r/TrueAntinatalists • • Sep 07 '21

Discussion Antinatalists should distance themselves from efilism.

0 Upvotes

Edit : My argument in this is merely for PR . For the record I believe antinatalists should not focus on extinction either but even if you think otherwise , my argument stays the same.


r/TrueAntinatalists • • May 20 '24

Other Online petition to criminalize procreation

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone. I have created an online petition that calls for an end to procreation. Let's try to get as many signatures as we can 😁.

Sign here


r/TrueAntinatalists • • May 03 '24

Not an antinatalist but trying to understand it I guess

1 Upvotes

So I'm a horrible breeder, and thus extremely biased here but I have some questions/moral problems with the philosophy.

This one is presumptive, but are antinatalists generally suicidal/extremely depressed themselves? My hope is no, but if so, I think that is quite the bias toward such a worldview, not that a bias toward a certain worldview makes it incorrect.

I have heard the consent argument many times. However, if a being does not exist it has no preference, and preference is required for consent. The act of creating a moral being confers preference into that being. However, it does not make sense to say that you have or haven't gotten consent from a non-existent moral being. Maybe I'm not logically sound here (if so point it out), but that's the way I see it.

Next, environmental issues. I like to display this visually with the MIT EN-Roads simulation. But decreasing population growth to zero is one of the interventions with the lowest effect sizes. I get that eventually everyone would die and global warming would get better as long as we have stabilized anything we are maintaining that could cause environmental catastrophe. However, it wouldn't effect much in the short period that it matters most.

The poverty arguments are probably the strongest I've seen. But we can't exactly just mandatorily sterilize all the poor people. That is a violation of the consent of an existing moral being. Plus it may be a different type of policy issue. There are countries with more robust social safety nets than others and their poor children generally grow up to be in similar social situations to middle class peers, and suffer less due to their inequity. Because these policies already exist, I find them to be more realistic, but maybe that is naive. So I guess my argument is that we should improve the material conditions of the populous first, before turning to, what I view as, dramatic means. Though I can also kind of understand the utilitarian argument here, it still makes a moral argument about a non-moral entity. "These non-existent kids will suffer, so they shouldn't exist" doesn't really make sense because those kids don't exist, so idk how they could be the subject of a moral argument. And I know for a fact not all impoverished people are unhappy, so it also doesn't make sense to say those currently alive would rather not exist. I know some may, others may not

As an aside, I have had friends site some research that found some of the variability of happiness scores is explained by heritability. However, being the pompous scientist I am, I will recommend looking into the difference between "heritable" and "genetic". Many of these traits start to decrease generation by generation (possibly due to maternal environment, epigenetics, etc.). Which I think should give pause to those who want to inhibit depressed people who want children from having them.

Regardless, I do not expect you will be unable to give strong arguments for these issues. I have not thought super hard about antinatalism compared to other philosophies, so it is a bit of a blind spot. I understand that philosophical arguments are almost always very strong and am willing to challenge myself with tackling your responses, even if it's just on paper and not necessarily on Reddit. Thanks for your time.


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Jul 26 '20

Excerpt I liked and share with you this Text from a book by Jordan Peterson

2 Upvotes

.. topics rarely discussed in university, such as the simple fact that all the ancients, from Buddha to the biblical authors, knew what every slightly worn-out adult knows, that life is suffering. If you are suffering, or someone close to you is, that’s sad. But alas, it’s not particularly special. We don’t suffer only because “politicians are dimwitted,” or “the system is corrupt,” or because you and I, like almost everyone else, can legitimately describe ourselves, in some way, as a victim of something or someone. It is because we are born human that we are guaranteed a good dose of suffering. And chances are, if you or someone you love is not suffering now, they will be within five years, unless you are freakishly lucky. Rearing kids is hard, work is hard, aging, sickness and death are hard,...


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Sep 24 '24

Discussion Sterilisation.

0 Upvotes

I won't go into details but in my late teens I was in court for doing something bad in a sexual way. It was deemed it would be in my best interests and safer if I was sterilisation by vasectomy. I had it done and understand why. I think it's best with intellectual disabilities to have this done.


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Nov 13 '20

Discussion Is it possible to be a “temporary antinatalist?”

0 Upvotes

I think there should be a general woman’s strike on all reproduction until the patriarchy is dismantled.


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Jul 12 '26

This Subreddit

0 Upvotes

Let’s Hope This AntiNatalist Community isn’t infested with Feminist, Simps & Anti Male people. Let’s Also Hope The Moderators Here Doesn’t Abuse Their Power Like The Other AntiNatalist Subreddit Moderator Does.


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Mar 21 '21

Discussion Should Breeders and Rapists be held to the same standards?

4 Upvotes

I was having a discussion with an individual about how breeders and rapists should be treated. He opted out of the discussion after beating around the bush and throwing a few personal remarks.

I'd like to continue the discussion here with anyone intrigued since I'm interested in knowing what others think on the issue, and knowing more about the subject in general.

The (last parts of the) argument is as follows: Rapists who have raped or will potentially rape should be locked up in order to protect future potential rape victims. By this line of argument, breedists/natalists who have birthed or will potentially breed should be locked up in order to protect future potential victims.

I know realistically the latter wouldn't happen because it doesn't have majority consensus. Also, there are circumstances such as the dependent children of the breeders who'd need the breeders in order to be sustained.

But in a theoretical world where all the already-born children are taken care of, is there any factor that differentiates the rapist from the breeder and why we should treat them any differently from each other?


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Jul 12 '22

An argument that arose between me and my friend, I would love a proper explanation

1 Upvotes

Is anti-Natalism presenting tangible (numerical) facts, or is it a theory based on completely philosophically unproven philosophical principles / facts that do not contain philosophical ethics?


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Mar 27 '23

help me

2 Upvotes

i have developed a pathological fear of pregnant women. i get panic attacks just by seeing one. how do i overcome it?


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Oct 10 '22

Video Defense of the RED button 1. #efilism #promortalism #extinction

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/TrueAntinatalists • • Sep 25 '21

Discussion Pain vs Joy

4 Upvotes

Why do you guys believe that human life is solely defined by pain and suffering instead of the view that most people (including myself) have, that holds life to be defined by joy?


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Jul 05 '26

Discussion Natalists don't deserve our sympathy. They are bad people.

14 Upvotes

Natalists are bad people and bad people don't deserve sympathy. We antinatalists are morally superior and thus we should reserve sympathy only for our kind. We are the only good people in the world. They are not good.


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Mar 22 '21

Dont we should should start a protest

0 Upvotes

Hello , dont you guys think we should start a protest for antinatalism ? As it requires media attention and publicity Becoz hardly a few people knows about this term . Getting media attention is the easiest way to promote antinatlism . i know so many people who thinks like us and would also support this philosopical position but it is just that they dont know about such thing called antinatalism .

Government should impose following ponts :

  1. You cant reproduce if you have any inheritence decease or any ailment which can easily transfer to your child

  2. People below the poverty line or without a proper financial stability CANNOT reproduce a child .

  3. Only 2 children shall be allowed to have

  4. Abortion should be legal and only the consent of girl should matter and nobody else

  5. Sex determination should be legal ( to avoid unwanted pregnancies which people carry to get their specific gender )

  6. Hysterectomies should be allowed if it is 100% safe and girl doent want to have periods ( ofcourse periods should be a choice )

  7. Tubal ligation should be allowed to woman ( no age bar )

  8. Parenting styles should be strictly checked before permiting them to have a child

  9. Legalization of euthanasia ( cases where child or an adult' s life is very painful and if they wants )

  10. Child can sue his parents if he/she is not happy with life

  11. If a couple fits in this category then only they get a license to have a child


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Dec 10 '22

Discussion Thoughts on Andrew Tate?

6 Upvotes

This man converted to Islam, because in his life he wants to escape the "black hole" of hedonism. So obviously the only sane choice was to convert to a religion in which he can own four wives at once.

He talked proudly in one of his recent interviews about his "genetic legacy" and how many childrens he will have.


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Jul 16 '26

Discussion I expected antinatalist women to be more empathetic to men unlike the feminists but seems like even they don't acknowledge male sufferings.

0 Upvotes

I cannot understand people who genuinely believe men have it better. I will easily swap my gender if I have a choice. Right now transition methods are not perfect so I won't do it since I will not be accepted by any man as their partner. Also in my country it will be much harder.

Also people think women have it hard in India. Idk, all women I know in my relative circle don't even need to do any work or job and their husbands take all responsibilities. I feel so jealous.

My point is I stopped caring much about the antinatalist community. They make me feel threatened.


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Dec 06 '21

How to achieve the ultimate goal of Antinatalism/Efilism - A practical proposal.

5 Upvotes

Note: This is my copy pasta from /r/efilism

So this is something that r/antinatalism will ban you for even mentioning, dont know why though.

Basically, the practical end goal of antinatalism (or Efilism) should be the prevention of all possible forms of lives right? In order to achieve that, we must invent some kind of self replicating Von Neumann robotic probes that would expand throughout the universe for eternity to seek out and "neutralize" (painlessly) any life or proto life, correct?

Critics brought up the problem of consent, because most living things do not wish to be neutralized, so what if we modify the probes to spread the message of antinatalism/efilism and only neutralize sentient beings that consented?

But what about those that do not consent? Well, the probes could establish a "base" near them and keep preaching antinatalism/efilism to their descendants until all of them agree to neutralization. Nobody said its going to be fast and easy.

But what about non sentient life that couldnt give consent and continue breeding/replicating through genetic instincts? Well, this is more tricky, should we wait for them to evolve into fully sentient consenting beings? Because if we neutralize them before they evolved, it would be against their possible future evolved consent right? Actually, No, because this is the same problem with unborn future people, we dont need their consent to prevent future suffering (if they were birthed), so it wouldnt violate AT principles. Is it moral to painlessly neutralize cows and chickens for example?

However, we still have ONE big problem, that is of the welfare of the sentient beings that want to live and breed, they most likely require a living environment/ecosystem filled with animals in order to not suffer while being alive and since AT/efilism do not permit inflicting suffering, the probes wont be able to do anything to them, their environment/ecosystem or the animals they need to live a "semi decent" existence.

In conclusion, the consent of the existing/living sentients must be respected, but the most practical solution for AT/efilism should still be creating these self replicating, anti-life "preacher" probes (I dont have a good name for them yet, haha). We can only hope that these probes could one day in the far far future travel to all corners of the universe and maybe even other dimensions (wherever suffering may exist) to spread the idea of AT/efilism and get all living sentient to consent, it would be a forever project but at least it will significantly reduce suffering over time. Am I right?

Note: Some say we dont need consent, but if that is true it would no longer be antinatalism/efilism would it? It would be a new philosophy that has no name, a philosophy that promotes forceful ending of living things. I invented a word for it........EXTERMINATISM. lol


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Aug 18 '23

Hello everyone, I openned a new sub for people who got f*cked over by school

2 Upvotes

r/TrueAntinatalists • • Nov 12 '21

Video That Vegan Teacher made a short video about antinatalism and environmentalism!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
13 Upvotes

r/TrueAntinatalists • • Jul 15 '22

Other PSA to people who spend their time clashing with those who have the mindset to ethically abstain from procreating

9 Upvotes

I am coming from a biased POV when I say this: I am of the sense that if one is going to come out and speak on the ethics to the consideration of creating sentience, that if they oppose abstaining from procreation (or do not defend opposing procreation), they at the very least should clearly voice their understanding of their inherently selfish/narcissistic or at the very least innately and willfully ignorant, let alone harmful perspective.

This is in essence what antinatalism looks to show and address within framework of anyone who seeks to impose birth and death, and such the inherent underlying motive in that mentality. How sentience, in mass, promotes an unethical will to continue this existence.


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Jun 14 '20

Discussion I thought I was an antinatalist until...

0 Upvotes

...until I realized all the philosophical/ideological baggage attached to it.

I fully agree that having children is unethical at this point in time. I see that as an ethical view rather than a philosophical one. Ethics are simple- no ideologies necessary.

"Assigning a negative value to birth." The word "negative" is ideological, and quite meaningless. It describes a value polarity which cannot exist without "positive" - another meaningless word. None of this has anything to do with ethics.

I think antinatalism should be an ethical stance, not an ideological one that makes grand statements about the horrors of existence.

If you look at the few remaining hunter-gatherer "indigenous" cultures, they are incredibly happy people. They do not suffer from depression, suicide, or mental illness. They are genetically much more robust and do not suffer from most of the diseases and defects of modernity. They live leisurely lives in a loving family setting and sing their own songs, tell their own stories. Their existence is not horrible until they come in contact with us, the polluted ones.

Civilization is the cancer, and the ideology of "antinatalism" seems to completely miss that fact.


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Jun 11 '21

Other There's a good chance antinatalism is futile.

6 Upvotes

We don't know where we were before we were born, which means that there's no guarantee that unborn people rest in the void of non existence. There's a chance that "the void of non existence" doesn't exist and we were actually slaves before we were born and we will continue to be slaves after we die.


r/TrueAntinatalists • • Aug 04 '22

Other Nefarious Rockers - DNA is carnage incarnate (antinatlaism song)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/TrueAntinatalists • • Aug 18 '24

Video The only way to stop Rapes forever #suffering #truth #facts #shorts #youtubeshorts

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes