This is a follow-up to my previous post, where I shared my initial observations after testing different 34 mm trackball spheres.
Original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/Trackballs/comments/1wq70qg/i_tested_5_different_34_mm_trackball_spheres/
Since then, my collection has grown. I have acquired two additional trackballs and two more Perixx spheres, so I thought it was time to expand the experiment.
This is still an ongoing comparison. In particular, the black and pink Perixx spheres are relatively new additions, and I haven't completed testing them across all devices yet.
The five trackballs
My current setup includes:
ProtoArc EM01 RGB
ProtoArc EM01 NL
Logitech MX Ergo (original model)
Logitech MX ERGO S Plus
ELECOM EX-G Left
There is an important detail regarding their usage history: the ELECOM EX-G Left and the MX ERGO S Plus are both recent acquisitions. The ProtoArc EM01 NL has been in use for a few months, but is still relatively new compared with my longer experience using the EM01 RGB and the original MX Ergo.
Therefore, not all devices have the same usage history, and I am taking this into account when comparing their behaviour.
The eight spheres
I now have eight 34 mm spheres to compare:
Original spheres:
ProtoArc graphite (original EM01 RGB)
ProtoArc red (original EM01 NL)
Logitech grey (original MX Ergo)
Perixx replacement spheres:
My testing environment
One of the most important aspects of my experiment is actual cursor movement rather than simply judging how smoothly a sphere spins under my thumb.
My horizontal desktop span is approximately 6440 pixels, across multiple monitors.
I use Momentum Pointer, which makes a considerable difference to the way I operate my trackballs. With it enabled, a vigorous thumb movement can effectively launch the pointer across a large portion of my desktop, sometimes covering the entire horizontal workspace.
This makes cursor travel, fluidity and the ability to make small corrections particularly important in my comparisons.
I also pay attention to:
Initial surface texture.
How the sphere feels after extended use.
Friction and resistance during movement.
Tracking consistency.
Actual cursor displacement.
Differences between trackball mechanisms and sensors.
Some observations so far
My previous tests suggested that the same sphere can behave quite differently depending on the trackball in which it is installed.
The Perixx green has been particularly impressive in several devices, while the blue has also delivered excellent results, especially in the ELECOM EX-G Left.
The gold sphere has a slightly different character, with more grip and a surface feel closer to the original ProtoArc graphite sphere.
The new black sphere is showing promising results in the MX ERGO S Plus. Its initial texture felt somewhat gritty, but it has already started to become smoother with use.
The pink sphere, currently installed in the ELECOM EX-G Left, is showing a similar evolution.
An interesting detail: all the Perixx spheres seem to have a slightly gritty texture when taken out of the box. This sensation appears to diminish with use. I intend to monitor this over a longer period before drawing any conclusions.
The newer trackballs
The MX ERGO S Plus has been an interesting addition.
My first impression, using the Perixx green sphere and Momentum Pointer, was that its cursor movement felt approximately 70% better than that of my original MX Ergo.
This is a subjective estimate based on my experience, not a laboratory measurement. I still need to test the other spheres and spend more time with the device.
The ELECOM EX-G Left has also been interesting. Its behaviour with the Perixx blue and pink spheres has been particularly promising.
I am also continuing to investigate the similarities I noticed between the ELECOM and ProtoArc devices, although I don't have enough technical evidence to establish any relationship between their internal components.
What remains to be tested
I still need to:
Test the black and pink spheres in both ProtoArc EM01 models.
Test them in the original Logitech MX Ergo.
Complete the comparison of all spheres in the MX ERGO S Plus.
Compare Bluetooth and 2.4 GHz behaviour where applicable.
Investigate the possibility of independently operating two trackballs using MouseMux or another solution.
Final thoughts (for now)
I don't have a definitive winner yet, and I don't want to rush into a ranking.
One of the most interesting things I've discovered is that a sphere doesn't necessarily have a fixed performance independent of the trackball. The mechanism, contact points, sensor, firmware and pointer processing all seem to influence the final experience.
I also want to give the new black and pink spheres enough time to settle into their respective devices before making any definitive comparisons.
I'll share another update once I have completed more of the testing.
If anyone has experience with these Perixx spheres, particularly the black and pink versions, across different trackballs, I'd be interested to hear about it.