r/TrueAntinatalists • u/Vindicator5098 • Oct 24 '24
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/Last_Pomegranate_871 • Jun 01 '22
Discussion I personally think promortalism kind of makes sense
When we are born we essentially become reduced to slaves. And I'm not talking about being a slave to the socio-political system per se, but rather a slave to our own biological shell that we must maintain in order to survive.
You can't just tell this meat suit to shut up, either. It's the master, and when it is hungry, you damn well better feed it. When it is sleepy, you damn well better prepare to pass out. When it is cold, you damn well better buy some thick clothing to keep it warm. The list goes on.
What I'm saying is, we're not as free as we think. Life is all about the struggle for survival. I think the ability for some people to be able to look past this fundamental aspect of existence and focus on various distractions such as hobbies and friends and careers is admirable, but ultimately I believe they are just pointless coping mechanisms.
I don't want to be painted as some kind of person that thinks the whole world should get nuked or whatever, but I also think living is pretty messed up. Call me a depressed pessimist though, I don't mind.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/Savonarola1452 • Sep 30 '23
Unpopular opinion: Poverty is a fate worse than death
Not having food on the table, having to sleep without heat, having to give up on essential things because you aren't a billionaire, having to work in a very humiliating job where you take abuse by the public 8 hours a day 5 days a week, getting kicked out to the streets at the risk of getting raped or trafficked and accumulating more irrecoverable trauma which leads to permanent mental disability - all of this is worse than death. Death, in this case, is freedom from all the crimes committed against you, from all the pain and suffering and unlivability of life. For some people it doesn't get better and they need to rest forever.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/Baroness_Munchausen • Aug 20 '25
Discussion r/antinatalism is being moderated by a mentally unwell individual who stalks and targets users. Their behavior is highly concerning and harmful to the community. The public deserves to know what is happening.
On August 17, I have received a message I am banned from r/antinatalism, a community I do not interact in with in any way. I am not a part of r/antinatalism. I have not upvoted or downvoted any content from r/antinatalism. I have not commented on any posts from r/antinatalism. I have not posted any material on r/antinatalism. I have not interacted with r/antinatalism at all. So, why exactly have I been banned from r/antinatalism? Which rule have I broken?
I replied to the ban message, which read “Efilism < Aponism,” and asked why I was banned from a subreddit I am not even part of.
I have still not received any response to this day.
Here is a screenshot:

So, I decided to investigate what exactly happened. Out of all the moderators, only one openly identifies as an aponist, moderates r/Aponism, and seems determined to spread aponism at any cost. That is how I figured out who banned me from r/antinatalism. Given that I have not interacted with that subreddit at all, I realized I was stalked, targeted, and banned by someone who lurks in r/Efilism2.
After receiving no justification for the ban, on August 19 I decided to write to the moderators of r/antinatalism to make them aware of what is happening. Users are being stalked, targeted, and banned without ever interacting with r/antinatalism.
Here is a screenshot of my correspondence with the moderator:

After the last message you see in the screenshot, I was immediately muted by u/Numerous-Macaroon224 without being given the opportunity to respond.
Note that he didn’t answer why I have been banned from r/antinatalism, but instead talks about me and other people wanting to harm him and his wife. His behavior is highly concerning, as he abuses his power and displays signs of narcissism, paranoia, and schizophrenia
Here is a post by u/Numerous-Macaroon224, made on August 2, bragging about banning efilists for every 25 upvotes using Rule 4. He also wrote: “I will realistically ban as many efilists as I can today.”

Apparently, he cannot find enough efilists in r/antinatalism to ban in order to feel powerful, so he lurks in r/Efilism2 and stalks, targets, bans, and harasses users who have no interest in r/antinatalism.
On August 19, u/Numerous-Macaroon224 even made a post attacking the former mod of the sub, the person who co-published work with Cambridge University Press and popularized antinatalism on YouTube. In the comments, u/Numerous-Macaroon224 even brags about getting rid of Amanda. I never expected r/antinatalism to sink this low.

Apparently, many users tried to explain that Amanda's words were taken out of context and that the short clip is highly manipulative, but they were immediately banned by u/Numerous-Macaroon224. After all, he doesn’t tolerate people who oppose him in any way.
Here is another screenshot:

Apparently, even the character Rust Cohle from True Detective would be banned from r/antinatalism for being an extinctionist and saying:
“I think the honorable thing for our species to do is deny our programming, stop reproducing, walk hand in hand into extinction, one last midnight, brothers and sisters opting out of a raw deal.”
― Rustin Cohle, True Detective, Season 1
I highly recommend that the other moderators of the sub take action against what is happening in the community. One person abuses his power, stalks, targets, bans, and harasses users, simply because he gets away with it.
If you were recently banned from r/antinatalism, please share your story in the comments. Provide as much information as possible to help the moderators of r/antinatalism take action against the highly alarming behavior of u/Numerous-Macaroon224.
u/Numerous-Macaroon224 is a disgrace to r/antinatalism.
Do not stay silent. Bad actors must be exposed.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/[deleted] • Nov 03 '21
Discussion What is happening to r/antinatalism ?
Recently , seems like a lot has changed . The subreddit pic and banner have changed from something peaceful to idk what to call it . Apart from this the discussion has entirely changed from the philosophy to hating on children and parents .
Earlier I used to see quite strict moderation , but it seems missing these days . Calling chidren disgusting , venting about suffering has increased alot .
What do you guys think ?
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/Efirational • Apr 16 '20
Discussion Opinion: Instead of focusing on not having children the AN community should focus on the right to die
Here are my arguments for this proposition:
The current idea of trying to make people voluntarily stop having kids is a lost cause: as David Pearce and others have noted, it's not a viable strategy because it's improbable that you will manage to convince the entire population to stop having kids, as long as even 1% will not be convinced earth will still continue to be repopulated. Do you really see yourself realistically convincing all the Muslims in the world to stop having kids? or the Amish?
The best way to solve the negativity of life to people who suffer from it is allowing them to exit life in a simple, painless and dignified way. In this way, you will also give the opportunity to people who enjoy life to continue living.
Currently, suicide is not very simple and might be dangerous, all the best and painless ways have been made illegal and there is an ongoing attempt to make it even harder, you used to be able to kill yourself using exhaust gas from cars, but it's not possible anymore - the same true for the newer generations of sleeping pills which have are not lethal. If you fail your suicide attempt you might be seriously injured which will make your life even worse.
There is a social taboo about discussing suicide and people who want to exit can't talk about it with their loved ones if the authorities will know about your plan you will be arrested and put in a mental hospital, the same fate might await you if you fail in your attempt.
Legalizing and normalizing suicide will give many suffering people a viable way out but it will also force authorities and society to make life better for the people who don't choose this to minimize suicide rates. People will be more worried about bullying or abuse knowing that the result might be a suicide.
As happiness is partly genetic, it might also lower the odds of depressive people to have kids and by this improving the average happiness of the humans that are being born.
Spontaneous and "irrational" suicides can be mitigated by smart regulation that makes people wait a time period and go through treatment before they are allowed to commit suicide.
From what I understand in Germany there is already a plan to make assisted suicide legal so, by all means, this is not some unrealistic plan (like convincing everyone to not have children or making the world explode like the efilist want), it's actually something that can happen in our lifetime. AN activism can actually make a change here.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/[deleted] • Jun 28 '21
Other Something funny I have thought: Adopted children get made fun of in school for being adopted; but if you think about it, the highest probability in which your parents actually wanted you is when you are adopted.
For all we know, if your parents choose to biologically conceive you, it might have well been an accident which you do not know of.
I wanted to post this on r/antinatalism but my account did not have enough karma.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/Oldphan • Jan 22 '22
Other All Sentience is trapped Inside the Double Hell-ix Sculpture
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/[deleted] • May 03 '22
The upcoming horrifying effects of this can't be understated
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/hodlbtcxrp • May 28 '22
News Mass shootings in schools highlight the need to not give birth
There was recently an NRA meeting that was greeted by protesters following recent mass shootings. If you have a child, he or she can grow up and get shot, but there are many other harms e.g. they may be stabbed, beaten, verbally abused, raped, etc. They may also be the ones who cause harm on others rather than the other way around.
Studies show that children who bully grow up to become more successful and sexually attractive than those who are the victims of bullying. What this shows is that there is fundamental lack of justice in the world, that might makes right, and that bringing new life into the world will expose new life to this reality.
The best way to protect your child is to not have them. All the resources you would have put into your child can then be channelled into protecting yourself from those who seek to harm you. Any surplus wealth can be put into trying to further the antinatalist cause.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/harsht07 • Dec 28 '21
Other I wrote a Dialogue on Antinatalism that addresses and attempts to resolve common objections that people raise.
N: Congratulations on your wedding! I hope you deliver the good news soon.
AN: Good news?
N: I’m talking about babies! How many do you want?
AN: None.
N: Why? Do you prefer a childfree lifestyle?
AN: Not quite. Word “childfree” is associated with a lifestyle adopted by some couples who don’t want their freedom restricted. Motives of childfree people mainly pertain to saving time, money, and energy. My motives are different.
N: What other reason can anyone possibly have?
AN: Before I tell you my motive, why don’t you give me a good reason to have children?
N: Reason for having children? Why should one have a reason for doing something so obvious?
AN: Do you comply with a norm without questioning it?
N: I never gave it a serious thought, let me think. Don’t you want someone to take care of you when you’re old?
AN: I would prefer not treating a person as an insurance for old age.
N: Don’t you want someone to keep your bloodline alive and carry it into the future?
AN: I don’t see what that achieves exactly. We have a longing for immortality but making copies of my DNA would not carry my particular consciousness into the future. My death is my end.
N: But aren’t your children an extension of yourself?
AN: Though I am not going to have children, I would like to see my children as individuals who have their own will, not as extended copies of myself.
N: Majority of people have kids. If you don’t, you will be the odd man out. You will have less in common with other folks and it's not a good idea to deviate from the status quo.
AN: I do not have the heart to tell my children that their existence is a consequence of society’s pressure and expectations. Besides, falling birth rates in some countries indicate that people are beginning to realize that procreation is a choice, not a default.
N: You asked for reasons to have a child, but at times, people engage in procreation simply because it is an instinct, a desire to have a baby. And desires by their very nature are inexplicable.
AN: I agree. But the reasons you stated for procreation were all an expression of desire. A desire to have someone to care for you in old age, a desire to create someone resembling you, a desire to escape from societal pressure. So do you admit that all reasons for procreation, whatever they may be, are rooted in self-interest?
N: I’m not sure. The child brought to existence gets the gift of life, so the motives of parents do not stem from pure self-interest, it's for the benefit of the child too.
AN: How so?
N: Obviously, existence is better than non-existence.
AN: Do you realize the absurdity of what you just said? Only living people can say this. I haven't heard of any non-existent people saying “Hey, I would like to get out of this void and get some existence”. One cannot make such a comparison unless they have experienced or imagined both the states of existing and not existing.
N: Well, I can imagine what non-existence feels like. It feels like a black void, devoid of any sensations.
AN: You are confusing absence of experience with experience of absence. When you say that existence is better than non-existence, what you’re actually comparing is someone being alive vs. someone imagining themself being dead. Of course a normal living person, owing to their survival instinct, would prefer continuing to exist over dying. Making such a statement from a non-existent being’s point of view is absurd, because there is no point of view to speak of. I would be surprised if any newborn child feels anything close to “Wow, I am relieved. I am so glad I exist now after experiencing non-existence for so long”.
N: Makes sense.
AN: So do you acknowledge that any reason for procreation cannot include the interest of the potential child, and that any reason for procreation, has at its basis, the desires of parents and society?
N: It seems so.
AN: But are our desires worth chasing if it creates pain and brings misery to someone?
N: Certainly not, that would be a selfish thing to do. But how is it relevant to what we are discussing?
AN: No life is free from misery and pain. By bringing a child here I would be subjecting it to life’s suffering, and ultimately, sentencing it to death, just to fulfill my desires rooted purely in self-interest. I don't want to be responsible for someone’s suffering and death. As Peter Wessel Zapffe said: “To bear children into this world is like carrying wood to a burning house.”
N: That’s so pessimistic.
AN: So?
N: Gloomy attitude like that makes you so negative.
AN: Does calling a statement “Optimistic” or “Pessimistic” affect how true or false that statement is?
N: Being Positive or Negative refers to mindset and temperament. A statement is different, it has a truth value i.e. it is either true or false.
AN: Consider this sentence: “Everyone dies.” Is this a mindset or a statement?
N: It’s a true statement, which makes it a fact.
AN: How about this sentence “Suffering in life is guaranteed.”?
N: Suffering is subjective. It depends on how you define it.
AN: Suffering is that which you strive to avert as far as possible, and do not want to experience regardless of its severity. Unpleasant bodily sensations constitute physical suffering. Unpleasant thoughts, mood, and emotions constitute mental suffering. Health issues, emotional distress, stress due to work, grinding 40-50 years of your life at work to ensure survival, losing loved ones, and torment caused in moments preceding death are some of the instances of suffering that no one escapes.
N: That doesn’t sound like a big deal. Most people don't even think of these experiences as suffering. More severe problems exist, like terminal diseases, mental health issues, poverty, war, racism, rape, murder, violence, human trafficking, etc. and you are complaining about trivial things like having to work and minor health problems?
AN: Certainly, the issues you mentioned are more severe, but comparing smaller issues against the major ones does not invalidate the smaller ones. Also, creating a new being means exposing it to the risk of getting involved in one of these severe misfortunes you just mentioned. I am not willing to expose my potential children to such risks.
N: But most of the people live normal lives without getting involved in any of these crimes, and chances of suffering from a terminal disease or having a serious accident are pretty low.
AN: Magnitude of probability is irrelevant. The mere possibility, regardless of the probability, constitutes risk. It is as if while deciding to procreate, people place their bets on a safe future for their child and roll the dice. As if they were playing Russian roulette with their potential child, with poverty in one chamber of the revolver, illness in another, and so on. Either that, or they are oblivious to these misfortunes.
N: Every action has some risk associated with it. Would you stop driving because of the risk of an accident every time you drive?
AN: Your analogy is not valid. When I drive, or do anything dangerous, I expose myself to these risks. I am aware of the possibilities and I know what I am signing up for. When someone procreates, they expose someone else i.e. their child to these risks.
N: What you say is correct, but I am sure that your future children won’t mind if you took these risks on their behalf.
AN: Let's say you have a plan to execute which involves a person, but it might harm them. Would you attempt to have a discussion with that person and seek their consent before executing your plan, or would you apologize to them after that risk manifests into real harm and hurts them?
N: Seeking consent would be a better idea. How is this relevant?
AN: Is it possible to receive consent from someone who does not exist yet?
N: Don’t speak nonsense.
AN: Exactly. An unborn child cannot consent, or rather, there is no point of view of an unborn child. But what we are concerned with is receiving consent, which is impossible.
N: You’re being paranoid, you should relax a bit. I admit the presence and risk of suffering, but that should not influence you to not have a child. There are good things in life as well.
AN: What does an average good life look like?
N: It is subjective and depends on what you consider pleasant.
AN: Does having pleasant things or experiences compensate for my pain?
N: What do you mean by compensation?
AN: Having these pleasant things in life does not erase my suffering. Pain and pleasure are not analogous to positive and negative numbers of mathematics that balance each other out when added. Would it be acceptable if I were to deliberately inject someone's body with a deadly virus and offer them loads of money as compensation, especially if I do this without their consent?
N: If you believe that good things in life do not make up for the bad things and vice versa, then it logically follows that just as you are responsible for your child’s suffering, you are responsible for your child's happiness too. And being responsible for someone’s happiness is definitely a good thing.
AN: Can you define Happiness or Pleasure?
N: Happiness is a pleasant feeling or mood felt when one fulfills their wishes. You enjoy your tasty meals, have loving friends and family, consume various forms of media for entertainment, and now you’re even married, and yet rant about suffering. What more could you ask for? Doesn’t having these things make your life happy and fulfilled?
AN: To me it seems that the things which you mentioned just help me fulfill my wants and needs, which, if unfulfilled, will cause pain and frustration. I naturally become hungry, so I eat to avoid the pain of hunger. I appreciate my friends and family, but in their absence, I’ll experience loneliness which hurts. I watch TV, read books, play games, etc., to avoid boredom, which is also a form of pain. Hunger, loneliness and boredom are the default states of existence. If you sit idle and do nothing, these come to you naturally by default. You need to constantly make an active effort to keep them away, and there is no guarantee of your effort being always successful. What you call happiness is simply an absence of these default states of pain. What happens when one’s needs and desires go unfulfilled?
N: The person gets frustrated or feels dejected. How is this relevant again?
AN: If I procreate, my children would have these needs, wants, and desires. When my childrens’ needs are fulfilled, they will experience pleasure, or happiness.
N: That’s correct. You would be creating happiness, and that's a good thing.
AN: Creating children means creating their needs and wants that are unfulfilled by default. I would be responsible for creating their needs of food, shelter, entertainment, etc., which have no guarantee of always getting fulfilled throughout their lives. Condemning children to unfulfilled needs so that they could experience joy when those needs are fulfilled seems tantamount to deliberately creating a problem for the sake of experiencing relief when it is solved.
N: You are correct, but isn’t that the beauty of life? Suffering is a necessary part of life, it makes life meaningful. Overcoming hardships builds character. It makes us wise and virtuous. As a famous philosopher said: “What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger”.
AN: That is a rationalization people use to cope with the pain they couldn't avoid. What purpose do virtue and wisdom serve?
N: They make us resilient and prepare us for life’s greater battles.
AN: A direct implication of this line of argument would be that we all should impose suffering on other people to make them virtuous. We should tell them, "If you don't suffer a little right now, you'll suffer greatly in future. The strength you derive from your present suffering will help you combat future suffering of greater severity. Therefore, you should be happy about your present suffering."
N: I don’t see the point you’re trying to make.
AN: Suffering only has instrumental value, it is useful only insofar it helps combat future suffering of greater intensity. It's not an end in itself. Consider a person who isn’t under any circumstantial restriction or compulsion, would they freely choose to impose suffering on themself when doing so accomplishes no other end? In other words, is suffering desirable in itself?
N: A normal person won’t do that, but a Masochist will.
AN: Exactly.
N: I get what you’re trying to say, but not everyone shares your opinion. If you bring someone to this world and they don’t find their life worth continuing or enjoyable, like you, they always have the option of leaving by killing themself.
AN: Although I admit that it is the most logical step one could take if they find their life unbearable, my survival instinct overrides my rational mind. But that’s not what we are discussing. A life worth starting is different from a life worth continuing. A living person’s survival instinct can be seen as an interest in continuing life. Whereas for an unborn child, we cannot speak of a point of view as discussed earlier. Also, suggesting suicide to someone who finds life unbearable is like adding fuel to fire. Contemplating suicide leads to immense internal struggle and the act of suicide itself causes suffering.
N: If everyone starts thinking like you Humanity will go extinct. Whoever supports human extinction is a nutcase.
AN: What’s so bad about extinction? Anyway it's only a matter of time. Do you think humanity is immortal?
N: We do not know. Maybe humanity will achieve immortality with progress in science and technology. But as humans it is our moral duty to ensure humanity’s survival.
AN: What do you mean by moral duty?
N: It is something that everyone should do. You must be crazy to think that extinction is okay. No normal human would wish something terrible like this.
AN: Why is extinction terrible?
N: Humans are highly evolved creatures and we have made it so far. If humanity goes extinct our progress, culture, legacy, achievements, everything will go to waste!
AN: And why is that a bad thing? There will be no one around to experience the loss of things you mentioned.
N: You just don’t get it.
AN: Practically speaking, I am 100% certain that not everyone shares my thoughts. I have had similar discussions with several other people before and none of them agreed with me. So you can rest assured that people won't stop reproducing anytime soon.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/Savonarola1452 • Apr 10 '23
People abuse their children and kick them out to the streets, but when we say we don't want to have children cause we can't protect them then we are "selfish" and "mentally ill who lack clarity of thought". Actions speak louder than words.
Title
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/partidge12 • May 17 '21
Discussion Thoughtful quote from David Benatar
I've already posted this in r/antinatalism but I think it is probably more appropriate for this subreddit.
I came across this at the tail end of one of David Benatar's interviews and thought it was worth sharing. This was his response when asked if he wished he had never existed and if he thought about it much.
I've amended the quote to show the full transcript for clarity's sake.
Interviewer: Do you wish you had not been born? Would you rather not exist?
David Benatar: Yes. I'd rather not have existed. That's different from 'would I rather be dead'.
Interviewer: Do you think about that much?
David Benatar: Yes. I think we all should. Now some people might say that's crying over spilled milk but there are prospective benefits to be gained here because I think if you have a certain sensitivity to the way the world is, and to the amount of suffering there is in the world, not just your own but other peoples', then you might think twice about having children, about participating in a culture that encourages people to have children, that frowns on people who don't, so I think there is something to be gained by thinking about these things"
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/[deleted] • Oct 04 '20
Discussion If Antinatalism is Immoral
If antinatalism is immoral, then every natalist who decides against having a 2nd child, or 3rd, or 4th, etc. is also doing an immoral act, by their logic.
If a father of 4 children judges an AN for for not having any children, and considers it immoral, then the AN should reply and say to the father that it's immoral not to bring your 5th child into existence, and thus he's depriving his 5th child from the "gift of life".
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/XxANAL_SEEPAGExX69 • Jul 25 '24
News Kids? A Growing Number of Americans Say, ‘No, Thanks.’
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/[deleted] • Aug 07 '21
Discussion Parenting is Hard Because It Doesn't Matter How Many Things You Get Right, But How Many You Get Wrong
Rich parents who materially provided everything the child wishes, for example, yet the child grew up emotionally neglected is not good parenting, no matter how many hours of work the parents have sacrificed for the child.
And they do not have to be big mistakes, even. Minor mistakes and blunders could and do accumulate and manifest later in life.
It's simply a huge gamble on top of being a hassle.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/[deleted] • Aug 02 '21
Discussion "The Grief Experienced at the Hour of Death, Is Far Greater than the Joy Felt When a Newborn Announced"
Rough translation of one of the verses in one of Al-Ala Al-Maarri's poems.
Indeed, why take the risk and be a parent knowing that if one of your offspring dies, you'll be left scared for life? All the joys and good memories will be sources of pain from then on. Tears of joy at the hour of birth won't come close to tears of grief at the hour of death.
" Life is nothing but wrestle and struggle,
Yet, I wonder why people harbor desires
For wanting more of life"
Again, a rough translation. It's much better in the original language.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/[deleted] • May 08 '21
Discussion How Religious People Respond To Me
Some religious individuals say to me "well, if i shared your atheistic views then i would agree, that yes, it's immoral to have children in a cold indifferent universe. But there is a god, and he is kind and merciful."
I would argue that it doesn't make a difference whether there is a god or not. You still can't control anything; instead of a chaotic universe, insert a mysteriously capricious god.
Just because god says that he's merciful and honest doesn't mean he isn't lying. Especially considering the state of the world. Can you honestly look at human history and say that a merciful god witnessed all that and allowed it to happen?
And the stakes are much higher if you're religious, in addition to the whole gamble of heaven and hell, you're creating a consciousness that will last forever. How can you bear such a responsibility?
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/Savonarola1452 • Aug 03 '23
Abusive families are the norm and supportive families are rare
A few months ago, I took psychodrama classes. These are classes where people re-illustrate different life events that affected them negatively and try to somehow "recover" from.
What I noticed from these classes was that so many people came from abusive households. I heard so many heart breaking stories of family members sexually assaulting their children, fathers leaving the house, parents physically abusing their children so the children had to run away, it was terrible, and that's exactly the point. It seems that abusive families are the norm and supportive families are the rare ones. Which leads me to the next conclusion.
Parents have children, not because they want to raise "the next generation that will lead the nation", but because they want to create someone they could control, take their frustrations out on, they want a little slave for themselves so they could do whatever they want to it, rather than raising a human being to become an actual something.
Kinda "funny" is that these are the exact people who would dismiss antinatalism as a mental illness, or some sort of insanity, when they are the ones actually f*cking up human beings and comitting crimes against their own family members.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/Cyniex • Mar 31 '22
Discussion What do you people think of the current "division" in r/antinatalism regarding Veganism?
Let me preface by stating that I am not yet vegan. And I hope this post is okay to post on here.
Most people are accepting of the fact veganism and antinatalism goes hand in hand, but also accepts that not all antinatalists need to be vegans. The problem as I see it, are the anti-vegans projecting, because they don't want to accept that there are negative moral implications to using animal products that are similar or even equal to antinatalist principles, they are mad about the discussion and claiming that it's just vegans being self-righteous, when actually many non-vegans agree or discuss in good faith. They end up acting like the natalists, that often brigade the sub and show their own selfishness and are actually the root cause of the problem they are complaining about.
Basically, what I mean is that there isn't an actual divide on the sub, it's just a bunch of people who hate vegans for no actual reason.
Although I'm very open to hear what your views are.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/Savonarola1452 • Nov 10 '21
Discussion The Right To Be Left Alone
The right to be left alone is a basic human right. It contains the right to life and security and the right to privacy. I can't be bothered about society 24/7 because I must help myself now in order to be able to help others later. This right is being constantly violated in this world. Look at the animal kingdom. Animals are always in a rush of hunting and gathering food and running away from predator animals. It must be a nightmare. The human world is no different, where you have to work long workdays in soul draining conditions, being left with no time, no energy and no money for yourself. The reason I'm both antinatalist and a right-to-die supporter is because the right to be left alone is being constantly violated and it's impossible to function like that.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/[deleted] • Dec 25 '24
Minimalism = Antinatalism ; true minimalism goes with minimising consumers.
🌟🌟True Minimalism Lies in Having Minimum People🌟🌟
🌟 Minimal Consumption Leads to Better Resource Allocation
A smaller population requires fewer resources, ensuring that essential supplies like food, water, and energy are not wasted. This allows for a more equitable distribution of resources among those already living, enhancing their quality of life.
🌟Better Quality of Life for Existing Individuals
By reducing the creation of new dependents, we can focus on improving the living conditions of those already present. This ensures better access to healthcare, education, and basic necessities, creating a more sustainable society.
🌟 Lower Income Disparity
A reduced population lessens the competition for resources and opportunities, leading to a more balanced income distribution. This minimizes the wealth gap, allowing for a fairer society where everyone has access to basic needs.
🌟Avoiding Overpopulation and Resource Strain
By not needlessly increasing the population, we can avoid overburdening the planet’s finite resources. This helps to combat issues like deforestation, water scarcity, and environmental degradation, paving the way for a sustainable future.
🌟Prioritizing the Needy
Instead of creating new lives that require resources, true minimalism emphasizes supporting the vulnerable and underprivileged who already exist. This approach ensures that no one is left behind in the pursuit of a better world.
🌟 Ethical Responsibility Toward Existing Life
Minimalism teaches us to prioritize the well-being of those already alive. Providing resources to the needy strengthens communities and reduces suffering, rather than stretching resources thinner by adding more dependents.
🌟 Sustainability Through Simplicity
Focusing on a smaller number of people reduces resource consumption and environmental impact, promoting a simpler, more sustainable way of living for future generations.
🌟 Reduced Social and Economic Pressure
A smaller population lowers the strain on public services, housing, and job markets, creating a more stable and manageable society where everyone has a fair chance to thrive.
🩷 Improved Emotional and Community Bonds
With fewer people, communities can foster stronger connections and support systems, ensuring everyone has a place and a purpose within society.
💚 Respecting Planetary Limits / Environmental Enhancements
True minimalism aligns with the planet's carrying capacity. By focusing on the needs of existing people, we ensure that humanity lives within Earth’s ecological boundaries, avoiding catastrophic consequences for future generations.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/[deleted] • Jun 25 '21
Discussion The Supposed Desire to Have Children is Greatly Exaggerated
Critics of antinatalism often say that AN is futile because you cannot possibly go against the internal instinct people have to reproduce. I might agree that AN (on a large scale) is futile, but i would say that their reason is false.
The desire to reproduce, i would say, is mostly, if not purely, social/religious, it's not as instinctual and "biological" as they believe it to be. If it was so instinctual, then there wouldn't be any need for societal pressure to force people to reproduce (however indirectly it might be).
If normies lived in a town where there was no societal pressure to reproduce (or even there were no childbirths/children at all), i would think people would go on with their lives without giving serious consideration to the idea of having children. And why would they? If having children is not set as a goal for them by society, then why would they, after living decades without any offspring, change their whole lifestyle and take on the huge burden of having a child? It simply doesn't make sense.
r/TrueAntinatalists • u/LoverOfFurryBeauty • Jun 27 '21
Discussion Is the definition of a "good life" the same as slavery?
Whenever I hear people talking about "a good person", the person is usually depicted as a hard worker who got good grades in school.
So does this mean that the definition of a good life is to be able to work hard like a slave? In this sense, is the purpose of life slavery? And is the purpose of giving birth, molding new lives into slavery?
What are your opinions on my thought? Is it a good reason to support antinatalism?