r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Feb 09 '23

Why exactly is gender dysphoria not a mental disorder?

47 Upvotes

I want to preface this question by saying there should be nothing shameful about mental disorder. We are trying to reduce the stigma of mental illness. Most people have some form of mental illness these days. I also think I know the answer I just wanted to make sure I understand. It would seem like the big difference is people lean into their dysphoria and it helps them to do so. Trying to "fix" it ends up hurting people. Does that make it entirely unique as a condition? What is something similar? Just thinking maybe Narcissistic personality disorder. Because if you were to treat those people like there was something wrong with them they wouldn't probably enjoy that. If we supported their beliefs they'd feel more fulfilled and happy probably. Not saying there would be any other similarities.

In 2019 the WHO stopped recognizing gender dysphoria as a mental illness and the article I read said their explanation was that they understand it better now and they want to reduce the stigma. However, by doing that don't you raise the stigma of mental illness by basically saying "mental illness is bad, but this isn't that." Doesn't dysphoria come from the mind? What is the clinical difference between it and a mental disorder that requires it being considered in a new category of "sexual health condition" or whatever it's considered now?


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Nov 23 '21

I think my sister is gay. How do I subtly drop hints that it is safe to come out to me and I'll support her?

45 Upvotes

Created a new account just to ask this question. Will delete this later.

My sister showed many signs of being a gay. She is tomboyish and pays keen attention to female stars than male stars (Maybe she just likes their sense of fashion or envies their body).

She also hates if me or her friends associate her with any boy. She also giggles a lot when chatting with her friend whom she considers her best friend. She also talks a lot about her to me.

We live in a very conservative society and my parents are quite conservative too. And I assume that it is natural for her to assume that I am also conservative.

I am not asking you to give your judgement on whether she's gay. Since, as a person who knows her quite well, I don't know about it and I certainly am not letting you decide that.

And what I am asking is that, what should I do to let her know I support her if she's gay. And these actions shouldn't cause confusion if she's not gay.


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Aug 26 '20

Why put a brown and black stripes on the rainbow flag?

42 Upvotes

I know this is probably a terrible time to ask- but it's been confusing me and I really just want answers. I fully support BLM but I really don't understand why sometimes there's brown and black stripes on the rainbow pride flag. I tried to read an article about it, but it felt very unprofessional. The author kept saying something along the lines of "the only people who don't like it are straight cis white men" and it honestly really made me upset and even more confused. The rainbow pride flag is about sexuality identity right? So I don't understand why bring race into it? Am I just uninformed? I really want to understand but I'm terrified to ask. Please any feedback is necessary


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Jun 22 '19

Welcome to /r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT!

38 Upvotes

Hello and welcome!

As a frequent user of /r/TooAfraidToAsk, I see an influx of posts about the LGBTQ+ community and it's members. Oftentimes, the users that answer those types of questions are not part of the LGBTQ+ community. Which is totally fine! But you may not get the answer you're looking for.

Typically, the person posting the question will preface it by saying they are too afraid to ask the LGBTQ+ community out of fear of offending anyone. We're not as scary as we seem, I promise ;)

This is a safe space for those types of questions! You will not be judged for your question, at all! As long as your question is coming from a place of education and is asked respectfully, myself and other members of the LGBTQ+ community would be happy to answer them!

I know Ask LGBT and Ask Transgender subs exist. But those subs are mostly used by people in the community, asking other people in the community. I want this sub to serve as the bridge between non-LGBTQ+ people looking to learn, and LGBTQ+ willing to teach.

I've never created a sub before so this is new and scary but i'm looking forward to interacting with you all and to creating a space where LGBTQ+ people and non LGBTQ+ people alike can interact and teach each other a little something.


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Sep 22 '22

Women lesbians, how do you feel about trans men calling themselves lesbians?

35 Upvotes

What about non binary trans-mascs calling themselves lesbians, or non binary trans-femmes? Finally, how do you feel about changing the word "lesbian" to mean "non men loving non men" instead of "women who love women"?

Please clearly specify each demographic and which you mean in your comment if you include some but not others.


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Jun 01 '21

I'm SO confused about how everything is apparently transphobic (I'm a trans guy)

34 Upvotes

Ahhhh okay, I've been feeling backed in a corner with the way that society is twisting gender. There's so many people that can just SAY that they are trans/non-binary and then you HAVE to believe them or else you're "transphobic".

The problem is, then these people speak over other trans and non-binary people about what is right and wrong in the trans community, what it "actually" means to be trans/nb, changes what pronouns mean, create their own pronouns and genders and say you're transphobic for "invalidating" them, police how everyone else reacts to gender when the pronouns don't make sense..

They advocate that "gender is a social construct" when gender is innate, and gender ROLES and EXPRESSION are the social constructs.

They advocate that "pronouns do not equal gender" so that they can do anything they want to abolish gender. If pronouns didn't equal gender, then it wouldn't be validating to change them. When there is only he/him and she/her that are gendered, and then you have they/them as not gendered, and then you have all the olden pronouns like thon/Ze/zir/xe, etc already, why are they trying to take gender away from the only gendered pronouns that trans people need to feel comfortable??

Taking gender away from the only gendered pronouns is harmful to binary trans people. If those pronouns aren't gendered, then it would not be possible to misgender someone.

The thing that bothers me most is, how come LGB can protect their labels and what is or isn't included in their label, but trans/nb people cannot?? Why can't we protect what it means to be trans/nb too?

Like when there are terms like "bi-lesbians" and "bi-straights" that are downright offensive, why is someone creating a gender for themselves, a gender like "catgender", which they have no way of transition to and so to me it invalidates the struggles of trans people, can apply that new gender to themselves and then say they are "trans"?

(I'll still respect someone's neopronouns if they have them, but I believe that you can't create a "gender". You can create your own identity all you want and call yourself what you like and I will respect it, but creating something and calling it a "gender" doesn't make it one and doesn't make someone trans or non-binary to do so. Calling it the same thing to identify as a cat as it is to be dysphoric is so invalidating to trans/nb people to me that it makes me sick. And before people say it's because of autism, most autistic people don't understand neopronouns (the xenogender ones) either. They are too outside the norms of gender for most of them to comprehend how they work and will usually just go by they/them if they are not comfortable with their own gender. I have asked quite a few of them about it already.)

Why is this not offensive to non-binary people, who get the worst of it when they come out to someone as non-binary and the response is "haha I identify as an attack helicopter!"

Because the "I identify as" "jokes" didn't come from nowhere, and is CLEARLY harmful as anyone who hates trans has fuel to use against us the more we don't protect what it actually means to be trans and non-binary and let anything associated with identity be considered "gender".

Gender is not a choice.

On top of that, how can people with NO DYSPHORIA AT ALL come into the trans community and then call people transphobic for being skeptical about how they are trans? Is that not invalidating of the trans experience too? (because from what I have seen, those people are usually afab and okay with their female bodies, and LOVE to talk about what is and isn't okay for trans MEN that have dysphoria to feel or what is okay to refer to transmen as or what is "not offensive" to trans people)

(and I'm not talking about the "non-dysphorics" that only feel gender "euphoria" because that's a different thing entirely, although I do wonder where is the line between that and for example, a drag queen that is a cis man and gets euphoric for presenting as a woman? Just because they "say" they are trans is the only difference between them? What am I missing?)

Idk man, I'm tired of trying to help protect what it means to be trans and then being called transphobic for it, despite being a trans person myself. But the trans community is so toxic nowadays. If you believe you need dysphoria to be trans, you get kicked out of trans spaces on Reddit and called a transphobic TERF.

I think that trans people need the help of our LGB+ family to help navigate what is going on and find a balance since it's currently this extra level of "wokeness" happening and it's making trans and non-binary out to be a joke.

I think LGB are a bit afraid to speak out about terms concerning gender because they are not trans themselves, but we need help because we are silenced in our own communities when we try to speak against some of this stuff.

And if I'm wrong, please just help me understand. Please help me accept how this is okay with some examples of how this happened with sexualities and what happened because I can't even recognize the trans community as something I relate to or feel safe in anymore. More and more trans people go stealth and abandon the community as soon as possible because it doesn't help them to be associated as trans anymore because of how much the meaning is changed they can't relate to it anymore either, and for me because I am not allowed to an opinion on gender without people implying that I am a hateful piece of shit.

(to be clear, I don't go up to people and tell them "you're not trans enough" before people assume that about me, I'm not a dick)

I need help knowing where exactly is the line where it is okay to protect what is trans. What is actually transphobic to say "that's not what it means to be trans/that's not trans" to in order to protect it as a respectable label?

If there is no line, that doesn't make any sense and the trans community is doomed for binary trans people with dysphoria since we are becoming a minority in our own spaces. If there is no line, we need help from LGB to help determine where the line is and reinforce it.

TLDR; am I actually just a hateful piece of shit, or am I right and the trans community needs help? Or something in-between?


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Sep 27 '22

Why do Trans Women post in Femboy spaces?

31 Upvotes

I see a lot of trans women posting in femboy spaces and don't understand why.

Trans women with gender dysphoria generally aren't comfortable with any terms about their gender assigned at birth, including boy... So why do so many post in spaces for boys?

Femboys are meant to be feminine boys, not women, but trans women are women. If trans women are women, why are they posting in spaces for men? Isn't it discriminatory to call trans women femboys? They aren't boys last I checked, so I just really don't understand. Every time I've asked one directly on femboy subreddits I got banned and chewed out for being "exclusionary and a transphobic asshole", when in actuality over half my friends are trans people and I was literally just asking a question.

I do not understand how someone can ask to be accepted as a woman and simultaneously post themselves as a boy in femboy subreddits. I've had this as a burning question for a long time.


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Jan 12 '24

Am I the only one who hates the word ‘queer’ as a bisexual?

26 Upvotes

maybe it’s because I always knew it as a rude word to describe gay/bi folks. To me it has the same connotation as the word dyke, which I know has been “reclaimed” by some, and so has queer, but when someone refers to me as such I’m just like 😬. I just wanna know if I’m alone in feeling like that.


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Sep 29 '20

Message from the Moderator

26 Upvotes

Thank you all so much for using this sub the way it was intended and for participating in discussions.

I do have to apologize though for i've ignored a few reports that were just brought to my attention over the last few months. I hadn't seen the reports until now and I sincerely apologize for not seeing the troll plaguing this sub.

I have removed the posts and will be on the lookout from now on. Please continue to report any posts or comments that break sub rules, thank you!


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Jan 22 '24

Can everyone in the LGBTQ+ community use the rainbow flag?

25 Upvotes

I recently came out as bi and was looking at cute pride stuff to wear. Is it okay to wear rainbow stuff, or should I stick to just bisexual pride colored things?


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Mar 27 '22

Why do so many trans women refer to themselves as ‘girls’?

23 Upvotes

I’m a young, cis, bisexual/ pansexual woman and I support trans rights. I’ve always found the use of ‘girls’ when describing women to be infantilizing and other cis women I know almost never refer to themselves as ‘girls’ for this reason. Trans women seem to do it all the time and I find it rather odd and a bit annoying especially since they’re often adults/ older.

Editing to add: Thank you - I posted this as a response to another comment, but I’ll put it here too: Thank you so much for your comment. Yours and another comment have really helped me better understand the situation. I appreciate it. I almost always refer to adult women as women and not girls as a matter of respect, so when I see trans women calling themselves girls I suppose a part of me associates it with disrespectfulness. I’ll even say ladies ie. Ladies night. Ladies trip etc as I took a few gender studies courses that opened my eyes about the way language and society infantilizes women in a variety of ways. Your comments have provided another perspective that I had not considered.


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Jun 04 '24

Why do people join an lgbt support group if not to make friends?

21 Upvotes

gay guy here {:-)

so afew months ago I joined an lgbt support group and I often offer to get drinks afterwards or to hang out but they always refuse. This confuses me because in my opinion the only reason support groups exist (lgbt or not) is to make friends with people of similar experiences

so what other reason is there to join one?


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Jun 03 '24

Are asexuals and aromantics a part of the LGBT community?

21 Upvotes

A trans friend of mine said they don’t belong in the lgbt community because people have died for lgbt rights whereas asexuals and aromantics haven’t been persecuted. They also argued that any person, cisgender or trans, gay or straight, could also be asexual or aromatic and so they think asexuals and aromantics deserve some other category outside of the lgbt community.

As someone who is ace, at first I felt hurt despite never pursuing being a part of the community but I think they make good points and think maybe I agree? I want to see what others think because I’m curious if it’s wrong.

Edit: I meant to also ask about “Demisexuals.”


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Nov 26 '23

Is there a reason why most american non-binary people that I see on the internet are AFAB?

21 Upvotes

This is completely empirical. I don’t mean this question to be offensive or backhanded to non-binary peeps. Please correct me if i accidentally do so.

It just happen to come across posts of people across communities like in cosplaying, niche shows and media that people fandom off (which most of them belongs to the lgbt+ community and/or are non-binary) and I just wonder why i rarely see AMAB enbys and more on AFAB enbys/lgbt peeps with their preferred labels and neopronouns in the internet. Is this a gender psychology thing related to american culture and assigned sex at birth as to why most of them are AFAB?


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Jun 25 '22

If sex and gender are different, why do trans people need surgery? NSFW

20 Upvotes

I consider myself pretty left, but I come from a country where trans people is a fairly new concept.

I try to be supportive as much as possible with LGBT issues, my brother is gay and I have seen how difficult life was for him before he came out, and was supportive from day 1.

Trans issues are just a bit different for me still, and I'd like to have a better understanding so that I can actually fully support the idea, say for instance my kid was trans, I'd want to "truly" support them and not have any worries in the back of my head.

A big thing is sex reassignment surgery, to me it feels like, if you don't feel masculine, or don't fit into that societal role, then 100%, do what you wanna do. But it comes dangerously close to mental illness if that goes to the point of wanting to remove pretty crucial organs, like if someone wanted to remove an arm, I'd be concerned.

In general I get the concept of gender =/= sex, but then, why does sex need to change if gender doesn't "match"?

As far as adults go, I'll always say people can do what they want, even remove an arm, so it's not my place to impose any views, but if it's my own child, I'd be very concerned. And I guess the main concern is if it's generally accepted to go through these procedures younger and younger, you get into very dangerous territory of doing permanent changes to feelings that might just be temporary.

So, please, if anyone can give me insight into this, I really want to have my mind changed.


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Feb 27 '22

Why are there people who identify as he/him lesbians?

20 Upvotes

Sorry in advance if this is rude.

I’ve seen on the internet some people who identify as lesbians who use he/him pronouns. I mind my own business, so I’m not going to be a dick to someone like that.

But I don’t understand why.

If I understand correctly, a lesbian is by definition a woman. I’ve heard lesbian advocates say “even if I’m butch, I’m still a woman,” hence she’s a lesbian. She’s a woman who loves women.

But then I saw online lesbians who use he/him. Why use men’s pronouns if you aren’t a man?


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Oct 04 '21

Is it wrong for an lgbtq person to tell me I'm a closeted lesbian?

20 Upvotes

Really weird, but I have a sister who's bi and mostly into girls. I've been an ally since my two friends came out in 7th grade, but am certainly straight. My sister is going around telling people I'm a closeted lesbian, making jokes and comments about me being lesbian and has roped my parents into convincing me I'm gay. My mum is trying to tell me it's okay to be lesbian, in a way that comes off as you are, and my sister continues to tell all her friends that I'm closeted like some sort of trophy. I want her to stop, but I think the first thing I'll need to know is if this is ok, or even normal within the community? Thank you all for your help, it very much appreciated,

Update: Last night I brought my guy friend over for her to meet, I want to date him but we haven't started yet. After my sister asked if we were dating and I said no she told him I was a lesbian. When I told both of them I wasn't, she gave me a look of 'are you sure I don't know better?' And confirmed that I was in fact a lesbian. I asked her why she was telling people that and she lied. She told me she'd only told one person and they didn't believe her, I know it's a lie because I've heard her tell different people even in front of me. I asked again why she was doing it and she avoided the question. I'm not sure what to do, or if she's hiding something bigger about this,


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Feb 01 '21

How can you be gay and non-binary at the same time? Isn't it a contradiction?

20 Upvotes

I am really curious and hope this isn't a rude question. I don't want to offend anyone and I am not against it at all, just wanna understand how the lines are there. I just stumbled across a headline which said something about being gay and non binary which made me question whether or not this is a contradiction. After all being gay means you are attracted to the same gender while non binary means you don't identify as a gender. But if you don't identify as a certain gender but as both how can you be gay? After all, that means you are attracted to the same gender and if you are identifying as both that just doesn't make sense. Or do you take your biological sex in that case?


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • May 13 '20

Can transgender men choose how big their penises are?

20 Upvotes

I recently watched an episode of Curb Your Enthusiasm, and one of the characters was a transgender man (played by Chaz Bono). The character had an unusually large penis, which is what he had chosen.

Can transgender men choose the size of their penises before they have gender confirming surgery?


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Dec 31 '20

Today at work I accidentally called someone who prefers “they/them” as “Sir” and didn’t find out until they corrected me but they didn’t tell me what to call them. I want to know what is the proper way to formally address a customer who prefers they/them pronouns?

19 Upvotes

r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • May 22 '24

are there any trans people who Transitioned as kids in the 90s or before?

18 Upvotes

as far as I know the earliest recorded case of a child transitioning is Kim Petras and even she transitioned in the mid 2000s

but that’s dosen’t mean it didn’t happen so I’m curious if any of you have heard of people transitioning young earlier


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Dec 23 '23

Is "Be Gay, Do Crime" meant to be a homophobic phrase?

17 Upvotes

I've never understood this phrase and I just want to know what it means.


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Feb 25 '22

Is it normal to be romantically attracted to men but not physically attracted to them, and physically attracted to women but very rarely romantically attracted to them?

17 Upvotes

(Please excuse my grammar, English isn't my first language)
I'm (F) still new to this and I'm still exploring my orientation. What I am certain of is I've been attracted to both men and women in different contexts.
I've had a few romantic affairs with men and they've gone well, but I've never considered them physically attractive. As in, I get attracted by their personality and not their looks (I am still a minor so I don't really dabble in sexual attraction yet) but I don't feel like I'm sexually attracted to them either. I've been in one relationship with a dude and it was fun and very romantic, but (unrelated) we ended things. I've kissed a couple boys, and I didn't really like it much.
On the other hand, I find women very physically attractive. I don't know if I just find them aesthetically pleasing or if I'm genuinely attracted to them. Again I'm not sure about sexual attraction, but I've kissed three to four girls (the fourth is debatable) in my lifetime and I liked it a lot. I don't really feel like I've formed any emotional connection with any of them though. I've never been in a relationship with a girl, except one, but it was short lived.

I'm not in a rush to figure out my orientation, I still have a lot of time to figure myself out, but I'm just asking because I'm curious.


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Feb 10 '22

Would you be interested in a sub for people that have outgrown their childhood gender dysphoria?

17 Upvotes

So, I don’t actually know whether or not I had dysphoria as a kid but I think I did and I also wanna hear other people’s experiences but I can’t find them anywhere on the internet (Reddit or otherwise) so I thought of making my own little community on Reddit

what do you guys think?

p.s. don’t worry, I’ll ban any transphobia (including towards trans kids)

Here I made if your interested: r/Hereovertherainbow ignore the stupid name i originally wanted to use it for something else but then scrapped it


r/TooAfraidToAskLGBT • • Nov 16 '20

Why do some people think you don’t need dysphoria to be trans?

17 Upvotes

If you don’t have dysphoria and you transition (medically socially whatever) won’t you get dysphoria since you weren’t uncomfortable in your body to begin with? I don’t think dysphoria means hating your body it just means being uncomfortable with your natal primary or secondary sex characteristics. I am just trying to keep and open mind and I really don’t want to add fuel to the dysphoria fight I just am trying to understand the other side.