r/Torchbearer • u/nlitherl • Jul 17 '22
r/Torchbearer • u/The-Allmighty-Tim • May 09 '20
Dose anyone have any hombrew rules for running shadow (the one ring rpg) in torchbearer
r/Torchbearer • u/tolavsrud • Mar 05 '20
D&D, Torchbearer and Colonialism
torchbearerrpg.comr/Torchbearer • u/23Kosmit • Sep 20 '24
Problem with conflict captain
Hello, I am reading the books for torchbearer and found out there is the same mechanic as in mouse guard which is the conflict captain. I hated that mechanic in mouse guard. It boiled down to only the captain choosing the actions and playing the game where others just threw dice. Can you sell it to me? Is it somehow better or more crucial in torchbearer? Or could it be removed no problem and players would just pick their own actions? I know I should first try before modifying but I found it really not fun in mouse guard. Thank you for understanding and answers.
r/Torchbearer • u/kenmcnay • Aug 08 '20
Four Dwarven Characters for Torchbearer
Hello all,
I’m courageously self-promoting again with my own content on Prevail. There is a collection of posts showcasing four dwarven characters imagined at levels 1, 4, and 9. All links below lead to the posts on Prevail. Each level build includes a downloadable character sheet.
These are built using only the existing 1st edition Torchbearer rules.
I wrote a preface to introduce the characters, posted concise descriptions of the builds, and some character biography. I also wrote a conclusion for this collection.
There is no pay-wall for any of this content. This is available for followers and supporters freely. I just want to share my creative work from this endeavor with the community.
Preface (link)
These four dwarven characters are not currently in-play. I do not often play dwarves, and the most frequent cameos are as NPCs with some sort of business to offer PCs. So, I’m inventing the stories completely for Torchbearer. This is somewhat spontaneous as far as projects go; there was not a stretch goal or a character fiction poll result that dictated I should be releasing these. But, following the four elven characters in May, I really felt eager to create the dwarves. In fact, I’ve already begun work on a group of halflings! This is a fun project to undertake.
As before, I’ve had a little money to spend on artists to commission portraits of the characters.
Orlind Jeulmeinger - the stonemason
Orlind comes from a known and reputable clan, with eager travels ahead in his life. He sets out to learn about stonemasonry from other cultures and in other places. It includes delving for lost or secret architecture and methods. And, Torchbearer I feel proved a good space for his story. I felt this is a story that would fit within the lore and would extend coverage of the cultural notes for his purpose of journeying and delving. I used opportunities to lean Orlind toward discipleship to divine beings. I feel he is a balanced and capable Dwarf Adventurer.
Arvind Jeulmeinger - the swordsmith
Arvind comes from a known and reputable clan, with eager plans ahead in his life. He sets out to learn about swordsmithing from other cultures and in other places. It includes delving for lost or secret techniques or materials. And, Torchbearer I feel proved a good space for his story. I felt this is a story that would fit within the lore and would extend coverage of the cultural notes for his purpose of journeying and delving. I used opportunities to lean Arvind toward villainous gains. I feel he is a balanced and capable Dwarf Adventurer.
Kip Seamus Kramand - the cook
Kip Seamus comes from a heritage of hospitality, which fits my sentiment about using dwarves as merchants of some sort. He takes his journey to learn from other cultures and gain more renown as a masterful cook. I think this fits Torchbearer, but I felt it would skirt the line of practicality depending on the campaign and play group. If the style lends itself to light-hearted role-play, I think Kip Seamus would work well. I do feel he is balanced, but not aligned closely with the traditional Dwarf Adventurer.
Fin Reagan Durmand - the pilgrim
Fin Reagan is a pilgrim of a certain sort. He is trying to escape his family’s clutches, but also make a place for himself in a new land. As such, I feel he is the best aligned with Torchbearer game play. He need not drive the action and drama of a play group, but instead can serve many support roles. I chose to lean Fin Reagan toward assisting or replacing a Ranger, but any other choices could be made to give a different lean to the build. I feel he is the most balanced, and most easily adjusted for the needs or wants of the campaign or play group. He is a capable Dwarf Adventurer.
Conclusion (link)
I hope everyone enjoys the collection and finds something to discuss from my renderings of these four dwarven characters. I think there are gems of insight for any player or game master.
This is the second project of this type, and I am already planning a third to place halflings on the stage.
I’ll return to review these projects again following the release of Torchbearer 2nd edition.
r/Torchbearer • u/Ariolan • Apr 18 '22
More mainstream variant ?
OK this might be the wrong shop to ask but looking at TB2 I was wondering whether anybody has experience removing certain bits that look very fiddly
losing character classes altogether and just making everybody an adventurer with different skills (gaining perks aa they level)
losing conflicts and getting something more straightforward instead. Let me elaborate a bit - I always wondered why combat needs to be this excruciating detailed blow-by-blow simulation, but breaking a lock is a one roll. So, has anybody any ideas of making conflict a one-roll (and in the case of combat keeping the goal idea). I tried asking this on the kickstarter but got told off a bit by the devs - surely there must be other people with limited endurance for the extreme intricacies….. Thanks for the input.
r/Torchbearer • u/SpydersWebbing • Mar 14 '20
Hallucinations: Session Three
Ensivalen meditating cubes belong in a museum.
r/Torchbearer • u/[deleted] • Feb 12 '21
Spell misfire table, DCC style?
I like Torchbearer more than DCC in almost every aspect, but I really like DCC's magic misfires. Obviously twists accomplish the same thing, but I like having the wizard roll for the results of a spell gone wrong. Has anyone created a table of twists for spellcasting?
r/Torchbearer • u/kenmcnay • Nov 14 '20
Three Halfling Characters for Torchbearer
Hello all,
This is another post of self-promotion with content on Prevail. There is a collection of posts showcasing three halfling characters imagined at levels 1, 4, and 9. All links below lead to the posts on Prevail. Each level build includes a downloadable character sheet.
These are built using only existing 1st edition Torchbearer rules.
The preface post introduces the characters in profile. The individual posts show precise builds and describe the process with a bit of additional character biography. The conclusion post wraps up my thoughts on the project and offers final comments.
Nothing from this project is behind a pay-wall. This is available to followers and supporters. I just want to freely contribute to the community with my creative content.
This is the end of single stock-class character builds. I will have a period of rest from this sort of project, but anything in the future will gather a diverse team of stocks and classes as an adventuring party. I am likely to set aside the project until 2nd edition Torchbearer rules are fully completed and published.
I joined the kickstarter, so I have been tracking the preview content; I’m aware of many revisions and alterations that may impact the three character build projects I’ve released. I will return to write addendums regarding how the 2nd edition rules would require changes or would invalidate the character builds.
Preface (link)
These three halflings are not in-play nor from a previous game, so the stories are entirely fabricated for this project. As such, I chose to draw upon inspiration from the Middarmark Gazetteer for added depth and anchoring the character growth in existing lore. I also used the Nature descriptors as leads to describe the conceptual profile behind each build.
I think it is fair to admit I have never played a halfling nor run an NPC halfling. I simply don’t find the need to portray these diminutive fantasy people as a separate race from humans, so I’ve always merely merged them with humans rather than giving them a distinct cultural or geographical niche. I feel it might be ethically responsible to mention that in case there are readers in the audience with particularly strong feelings about halflings (or the other rendered names for these fantasy people, such as kender or hobbit). If you, reader, feel I’ve got it all wrong or am missing the unique pleasure of halflings as a distinct people, please share your comments! I would love to hear more opinions and compare thoughts on the topic.
Ing Roan Gamwich of Holmon - the bloodletter
Ingr joins a roving band of huldufolk in the Doalrode caravan. He originates from Veihus from a temporarily settled family. After several adventures, he is ready to gain a companion and progress to some future outside the vagrant living of the Doalrode group.
I used the halfling descriptor, sneaking, as the conceptual foundation for his character profile. He is built as the most directly aggressive and martial rogue of the three characters. His fylgja is Raven.
Lorelei Fairbairn of Talbot - the merrymaker
Lori leaves a hostess role at a Tarn Tanleth estate to begin an adventuring life. She knows a bit of the history and legend of the fallen tower of Tanleth the magician, so that is an initial lead for her early adventures. After several adventures, she is ready for a companion to join her as she grows into a role as a power-broker and mediator for the upcoming generation of Tarn Tanleth Gotts.
I used the halfling descriptor, merrymaking, as the conceptual foundation for her character profile. She is built as the diplomatic, social, and arcane-trickster of the three characters. Her fylgja is Horse.
Romilda Jellesal of Orgullas - the soothsayer
Romi leaves a steward role at a Rimholm estate to begin an adventuring life. She knows a bit of the history and legend of the Sakki Downs, so that is an initial lead for her early adventures. After several adventures, she is ready for a companion to join her as she grows into a role as a cult figure and shrine maiden to Sigrun Shieldbreaker among the Bjornings.
I used the halfling descriptor, riddling, as the conceptual foundation for her character profile. She is built as the dark horse harbinger of doom and theologian of the three characters. Her fylgja is Gull.
Conclusion (link)
I hope everyone can enjoy the project and finds something to discuss from my rendering of these three halfling characters. I think these bring good insights for play, and have appealing stories to consider in play.
This is the third project of this type. I will have a restful break from this sort of project for the foreseeable future. When I return to this sort of project, I will write multi-stock-class teams.
I’ll return to review these three single-stock-class projects again following the release of Torchbearer 2nd edition to write addendums describing how the new rules impact the build and the process.
r/Torchbearer • u/No-Tart5584 • Apr 01 '26
Simplifying Torchbearer
I am very excited to start playing Torchbearer as a GM with my group. The games looks magnificient but I am afraid that my players might get overwehlmed by the complexity of the system.
I would like therefore to ask you the question: if you were to simplify Torchbearer, which game mechanic would you keep and which would you discard for now.
For example, I am thinking about simplifying the use of persona vs fate points which crop up all over the place.
Any help would be welcomed.
r/Torchbearer • u/kenmcnay • May 09 '20
Four Elven Characters (at different levels)
Hello all,
I do get uncomfortable self-promoting, but I exercise courage publishing my own content and sharing it.
I made a series of posts showcasing four elven characters and imagined builds at levels 1, 4, and 9. All links are below to look at the posts. The level builds have an attached character sheet.
I began with a preface to introduce the series and characters, posted concise descriptions of the build process and some character bio, and made a conclusion for the series.
There is no pay-wall for any of this content. This is available for followers and supporters freely. I just want to share my creative work from this endeavor with the community.
Preface (link)
These four elven characters are from different games in which I am or have been a player, so I am converting three into Torchbearer. This endeavor was a spontaneous project while I had extra time during the lockdown and a little bit of spare cash to spend on artists to commission portraits of the characters.
Aelar Elleid - the fire sorceress
Aelar comes from nobility with some resentment and a desire to master fire magic. In other systems, this might go over quite easily, but Torchbearer proved it was difficult to develop an elementalist. I used opportunities to expand her repertoire for additional magical capacity and adjusted my sense of the flavor text describing the spell casting and outcome. She is not a balanced presentation of Elf Ranger.
Indus Monette - the illusionist
Indus comes from a remote village with an innocent wanderlust and a gift for illusion and charm magic. In Torchbearer, this was easy to support at multiple levels while engaging in wilderness chores as a balance against the magical interest. I used level benefits with Indus to develop the balanced duality of Elf Ranger.
Nimbal Grosponte - the mage-knight
Nimbal comes from a warrior heritage with disciplined training and a desire for renown. In Torchbearer, it proved easy to give him talent for combat magic, martial prowess, and additional facets of adventuring support. He is a balanced magister and warrior which fits the duality of Elf Ranger.
Gabrielle Michelle - the warrior-sorceress
This elven character comes from a remote homestead within Elflands and intends to live adventurously until finding a suitable future role in society whether among men and halflings or among elves. As an original Torchbearer character, I have been bumping against constraints of character creation and Stock and Class design. But, she does have a blend of magical capacity, warrior spirit and wilderness guide. My intent is to create a support character for the adventuring party, and I feel she stands up well under that mantle.
Conclusion (link)
I hope everyone enjoys the series and finds something to discuss from my renderings of these four elven characters. I think there is a gem of insight for any player or game master. I enjoyed the project and will attempt again in the future before Torchbearer 2nd edition is released.
r/Torchbearer • u/vFlFg • Nov 14 '17
Check Tracking
Is there a maximum number of checks a player can have at once? (Eg 8 per trait as the character sheet design might imply) I was thinking about using objects to track checks instead of the sheet, but wasn't sure if it's important to know how you earned them.
r/Torchbearer • u/Mudbucketguy • Sep 16 '16
I've been recommended this game, convince me!
I got recommended this by a acquaintance but didn't have the time to get the reason why it's good.
I said:
"I'm tired of D&D. But I'm about to run a Dark Fantasy game where death is always close and everyone you meet could possibly save your life or end it. Any recommendations?"
And with that explanation I got recommended Torch Bearer (and Lamentations of the Flame Princess).
Torch Bearer looks fun but I wanna know what divides it from the rest.
TL;DR: Convince me why I should get and play Torchbearer! :)
r/Torchbearer • u/goblinerd • Oct 24 '22
TB2 Armor Questions
1- iirc, I read somewhere that armor functions as follows, but I can't find where:
Leather Armor can absorb 1 point of damage per Conflict.
Chain Armor can absorb 1 point of damage per round
Plate Armor can absorb 1 point of damage per attack.
Is any of that correct, and where is it written in the books?
2- Berserker's Shield States "may absorb one point of damage per hit, but it is only destroyed on a 1d6 roll of one. It absorbs one point per conflict."
This confuses me, is one per hit or per conflict?
r/Torchbearer • u/Outward_Dust • Aug 23 '23
What are your favourite Stock and Classes?
Pretty much the title, what do you guys enjoy playing as, what fantasy do you gravitate too and what are some cool features from each class that just grabs your attention?
r/Torchbearer • u/Hipsterwhale • Jan 20 '20
How do I get a hard copy? How to start?
I've been trying to track down a physical copy and I'm not sure what books or documents id need.
I've heard a reprint is coming but I'm not sure if that already happened and it's sold out again.
What do you recommend I do to try and add this to my collection
r/Torchbearer • u/tolavsrud • Apr 16 '20
Sagas of Rimholm by Chalk Horse » You're a Gestir
r/Torchbearer • u/SpydersWebbing • Mar 06 '20
Hallucinations: Session Two
Maps! Injuries! And secret tunnels!
r/Torchbearer • u/AnRPGer • Feb 12 '19
Really wanting to like Torchbearer
Let me preface this by emphasizing how much I want to love this game.
TB is bold in its design, and veers far away from traditional RPGs (of which I would lump D&D, DCCRPG, Pathfinder, etc altogether - I know they have differences, but compared to TB, I would say they're more similar to each other).
I also love its resource management angle, inventory, etc - all those details that make dungeon crawling feel more immersive.
But at the end of the day, how should one approach TB? Because when I approach it, either as a role playing game, or as a board game, I get into trouble.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Problem with approaching TB as a role playing game
On one hand, some of the game mechanics feel seriously dissociated from role playing 'logic' or 'realism'. Ie, some of the mechanics feel very 'game-y'. Some examples (and maybe I've gotten some of these rules wrong):
You can substitute nature for an untrained skill, but not for a trained skill... why? (One of my clerics I rolled up was very frustrated that she was trained in fighter with rank 2... while her nature was 5. I really don't like wishing that I WEREN'T trained in something).
You can only help skills with skills, abilities with abilities. But if you help a beginner,... suddenly you can help with nearly anything. Why? (again, a wizard with arcanist 4 can be WORSE than a wizard with no training in arcanist at all... if he's in a party with 4 other PCs who all don't have arcanist.)
Actually, nature is a hard stat to wrap my head around in general. It is sort of like a 'one size fits all', in that it can substitute for anything... but only for things you test with beginnger's luck. Does Tymora, goddess of luck, have a special relationship with... whatever the Nature god would look like in this game? It must be a fickle relationship, because when you spend a persona point (whatever that means) to tap your nature, you are actually more restricted when it comes to untrained skills (they have to be within your descriptors) as opposed to trained skills (they don't have to be within your descriptors).
I also simply, for the life of me, cannot explain nature to my players. I can explain how it represents how 'dwarf like' and how 'elf like' you are, but I cannot explain how in the Nine Hells that behaving more like your race will make you better at fighting, wizardry, weaving, alchemy, and being a peasant (as well as every other skill you're not trained in).
Counting traits against yourself... to earn checks? So that you can rest? I get that this is to promote roleplaying your character's flaws... but how do I make any sense of it? How does suffering from a personality flaw make it easier to sleep at night? I have plenty of personality flaws in real life, but thinking about them at night usually makes it harder for me to sleep, not easier...
And of course, the conflict rules...one of the very first house rules I implemented in my games was to remove social conflicts so that my NPCs and monsters could actually have natural conversations with my players.
I will admit that all this (sort of works) if you take the approach of, "roll a bunch of dice together/apply mechanics/spend your points/etc, THEN figure out what the heck happened". Is this how the game is supposed to be played? I hope not, because then I don't think I could ever like it. Though then at this point, I offer no judgement, and simply acknowledge that this game isn't for me (even though I badly want it to be).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Problem with approaching TB as a board game
So I tried to completely shift how I even view the game. It isn't a "D&D clone"(nor would I want it to be). Maybe its meant to play a bit like a board game.
I've run the game twice before. The first time was a quick TPK. The second time, the party was still alive but... dear God, the conditions....and they've no checks....
Then I started to compare the game to something like Pandemic...if only in the sense that: Wow, this game is dread inspiring and brutal. And conquering it would mean something.
Except, there is way too much GM fiat.
The TPK happened from the party trying to climb down a 20 foot cliff while injured. They were on the other side of a collapsed tunnel, so they couldn't turn back. They had so many conditions, they literally could not pass their dungeoneering checks. And they had no checks, and so couldn't rest. I ruled that they were basically screwed, since failing their dungeoneering check would inflict the injured condition again... killing them.
Then I realized that they didn't have to get the injured condition again for failing their dungeoneering check. As the GM, I could have given them something else.......so minor as the damned hungry condition. That would have made quite a bit of difference. And its all up to me. Ie, the difficulty of the dungeon is all up to me. Without hard rules, how can the accomplishments be meaningful?
(NOTE, I did realize, after the fact, that they could have 'toughened it out' to remove the injured condition... but can they do this during the adventure phase?)
Regardless, my point that the difficulty is 100 % up to the GM still stands.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
As it does for any tabletop RPG... and so, I go back to viewing the game as a role playing game... but with absolutely no clue what any of these terms/mechanics actually means (in terms of realism, not in terms of their application), and so, the vicious cycle continues.
And yet people have been running/playing this game for years, and so either it simply isn't for me, or, I'm doing it all wrong. I'm going to check out some let's play videos of Torch Bearer (which I haven't done yet; recommendations, anyone?)
Also, I've only run two games....I'm going to keep trying. I recognize I'm super new to it, and simply adjusting my brain out of traditional 'D20' games might take some time.
EDIT: Wow, you guys have been really specific, really helpful, and really nice. Thanks a bunch, you guys rock.
After reading all of your posts, I think it may be possible that I'm throwing out conflicts too frequently.
I think another part of the problem, is that my players are not the 'think-outside-the-box' types, and I don't mean this as an insult. They have a lot of experience playing board games, and so have an (understandably) somewhat rigid mindset in regards to the game. So, on top of me trying to learn a very different kind of rpg, I have players trying to learn how to play rpgs in general.
The adventure, for the record, is the one at the back of the book. Its brutal! (at least, for our group). 15 kobolds in one room? !
The TPK came from the party tripping the alarm wire, resulting in having to fight 12 kobolds. The party promptly chose to flee... which they barely succeeded at doing (1 disposition point left), and so had conditions... then they tried to set up camp with their one check among them... rolled snake eyes (disaster!), then rolled snake eyes again (cave in!), which injured them (on top of their other conditions), and sealed off going back. In front, they had the crystallized waterfall to try to climb down... at least they got to see one of Nature's wonders before they died.
No one was upset and we had a good laugh about it. They rolled up new characters, and things went better the second time around.... until they found the room with 15 kobolds!.
In fairness they did drive the 15 kobolds off (barely), but I also gave them a generous bonus to their disposition, since the flavor text of the adventure did describe that half the kobolds were asleep/arguing with each other, etc. There doesn't seem to be much in the ways of a surprise mechanic in TB, and so I give out disposition bonuses to the side that has surprise (I guess this is a house rule? Is it a bad one?)
The players probably should have tried to exploit the fact that the kobolds were bickering with themselves.
EDIT 2: Also, morditepress seems a gosh darn treasure trove. Will definitely read through those articles (and the nature one especially) when I have time. Thanks!
r/Torchbearer • u/[deleted] • Feb 16 '21
Looking for a play by post game
Hi all, just like the title says I am looking for a play by post game!
