the family, and as a result she shuts everyone out and also has a weird sex thing going on
The man who became an alcoholic/drug user after his wife was raped, and is now possibly raising the rapist's son as his own. Oh and his wife left him BTW, and also thinks he's a bad person
The young pretty boy who "all the girls liked" but is now suicidal because of PTSD from the war - which his physical scars are a constant reminder of - whose mother probably tugged him off before tucking him into bed. Oh and BTW he has a supermodel girlfriend but he can't get an erection and hates everything in general.