r/Tomiki • u/nggrfggtkhike • Feb 13 '21
Discussion "Sport" aikido
They mock aikikai as "dancing". What would that make "sport" aikido?
If the matter truly is about combat effectiveness, shouldn't people be moving towards daito-ryu?
There are the thought leaders and there are the corresponding echo chambers of the various lines. I think the leaders have thunk wrongly, made bad choices, steered their fleet into the rocks. Aikido has stranded its adherents on various barren islands - to die slowly into irrelevance, to live on only in dusty history books - or back water websites.
There is something wrong. Aikido is not judo. Aikido is not a sport. The narrow, sterile competition "lab" is not working - there is no feedback loop into the curricula. Tomiki's entire thesis has collapsed under the weight of its own disproof. The leaders let this happen.
Is it too late? Probably.