Hi!!
Long time lurker here. Since this sub helped so much with deciding my options for surgeries I thought I'd post my experience with Feminization Laryngoplasty and Thyrohyoid elevation (Femlar) with Dr. James Thomas in Portland.
I'm not a professional singer or anything, but I looove to sing. This made me really nervous to consider any VFS. So, I took voice training lessons from a professional clinic. I have really good control over my voice and good get a good passing voice, but it was so taxing. More importantly to me, involuntary noises icked me out (especially during sex. booooo).
If I never talked I passed 100% of the time. When talking it dropped to maybe 50/50 (I live in a deeply red state so these numbers are pretty accurate). I just felt that the stress and dysphoria that would be relieved from a successful VFS surgery would be worth the risk.
Feminization Laryngoplasty with Thyrohyoid elevation is a technique where the vocal chords are shortened and the extra cartilage from exposure to testosterone is removed. The result is a larynx (voice box) that is identical to if you had never been exposed to testosterone. A bonus from the removal of the cartilage is that its basically a super trach shave (again, its as if your larynx was never poisoned by male puberty). The resulting structure is then sutured to a thin plate. Theoretically, this not only raises your pitch, but also changes your resonance. It also reduces volume. There is a 2inch-ish thin horizontal incision on your neck, placed where your neck folds are.
This is in contrast to Wendlar Glottoplasty, which only raises pitch, and also creates a "shelf" from the stitched together vocal chords that can trap mucus.
From what I understand, the surgery is much more successful the younger you are. I'm under 25 and also quite fit, so I felt good about my odds.
~consult~
Getting a consultation was a bit tricky as their office is a bit hands off and hard to communicate with. After emailing and calling, I got an appointment scheduled. I was able to fly in, make the consult, and fly back the same night. The consultation is pretty chill, Dr. Thomas and the surgical assistant Jonica take recordings of your voice, vocal range, and endurance while a camera is stuck down your throat through your nose. They numb you with a spray, and I'd say it's about as uncomfortable as cleaning your tongue when brushing your teeth. Dr. Thomas said I was a good candidate and had good bedside manner answering questions very honestly. They mentioned that their clinic gets a lot of singers, which gave me some more confidence. The quote that stuck out with me here is:
"If you want to mitigate any possible risk, keep training your voice. It's difficult and uncomfortable, and has its limitations. If you can tolerate some risk, and nothing goes wrong, you never have to worry about it again."
He said the main risk is that it heals unevenly, say he sutures asymetrically, which causes an extreme raspy voice. Second, infection can happen, but risk has been seriously reduced with their new antibiotic regimen. Lastly, in some patients, nothing changes with their voice and he said the clinic can't figure out why. Again, very honest which I appreciated.
Back at the front desk, they informed me that insurance is a really long wait, and that most people pay cash (around 15,000USD). As the surgical center (wilshire) and the clinic where in network, I said put me on the waitlist. As a month went by, it became clear that the insurance waitlist is a murky and unclear thing. I don't think these dates every actually happen. I think they try to push people to pay cash since they're a small clinic and I'm sure insurance underpays. I can respect that (but also grrr). However, they assured me that they will submit a claim, and whatever they actually pay they'll refund me.
Included in the cost is postop care, as well as laser tuning in the clinic to fix any problems. They can use this to mostly correct the raspy complication, and they can pitch the voice up a tad later if no change occurs from the surgery (again, included in cost).
So, I took out a loan and got a surgery date (they usually have lot of openings beginning like a month out).
~SURGERY~
Again, communication wasn't the best, but I was sent an info sheet. Surgery dates are on Tuesdays, and you need to get to portland on Sunday. There's a Pre-Op monday morning, and then post-ops every day until Friday. Most are cleared to go home, but some have to stay saturday as well. I ended up staying in an airbnb for just under $1000. Lodging must be within 3 miles of the clinic.
Monday: Preop was essentially a second consultation. I asked my final questions and proceeded onto tuesday. You get a script for your meds (norco for pain and cough, cefpo as antibiotic, prednisone for swelling) and have to fill them before surgery tomorrow. Normal anesthesia prep. Dr. Thomas gives you his personal phone number and encourages you to call or text him at any time for help concerning the surgery.
Tuesday: Surgery day. Wilshire Surgical Center was awesome and everything was a breeze. I woke up feeling woozy, and with a drawing board to communicate. Vocal rest is now mandatory. I was a bit worried about accidentally speaking, but because your vocal cords are so swollen you can't make noise even if you wanted to! I didn't feel too shitty and pain was only a 5 out of 10 at the worst. It's a bit tricky to breathe, and the hardest thing is not coughing. I drank a lot of cough syrup (I found dexlam max strength to be the most effective). There are no diet restrictions and I ate like an animal when I got back to the airbnb. Swallowing is going to be uncomfortable for a few weeks, but nothing intolerable.
Wednesday: I felt fine enough to walk 10 minutes to the clinic, where they checked out the internal structure with the nose camera again (they will do this every postop). Everything was fine, and pain peaked at a 3. Using text to speech on my iphone (it's built in the accessibility menu) was so helpful. I started to walk around portland today.
Thursday and Friday: These postops were similarly uneventful and I felt good enough to romp around town and have some fun. I was discharged friday, where they gave me two letters, and then I flew home. The first letter is a general description for future anesthesiologists of what intubation tubes to use (your larynx is now smaller that what is probably on file) with no mention that you're trans. The second is a detailed description of the structures (shows you're trans) in case you need surgery in that area again withing a year so that the structures are not damaged. I felt a bit whole body uncomfortable for another 2 days.
100% vocal rest (no noises of any kind) is active for two weeks postop. One week after surgery you remove the outer stitch, which is sutured in such a way you just pull on it from one side and all of it comes out. When I did this, it got stuck around halfway through in the surgical glue. It wasn't painful, but it definitely made me queasy. I text Dr. Thomas about it and he coached me through it. I think because of this the scar was a bit raised in that area. I've been putting pracasil on it since and the scar is pretty unnoticeable now.
~75% vocal rest - week 3~
two weeks after surgery, you're allowed to talk 25% quantity and volume (so mostly yes or no's). I was really excited to hear my voice, but honestly not much would come out because I was still so inflamed. Having to communicate by TTS wasn't terrible, but was definitely starting to be annoying (I love to talk haha). Also, the pain swallowing as quite annoying.
~50% vocal rest - week 4~
3 weeks after surgery, the number moves to 50% quantity and volume. I started to be able to talk, but it was really quiet and still pretty deep from the swelling. The swallowing pain was gone this week.
~75% vocal rest - week 5~
This is where things really started to improve for me. I started talking quite a bit and was absolutely delighted by my pitch increase and resonance change. I talked maybe a bit more than I should have here, but everything felt great.
~100% - week 6~
back in business! your voice stays weak for a bit (they say it takes up to a year to fully settle), but I could fully talk. I immediately noticed I never get misgendered anymore, even on the phone which is incredible. I'd describe my voice as fully feminine, on the androgynous side when I wake up or am sick. When using voice training techniques I'm at a high femme range and resonance. You have to fully learn to sing again which was weird, but I got the hang of it after another 2 weeks or so. Now (4ish months out), I can sing to my hearts content. It's not great since I'm having to learn to sing again, but songs I could never sing before are well within my range. I can belt higher, and I can really feel the head voice. Falsetto is tricky but I can get whistle notes! There is a definite loss in volume, but it's fully within normal ranges. I can still get loud if I want to (and my voice sounds even better).
The craziest parts for me have been the involuntary noises. When running your panting and gasps are femminine. Your laugh is feminine. Sex? Your moans are now femme (HELL YEAH).
I got a pretty intense respiratory cold recently and it definitely introduced some some more swelling and my voice deepened a tad (still totally passing). It's slowing moving higher again. I'm curious to see how it acts when fully healed!
I got an EOB for only around 2,500USD ish, but I haven't heard from the office yet. I'll post back here when I get my refund!
Also, I won't be posting recordings for personal reasons. Sorry!!
TLDR: femlar is awesome if you have no complications
Feel free to ask me anything!!!
xoxo