r/TopCharacterTropes
•
u/Lord_Antheron
•
7d ago
Hated Tropes [Most Hated Trope] Ron the Death Eater Spoiler
Edit 1: If you can't read a long post, then just don't read it. I'm not going to shorten it just because it's not suitable for a third grade level.
Ron the Death Eater is essentially the ultimate culmination of "once done, never forgiven." A character can have a virtually immaculate track record. Heroic, brave, well-meaning... basically just a good guy overall...
... But if they slip up even a single time, all bets are off. The fandom will rip, crush, tear limb from limb, and just utterly mangle this character into a caricature of irredeemable evil such that the bad, even if the good outweighs it by every quantifiable metric, becomes the only thing people remember.
If common fandom sentiment of "you can't handle morally grey characters" was put into a dictionary, these characters would appear on the adjacent page, taking up the entire thing in a glossy, high resolution picture.
In the most extreme and loathsome of cases, people will even twist the narrative logic like a balloon poodle such that they convince themselves that if the good guys are actually evil, then the villain was the "real hero" all along. It doesn't matter how obviously evil this villain is, people will find that their minds are just too small to wrap them around the idea that there are varying shades of grey. Instead, there must be a good, and there must be a bad. So if good is actually bad, bad becomes good by default. TV Tropes calls this "Draco in Leather Pants" and they often go hand-in-hand.
I absolutely abhor this trope with all my being, and could not possibly have a lower opinion of those who enable it.
ALL OF THESE EXAMPLES ARE VERY LONG, BUT I ASK THAT YOU READ THEM IN THEIR ENTIRETY BEFORE YOU SQUARE UP TO BE A VILLAIN APOLOGIST.
Example 1: Eltariel (Middle-Earth Shadow of War)
Eltariel is the Blade of Galadriel, an Elvish assassin dispatched to Mordor by the Lady of Lórien herself with an impossible task: kill the Nazgûl.
For the vast majority of the game, she is a staunch ally of the protagonist, Talion. Her introduction is saving him from being assimilated by the Nazgûl, and she subsequently assists him in many battles against the Ringwraiths for the rest of the main campaign.
There are several parallels drawn between the two of them. Both of them are trapped in a miserable land, unable to leave until their task is completed. Both of them are essentially being unfairly used by their benefactors, Eltariel by Galadriel, and Talion by Celebrimbor. Both of them are burdened with an impossible task, slaying the Nazgûl and slaying Sauron respectively. Both of them were once a single unit in a collective of many, but all of their friends and allies met horrible deaths in Mordor.
Yet while Talion remains optimistic that Sauron can be destroyed, Eltariel has lost all hope of ever being free, hardening her heart with the philosophy of "in the war against evil, stalemate is victory."
Near the end of the game, it's revealed that Celebrimbor was manipulating Talion all along. He knew from the beginning that Sauron could not be destroyed, and never intended to either. His ultimate goal is to use the New Ring to enslave Sauron and all his armies, and conquer Middle-Earth himself to rule over it as the Bright Lord. His first act is to enslave one of the Nazgûl.
Talion has already been crossing lines by enslaving Orcs, but he refuses to enslave Men. For him, this changes everything... but it also does for Eltariel. For the first time in what is likely decades, Celebrimbor has given her hope. The Nazgûl really can be destroyed. Sauron can be stopped. She can finally go home. She can finally be free of her impossible burden. And Celebrimbor, now requiring a more obedient vessel... takes hold of her desperation, and strangles it with almighty ease.
Eltariel abandons her prior reservations, and takes the New Ring from Celebrimbor's hand. Talion is left to die, and the two of them go to confront Sauron themselves. From this point forward, the fact that Celebrimbor has brainwashed Eltariel could not possibly be more clear. In contrast to his appearance within Talion essentially being half-and-half due to their relationship as grudging equals, Celebrimbor's form envelops Eltariel entirely. They aren't partners, she's merely his puppet. Eltariel spends the fight ranting and raving about how she's never felt such amazing power before, clearly speaking out of character. And when they lose, and her connection to Celebrimbor is lost, the story picks up with her being the playable character of her own DLC, and she is very clearly both horrified by her foolishness and regretful that Talion is now being corrupted.
By the end of her story, she abandons her dream of returning home and instead chooses to stay in Mordor, wishing to honour Talion's memory by continuing the fight until the One Ring is destroyed.
... The fandom ignores all of this, and boils her whole character down to a hypocritical, snobby bitch who betrayed the golden boy and selfishly horded the New Ring for herself when it could've saved him from turning. Even though... no, it fucking couldn't have, but that's not a conversation they're ready to have. Eltariel had a single moment of weakness at her absolute lowest point, reaching the very first glimmer of light in the darkness in years, clearly regretting it afterwards... but it doesn't matter. She's a villain, and deserved to suffer.
I don't even want to know what these people would think of Boromir.
Example 2: Cassandra (Tangled: The Animated Series)
If you want an idea of how deranged some of the fandom is about this character, the owner of the Tangled subreddit considers her such a threat to the canon pairing of Eugene and Rapunzel that she made it a punishable offence to say anything mean about them, or imply that Cassandra was ever right to criticise them.
Anyway.
Cassandra is Rapunzel's Lady in Waiting who yearns to be recognised for her achievements and make a name for herself. This is rather difficult to do since Corona (the setting) is implicitly patriarchal in nature, and she wants to be a Royal Guard capable of heroic deeds.
People often mischaracterise Cassandra as being angry that Rapunzel gets all the attention she wants. But there's a difference between resenting someone for receiving attention, and resenting someone for showing you up. Arguably Rapunzel's biggest character flaw, apart from her naivety, is that she's too perfect, and an unintentional deconstruction of the Mary Sue archetype. She is a superior artist, fighter, athlete, diplomat, etc. etc. etc. and she never knows how to turn it off or take a step back. She's not egotistical, but she's certainly not humble. Cassandra has to try very hard to be taken seriously in any capacity, and she always comes up short because Rapunzel can't help but involve herself in everything.
The Challenge of the Brave is by far the most prominent incident of this in season 1. Cassandra essentially sums up the situation very well: for Rapunzel, this is just a way to goof off for an afternoon. For Cassandra, it's yet another lost opportunity to receive any recognition for her efforts. Recognition that Rapunzel really doesn't need to make any effort to receive every day.
People appreciate Cassandra's small triumphs momentarily and they allow her to have moments when it's convenient, but nothing about her station in life ever really improves. She never earns a proper spot on the Guard. She's always under threat of great punishment for acting out, like being sent away to a convent, even though she's repeatedly proven her good intentions and worth. She's continuously undermined by people like Adira, who Rapunzel trusts almost immediately, which diminishes the perceived value of her connection with Rapunzel. She is a side character in her own life, and she knows it. What few bones the universe throws her only serve to remind her that she never truly amounts to anything.
Rapunzel herself also doesn't help matters, despite meaning well. She has a callous disregard for boundaries and repeatedly demonstrates an inability to let people have their own opinions or differences. She can't just let Cassandra brood a bit or be angry at for essentially crippling her, she keeps trying to force her to talk about her feelings. She can't let Cassandra and Eugene just not like each other but still be bound together by the fact that they both care about her, she locks them in a prison cell to try and make them become friends. She can't accept that Cassandra has a better read on certain people than she does, and that she's not the universal social butterfly she likes to be. She gets fussy because Cassandra's celebratory events in Vardaros are more popular than hers, and disapproves of all of them because they don't suit her standards of what events should be.
As such, Cassandra was already falling apart for many justified reasons, but it all comes to a head when it's revealed that she's actually Mother Gothel's daughter, and was abandoned when Gothel kidnapped Rapunzel. This one is... something a lot of people are stuck on, ragging on Cassandra for "victim blaming Rapunzel." First of all, I don't know why people expect Cassandra to act rationally about that. That was an... earthshattering revelation that she didn't have any time to process at all, and was dropped on her like a fucking piano by an actual demon. Expecting logic out of her in that regard is... not just stupid, it's crazy.
Second... "Gothel chose you over me" is meant to be the capstone to a long string of instances where Rapunzel one-ups Cassandra that... I suppose you just overlooked. The point of that isn't "It's your fault my birthmother kidnapped you and used you as a tool for all those years" it's that Cassandra has had confirmed, in her mind, once and for all, that she's so far beneath Rapunzel that even her own flesh and blood would choose Rapunzel over her. Even Rapunzel, at this point, has continuously chosen someone like Adira over her, and demonstrates callous disregard for her wants or boundaries. She doesn't feel like she has anyone who would put her first.
Even when she becomes a villain, she's really not that evil. She's more interested in finding some way to be taken seriously, with no clear direction as to how to achieve that. It's hard to say she's even that malicious either. Most of her attacks are against her friends, all of whom she has an axe with which to grind. She isn't deliberately trying to massacre innocents. It's worth noting that she even explicitly says to Varian -- despite them being enemies at the end of season 1 -- that she knows he didn't ask to be involved in any of this, and so she won't harm him so long as he doesn't become a problem. She attacks him during their duet because he's pushing her buttons, and she's emotionally unstable. He wants to help her, but he does a poor job of it. She notably doesn't express pleasure when attacking her foster father Captain, only reasonable anger for having critical aspects of her history concealed from her. She's mad at him, but she's not happy to hurt him. There's no old anger boiling to the surface there. Just despair manifesting as momentary rage.
She also had many, many, many opportunities to kill the other characters. Effortlessly, at that. Hell, when she took over the castle, she could've just snapped her fingers and sent a black rock through Eugene's skull before he could even react. Instead, she tossed him around and disarmed him. She mostly trikes with blunt force rather than lethal blades. She's pulling her punches on purpose.
People overlook these aspects of nuance and the why of what led to Cassandra to snap, how loyal she was for the most of the show in spite of how much shit she put up with and her justifiable grievances... instead getting angry at the fact that she had an "unearned redemption" even though... no she didn't? Like. She didn't get redeemed, she got a fresh start. Redemption comes after. They're complaining about something that did not happen.
She can no longer cause them any harm, but she still has a lot to make up for. She understands that she isn’t there yet. That’s why she’s walking out of Rapunzel’s life. She needs to figure herself out. Fix what’s going on inside. Put some good out into the world. She doesn’t deserve to be part of their life again… yet. But she has a good heart, and she’s being given a chance to redeem herself. If she got a spinoff or there was a season 4, that’s probably what would’ve happened.
People are quick to dismiss the start of her solo journey as "unearned redemption" because it's unfathomable to them that there can be new beginnings at an ending, rather than there being the ending and nothing else. Really, they don't want redemption for such a character at all. They want punishment.
Cassandra's really not a horrible person. All things considered, she's actually the best fucking friend Rapunzel could've asked for, and willing to put up with more than any reasonable person should've. But people only see her as a victim-blaming narcissist who got a redemption she didn't deserve, and was bitchy for no reason.
Example 3: The Golden Path and their Leaders (Far Cry 4)
A sentiment that has (thankfully) been largely abandoned by the main Far Cry community, but is still held by many outside of it, is the idea that: "Waiting 15 minutes at the start of the game for Pagan Min to come back is the best ending. You can avoid any danger, accomplish your goal, and get a free country from a nice guy who will treat you right. The Golden Path just uses you and wants to create a narco/fascist religious state, they're clearly the worst here."
Now, to be blunt, Pagan Min is... obviously evil. Just for a quick recap:
Even before he took over Kyrat, he was a brutal enforce for the Triad in Hong Kong, getting up to all sorts of unsavoury criminal activities.
He killed his father and took over the business some time before coming to Kyrat, but he was running it so self-indulgently that many of his own allies tried to kill him out of concern that he'd run it into the ground due to a lack of professionalism.
Looking to expand the business, he took an army of his criminal mercenaries into Kyrat, joined up with the Royalists faction of an ongoing civil war, used his connections to locate a distant, child heir to the throne after the previous royal family was massacred, and pretended to help the royalists out of pure altruism.
Once the war was won, he turned on the Royalists, massacred them, stabbed the kid to death, and seized the throne for himself.
He wasted no time going all in on propaganda.
Pillaging and destroying cultural sites of religious significance, primarily for the sake of stealing any artefacts made of gold either to keep for himself, or to melt down and make an actual golden statue of himself.
Created food shortages by forcing farmers to grow poppies on their farms instead of food, which would then be processed into heroin. Anyone who refused was killed.
Appropriating several legitimate businesses like Rochan Brick and Kyra Tea to use their logistics and facilities for heroin instead.
Violating every safety regulation in the book by allowing chemical runoff from his drug factories to spill into natural water supplies. So now there's water shortages too.
This led animals to consume the contaminated water, and become irregularly hostile to everyone. That's right, there's a lore reason for all the animals trying to kill you entirely unprovoked. He made no effort to fix this.
He changed the currency on a whim so that the economy was completely fucked virtually overnight. He says he did this during his "dark" phase, meaning he basically just did this because he thought it would be funny.
He's racist towards the very people he conquered.
Sex slavery. A big part of his regime, especially in Noore's part, is sex slavery. Many victims are kidnapped from local villages, and are subjected to violent sadomasochistic treatment without their consent. He also gets them addicted to drugs so that it's harder for them to escape. A tactic used by actual pimps and human traffickers.
Human experimentation, brainwashing, and torture in labour camps and gulags. His personal fortress is literally called a gulag. The Shining Minds reformatories are labour camps where people's minds are broken until they are completely desensitised to their own pain, and the pain of those around them. Encourages people to sign up for these camps if they need employment. Claims "No prior experience required, all applicants welcome." So, he expects people to turn themselves in to be made into slaves.
Claims Kyrat is a place of “free expression” and encourages citizens to voice their opinions in an “orderly and respectful” manner at “any Royal Army facility.” Also says that no reservations required, but be sure to bring a change of clothing in case “an overnight stay” is required. So, he invites people to vent their grievances... and then detains them overnight. Probably to torture them.
The Singaporean Incident. He straight up calls you on the phone to gleefully brag about this. He sponsored a class of students to study medicine in Singapore. They never came back, because... yeah, he's fucking crazy. They wanted to get out of Kyrat and away from him. He had his Triad contacts in Singapore capture them, return them, and then find a "fitting end" for all of them. As well as have their families tortured to death. What a nice guy.
He banned religion. Like. Straight up. Religion as a concept is banned. Punishable by death.
Established a breeding program for endangered animals in Kyrat... so that he can take payments from wealthy foreigners for the opportunity to hunt one, and consume parts of them like tiger penises and rhino horns with the belief that it will preserve his youth.
Basically just murders any of his subordinates who disappoints him. Tried to have his tailor killed because he was worried his clothes weren't unique enough. Killed a kidnapped TV chef because Ajay rightly got the fuck away from him. Ordered an entire propaganda factory destroyed and all its staff killed because they spelled his name as "Pagen" and it pissed him off.
Everything he did to Noore. She was part of a humanitarian relief group called Doctors With Open Hearts (fictional version of Doctors Without Borders) who provided aid to Kyrat, and wrote a paper on Pagan Min's many human rights violations. Pagan, being a petty and evil piece of shit, lured her into Kyrat under the guise of taking her suggestions for improvement seriously, but instead kidnapped her family and used them as leverage to enslave her into running all the blood sports, booze, and brothels (which run on sex slavery) in the country. Tragically? It was all for nothing. Pagan had her family killed by De Pleur years ago. Anything she was clinging to? It's long gone. He made a good woman into a monster because she dared to stand up to him.
Doesn't even try to invest any of his fortunes into actually improving the country. Instead he just covers up its issues. His regime's official Kyrati guidebook claims that rats aren't a problem in any capacity in Kyrat, and anyone who claims to see one will be committed to Durgesh for insanity.
He’s been doing this for twenty years.
And he takes no responsibility for any of it. His grand plan is to take this hot wet mess of his and just pass it off to Ajay so he can ride out on a golden parachute.
There are many, many more examples of these. No, really. Ask me for more examples if you want. Or, if you don't believe me? Ask me for evidence. I have it.
The Golden Path are the local rebels, trying to take back their homeland from a foreign conqueror. And throughout the entire game, they are basically purely benevolent. Almost all the main missions and all of the side content is dedicated to solving problems Pagan Min created in the first place, to the detriment of the common man.
The Golden Path are also not a monolith. It's established in the side missions that due to the division in leadership and the overall inefficiencies they face, most of the humanitarian relief efforts carried out by the rebellion are not set up by Amita or Sabal. Instead, the rank and file have to take the initiative themselves, and do what's right.
I REPEAT JUST FOR EMPHASIS: THE VAST MAJORITY OF THE GOLDEN PATH IS SO BENEVOLENT THAT THEY DO GOOD THINGS OF THEIR OWN ACCORD SIMPLY BECAUSE THEY ARE MOTIVATED BY THE DESIRE TO HELP PEOPLE. THIS IS CANON AND ESTABLISHED BY THE SIDE CHARACTERS SEEMINGLY SPECIFICALLY TO DISTANCE THEM FROM THE IDEA THAT JUST BECAUSE THEIR LEADERS AREN'T SQUEAKY CLEAN, THAT DOESN'T MAKE THEM VILLAINS.
This is what the Golden Path is at its core: average people, getting down in the dirt to do right by their fellow countrymen, with no task too small or beneath them. Let's go over some of the things they do.
Hostage rescues and protection of the locals from the Royal Army.
Coordinating assassination missions on Royal Army officers, usually with some nasty skeletons in their closet.
Protecting locals from dangerous wildlife.
Delivering cases of rifles to civilians so they can protect themselves from Pagan's governors.
Smuggling ancient statues out of the country to art buyers for a high price. They'd rather give up pieces of their heritage, knowing that those pieces will be safe, than see them destroyed by Pagan.
Smuggling contraceptives and disease tests into the brothels, which do not provide these by default.
Movement of books banned by Pagan Min to build secret libraries all over Kyrat.
Delivering shipments of food and fresh water to starving villages to combat shortages caused by Pagan's drug business.
Avenging people unjustly killed by the Royal Army. Also known as the "Eye For An Eye" Missions. People have been driven out of their homes. A man’s father was murdered for changing the radio broadcast from Pagan Min’s propaganda to rock music. An entire village had the daughters of the families taken to be forced into prostitution. This is what the Golden Path fights against.
Hunting for the sake of feeding the people.
Defending what religious sites haven't already been destroyed by Pagan.
Gathering up the intel and handling the logistics necessary for Ajay to do all the stuff he does.
So how exactly are these the "greater evil" here? To the people who claim this, can you name one, single thing the Royal Army has done that is even close to good? Just one thing? It should be so easy. One thing.
No. Of course not. Want to know why? Because the Royal Army are a bunch of comically villainous irredeemable douchebags, and it's actually a stated plot point that what few members aren't? Pagan Min actually hates them, and goes out of his way to ensure their good works are undone as often as possible. I'm not even joking. Pagan's army is horrible intentionally. He goes out of his way to make sure they're like that.
Let's also not act like Amita and Sabal are completely void of redeemable qualities themselves. They're imperfect people, but they're not completely monstrous like Pagan is. They have ugly spots. Some really ugly spots, but they're still acting in what they genuinely believe is the best interests of Kyrat, and it shows. Unlike Pagan Min, who only acts in the best interest of himself.
So why do people overlook all of this?
Because Pagan Min is conventionally attractive and portrayed by Troy Baker doing a hot accent.
Seriously, I'm pretty sure that's mostly it. People blow sunshine up his ass about how charming and funny he is. If this guy was ugly as fuck and sounded like a strangled turkey, he would not have nearly as many people claiming he's so great. I guess I'm inoculated against this because I'm not attracted to men in the first place?
People also have a weird tendency to just... make shit up to depict the other two options as worse than they actual are? The rumour that Sabal plans to marry a child is incredibly prevalent, but there's... there's really no evidence for it whatsoever. There's actually more evidence as to why he wouldn't do that. He'd absolutely allow traditionalist child marriages, but people feel the need to say he personally is a nonce, because that's a bigger "gotcha." People claim Amita will "make Kyrat a narco state" even though it already is one BECAUSE OF PAGAN MIN, but she's actually taking steps to regulate it such that it isn't destroying the environment and leading to starvation too.
The only other explanation I can think of is that they played the game drunk, or didn't play the game at all. Because everything I just discussed in this post? This is... kind of hard to miss. He calls you on the phone multiple times throughout the campaign to brag about the worst things he's done. For some reason people think this absolves him of his evils? Because he's "honest" I guess? As if that fucking matters?
What's legitimately frustrating about this is that Far Cry 4 has... really good writing for a Far Cry game. They put a lot of effort into the worldbuilding. Some of the moral issues that you're faced with do raise some interesting points if you take into consideration what the "right" thing may be based on your perspectives on religion, economy, environment, etc. and so on. And it is always good to point out that wars are not clean. The best of intentions don't always lead to good outcomes. Extremists may be well-intentioned, there may be moral or ideological decay, or there may even just be ideologues making a power grab whilst weaponising the altruism of people who don't have a mind for leadership, but whose hearts are genuinely in the right place.
... And all of this gets overlooked by the fuckheaded lackwits who say "Well uhhhh but... funny suit guy gives you crab rangoon and free country soooooo..."
People attempt to construct all sorts of absurd reasonings for why siding with Pagan is the best ending anyway. The most popular of which was "well he's not good for the country but he's still good for Ajay" even though this is also laughably wrong for reasons I've explained in this post.
Honestly I could go on about this for four times the length of what I've already written, but the point is... if you think Pagan Min is a good guy, or even the lesser evil, you are objectively wrong, I can prove it, this is my favourite video game that I've been playing, datamining, studying, loving consistently for the last fourteen years, I know more than you, and I will throw a book at your head. If you actually believe that the country is in a worse place by the end of the game than it was under the guy whose best friend quite literally hosted monthly parties for his soldiers to butcher and rape civilians to death for fun, you're completely hopeless.