Ahhhh okay, I've been feeling backed in a corner with the way that society is twisting gender. There's so many people that can just SAY that they are trans/non-binary and then you HAVE to believe them or else you're "transphobic".
The problem is, then these people speak over other trans and non-binary people about what is right and wrong in the trans community, what it "actually" means to be trans/nb, changes what pronouns mean, create their own pronouns and genders and say you're transphobic for "invalidating" them, police how everyone else reacts to gender when the pronouns don't make sense..
They advocate that "gender is a social construct" when gender is innate, and gender ROLES and EXPRESSION are the social constructs.
They advocate that "pronouns do not equal gender" so that they can do anything they want to abolish gender. If pronouns didn't equal gender, then it wouldn't be validating to change them. When there is only he/him and she/her that are gendered, and then you have they/them as not gendered, and then you have all the olden pronouns like thon/Ze/zir/xe, etc already, why are they trying to take gender away from the only gendered pronouns that trans people need to feel comfortable??
Taking gender away from the only gendered pronouns is harmful to binary trans people. If those pronouns aren't gendered, then it would not be possible to misgender someone.
The thing that bothers me most is, how come LGB can protect their labels and what is or isn't included in their label, but trans/nb people cannot?? Why can't we protect what it means to be trans/nb too?
Like when there are terms like "bi-lesbians" and "bi-straights" that are downright offensive, why is someone creating a gender for themselves, a gender like "catgender", which they have no way of transition to and so to me it invalidates the struggles of trans people, can apply that new gender to themselves and then say they are "trans"?
(I'll still respect someone's neopronouns if they have them, but I believe that you can't create a "gender". You can create your own identity all you want and call yourself what you like and I will respect it, but creating something and calling it a "gender" doesn't make it one and doesn't make someone trans or non-binary to do so. Calling it the same thing to identify as a cat as it is to be dysphoric is so invalidating to trans/nb people to me that it makes me sick. And before people say it's because of autism, most autistic people don't understand neopronouns (the xenogender ones) either. They are too outside the norms of gender for most of them to comprehend how they work and will usually just go by they/them if they are not comfortable with their own gender. I have asked quite a few of them about it already.)
Why is this not offensive to non-binary people, who get the worst of it when they come out to someone as non-binary and the response is "haha I identify as an attack helicopter!"
Because the "I identify as" "jokes" didn't come from nowhere, and is CLEARLY harmful as anyone who hates trans has fuel to use against us the more we don't protect what it actually means to be trans and non-binary and let anything associated with identity be considered "gender".
Gender is not a choice.
On top of that, how can people with NO DYSPHORIA AT ALL come into the trans community and then call people transphobic for being skeptical about how they are trans? Is that not invalidating of the trans experience too? (because from what I have seen, those people are usually afab and okay with their female bodies, and LOVE to talk about what is and isn't okay for trans MEN that have dysphoria to feel or what is okay to refer to transmen as or what is "not offensive" to trans people)
(and I'm not talking about the "non-dysphorics" that only feel gender "euphoria" because that's a different thing entirely, although I do wonder where is the line between that and for example, a drag queen that is a cis man and gets euphoric for presenting as a woman? Just because they "say" they are trans is the only difference between them? What am I missing?)
Idk man, I'm tired of trying to help protect what it means to be trans and then being called transphobic for it, despite being a trans person myself. But the trans community is so toxic nowadays. If you believe you need dysphoria to be trans, you get kicked out of trans spaces on Reddit and called a transphobic TERF.
I think that trans people need the help of our LGB+ family to help navigate what is going on and find a balance since it's currently this extra level of "wokeness" happening and it's making trans and non-binary out to be a joke.
I think LGB are a bit afraid to speak out about terms concerning gender because they are not trans themselves, but we need help because we are silenced in our own communities when we try to speak against some of this stuff.
And if I'm wrong, please just help me understand. Please help me accept how this is okay with some examples of how this happened with sexualities and what happened because I can't even recognize the trans community as something I relate to or feel safe in anymore. More and more trans people go stealth and abandon the community as soon as possible because it doesn't help them to be associated as trans anymore because of how much the meaning is changed they can't relate to it anymore either, and for me because I am not allowed to an opinion on gender without people implying that I am a hateful piece of shit.
(to be clear, I don't go up to people and tell them "you're not trans enough" before people assume that about me, I'm not a dick)
I need help knowing where exactly is the line where it is okay to protect what is trans. What is actually transphobic to say "that's not what it means to be trans/that's not trans" to in order to protect it as a respectable label?
If there is no line, that doesn't make any sense and the trans community is doomed for binary trans people with dysphoria since we are becoming a minority in our own spaces. If there is no line, we need help from LGB to help determine where the line is and reinforce it.
TLDR; am I actually just a hateful piece of shit, or am I right and the trans community needs help? Or something in-between?