r/TransLater • u/Sudden-Smile-3869 • Apr 06 '23
Grow Up!!!
Am I the only one who is appalled when older trans decide to dress like slutty teenagers? Good grief, we get so much crap as it is, and I don't think it helps when a person dresses totally inappropriate to their age. I am not saying we can't be sexy, but Lord have mercy, the person I saw yesterday while shopping was just ridiculous - and that is probably the person who complains about being misgendered and how terrible people are to her. Well, dress your age and consider being at least a bit conforming to societal norms. It is hard enough being trans and making an effort, and sometimes I feel like some folks just wanna be attention whores, and that is more the desire than to be transfem!
Just my two cents!!! And please don't push this post into a rant against trans who are non-binary or don't "pass" well, because that is NOT my point!!! I just think we, as a community, would be in a better place by considering, at least a little bit, the binary world in which we exist, and the societal norms that exist (whether we agree with them or not!). We are getting a lot of pushback right now, and I think at least some of the pushback can be minimized by considering those norms, and not insisting that everyone has to yield to us - some middle ground would be helpful!!!
EDIT: THANKS FOR ALL THE THOUGHTFUL REPLIES (AND EVEN THE SILLY ONES)!!! In sum, I sure agree that people should stop insisting on any particular style or dress, and no, I didn't accost the woman nor would I have done anything but be supportive had I spoken or interacted with her - that said, society is what it is, and I appreciate the comments that suggest that at least some consideration of the broader rhythm of our civilization is probably best - that said, cheers to all my sisters, and much love regardless of what bra you may, or may not, be flashing in the grocery store - I may not necessarily think it a good idea, but I got your back if and when it becomes an issue with some transphobe, I assure you!!!
49
Apr 06 '23
Part of the desire to dress “immaturely” is because a lot of trans women missed out on growing up the correct gender. I’d recommend understanding and grace in these situations.
13
4
-2
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
Wanted to confirm I hear that, and believe me I went thru that phase big time (but kept it at home with the booty shorts and crop tops - LOL) - as to my actions in this regard, see my edit as to grace :)!
19
u/SeneInSPAAACE Apr 06 '23
Am I the only one who is appalled when older trans decide to dress like slutty teenagers?
Probably not, but you could also consider it a person who may be just a year into puberty, with all the fashion savvy of a 12-year old.
However...
Good grief, we get so much crap as it is, and I don't think it helps when a person dresses totally inappropriate to their age.
Playing for "good optics" has not historically worked. Being the last in line to the firing squad is still in line.
We are getting a lot of pushback right now, and I think at least some of the pushback can be minimized by considering those norms, and not insisting that everyone has to yield to us - some middle ground would be helpful!!!
Doubtful. I think it's more likely to be a "If you get the Devil an inch" scenario.
1
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
The whole point is being a little less 'visible' in outlandish fashion might make a firing line less likely - there are a lot more of "them" than us, and completely ignoring societal norms given the imbalance in numbers is (IMO) far more likely to lead to firing lines than having some consideration for 'them' and their societal sensibilities - just thinking out loud here, and thanks for your thoughtful reply!
23
u/dretsuat Apr 06 '23
The pushback against trans people has zero to do with how some dress in public. We could all dress like nuns and the transphobes would still mock us. All this type of sentiment does is concede ground to our oppressors and that’s something we should never do. Just my two cents.
0
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
Thought experiment - let's say we all dressed as nuns, and no one could tell the nuns from the nunettes - in that scenario, no one would know to "mock us" because we would be compliant with the societal 'nun norms' (that is funny to me - LOL!) - the point is one can't mock what one doesn't see - thus, my point about a bit more blending in - considering societal norms is not conceding ground to 'oppressors' it is simply considering the overall picture instead of solely our own selfish desires - IMO!
2
u/Ms_Masquerade Trans Woman Apr 07 '23
This thought experiment is rooted in the assumption all trans women can pass. Some can't, and those who can't shouldn't be attacked as disrespecting social norms like your thought experiment assumes.
0
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
No passing assumption was intended - but mostly wanted to reply to you and emphasize I am NOT saying the person should be 'attacked' or for that matter mocked or ridiculed, and again, I would defend that person to the death if that happened. I would also note that if one doesn't 'pass' (whatever the heck that really even means, given how masculine some girls can be, and how feminine some guys can be!!!), it does make sense to not draw even more attention to oneself by ignoring the basic social norms (like not wearing a mini and bra to the grocery store), but that is just my thought process!
2
u/dretsuat Apr 07 '23
It’s extremely naive that you think people who hate trans folk do so because a few of us might stick out in a store. They hate us because our very existence is in contravention of social norms.
22
u/Veronica-Ocean Trans Femme Apr 06 '23
How about you do you, and let them do them?
1
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
Not my point, my dear! I would LOVE for that to be the case, but the point of the post was we exist in a society, and that demands some consideration of the overall situation - see my edit for clarification!
1
1
6
Apr 06 '23
Trans or Cis - no one appreciates people who dress inappropriately in public..
In their defense.. a lot of trans women don’t have much style sense early on so it can be difficult. It’s still very difficult for me after a couple years of transition!
2
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
I hear this! Took me 10 years to figure out I am more of a Boston Proper girl, and sadly will never rock a hot pink mini-skirt to a concert!
6
u/Stefanie_Diorio Apr 06 '23
This all reminds me of the gay rights movement in many ways. ‘Conformists’ vs. ‘Stand-outs’ vs. Phobic Society. Both Conformists and Stand-outs had their unique strengths & weaknesses when dealing with the phobes and ‘un-informed middle’. Regardless, neither group made much progress in changing phobic minds. In regards to activism, either group alone was vastly weaker without the other. Like it or not, merely existing was in itself an act of radical activism no matter Conformist or Stand-out. The phobic opposition weakened only when enough people felt safe enough to come out to friends and family to make something so radical into fairly normal… at least in the eyes of the middle as it became more knowledgeable.The transgender community has not yet reached that milestone. Hopefully someday soon.
In the meantime, cut your sisters some slack regardless of which camp they belong. Better yet, somehow find a way to support them. We need to stick together.
1
17
u/CDTia Apr 06 '23
Let them have it. They missed out on their younger years.
10
u/Amber_Steel86 Apr 06 '23
I have to agree with this. They didn’t get to do all the fun stuff they wanted to when they were kids.
1
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
I hear ya! Me either - what I would do for the chance to be young again, instead of growing up in the 1970's when you damn well better follow societal norms - not a fun time for a little sissy boi!!!
4
u/ashleygison45 Apr 06 '23
Also I often see many Crossdressers dress the way you describe, but rarely or almost never see someone who is transgender dress other than to blend into society. Are you sure the people you are referring to aren't Crossdressers (who still identify as male internally) and often dress to shock as an experience and aren't thus interested as much as blending into society like we are?
1
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
I am not sure of anything, and I did not engage this person to know the answer - I just know society and transphobes can be tough, and ignoring society entirely (and its norms) seems (which was the point of the post) to be (possibly) creating more pushback than we need!
4
u/Jackie_fitz Apr 06 '23
I have not started my transition yet, but I do go out cross dressed, and during the day I try to blend. I live in a rural area of Virginia and have never had a problem and if I’m getting the stink eye, I haven’t seen it. But, at night when I go out you can be sure I want to look great! I still have some great athletic legs that I love display in a miniskirt. I’ve also done the skinny jeans and heels during the day and received more than a few winks, and a softly spoken cat call or two. Bottom line, if someone feels comfortable wearing something in public, go for it. Frankly I have no idea why someone would want to transition to be a frumpy plain Jane, but if that’s your thing then be the frumpiest plainest Jane ever.
2
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
Boho and Boston Proper for me - no frumpy jane!!!
And for the record, skinny jeans and cute points are the hottest - but that was NOT what this person was wearing (think crazy short ripped jean shorts, along with a hot pink skimpy bra, and black pumps, on a 60-plus-year-old very tall person) - but see my edit for clarity on that! Thanks for your thoughtful insights!
3
u/deerseed13 Apr 06 '23
I’d say we are getting push back because our very existence is against “norm”. We aren’t supposed to even exist by the cis white christian USA norm. God doesn’t make mistakes, right?
This also feels like it has a lot of undertones of the “well, what was she wearing?” mentality.
1
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
Thanks for your comments - just wanted to clarify I am NOT suggesting any of us deserve anything due to who we are, or what we wear - see my edits for clarification on that issue! Just suggesting there is a bigger picture than any one of us and that our collective actions may have an impact on each of us individually.
2
u/sodetroit Apr 06 '23
I see all kinds of people dressing inappropriately. I know you feel the optics are bad and perhaps they are just making a statement. I prefer to look my best and dress nicely, we just can't hold everyone's hand. I'd like to think I represent us professionally with either gender I'm presenting as. I always say good looking is good looking!
2
2
u/TheSoundOfMoo Apr 06 '23
Please take that judgemental shaming attitude to a space that appreciates it. Responding to threats with concessions and fear is a good way to end up as the most modestly dressed girl in the concentration camp. This is life or death, and how anybody dresses is immaterial. I'll take the catgirl brigade over hiding any day.
1
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
See my edit! I am NOT judgmental shaming - that wasn't the point! The question is why so much pushback recently and what can we as a community do to minimize or eliminate it - I am working to avoid the camp, not take actions that just make Bubba and his buddies want to start one!!!
2
Apr 06 '23
Hi there, I'm 52, and transitioning and if I felt the vibe to dress like a slutty teenager I would. Actually I encourage every trans girl to do what feels good no matter what anyone thinks. We want to be happy and free to express ouselves which ever way we feel, a right you also reserve. If you don't like it, could you maybe just look the other way and keep it in your mind?😬 I get you find it icky and feel they misrepresent. I disagree, there's all kinds out there, some kooky I suppose, just like in the general population. Live and let live? You can dress how you think is proper and represent 😊.
I personally want to pass, and I dress casual chic.
1
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
Thanks for your thoughts - not a matter of whether I find it icky or they misrepresent me - the issue is the trans community as a whole and the pushback we are suddenly getting in spades! Society and its pressures are real, regardless of how much we all want to just live and let live - if that was really a thing, there would be no transphobes - IMO!
1
Apr 07 '23
I'm not blaming us for transphobes at all. People make their own choices whether they want to be evil or not, whether they want to be reasonable, and open-minded or not. I get what you're saying, you would rather have passing girls as representatives for the trans community, than the kind that that are visible trans, or don't pass. You want realistic spokespeople for the trans community. I agree it's a good thing to have your average trans girl as the poster child. We have to put forth that poster child I guess, because the transphobes are putting forth their poster child, the man in the dress. I'm in Canada , and I don't experience any of that transphobia, but I really do have a broken heart for my sisters in America. Seems to me that for everything you want in America including your freedom and peace, you must fight tooth and nail for. Everything is in the context of a battle. Just an observation from north of the border. Fight girls, you can do it. I'm here for you.
1
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 08 '23
Just to clarify - I do NOT want just passing girls - that wasn't my point. I was simply suggesting that if we are in a fight (and I agree with you about America entirely in that regard!) that we should consider all the variables, and societal 'norms' are one of those variables, regardless of how we feel about those norms.
For the record, I would not say I pass, but I also don't do things to draw attention to myself, and I would love for our 'spokesperson' to be non-passing (because to me, that is NOT what trans is about!!!) but be a bit more demure than the person wearing booty shorts and a pink bra to the grocery store - seems reasonable to me at least, notwithstanding my normal don't give a rats ass attitude!
Thanks for the chat, and be blessed and warm in Canada!!!
2
u/nytefox42 Apr 06 '23
Am I the only one who is appalled when older trans decide to dress like slutty teenagers?
I can confidently say you aren't the only ageist, slut shaming asshole, no. Sadly.
1
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
Respectfully my dear you miss the point entirely if you think I am slut shaming - the point of the post is about the pushback our community is getting, and what we can do to avoid making transphobes (who badly outnumber us) become more difficult - that was the point - see my edit - had anyone confronted her, I would have been the first to defend, and I would love to throw a short pink mini-skirt on and go chase the boys!
1
u/nytefox42 Apr 07 '23
No, my dear, slut shaming is exactly what you're doing. By the very act of calling the way they dress "slutty" and telling them they're wrong for it, you're slut shaming.
1
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 08 '23
On last try - I did NOT tell anyone they were wrong - I am discussing the broader issue of our community, and how people perceive us, and whether that makes any difference in our acceptance level in society - given the recent pushback, it seems an appropriate subject.
What I said is I was appalled, much like i would be if a 60 year old cis woman was running around in the store in booty shorts and a pink bra, but I did not confront, stare, or otherwise do anything.
Thanks for conversing and be blessed!!!
1
u/nytefox42 Apr 08 '23
The whole post is using a derogatory term for the way people dress and telling them they shouldn't dress like that.
1
u/EvelynEvil666 Apr 06 '23
Geez…..let people dress how they want. I mean the line MUST be drawn if anyone is going out in Pampers, tho. That’s a bit too young dressing.
2
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
I think in jest about the pampers you make my point - there IS a societal norm, whether we like it or not, and the point of my post was about pushback against our community, not whether this particular individual was dressed in any particular 'right or wrong' way! Thanks for your reply!!!
1
u/EvelynEvil666 Apr 07 '23
Maybe I do. I dunno. I mean…I’ve thought about it…well before realizing my truth. I dress in jeans, concert/metal Ts, and adidas. I’m 47. I DONT ever see it changing. As a trans girl…as an aging person…..it’s my style…it’s who I am….and I’m not changing….even when/if I am 80. There IS a societal expectation…..but I personally don’t GAF. But I’m not going out in pampers anytime soon…..YET! 😉
2
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
For damn sure clothes don't make the girl! I am not one to argue being trans fem means pink frilly skirts and bright red lipstick!! And I totally understand the don't GAF - that is exactly how I feel on an individual level!! The post was an attempt to discuss the broader issue of how much our DGAF attitudes may (or may not) be influencing the current debate (and too much incredible ugliness, on both sides frankly) concerning trans in American society. Cheers, Ms. Evelyn, and thanks again for the reasonable discourse - you and several others on this thread have made some interesting points - always refreshing to find open minds and intelligent discourse :) !!!
1
u/EvelynEvil666 Apr 07 '23
You are very welcome. 🥰 I just don’t wanna insert any toxicity. It’s bad enough out there. Imma just be me. But with boobs. 😜
2
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
Amen and amen - and an aside on the boobs comment: never could have guessed just how comfortable and "normal" having boobs really is for me - was one of the most affirming things for me about being trans...when the E started doing its magic, and the entire experience felt and seemed so normal and "right"...and wow does this mental train take me right down the lane of the person in the store - LOL - let's explore gender from the start of all I missed!
Be blessed girl!!!
2
u/EvelynEvil666 Apr 07 '23
Ditto, honey! 💜💜💜 it’s NUTS! Like…boobs, where ya been my whole life? You were supposed to be right here ALL ALONG! 👇🏼 well, thanks for FINALLY coming to the party! Stay for a while! 🥰
2
u/redcd555 Apr 06 '23
We are getting a LOT of pushback and hate from around the country, all needless. I also understand both sides we are older and supposedly more mature but I also get looking at myself and seeing all I lost, the fun the excitement the feminine feeling. There is so much we missed but I also see what I have great kids , grandkids and I don’t want to lose them. We all need to find a way forward but we also have to live with our choices. Good luck ❤️❤️❤️
2
u/sweetmuffinX Apr 06 '23
I see it a lot but I never judge or complain we had it tough been transgender I don't judge others who dress inappropriate if they happy then let them be to express who they want to be 🥺❤❤
2
u/pixel-soul Apr 06 '23
This sounds suspiciously like “if you dress that way you’re asking for it because of societal norms” and I’ll be honest…I’m not a fan. Cis get people have been demanding I act a certain way all of my life, and I did. I put on the mask and I played the fucking male clown. And now that I’m out, I’ll be goddamned if anyone, trans or cis, is going to get me to function by societal norms.
You do you, OP. But don’t try to do anyone else.
2
u/Juniper_2789 Apr 06 '23
Nah it’s a bit victim blamey to say we need to dresss better to be treated better. People treat us like shit cause they’re biggots. Doesn’t matter what we wear. I think people should be able to dress however they want and age doesn’t matter.
2
2
u/TooLateForMeTF 50+ transbian, HRT Apr 06 '23 edited Apr 06 '23
How about you do you, and let other people do them without getting all judgey?
For a lot of us older trans gals, yeah, we go through a phase of dressing like teenage girls because we didn't get to do that when we were teenagers.
Existential dysphoria is real, and this helps. So, like, some compassion please?
Moreover, if I choose to dress that way, this does not mean anyone has to "yield" to me. Like, what? I'm not asking them to like it. I'm not actually asking them for anything. Well, nothing more than the basic respect everyone should give to everyone else for their self-determination and autonomy. Which I think is really not an unusual or unwarranted ask.
But if I feel like I "shouldn't" dress that way on account of a general societal trend of transphobia, even though I want to, and therefore I don't, then it's me who's yielding to society's expectations about my gender presentation.
And you know what? F*** that. I'm so done with that. That's what being closeted and being an egg is: I've spent my whole life yielding to society's expectations about my gender presentation, so that now I am the "older trans" gal who has to contend with transitioning at this age because I felt like I "shouldn't" actually be myself for so very, very long.
No. Done. To hell with that garbage. I am done yielding. Me being my authentic self does not require anyone else to yield anything more than basic respect. Which they should be doing anyway.
2
u/Millenni0ld Apr 06 '23
A lot of my exploration of my trans identity has been buying random women’s clothes wherever I can find tall sizes online for cheap and I’m sure some of that might be considered too young for my late 30’s body. Although since I rarely go outside and nobody outside of random people on the internet even know 100% that I am trans (aside from clues they might pick up on), the only people seeing me usually is my spouse…
Also, I think some trans people weren’t socialized as children in their proper gender and so didn’t get that training that cis girls get from a young age about how to dress, put on makeup, etc so I think there’s always going to be a learning curve, right? Like when you’re just starting out on your trans journey. Especially if you’re like me and don’t really get out much so don’t really see how other women your age dress and basically all you have is TV/movies/YouTube/Twitch to get ideas.
That being said, I think people should be able to dress however they want regardless of whether they’re cis or trans. There’s too much focus in society in general on judging other people for their appearance and I think we would be better off if everyone was a little less worried about how other people look. Clothes or otherwise.
2
3
2
u/Samus69Aran Apr 06 '23
There’s enough division right now without dividing or shaming our own community. What would be better is to embrace and help those who “don’t know how to dress” (if that’s even the case). Otherwise let people be, or we will fall into the same behaviours of GCs, but from the opposite side; policing how people should and shouldn’t present and shaming those that don’t fit in with a narrow view.
1
Apr 06 '23
Girls don’t hate me, but when I came out to my older sister, she had some advice for me…“mutton should not dress like lamb”. I thought OK that’s pretty good advice, but then I started getting the Lands’ End catalog and all the clothing is for old women with elastic waist bands!! I’m not that person either. I like a BoHo style, I’m 59 I’m never gonna pass…ever! As an example,I can palm a bowling ball. Some of us just get handed crappy genetics, (oh they’re fine for running a plow behind a mule) but I still want to dress a little bit more hip than my old lady counterparts. I do my best and I’m not flashy. So, I think to sum it up, let your conscience be your guide. And, if they don’t make an LBD in your size, there is a reason. Don’t search the earth trying to find one, disappointment awaits.
2
Apr 06 '23
Same, I'm weirdly secular modest but I wasted one life in the dockers and blue-button-down world. Giving myself permission in the new one to be the gothy witchy person I always wanted to be.
1
Apr 06 '23
I think a big portion of it is living out what we missed as teens or young 20 year olds… I know I wear super short shorts and dresses because I missed getting to do that in college. Same reason myself and some other trans friends plan sleep overs and girls nights. I think a lot of “younger” behaviors I participate in is because I didn’t get to do that as my true self.
And I think about what someone earlier said. They might have a small network of trans friends or girls willing to help with dress and style tips. I know my daughter is learning that stuff right now and it can be tough. Idk just my thoughts, in short let it be and let people be themselves
1
-5
Apr 06 '23
Just here to say, I agree. I have a deep desire to dress like a teenager and dressed far to young / inappropriatly when I was cross dressing (before I knew I was trans).
Since discovering that I'm really trans and not a perv my desire to dress has been to be seen as a woman, for me thats dresses with short sleeves to hid my shoulders, and mid thigh length. Like a woman in their 40's might dress.
In short I don;t want to stand out, I don't want the world to see me as "a bit trashy", so as other people say - I'll do me but I roll my eyes everytime I see people doing things that are highly sexual in public, it heps the narative of trans women are perverts.
0
Apr 06 '23
[deleted]
2
u/Sudden-Smile-3869 Apr 07 '23
Thanks for your thoughtful and intelligent reply! Agree and agree, and agree! My whole point of the post was about our community, and the fact that society picks the worst examples for display - perfectly stated!
And yes, some of the extreme positions (another IMO is the person who says he identifies as female, and then without anything more insists on visiting the lady's room - let's at least make an effort at looking fem before slamming into the girls room!!!) are very problematic for normalizing trans issues. The pendulum never stops in the middle!!!
26
u/EffieJayne Apr 06 '23
Oh lawd, let people, cis or trans, dress how they want...it's none of your business really.