This may be an unpopular opinion due to the hype surrounding the event. But if there is ever to be a Deep Dip 3 I think it would be worth discussing some of the problems with this map. While it still may be a bit early to be talking about a 3rd map, I thought I would be the first to kick off the discussion. This post is from a viewer’s perspective, not a player’s. I will be drawing comparisons to Deep Dip 1 throughout the post to make some of my points.
The major areas of concern that I can observe are:
If you feel like I am off base in any of my assessments, a critique of my points would be welcome.
To start if we look at the overall viewership experience it was great for the first couple of days with constant progress, new strategies being discovered, streamer enthusiasm, etc. But as the event progressed it became increasingly less engaging with many hours spent watching the first few floors. Deep Dip 1 in contrast was engaging throughout the whole event, with new developments, discoveries, and progress happening every day. No doubt the finale of Deep Dip 2 will be a large event and a great viewing experience. However, the same would be true had the event lasted only a week or two. Slugging through many hours of content for a small development is a horrible viewing experience.
The reason for the viewership experience being negatively impacted is intrinsically linked to the map's design. The spiral design means that a single mistake/fall usually means a reset to floor 0 or otherwise a substantial loss of progress. While the map designers have placed intended recovery points to somewhat alleviate that, there are way too many areas where this is not the case. There is almost no suspense when a fall occurs as most just take you to the bottom, or a curated recovery point. Deep Dip 1 had sections of the map that meant losing all progress as well, but they were often highlights of the map, where particular tricks/jumps were especially dangerous when failed. The most iconic of which was the snake circling the entire map or the short jump at the start of floor 7. And the higher you climbed the risk of falling to the very bottom decreased significantly. Deep Dip 2 feels like almost every fall/mistake is the snake from the first map. This is on top of having the “snake”, which this time goes through the middle of the entire map and includes tricks from many different points on the map as opposed to just one.
To add insult to injury the abundance of plastic makes many tricks inconsistent even when no mistake is made. Contrary to the first map where most tricks were due to the player's own mistake. This is a frustration that was voiced by multiple streamers. Paired with the map's design, having 10, 20 or 30+ minute runs end due to bad RNG is no doubt horrible to play but also to watch. Seeing a streamer frustrated for hours on end is inevitable in a challenge such as this one, but at the very least it should be because of their own mistakes. Besides plastic there is an abundance of areas that have been constructed in such a way, where a dead turtle is very likely leading many runs to end. Arguably the worst aspect of the map, at least as far as viewership is concerned.
As a small side note, particular effort has been taken to prevent any cuts on the map. This can be either good or bad depending on how you look at it. Personally, I thought the cuts found on Deep Dip 1 added a lot of charm to the map, and the act of discovering them was a major boon not just for the drivers but also for the viewers.
Finally, streamer mental, which ties into every other point I have outlined, and the main reason behind this post. I'd argue the map is just too cruel and demanding. With streamers having 170+ hours clocked in at the time of writing and almost an entire month's worth of time dedicated to completing this one map. To my knowledge, no other game in this genre (getting over it/only up) comes close to the level of dedication one needs to complete it. Hosting it as an event puts tremendous pressure on the streamers to perform well and entertain their audience. I thought this was meant to be a fun albeit difficult challenge. Now it feels like I am watching streamers torture themselves for hours on end.
I mean no disrespect to the mapping team when I say this. From my perspective they have overdelivered, and most likely unintentionally. Multiple streamers similarly stating they didn’t imagine it would take this long to complete. The event as a whole has a fantastic premise, and attracted the largest audience to Trackmania to date. Could it have attracted a similar crowd had the map been considerably more forgiving? I would argue yes, and the success of Deep Dip 1 proves this, and I’d argue is the main reason behind the success of the 2nd map. I'd like to stress, by no means do I wish to diminish the large amount of work that went into making this as good of an experience as possible. This is a massive project that took over a year to create, it can not be overstated, how much work has gone into this. Without those people there never would have been Deep Dip 2.
To summarise I am not saying the map should be approachable by new players, far from it. But, if Deep Dip 3 is to ever be made I do not think it should be anywhere near as hard as 2. Not even halfway between 1 and 2. Being similar or slightly harder to the first map with new tricks would be a fantastic viewing experience. However, this is just my sentiment as a viewer. The input of the participants, I'd argue would be a lot more valuable.
With that said, best of luck to the competitors. Your dedication is admirable and thank you.