r/TransIreland • • 7h ago

Write to your Sinn Féin TD/MLA

62 Upvotes

Hi folks

The Sinn Féin trans policy has now been leaked. It is an absolute mess of a document. It is carefully disguised as pro-trans people while anyone reading between the lines can see, it totally is not.

It is however still at a stage where it can be - just about - fought. At the very least, I think, we should be throwing down the gauntlet and telling them we can see through the dignispect.

Here is the rough email I have sent to basically every one of their TD's I've interacted with. I would not advise copying it, but it does outline many of our concerns.

"While there is a veneer of care and concern glossing the whole document, closer examination finds it is riddled with problems.

  1. Unilateral reversal of previous positions on recognition for minors. The party believes 16 year olds can vote. They cannot determine, without a fight in a court, who they are. One of these affects the average ordinary person a lot more, than a young person making a personal decision.

  2. The recording of sex at birth data would be a massive breach of GDPR and EU law and totally undermine the GRA and may even be in conflict w the Good Friday Agreement. It is beyond me how this was allowed to come about. A policy document should not contain advocacy for the state breaching the law.

  3. There are lines in conversion therapy section that imply a UK-style exception could be found by bad actors - and unclear if this is intentional.

  4. Absolutely baffling gendered spaces policy, I genuinely cannot tell you what the party's position is - bar the insanely expensive championing of single-user stalls. This obsession with choice in the document is not something the trans community has ever sought. Who is this for?

It is like a sieve. This is also part of the core problem - if trans people are not their stated and lived gender, we should not be allowed in gendered spaces. It's women's toilets, not women and also trans women toilets.

You have gone from two genders, to five - women, men, trans women, trans men, and nonbinary people. Who on earth is this for?

5. Despite claims otherwise, putting trans children in third spaces is inherently othering. I am also concerned that the document is somewhat unclear on if teachers have to 'out' students to parents - this has led to serious problems in the UK.

6. On healthcare a policy of 'leave it to doctors' does not work when our doctors are who they are. They will always defer to the failed UK policy rather than international best precedent and it is clear Sinn Féin would not interfere in this. The government recently has in scrapping the first failed new model of care.

Additionally, no provision is made for improving surgery access, currently unavailable in Ireland. Informed consent as a principle is all well and good but would not survive an encounter with our doctors.

In addition the puberty blockers ines are vague and unconvincing to all sides. Is the party ever going to look at the Dutch for example? I doubt it. They will defer to England. The lack of any mention of WPATH or international standards is concerning.

7. On sports, leaving it to the relevant bodies is all well and good, for some people, but the science is absolutely clear - After two years or so, trans women have essentially zero advantage in a sports context. The party has bowed down to bad actors.

8. While not within my own experience, intersex people are very clear that their main issue is what they view as mutilation-at-birth surgical intervention. The document does not tackle this.

9. The position on hate-crime is weaker than our peers and it is unclear what 'having an opinion' entails. Will actors like Graham Linehan be given a free hand to deadname and harrass people? Is Enoch Burke's opinion valid? What does this mean?"


r/TransIreland • • 1d ago

ROI Specific What are people's experiences with Imago?

22 Upvotes

So I was looking into ways of getting HRT without dealing with the ridiculous wait list the Irish healthcare system has and I came across Imago which supports trans people all across the EU.

From what I can tell from their website, they supply prescriptions that you can use to buy HRT from your pharmacy and imagos doctors also work with your GP.

Is there anything else I should know about Imago before considering it and what are y'all's experiences with it like?


r/TransIreland • • 2d ago

Does anyone else use this thought process?

9 Upvotes

I'm pre hrt trans femme and I do not really get to present how id like day to day because of circumstances. So sometimes even though ive had thoughts of wanting to be the other gender for 10 years and was pretty sure I was trans for about 6 years, I get an overwhelming panic of "what if im just wrong about everything and ive ruined my life".

So what I do it kinda break things down like this.

Im videogames I started playing as women and more feminine roles and It made me happy and I cannot go back to playing male ones.

I started shaving my facial hair clean shaven daily and I cannot stand seeing facial hair growing.

Ive grown my hair out to longest its ever been and its the happiest ive ever been with my hair and I think id vomit if I had to cut it short

I shave my body hair and while it didnt bother my much beforehand now I really prefer being shaved and get uncomfortable when im not.

I went out cosplaying a woman both at a con and for holloween and besides some people being rude, the entire process from my friend putting on the makeup to just walking around made me happy and my favourite picture of myself is me in that cosplay.

I was discussing this with my therapist and she just thought it was an interesting way to break things down so I thought id share it.

For me every step has been a thing that I just knew I wanted but before I did it I never felt insanely dysphoria about how things were before. Im just really hoping that if/when I start hrt that this pattern continues but even if it doesnt I think id at least be happy that what ive already done has made me very happy.


r/TransIreland • • 3d ago

Hi I'm Emma

Post image
71 Upvotes

r/TransIreland • • 3d ago

Sinn Féin Gender identity policy as posted on Bluesky

Thumbnail gallery
51 Upvotes

Seen this on r/irishpolitics , curious to see how the community reacts.


r/TransIreland • • 3d ago

Do I need a GRC

8 Upvotes

I moved to Ireland a year and a half ago and had updated all my legal documents in the UK, including birth ceriticate with a GRC there.

I applied for citizenship when moving over as I have irish ancestry and thought it would be useful, I used my updated birth certificate showing me as female. This got approved this week (yay!) and so I am on the foreign birth register with the female birth certificate.

Should I get an Irish GRC or does that out me in some way, as in all my irish records I will be down as female anyway? I am concerned that because I dont have an irish grc then maybe I am missing some kind of legal protection or recognition as my British GRC is obviously not relevant to irish law.


r/TransIreland • • 3d ago

Trigger Warning: Transphobia Sinn Féin set to publish policy on gender identity

Thumbnail
rte.ie
56 Upvotes

r/TransIreland • • 2d ago

I want to join defence forces next year

0 Upvotes

Trans mtf😢 i can only start diying soon then i turn 18 and want to make soemthing of myself because life has been SHITE so far and i could have my grc before starting the process i dont even have a branch in mind ive met a trans person exact same age as me who wanted to join df for years alot more enthusiastic then me but lost contact so idk there isnt alot of resources for me and some people on /defence forces are pricks


r/TransIreland • • 4d ago

just payed the 250€ startup fee for imago

26 Upvotes

im lowkey scared now like ive been planning this for so long and now ive done it im so worried ive made a bad decision and i wont even get t after the call with the physician.

im worried they will reject me because im underweight and i have no period because my ed made me lose it (im ftm).

do you think that will be an issue getting prescribed?


r/TransIreland • • 4d ago

Pharmacy in Cork that accepts Anne Health Tokens?

9 Upvotes

My partner started HRT through Anne Health while living in the North but recently moved to Cork and is finding it much harder to get his prescription filled. Does anyone know of any pharmacies in Cork that accept the Clynxx EEARx tokens from Anne Health? Or does anyone with a similar experience have any advice?


r/TransIreland • • 4d ago

All Island FTM Binders

8 Upvotes

Hey!

I'm a plus size trans guy and I was wondering what's the best binder for plus size people with bigger chests?

I've been using GC2B for years but I'm nervous to buy from them again considering I haven't bought a new binder in years and the import charges make me nervous, as well as I heard they changed their design?

Any good binder brands in the EU? Or am I better off spending the money on shipping and imports for a US brand?

Thanks so much!


r/TransIreland • • 5d ago

GRC Name change

8 Upvotes

Hey guys, im filling out this GRC form. I was told before that you can just put your prefered name instead of your dead name without needing a deed poll or anything but on the form it says they require evidence of use and repute over two years or a deed poll. Is this true cos i was told is not needed anymore. If it is true what sort of evidence do they mean?


r/TransIreland • • 6d ago

How do I start diy hrt asp

17 Upvotes

I need to get on e soon and IDK where to start on hrt it's all so confusing would anyone know any tips or anything to doing it myself?


r/TransIreland • • 8d ago

Nobody told me!

43 Upvotes

I am a Transfemale in my second week of HRT and I think the most incredible part of what is happening to me is how calm I feel!

I didn't realise that testosterone influenced so much of the feelings in my body and brain, I have never felt this way before and it is utterly amazing.

Before starting I would get worked up and frustrated easily, lose my temper, become snappy, mispercieve what was being said to me as an act of aggression towards me, in short, an asshole.

I don't feel that anymore, I know this is more than just hormones, I'm also happier in general to be finally accepting myself and taking steps to be the person I always wanted to be, but I never imagined it would have had such an effect on my mentality, it feels so good.

Thanks for reading, I needed to write this down ❤️


r/TransIreland • • 8d ago

All Island Where are the Irish girlies going to get their BA's?

8 Upvotes

Hi hi,

Just wondering if people could share where they've gone to get their boobs done? I'm currently researching and trying to play out my surgeries.

Thanks frens 🖤


r/TransIreland • • 8d ago

ROI Specific Moving back to Ireland while starting HRT in Italy – looking for advice

7 Upvotes

Hi!
I’m a 23yo trans girl from Italy, and I’m planning to move back to Ireland in January for job. However, I’m about to start my HRT treatment in Italy this December.
My intention is to travel back and forth between Ireland and Italy for a while, so I can continue my transition without interrupting my treatment.
I would like to ask if anyone has experience with a similar situation. Are there any private clinics or healthcare providers in Ireland that specialise in transgender healthcare and could help me continue my HRT?
I’d really appreciate any advice, personal experiences or recommendations.
Thank you so much! ❤️


r/TransIreland • • 8d ago

ROI Specific insurance

8 Upvotes

Is there any insurance that doesnt require me to have 5 years history with them for coverage for srs/ffs/anything?

I've read that certain jobs can remove that condition but i cant really get any job that would offer that


r/TransIreland • • 9d ago

ROI Specific Family Support Services/Groups

7 Upvotes

Hi there!

Would anyone know of good family support services for helping alleviate fears of parents?

I'm a young adult that's still financially dependent on my parents and I am in this bad conundrum where what is stopping me from living authentically is the fact my parents fear for my future discrimination wise, etc. Doesn't help they come from a foreign background where their fears are somewhat harder to fight back against.

It would be amazing if anyone could point me to towards anything relevant to the Midlands. I would be overjoyed if anyone knew of a service that could really make my parents feel understood in their fears and move forward with them for my health and wellbeing. I wouldn't be interested in anything that really doesn't try to empathise with the person's fears.

Any advice would help!


r/TransIreland • • 9d ago

Question

0 Upvotes

Hoii would anyone have any breast forms/padding or clothes they would be willing to give away? Thanks 🙏


r/TransIreland • • 9d ago

TY ball outfit for (sort of) closeted transfemme?

9 Upvotes

im in transition year (mtf) and all my friends are starting to get their dresses for ty ball. I’m partially closeted, basically im out to all my friends/school and introduce myself as she/her and my new name to those i meet but am completely closeted to my family. I have long hair and wear makeup regularly but my family just thinks im a twink and i dress slightly feminine but not really. Im really struggling to find something to wear that wouldn’t make me deeply uncomfortable but also wouldnt raise too many questions since formal wear is so gendered. any styling suggestions? i like to dress alternative but am open to anything really


r/TransIreland • • 9d ago

How can someone avail of free hrt scheme ?

12 Upvotes

What do you need to be eligible if i change my gender marker legaly can i convince some gp or any provider to give me treatment just from my legal gdnder marker ? In my head yhat makes sense the logistics if diy are headwrecking to me like buying medicine fr other countries is a bollix


r/TransIreland • • 9d ago

GenderGP paper prescriptions post time?

4 Upvotes

Just wanted to ask how quick peoples paper prescriptions from gendergp usually take to arrive after signing, preferably in the north dublin area? I might be getting a little paranoid over nothing but a friend of mine usually gets hers within 5 days after signing (we live in the same town), ive been waiting about 8 now and im wondering if waiting that long or more is normal?

im sorry if this is such a silly question, this is my first time getting a prescription for hrt and im not entirely sure whats normal or what should be raising alarms


r/TransIreland • • 9d ago

ROI Specific Social Groups?

5 Upvotes

Are there good trans social groups in dublin i could go to make friends. Many of the ones I find online are either for teenagers or trans men. Ideally one in person over online.


r/TransIreland • • 10d ago

ROI Specific What do I put down for a Randox, male or female??

7 Upvotes

Randox asks you if you are male or female when making a patient account.
I put down female, and in the patient page it says "Sex at Birth: Female".
Do I change it to male? does it matter? Can I keep it as female? (doing a female hormone blood test)


r/TransIreland • • 11d ago

ROI Specific Activists stage mock trial and execution of public trans healthcare in Ireland

Thumbnail gcn.ie
44 Upvotes