r/TransIreland • u/DaKrimsonBarun • 7h ago
Write to your Sinn Féin TD/MLA
Hi folks
The Sinn Féin trans policy has now been leaked. It is an absolute mess of a document. It is carefully disguised as pro-trans people while anyone reading between the lines can see, it totally is not.
It is however still at a stage where it can be - just about - fought. At the very least, I think, we should be throwing down the gauntlet and telling them we can see through the dignispect.
Here is the rough email I have sent to basically every one of their TD's I've interacted with. I would not advise copying it, but it does outline many of our concerns.
"While there is a veneer of care and concern glossing the whole document, closer examination finds it is riddled with problems.
Unilateral reversal of previous positions on recognition for minors. The party believes 16 year olds can vote. They cannot determine, without a fight in a court, who they are. One of these affects the average ordinary person a lot more, than a young person making a personal decision.
The recording of sex at birth data would be a massive breach of GDPR and EU law and totally undermine the GRA and may even be in conflict w the Good Friday Agreement. It is beyond me how this was allowed to come about. A policy document should not contain advocacy for the state breaching the law.
There are lines in conversion therapy section that imply a UK-style exception could be found by bad actors - and unclear if this is intentional.
Absolutely baffling gendered spaces policy, I genuinely cannot tell you what the party's position is - bar the insanely expensive championing of single-user stalls. This obsession with choice in the document is not something the trans community has ever sought. Who is this for?
It is like a sieve. This is also part of the core problem - if trans people are not their stated and lived gender, we should not be allowed in gendered spaces. It's women's toilets, not women and also trans women toilets.
You have gone from two genders, to five - women, men, trans women, trans men, and nonbinary people. Who on earth is this for?
5. Despite claims otherwise, putting trans children in third spaces is inherently othering. I am also concerned that the document is somewhat unclear on if teachers have to 'out' students to parents - this has led to serious problems in the UK.
6. On healthcare a policy of 'leave it to doctors' does not work when our doctors are who they are. They will always defer to the failed UK policy rather than international best precedent and it is clear Sinn Féin would not interfere in this. The government recently has in scrapping the first failed new model of care.
Additionally, no provision is made for improving surgery access, currently unavailable in Ireland. Informed consent as a principle is all well and good but would not survive an encounter with our doctors.
In addition the puberty blockers ines are vague and unconvincing to all sides. Is the party ever going to look at the Dutch for example? I doubt it. They will defer to England. The lack of any mention of WPATH or international standards is concerning.
7. On sports, leaving it to the relevant bodies is all well and good, for some people, but the science is absolutely clear - After two years or so, trans women have essentially zero advantage in a sports context. The party has bowed down to bad actors.
8. While not within my own experience, intersex people are very clear that their main issue is what they view as mutilation-at-birth surgical intervention. The document does not tackle this.
9. The position on hate-crime is weaker than our peers and it is unclear what 'having an opinion' entails. Will actors like Graham Linehan be given a free hand to deadname and harrass people? Is Enoch Burke's opinion valid? What does this mean?"