r/TrueAtheism • • Feb 25 '22

Why not be an agnostic atheist?

2 Upvotes

I’m an agnostic atheist. As much as I want to think there isn’t a God, I can never disprove it. There’s a chance I could be wrong, no matter the characteristics of this god (i.e. good or evil). However, atheism is a spectrum: from the agnostic atheist to the doubly atheist to the anti-theist.

I remember reading an article that talks about agnostic atheists. The writer says real agnostic atheists would try to search for and pray to God. The fact that many of them don’t shows they’re not agnostic. I disagree: part of being agnostic is realizing that even if there is a higher being that there might be no way to connect with it.

But I was thinking more about my fellow Redditors here. What makes you not agnostic? What made you gain the confidence enough to believe there is no God, rather than that we might never know?


r/TrueAtheism • • Aug 11 '19

Debated my parents two highly devoted christians lol

0 Upvotes

1:Told then that because god was god than free will is false and that went just as well as you expect. They involuntarily said that god was not omniscient

2:I asked them if jesus was proof of god being real. They said yes and involuntary agreed that islam,buddhism and every other religeon that has a jesus esk person is very much real.

There was alot of willfull ignorance and stubbornness on my parents end.


r/TrueAtheism • • Apr 01 '19

Could organized christianity be this sinple??

0 Upvotes

The Roman Catholic Church controlled people by using "Eternal Life" as the carrot and "Eternal Damnation" as the stick. The bottom line is your "holy book" declares that by giving up 10 percent of your income your chances of being in the "Eternal Life" group is promised, but not guaranteed. Follow the money.


r/TrueAtheism • • Mar 01 '22

The term agnostic is a misnomer and shouldn't exist.

0 Upvotes

When people call themselves agnostic, they generally fall into one of two categories:

"We cannot know that there is a god."

This is most commonly someone who rejects religion, but also misunderstands probability. To this person, "god/not god" are balanced on a scale at 50/50 and we just can't find a way to know one way or the other. To these people I say this: It's best to pay me the $50.00 you owe me. Let me explain:

First and foremost the claim "an intelligent god exists and created the universe" is absolutely something we can analyze, dig into, and place a probability on. All we need to do is look at the sub-claims implied and weigh them against what evidence we already have. For example, we know of no way that energy can be created or destroyed. Is there any evidence for this provided in the claim "god exists"? No. He's simply defined that way. Like it's his super hero power. We know that all the intelligence we observe has either come at the end of a long process like evolution or requires a creator (like a computer A.I.). Could there be a third option? Absolutely! But it would need evidence and support. Theists and agnostics never provide this.

Each time theists create a demand for evidence, but are unable to provide it, the probability of a god existing drops lower and lower. The more a god is alleged to be able to do the more evidence we need!

Then as we start to add in things like how we know that gods evolve from folklore and most people are taught to believe from childhood... well, eventually we see that it's ridiculous to put god/not god on even footing.

Furthermore, this 50/50 thinking is employed in precisely ZERO other aspects of the agnostic's life. If I tell them as a complete stranger "You owe me $50.00." they use a completely different set of logic. You won't hear them say, "Well even though we've never met and I don't let strangers borrow money I think it's just as likely that I owe you $50 as it is that I don't!" No. They say, "WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT! I don't owe you that!" Please just use one set of logical rules. Don't trundle out a different set of rules for discussions of god.

"I believe something caused all this, but I just don't know what."

Quite simply, this is some flavor of theism. Call it deism if you like, but there are a lot of theists who simply go about calling themselves agnostic simply because they haven't made a choice. I don't understand this belief system. To me it's similar to "vegans" who drink cow milk.


r/TrueAtheism • • Oct 14 '16

AMA I am openly atheist and living in the Bible Belt. AMA!

29 Upvotes

To answer some of the obvious questions, it has caused conflict in my family, specifically with my paternal grandmother. My parents do not know my beliefs, and neither does my brother. He does look at my Reddit post history occasionally, however... Hey Alex!


r/TrueAtheism • • Sep 08 '23

How do you think religious people would react if everyone just stopped having sex?

0 Upvotes

What if everyone, even married people, just stopped having sex? This would obviously mean a huge decline in marriages and births, but also in premarital sex, prostitution, and abortion. Basically, everyone is celibate for the rest of their lives. Do you think religious people would be upset and try to get people to have sex, or would they welcome the change?


r/TrueAtheism • • Feb 02 '19

Evidence for/against the resurrection?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone, theist here. I was an agnostic for a long time then decided to lean toward Christian theism due to some arguments made by philosophers such as William Lane Craig and Mike Lacona, mainly the evidence for the resurrection.

Recently I saw a video which kind of sums up the whole premises and conclusion: https://youtu.be/hKRRLpuGiQg

I’m really curious as to what you guys think of this position and am I exercising critical thinking sincerely in coming to the conclusion that these claims are valid, as they seem to follow logical deductive reasoning?

Would love to hear your thoughts.


r/TrueAtheism • • Apr 11 '16

Why does depression seem to be so rampant amongs atheists.

10 Upvotes

Not only is it a pretty common stereotype but our own sidebar has links to r/suicidewatch

Do people become depressed when they realize God is not real or are depressed people just more likely to abandon religion?

I know not all atheists have depression so no need to point that out but I am curious in anyone's personal experience here or opinion.


r/TrueAtheism • • May 21 '15

Life after death as an atheist?

3 Upvotes

I Know i should Just enjoy life because its the only one I got but as of late I cant help myself from thinking about death and the nothingness / oblivion it ensues. Yesterday I realized that death means a total loss of time perception. Billions OF billions of years pass instantaneously for the dead. Maybe this wont matter al all since you wont be revived to realize the time past. But Maybe it does. We dont really Know what happens at the end since gravitation contradicts quantum mechanics and the M theory seems Just philosofical fantasy. Id like to think our big bang is just one of an infinity of singularities. And since time Would be eternal one every an unimaginable number of times, our consciousness Would reappear. This Would be instantaneous for us since we cant perceive time when we are dead. This helps me cope with death as an atheist even though iltry to live to the fullest my life.What do you think? EDIT: So what I've gathered from here is that even if the universe did repeat itself and your consciousness reapeared it would be a different entity from the one you had in the first universe which makes sense. My consciousness exists as a proyection of my brain interacting with the world. Even if the world looks exactly the same, it is not the same world but as my consciousness isnt something physical I cant say if that'd be me. It would have no direct connection with me so maybe it wouldnt be really me. This is more of a philosophical question. Thanks for your input guys,even if most of you didnt agree with me, but I guess that was the point haha.


r/TrueAtheism • • Mar 31 '26

Please do not tolerate people using atheism to excuse their lack of basic human decency

0 Upvotes

I just saw a post where someone complains about white tourists disrespecting their country's local places that have cultural value.

One commenter says, I quote:

The concept of "sacredness", just like the concepts of borders, gender, and race, is a human construct with no universal meaning. One man's holy relic is another man's butt scratcher. They're both equally valid in their beliefs, but at least a practical use is more easily demonstrable than supernatural blessings.

This is the type of statements why few people want to call themselves atheists these days.

It is both factually wrong and malicious.

So many concepts in civilization are just "human constructs" (money, language, laws). They are still valuable and dictate reality all the time.

Especially in tourism where it's a luxury sector. How much money one makes in tourism is all dictated by people's beliefs.

I'll spare you the suffering of mentioning what this commenter thinks about holocaust memorials too.

Edit: I would like to point out that r/memes outsmarted the bastion of intellectualism that is r/trueatheism because it didn't have an identity to protect.

Not once did I say sacredness is actually a universal concept. Furthermore:

  1. The statement is correct only in a vacuum. It collapses the moment another person thinks differently, since human belief dictates material reality all the time,.

  2. No human actually abides by this statement

  3. The context in which the statement was made was an attempt to excuse being an asshole.

But I get it, protect your tribe.


r/TrueAtheism • • Aug 01 '24

I feel really torn. Both Christianity and Atheism feel equally “real” and valid to me

0 Upvotes

Background: I grew up in a very religious household. My family has had a lot of strange paranormal encounters and so have I. Satan feels very real but I can also see how he’s not. I can’t tell who is “God” and who is “Satan”. It’s really hard for me to distinguish between what is part of “Gods plan” and what is a trauma response from growing up in a dysfunctional household full of clutter and my parents yelling and fighting a lot. I can’t decide whether these demonic/paranormal experiences I’ve had actually happened or if they were hallucinations. It’s really tough because this Christian world feels so real to me. Especially because there was a time I called out to God and I perceive a miracle happening after. But logically speaking maybe it wasn’t a miracle and that was my own action the entire time. I’ve overcome a lot of mental health issues and I thought it was “God holding my hand” but maybe it was done purely by my own will? Can anyone relate to this? I really seek truth no matter how painful it is. I often thinking to myself

if I didn’t grow up in a super religious Christian household…let say instead I grew up a Hindu in India. Would I believe in Hinduism with the same fervor as I do/did Christianity? I think the answer is yes. Now if I was raised by atheist parents would I feel like it would be a similar effect.

It feels so confusing. It really feels like whatever you believe is the truth is the truth.


r/TrueAtheism • • May 04 '24

I kinda regret being an atheist

0 Upvotes

I have been an atheist since I was very, very young. (I think since I was 12 yo or so) However, after witnessing how much comfort religion brings to people, I kinda regret it. I was in a dark place mentally for most of my youth and I wonder whether it would have been different if I had faith. I recently read Demons by Dostoevsky I realized that the character I identified with was that atheist/nihilist that committed suicide....And it's scary because I realized that Dostoevsky was actually making fun of that dude.

Most substitutes to religion that atheists propose are just not good enough. For example, they will tell you if you want a sense of belonging just find a hobby. But lets be honest some random hobby does not give you the sense of community that religion does.

Just to be clear, I am not saying I think God exists in the literal sense. I am just saying that I recognize that religion helps many people. Does anyone struggle with the same feelings?


r/TrueAtheism • • Jul 27 '12

Sam Harris - 'Muslims do not Have a clue about what constitutes a civil society' - YouTube

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/TrueAtheism • • May 20 '13

Is new atheism tolerant of non-theistic violence? What does it matter if the gulag was not based on a doctrine of atheism?

6 Upvotes

I've read a general argument a few times now that Stalins (I'll avoid Hitler because of the tit-for-tat arguments about how religious he was/nazi ideology was) atheism did not cause him to commit atrocities.

True, but so what? Does the fact of secular massacres existing not disprove the hypothesis that religion is the problem?

For the record I'm not at all religious.


r/TrueAtheism • • Nov 10 '12

Do any perpetually single people feel like they would have found love my now if they were religious?

23 Upvotes

Like...

I don't believe in god or any supernatural stuff.

But damn I wish I could go to a "church picnic" and get hooked up with some cute girl.

I've tried looking all over the internet, but so far, no luck.


r/TrueAtheism • • Mar 04 '26

If there is no afterlife what is the point in living?

0 Upvotes

Recently I had an existential crisis. I'm now looking at death as a chore. If everything I do won't be remembered and won't matter what's the point in living. Since I see it like a chore why would I want to prolong the inevitable? I don't see what the point in living is if one day it will mean nothing. Like why question what the afterlife is or fearing if I can just see myself? How do you even find a reason to live if there is just darkness after and by living you are provoking the inevitable?


r/TrueAtheism • • Apr 16 '13

I agree with almost everything Dawkins and Hitchens have said about religion. ...But they're assholes.

3 Upvotes

First, let me just say, I made a similar post on /r/atheism, but mainly got angry, nasty comments back, not real responses. I'm curious to see if I get a better forum here.

Basically, I think they're unnecessarily insensitive and mean with their tone and rhetoric. They could make all the points they do without disparaging the people they're talking too and about (i.e. believers). Sam Harris is infinitely more courteous when he debates with people. Stephen Fry too. I love Dawkins and Hitchens for what they've said, but feel like they've fomented rage and lent credence to the delusion that there's a war on Christianity with their vitriol.

They may be right, but they haven't been nice. Neither has their opposition, to be sure, but that's not an excuse.


r/TrueAtheism • • Jul 21 '25

As a non-religious individual, which religious texts, verses, chapters, etc., have you found to be beautiful?

0 Upvotes

While I don't subscribe to any religion, I still believe that all religious texts hold some degree of value, as I find myself disagreeing with certain portions of some texts while being profoundly moved by other portions. I was wondering if other atheists have had a similar experience to me. Feel free to drop portions of religious texts or even books/chapters of texts that have resonated with you.


r/TrueAtheism • • Jan 11 '16

Can someone give me proof of God not existing because I'm an Agnostic

0 Upvotes

So I want to make a choice about religion and God, I need help making such a big decision about faith and stuff, I mostly believe that God may not exist but need help.My crazy family believes Jesus can heal my abusive narcissistic alcoholic father so they gave him another chance, its my final straw.I need the evidence "God" is either imaginary and used to f*** the masses or weather it exists.My thoughts points to atheism but I'm not sure.thanks.


r/TrueAtheism • • Feb 14 '13

Atheism+ is not atheism.

215 Upvotes

I'd like to comment on the emergence of the atheism+ movement. Atheism+, unlike actual atheism (which is merely the non-belief in a deity or deities), is an attempt to appropriate the atheist label for the uses of social justice. Atheism, is, in theory, dispassionate and apolitical; it does not seek to cause change or revolutionize society.

However, atheism+ demands a radical change in social and economic policy under the guise of atheism. Rather, atheism+ is progressivism (ususally feminism) playing at secularism. Oh, certainly, Rebecca Watson and P.Z. Meyers are atheists, but they are progressives first and foremost, and that slants their worldview.

Personally, I find atheism+ to be a hindrance to atheism in general, as it reinforces the stereotype of atheists being shrill leftists. It is inherently exclusionary, as it pushes away moderate or conservative atheists.


r/TrueAtheism • • Jul 25 '13

Is God Just Too Great For Our Finite Minds To Understand?

Thumbnail
patheos.com
4 Upvotes

r/TrueAtheism • • Mar 04 '19

Anyone deep down wish they were still Christian/part of another religion?

21 Upvotes

This is definitely a controversial idea, but hear me out. I'm an atheist of about a year and a half now, but more recently, I've realized I was much more happy under Christianity. Under Christianity, I felt like I had an eventually purpose or end goal to look forward to. Under Christianity, I had a security blanket even if everything went wrong. Under Christianity, I had a something to live for. And lastly, under Christianity, I had some kind of hope.

Now, as an atheist, I realize all of the filth under its cheery veneer, and even if I wanted to, there's way to many points against it for me to go back, but is it just me that wants to go back to the warm ignorance under religion, no matter how false it was. I just had this shower thought recently.

What do you think about this? Can you relate? Thanks for your time.


r/TrueAtheism • • Jan 24 '19

How are we as atheists entitled to say that anything is morally wrong?

21 Upvotes

I’ve struggled with this for a while. I’m a moral subjectivist. I believe that actions are only right or wrong relative to some goal. Rape, for example, can only be deemed morally wrong IF our goal is to protect the well-being of other people. But who decided that well-being should be the standard for what’s good?

So I’m stuck. I’m stuck concluding that morality is subjective. I’m stuck concluding that Hitler being wrong is just a matter of opinion. Help please.


r/TrueAtheism • • Jul 28 '14

Would the world be less advanced if Christianity and Islam never existed?

15 Upvotes

For example Muhammad united a loose collection of warring tribes into a single religious polity, which then began colonizing other areas.

The Islamic world then became the pinnacle of scientific/cultural advancement after Western Civilization entered the dark ages.

  • Fast forward

Crusades happened, which resulted in flourishing trade routes to the East, knowledge of algebra for the West and exchange of ideas and philosophies...

  • Fast forward

Manifest Destiny happened.

Because of manifest destiny, the US became the most prosperous nation on the planet and contributed to many technological innovations in the world. European colonizers furthered globalization.


Therefore while atheists despise religion, whatever evil resulted from religion lead to the progress of civilization or an unforeseen greater good.

For example without Christianity and Islam, Arabia would've still been a loose collection of tribes. The Islamic world would never have become the pinnacle of scientific and cultural advancement in the year 1000 AD (because Islam wouldn't have existed).

The Crusades would never have happened thus closing Western Civilization off to ideas and trade from Eastern Civilization.

Thus Western civilization would've progressed as slowly as the Mayans, Chinese, Incas, Native Americans, Japanese, who never had an Abrahamic religion to push them forward.


Another example of "evil" leading to a greater good would be WW2.

WW2 resulted in technological innovations such as space travel, nuclear power, radar technology, radio technology, penicillin (which has saved more lives than people who died from WW2), among many other things.


r/TrueAtheism • • May 10 '16

How to be a good method actor and still keep your sanity. Atheist loves to learn...and method act...it feels good.

7 Upvotes

As a lifelong atheist, when I go to Church every week for Mass (my fiancee is a practicing Catholic) I decide to really get into it. In other words, I get into the head of a believer as best as I can and, when she prays (we pray together) I do the same. It's sort of like "method acting" and I really enjoy the head and feelings I get when in that state, so much that I actually look forward to going to Mass and praying with my fiancee. Needless to say, she loves it as much as I do, so it's a lot of fun for me.

Of course my curiosity gets the better of me, so I've been reading a lot of literature about the meaning of the Mass and why people pray (even atheists do so, but not to a Christian concept of God, more along some nebulous "higher self" or something such). So now that I have a somewhat good idea of the meaning of the Mass and praying, it gives it all more emotional/intellectual significance to me. And, realizing that we humans share our humanity by definition I can find a lot of things that I can identify with in terms of the morals, hopes we all share, and lots more.

This has led me to do something I've never done before. Most of the literature I've read on these subjects (the Mass, praying, etc.) references sections of the Bible and the Catechism as the origins for these rituals. So, being the type of person I am, I like to go to the source of the investigation, so to speak. So, yea, I bought a Bible, after researching which one is the most accepted by scholars on the subject, and, though I do read the passages, I most enjoy reading the notes on the historical aspects of the words, etc. It's to the point, now, where I think I know more about my fiancee's religion than she does. So, now, along with my usual readings on cosmological and partical physics, I may enjoy reading my Bible. I sometimes laugh at the seeming incongruity of this. :)

It's all done in my never ending quest for knowledge. I'm an information sponge. Each time I've learned something it changes the way I look at our universe, people, etc. For me, knowing the make-up of something, whether it's a star and quantum physical realities or why someone believes what they do, just adds to my appreciation of everything else.

So, now, when I go to some event, in this case a religiously based or conceived function (wedding, funeral, etc.) I appreciate the customs in a more fundamental way that affects the whole of me, intellectual and emotional, and not only don't mind participating, but enjoy doing so because I'm able to get into that head in a more deeper way, through knowledge. As for God, now that I've learned about this very human phenomena, I have no problem believing, even if it's only for that moment of time and, yes, even though I'm an atheist.