r/TrueDetective • • Feb 17 '24

season 4 is insufferable

2 Upvotes

I turned this crap season off on episode 3 and have yet to work up the strength to finish it. Every episode got worse and worse. Me and my girl were just watching it and laughing the whole time at how bad the dialogue was. The way something would happen and then just cut to them somewhere else, acting like nothing happened. The paranormal stuff wouldn’t even be bad if it was a new story but you piggy back s1 which had zero paranormal. The level of stupidity required to do that is astounding. Then they show us the cult symbol and act like that makes up for everything. I have been looking forward to season 4, its been my #1 show since s1 e1 dropped and this moron butchered it on a level i have never seen before. My 10 year old niece could write a more compelling story. Plus everyone keeps saying but jodie foster makes it better. The acting is awful and the characters are awful, not a single person on this is likable or show redeeming in any way. S2 got so much hate but as cluttered as it was, the characters were likable and the story was diverse and entertaining. S3 went back to the roots to me but tackled child abductions and was fantastic. This season is unredeemable.


r/TrueDetective • • Mar 24 '24

Am I the only one who liked Night country? Spoiler

17 Upvotes

I like the supernatural aspect to it, I thought the acting and cinematography was amazing. It had the same kind of claustrophobia to it as the first season. I do however wish it wasnt so different but other then that, it was amazing.

Shout out to the native representation!!

Edit: not sure why y'all are so weird about me liking it. I've been a huge Jodie fan and love season 1 and 3 of true detective. The down votes are hilarious so keep em comiy


r/TrueDetective • • Oct 15 '24

It took me way to long for me to realise why martys daughter did those drawings as a child.

0 Upvotes

I've seen season 1 like 3 times now and it took me 4 watches to realise the implication that martys daughter was abused as a child at some point which is why she laid those dolls out that way and did those graphic drawings, becoming a goth as a teenager etc and marty and tbh Maggie didn't notice much like myself until I thought about it more.


r/TrueDetective • • Feb 04 '24

Forbes: 'True Detective: Night Country' Is One Of The Worst Mystery Shows Ever Made Spoiler

Thumbnail
forbes.com
33 Upvotes

r/TrueDetective • • Mar 02 '24

Can we at least admit that TD Season One's female characters were poorly written?

7 Upvotes

r/TrueDetective • • Mar 11 '14

Best review I've read that this sub will downvote to hell. The Failure of ‘True Detective’:

Thumbnail douthat.blogs.nytimes.com
10 Upvotes

r/TrueDetective • • Jun 19 '15

[Season 2] For the love of F*ck, can we stop...

35 Upvotes

comparing season 2 to 1? Seriously, I don't give a dusty f*ck if this gets down-voted into oblivion, I'm just sick of every damn review on here comparing it to season 1. The new season stands on its own, back the fuck up. [insert appropriate Ruston Cohle-ism here]

Seriously though, does anyone feel it's fair to compare the two?


r/TrueDetective • • Jun 30 '15

[Season 1] [Season 2] Does anybody else think that Season 2 tries too hard to be dark/gritty and ultimately comes off as a bit pretentious?

17 Upvotes

First of all I wanna say that I like this series, I really do. But some scenes that I can tell were intended to be deep/meaningful have made me cringe a little bit.

Vince Vaughn's monologue in Ep2 is an example of such a scene. It just felt very contrived, and his wife's reactions seemed unnatural as well.

Ani talking to the creepy psychiatrist dude is another case. When she said "...she became a detective" I half expected her to put on her shades and start puffing on that e-cig, and then walk off into the night as My Least Favourite Life played softly in the background.

But the worst, imo, are the bar scenes between Ray and Frank. It's quite interesting to watch them interact with each other, and gain some insight into the nature of their relationship, but why do they keep having to cut to that woman playing the guitar? It completely kills the tension between them and ruins the immersion. In this episode alone they showed her three different times, I think it was even more in the previous episode. The only reason I can think of is that she's going to play an important part in the series at some point, which is why they keep showing her. Nonetheless, it just feels so unnatural to keep cutting in close up shots of her for seemingly no reason other than "art".

In the first season, Rust was a little bit pretentious and " edgy", however Marty calls him out on it pretty much straight away, when he says "Stop saying odd shit" in Ep1. I thought that was really well done, because it allowed the show to get a bit "pretentious" (for lack of a better word) through the character of Rust, however, it showed that Rust wasn't the norm. Everyone thought he was a weirdo, which he was.

Season 1 showed us that Marty's personal life was ideal (or so it appeared to be at first). It's why Rust was so pessimistic and dark, because he wanted that perfect life that everyone around him seemed to have, but he couldn't because of the death of his daughter. You could sympathise with his character because he was a weirdo that didn't fit in.

In season 2, everyone feels like a bad version of Rust. They all share his intensity, but when all of the main characters are dark and "edgy" it feels as if that's the norm. I mean, who's "normal" in this season? Who can we compare any of the main four to in order to show how tragic their lives are? There's no Marty with the beautiful wife, two loving daughters, nice home.

Basically what I'm trying to say is that when the first episode establishes that everyone's life is complete shit, then nobody's life is complete shit. Why should we feel sorry for any of these people, this is apparently normal in the world of True Detective Season 2.

Seriously, who has it worse?

  • The man whose father locked him in the basement for days at a time as a young boy, without any food/water, who literally beat rats to death with his bare hands to survive?

  • The woman who had to raise herself because her mother committed suicide and her father refused to take responsibility for the family, and as a result she shuts everyone out and also has a weird sex thing going on

  • The man who became an alcoholic/drug user after his wife was raped, and is now possibly raising the rapist's son as his own. Oh and his wife left him BTW, and also thinks he's a bad person

  • The young pretty boy who "all the girls liked" but is now suicidal because of PTSD from the war - which his physical scars are a constant reminder of - whose mother probably tugged him off before tucking him into bed. Oh and BTW he has a supermodel girlfriend but he can't get an erection and hates everything in general.


r/TrueDetective • • Jun 02 '16

Second season described in one word.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/TrueDetective • • Feb 10 '24

WTF is going on here?

4 Upvotes

So I thought I would check this community because I really like the song Hank sang in the last episode and wanted to see who wrote it.

Instead I find this cesspool.

Is the show perfect, of course not, it's a TV show. I think the acting is good and the show is compelling, that's why I come back every week.

If you hate the show so much why tf are you watching every episode? There are literally thousands of hours of tv available. To spend your time on something you hate is mental af. I see why my daughter says she never reads her IG comments. Some of y'all folks are out of control.

If I was involved in the production of this project I would avoid this forum like the plague. There's very little constructive criticism just a bunch of hate for something you could just change the channel on.

But if someone knows the background on that Hank song, feel free to let me know.


r/TrueDetective • • Jul 30 '15

[Season 2] Fuck the critics. S2 > S1

1 Upvotes

It needed to be said.

Granted, an anthology series is especially likely to suffer from a sophomore slump. If S1 wasn’t a hit, we would have never had S2; hence, an unconditional guess that S1 > S2 has well over 50% odds of being right. But take a moment to focus on the merits here.

Yes S1 was great. Matthew McConaughey was compelling as Rust Cohle, the screenplay was brilliant, and S1E4’s six minute tracking shot was the most gripping television clip in the past several years. But as a detective narrative it foundered badly in the second half of the season. And it left too many hanging threads. Apologists say this was intentional (“nothing is solved”), but then why not truncate a few episodes earlier?

S2 has a more intriguing storyline, longer character arcs (Rust & Marty became known quantities early, the only shift being Rust’s stargazed awakening in the finale), and a mystery to solve that is not merely guessing the killer.

“There are too many coincidences!” I guess you forgot that Rust happened to ride with the same biker gang he needed to infiltrate. Or that Errol had incredible knife throwing precision, yet was uncoordinated enough to slather green paint over his ears.

“California freeways aren’t the same as Lousiana swamps!” Okay. Even better, go watch Nature on PBS.

“Vince Vaughn does comedies!” Create an Old School subreddit to sob on.

“Four main characters is too many!” Bullshit, you can name more than four Sesame Street characters.

Just my 2 cents.


r/TrueDetective • • Jan 27 '24

I feel like I'm going crazy (Season 4)

0 Upvotes

I keep seeing posts and comments in this sub about how good season 4 is, and I feel like I'm losing my mind. I just read yet another article about how the only reason people don't like this season is because they are anti-woke, and this season features female leads, indigenous stories, and LBGTQ representation.

As someone who is NOT anti-woke (I love it when women, POC, LBGTQ, etc. get more representation in film/tv), I still feel this season is just really bad television. I was so excited: the cold, dark Alaskan setting, female detectives (Jodie Foster in a season of TD!?), the spotlight on Indigenous stories and lore, etc... And yet it is practically unwatchable IMO.

It is such a bummer, but I don't even think I'll finish it. I HATE the sloppy connections to season 1. I'm so afraid that this has already tainted any future re-watch of s1 for me.

It almost feels like a psyop designed to stir up controversy. Like, oh you don't like it? Must be because you're racist, misogynistic, homophobic, etc. Can't possibly be the weak dialogue, complete lack of chemistry between any of the characters, forced feeling atmosphere, or lazy fan-service call-backs to s1. It is really frustrating that any valid criticism of the show is being chalked up to "review-bombing" by s1 fanboys. Maybe it is just... not good? Using the "woke" elements as a shield against criticism is so weak.

Anyways, if you want to watch something with the same overall "vibe" & quality of TD S1, but with women at the center, try Sharp Objects (2018, also on max). I guess I'm back to rewatching s1 & Sharp Objects until someone can put out a show that can match up. Please feel free to leave any recommendations for shows that are similar in quality.


r/TrueDetective • • Jan 29 '24

This new season is absolutely terrible.

10 Upvotes

Not being funny this is that bad it could be put under “comedy” HBO have a lot to answer for here. awful


r/TrueDetective • • Jan 15 '24

Did anyone else roll their eyes when they heard the new theme was Billie Eilish?

59 Upvotes

Like…c’mon.


r/TrueDetective • • Feb 19 '24

Unpopular opinion alert: I loved s4.

0 Upvotes

I didn’t think it was majorly dissimilar from S1. The sex talk, the hallucinations, etc. It’s got some more ‘current’ artistic choices - but that doesn’t make it woke. In fact, this whole ‘woke’ dialogue screams misogyny and racism. God forbid we have two female detectives in a setting wherein indigenous folk are also the main focus. I’m not referring to specifically on here, but also online, specifically on Twitter and Instagram. There have been some rancid posts about the two leads that are clearly vitriol.

Maybe I (21F) found more interest than others did in the lack of info given to the direction the plot went, which is totally fine. I enjoyed every episode immensely, and I don’t quite get the hatred this season is receiving on this sub. I feel like the focus on characters taking precedent over the case absolutely reflects most of s1 of True Detective. The whole big spiel only came to light in the last episode - same here in s4.

I liked this reddit sub for its takes on the other seasons, but here for s4 I’m seeing criticism I don’t think is necessary.

Edit: If you hate an opinion on a TV show, christ, get a job in it then.


r/TrueDetective • • Apr 07 '14

Anyone else think Ryan Gosling would be perfect for Season 2?

38 Upvotes

I feel like a character similar to his from Drive would be intriguing


r/TrueDetective • • May 05 '16

How Graphic is True Detective?

0 Upvotes

I've been thinking of watching True Detective, but for some reason I feel like its going to be a fairly graphic show. If anyone here has watched Daredevil, that's probably the cusp of what violence a show could have and I would still enjoy watching. Thanks.


r/TrueDetective • • Apr 03 '26

Not even 30 seconds into the intro and Martys already jerking off:

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TrueDetective • • Feb 05 '24

No one cares if you like it or not.

24 Upvotes

Jesus Christ I'm trying to solve a mystery here and sorting by new is just everyone's opinion on if the show is good or not. Not one cares. Stop posting. Like it or not just shut up please.

Ask the right questions.


r/TrueDetective • • Nov 06 '14

I think I made my first reaction face.....

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/TrueDetective • • Jan 17 '24

I am a woman of color and I did not enjoy the first episode

12 Upvotes

Why does it matter what gender or ethnicity I am? Because some people think that anyone who criticizes a show or movie directed and staring women (especially if any of them are minorities) is just racist or sexist, or some other kind of "ist".

So no, I am not those things, and yet I still did not enjoy it. I wanted to, and I hope it gets better next week and it turns into a great season. I actually want to enjoy shows, so I'm not looking for shows to hate.

But to whoever needs to hear this: it's ok to not like the first episode, or even the whole season if it turns out that way. It doesn't make you a hater, or a racist, or a sexist, or anything else.


r/TrueDetective • • Feb 25 '19

Nic Pizzolatto: Still can't write an ending to save his life

162 Upvotes

3rd TD season in a row where we get a lazy, hamfisted ending that is completely incommensurate with anything that has preceded it. Can't find a creative, fresh, interesting way to deliver the goods on filling us in on plot gaps we've spent 7 hours chasing? Sit a character down at a kitchen table who, in 5 minutes, explains the entire thing. No detective work involved at all, just two old cops listening to an old guy with one eye explain it all away. Can't find a way to throw us one last "curveball" plot twist (Julie is actually still alive)? Simply have a dead character appear in a vision who, in 5 minutes, explains the entire thing. This is just lazy pure and simple. God, was such a great season until this finale.


r/TrueDetective • • Mar 04 '19

Season 3 TWIST ENDINGGG!!!!!1!! Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TrueDetective • • Jan 21 '24

Other true detective space

80 Upvotes

Hey y’all, is there like another true detective sub? Or a place we can discuss the show that isn’t this, the arrogant male presence is way too intense here for me. I love Reddit as a place to discuss fiction that’s been so important in my life, and no other space on here that I frequent is like this. Have the non-misogynist true detective fans created a safer place for me to go? Can someone message me