r/tolkienfans • • Jun 19 '20

RIP Bilbo. Ian Holm, has passed away aged 88

5.9k Upvotes

r/tolkienfans • • Jan 18 '15

I have recut PJ’s Hobbit trilogy into a single 4-hour film (The Tolkien Edit)

4.4k Upvotes

Let me start by saying that I enjoy many aspects of Peter Jackson’s Hobbit trilogy. Overall, however, I felt that the story was spoiled by an interminable running time, unengaging plot tangents and constant narrative filibustering. What especially saddened me was how Bilbo (the supposed protagonist of the story) was rendered absent for large portions of the final two films. Back in 2012, I had high hopes of adding The Hobbit to my annual Lord of the Rings marathon, but in its current bloated format, I simply cannot see that happening.

So, over the weekend, I decided to condense all three installments (An Unexpected Journey, The Desolation of Smaug and The Battle of the Five Armies) into a single 4-hour feature that more closely resembled Tolkien’s original novel. Well, okay, it’s closer to 4.5 hours, but those are some long-ass credits! This new version was achieved through a series of major and minor cuts, detailed below:

  • The investigation of Dol Guldor has been completely excised, including the appearances of Radagast, Saruman and Galadriel. This was the most obvious cut, and the easiest to carry out (a testament to its irrelevance to the main narrative). Like the novel, Gandalf abruptly disappears on the borders of Mirkwood, and then reappears at the siege of the Lonely Mountain with tidings of an orc army.

  • The Tauriel-Legolas-Kili love triangle has also been removed. Indeed, Tauriel is no longer a character in the film, and Legolas only gets a brief cameo during the Mirkwood arrest. This was the next clear candidate for elimination, given how little plot value and personality these two woodland sprites added to the story. Dwarves are way more fun to hang out with anyway. :P

  • The Pale Orc subplot is vastly trimmed down. Azog is obviously still leading the attack on the Lonely Mountain at the end, but he does not appear in the film until after the company escapes the goblin tunnels (suggesting that the slaying of the Great Goblin is a factor in their vendetta, as it was in the novel).

  • Several of the Laketown scenes have been cut, such as Bard’s imprisonment and the superfluous orc raid. However, I’ve still left quite a bit of this story-thread intact, since I felt it succeeded in getting the audience to care about the down-beaten fisherfolk and the struggles of Bard to protect them.

  • The prelude with old Bilbo is gone. As with the novel, I find the film works better if the scope starts out small (in a cosy hobbit hole), and then grows organically as Bilbo ventures out into the big, scary world. It is far more elegant to first learn about Smaug from the dwarves’ haunting ballad (rather than a bombastic CGI sequence). The prelude also undermines the real-and-present stakes of the story by framing it as one big flashback.

  • Several of the orc skirmishes have been cut. I felt that the Battle of the Five Armies provided more than enough orc mayhem. If you pack in too much before then, they just become monotonous, and it lessons their menace in the audience’s mind. I was tempted to leave in the very first Azog confrontation (since it resembles a chapter from the novel), but decided to cut it for a variety of reasons. Specifically, I found it tonally jarring to jump from the emotional crescendo of Thorin being saved by Bilbo (and the sense of safety the company feels after being rescued by the eagles), straight back into another chase sequence. Plus, I think the film works better if Bilbo is still trying to earn Thorin’s respect the entire journey, as he was in the novel. Not to mention the absurdity of Bilbo suddenly turning into John McClane with a sword!

  • Several of the action scenes have been tightened up, such as the barrel-ride, the fight between Smaug and the dwarves (no molten gold in this version), and the Battle of the Five Armies. Though, it should be noted that Bilbo’s key scenes—the encounter with Gollum, the battle against the Mirkwood spiders, and the conversation with Smaug—have not been tampered with, since they proved to be excellent adaptions (in no small part due to Freeman’s performance), and serve to refocus the film on Bilbo’s arc.

  • A lot of filler scenes have been cut as well. These are usually harder to spot (and I’ve probably missed a couple), but once they’re gone, you’ll completely forget that they ever existed. For example, the 4-minute scene where Bard buys some fish and the dwarves gather up his pay.

I used 720×576 versions of the film for the recut. The resolution is slightly reduced after a few exports, but it’s still comparable to DVD quality. Here are some time-stamped screenshots, if anyone wants a better impression:

My main goals in undertaking this edit were to re-centre the story on Bilbo, and to have the narrative move at a much brisker pace (though not so fast that the audience lost grasp of what was going on). Creating smooth transitions between scenes was of particular importance in this regard. I even reordered a few moments in the film to make it flow better. The toughest parts to edit were the barrel-ride and the fight on Ravenhill (since Legolas and Tauriel kept bursting in with their gymnastics routine).

Here are a couple of examples of recut scenes:

I'm not really sure what Reddit's policies are for these sorts of things, so I won't post any links to where you can view the movie. However, it's fairly easy to track down. Just search for The Hobbit: The Tolkien Edit, or the TolkienEditor wordpress.

I hope you enjoy it! If you have any further questions over what was taken out and what was left in, feel free to ask them in the comment section below.

TolkienEditor :)


Update (24 Jan) - Apologies for the delay, but I have uploaded the 6GB version of the recut to the site. This version also has a few alterations, based on people’s requests, including trimming down the chase sequence through the goblin tunnels; colour correcting the transition from the Misty Mountains to Beorn’s house; taking out the Bombur “barrel bounce” (which is apparently the bane of some people’s existence); and tidying up the final fight on Ravenhill. I have no idea how to remove the gold-coating from Smaug, though. I tried a few variations, but none of them work very well. So, this is the final version of the recut, for good or ill. :P

Now, I do want to temper people’s expectations for the 6GB version. Considering the difference in size, the quality isn’t dramatically better. Rather, it is somewhere between a DVD and Blu-ray. The screenshots above are a good indication. That said, the image is sharper, and the colours are a little more vibrant, so it’s probably preferable for people who would like to watch the recut on a big-screen TV. Either way, it's available on the site in download and torrent forms.

Finally, I'm not going to be able to respond to all of the PMs people have been sending me, but I do want to offer a warm thank you for your feedback. Whether you liked the recut or hated it, thanks for letting me get it out of my system. :)


tl;dr – I’ve recut Peter Jackson’s 8-hour Hobbit trilogy into a 4-hour movie. It’s called The Hobbit: The Tolkien Edit. Check it out!


r/tolkienfans • • May 05 '24

RIP Théoden King. Bernard Hill has passed away aged 79. Forth Eorlingas!

3.7k Upvotes

r/tolkienfans • • Sep 03 '21

I'm reading The Lord of the Rings in English for the first time, and this passage blew my mind.

2.8k Upvotes

`Eowyn! Eowyn!’ cried Merry. Then tottering, struggling up, with her last strength she drove her sword between crown and mantle, as the great shoulders bowed before her. The sword broke sparkling into many shards. The crown rolled away with a clang. Éowyn fell forward upon her fallen foe. But lo! the mantle and hauberk were empty. Shapeless they lay now on the ground, torn and tumbled; and a cry went up into the shuddering air, and faded to a shrill wailing, passing with the wind, a voice bodiless and thin that died, and was swallowed up, and was never heard again in that age of this world

Wait, wut? Absolutely amazing passage, but that's not how it goes down in the Swedish translation:

Eowyn! Eowyn! skrek Merry. Raglande rätade han upp sig och med uppbjudande av sin sista styrka drev han med otroligt hugg sin klinga mitt mellan kronan och manteln när de breda axlarna böjde sig ner mot henne.

Which translates to:

Eowyn! Eowyn! cried Merry. Staggering he stood up straight and with the last of his strength he drove with an incredible slice his blade right between the crown and the mantle as the broad shoulders bent down on her.

What the shit? For twenty fucking years I've been labouring under the misapprehension that Merry was the one who killed the Witch King. I always imagined that Eowyn killing the bastard was an invention of Peter Jackson's.

But no, turns out I've been mislead for most of my life by a faulty translation.

Holy Christ. The worst thing is that I have told dozens of people: "Yeah, no, in the book it's actually Merry who kills the Witch King." I've been adamant on this point, because it was in the book!

Fuck you, Åke Ohlmarks.


r/tolkienfans • • Jan 19 '20

It was awfully nice of the 13 Dwarves to empty Bilbos larder before they were off so nothing would rot while he was gone.

2.8k Upvotes

r/tolkienfans • • Apr 01 '26 Polished Gold Turd LOL Annoyed Bravo Mindblown

Is anyone else outraged by the news that all new print editions of Lord of the Rings will be heavily edited to "align with Peter Jackson's film trilogy"?

2.8k Upvotes

We knew this was coming mindful of how the rights to the book are held, but I can't believe it's finally happening. The details still aren't clear, but from what I gather we're losing Tom Bombadil, the Barrow Downs, Old Forest, and the entire "Scouring" subplot. Boromir will likely change significantly, too, and there will now be involvement of Elves in the Battle of Helms Deep. Worst of all, it's been confirmed that the revised edition "will be considered canon," so the changes will likely affect other works too, including The Silmarillion.

Anyway, if you've read this far, please rest assured that I don't know half of you half as well as I should like; and I like less than half of you half as well as you deserve. But here we all are, on April 1st.

April Fools, fellow Tolkien lovers!

(Mods, please let this stay for a bit!)


r/tolkienfans • • Mar 13 '21

The passage that Tolkien apparently wept over as he was writing it

2.6k Upvotes

I read in more than one place recently that the following passage from the chapter 'The Stairs of Cirith Ungol' made Tolkien weep as he wrote it, and it is said elsewhere that this is the passage that most moved Tolkien from his own writing. It follows my favourite passage of the book, the exchange between Frodo and Sam at the top of the stairs. But this short passage about Gollum is key to his character and so desperately sad, and gives greater nuance to his character than is often portrayed in pop culture, and (I think) in the Jackson films:

"Gollum looked at them. A strange expression passed over his lean hungry face. The gleam faded from his eyes and they went dim and grey, old and tired. A spasm of pain seemed to twist him, and he turned away, peering back up towards the pass, shaking his head, as if engaged in some interior debate. Then he came back, and slowly putting out a trembling hand, very cautiously he touched Frodo’s knee- but almost the touch was a caress. For a fleeting moment, could one of the sleepers have seen him, they would have thought that they beheld an old weary hobbit, shrunken by the years that had carried him far beyond his time, beyond friends and kin, and the fields and streams of youth, an old starved pitiable thing.”


r/tolkienfans • • Mar 01 '22

Priscilla Tolkien dies at 93 after a short illness

2.5k Upvotes

With sadness it has been announced that Priscilla Tolkien, J.R.R. Tolkien’s youngest child and only daughter has died.

https://www.lmh.ox.ac.uk/news/memory-priscilla-tolkien


r/tolkienfans • • Aug 28 '19

I'm just wondering, what was Tolkien's opinion about the Hudson FY35 Forklift Truck, capable of lifting 7700 lbs?

2.5k Upvotes

The forklift comes equipped with a Japanese NISSAN K25 Engine, a Dual-fuel LPG fixture, wide-view Triplex 16.4 feet (5 meter) full-free mast, air tires, 42 inch (1070mm) fork length, a Toyota seat with seatbelt, Hydraulic transmission, and is available in orange.


r/tolkienfans • • Jan 03 '19

127 years ago today J.R.R. Tolkien was born; Happy Birthday, sir, and thank you for your work.

2.1k Upvotes

r/tolkienfans • • Dec 15 '25 This

"Tolkien created a sentient race whose only narrative function was to be slaughtered, sans remorse, then spent the rest of his life trying to explain why that was not genocide."

2.1k Upvotes

Article by a writer on facebook about Tolkien never extending mercy to orcs in the books even though they were sentient. What do you think?

Copy-pasted the article here, direct link here.

Tolkien created a sentient race whose only narrative function was to be slaughtered, sans remorse, then spent the rest of his life trying to explain why that was not genocide.

This is no glib provocation; this is the unresolved moral fault line running beneath The Lord of the Rings, one even Tolkien himself never managed to seal. Orcs are not elemental evil like a storm or a plague. They are not mindless beasts. They speak and reason and complain and fear punishment and resent authority and attempt escape. They live under systems of terror they did not choose and cannot leave. And yet the story requires their mass death as a moral good.

The entirety of Tolkien's cosmology clings to one rule: Evil cannot create. It can only corrupt. Life comes from Ilúvatar, and Ilúvatar alone. Morgoth and Sauron are parasites, not gods. This theological commitment renders the existence of orcs immediately perilous. Should orcs be alive, they must therefore possess souls. Should they possess souls, they must have moral agency, however damaged. And should they have agency, then their extermination becomes morally incoherent.

Tolkien knew this. He never left the problem alone.

In letters, Tolkien returns again and again to the origin of orcs, because no version holds. If orcs are corrupted Elves, then immortal souls are irreversibly damned for crimes they did not commit. If they are corrupted Men, then they are moral agents shaped by terror, breeding, and coercion, punished eternally for circumstances of birth. If they are beasts taught to speak, then Tolkien's own writing betrays him, because beasts do not debate rations, fear punishment, or desert abusive masters.

Every solution collapses into yet another moral defeat.

The orcs we encounter in the book act less like metaphysical evil and more like an underclass caught within a totalitarian war economy: beaten by superiors, starved for discipline, killed for disobedience, rewarded only with survival. Their cruelty is real, but also systemic. Violence is not an aberration. It is the only currency available.

The story gives them no choice.

Unlike every other fallen entity in Middle-earth, orcs are withheld even a theoretical possibility of redemption. Boromir falls and is mourned. Gollum betrays and is pitied. Saruman destroys himself through pride but is given chances to repent. Orcs are killed on sight. Mercy is never extended. No moral calculus is applied. Their deaths are treated as a cleansing necessity.

This is not incidental, this is structural.

The heroes of Middle-earth must remain morally pure. To preserve that purity, Tolkien creates a population whose lives do not count. The war must be total and total war demands enemies who can be erased without residue. Orcs exist to absorb moral violence so that the protagonists do not have to.

The chill comes faster nowadays. We know this logic. We've seen it before-entire populations declared irredeemable, inherited guilt treated as destiny, violence justified as tragic only because it is preemptive and cleansing. The logic was here long before Tolkien ever put pen to paper, but at least he managed to encode it into myth with unnerving efficiency.

To be clear, Tolkien was not a fascist, nor did he endorse racial extermination. He detested industrialized slaughter. He abhorred Nazi racial theory. He was, by all evidence, a man deeply uneasy with cruelty. That unease is precisely why the orcs matter.

They are where his values are compromised under stress.

Tolkien wanted a universe where mercy mattered absolutely, where pity could reshape fate, where even the tiniest moral act echoed beyond its immediate outcome. Orcs rupture that vision. There is no Frodo moment for them. No spared life that later shifts history. Their existence demands violence without grace, and the story complies.

Tolkien motions toward a cosmic cure. Privately, he speculates that orcs may, after their deaths, be cured of their brokenness, their wills freed by Ilúvatar outside of the world's bounds. This is telling. The possibility of redemption is displaced backstage, delayed beyond narrative accountability. The story itself can't contain it.

That displacement ought to cause us concern.

Because Tolkien accidentally speaks to a truth that modern ethics struggles to confront: systems can create cruelty so complete that individual moral choice becomes almost irrelevant; people can be born into violence so total that survival itself becomes complicity. It doesn't get one off the hook, but it does fracture simplistic notions of blame.

The orcs expose that fracture. They are not evil incarnate. They are what happens when corruption becomes hereditary and violence becomes infrastructure. Tolkien set out to write none of this indictment, nor could he write around it, either.

The tragedy is not that orcs die, the tragedy is that Tolkien was never able to find a way to let them live and still keep his world intact. That unresolved tension is why orcs remain the most unsettling thing in Middle-earth. They are the evidence that even a myth built on mercy can require someone to be beyond it. And once you see that, the moral clarity of the story never quite returns.

The orcs talk. And because they talk, Tolkien's world is forced to confront a question it cannot answer: who deserves to be saved, and who must be erased so the story can go on?


r/tolkienfans • • Jan 14 '26

Aragorn's rant about the herb master may be my favourite part of the entire trilogy.

2.0k Upvotes

Seriously, I was listening to the Serkis audiobook last night, and I couldn't stop laughing for a long while.

‘Master Meriadoc,’ said Aragorn, ‘if you think that I have passed through the mountains and the realm of Gondor with fire and sword to bring herbs to a careless soldier who throws away his gear, you are mistaken. If your pack has not been found, then you must send for the herb-master of this House. And he will tell you that he did not know that the herb you desire had any virtues, but that it is called westmansweed by the vulgar, and galenas by the noble, and other names in other tongues more learned, and after adding a few half-forgotten rhymes that he does not understand, he will regretfully inform you that there is none in the House, and he will leave you to reflect on the history of tongues. And so now must I. For I have not slept in such a bed as this, since I rode from Dunharrow, nor eaten since the dark before dawn.’

Pippin revealing that his pack was sitting right next to his bed the whole time, something Aragon was perfectly aware of was just the icing on the cake


r/tolkienfans • • Oct 29 '20

Tolkien died in 1973. Which, backwards, is 3791. 3 rings for the elven kings, 7 for the dwarf lords, 9 for men, and 1 ring to rule them all.

2.0k Upvotes

I just learned this from a YouTube comment, and my mind is blown.

Because I learned something from a YouTube comment.

Also, because of this amazing coincidence.

I imagine this is old news to some here, but I am one of today’s lucky 10,000 and I had to share.

It was a comment by “rdagst Sousa” on the Epic Rap Battles of History video featuring JRRT and GRRM.

That is all. Please carry on, and Happy Halloween.


r/tolkienfans • • Jul 23 '26

Sauron wasn't an idiot with a huge blind spot for not planning on the Ring being destroyed. (Most) People don't understand how ludicrous the idea of destroying the Ring in Mount Doom really was.

1.8k Upvotes

Maybe I'm preaching to the choir here, but I see comments about how Sauron should have just put guards at the entrance to Mount Doom or if he had just stayed at home and protected Mordor he would have won. While those takes aren't technically wrong, they typically make it seem like Sauron was an idiot for not having through the problem properly.

Sauron wasn't dumb. It was unfathomable to almost anyone that this would be possible.

Very few people even knew what the Ring was.
Sauron sent an emissary to the Dwarves before the Council of Elrond essentially asking if they could help him get the Ring back because it was a trinket he missed. He offered them Rings of Power and Moria in return. Realize this is the same line of Dwarves that Thorin's father Thrain led at one point, who literally had a Ring of Power. These Dwarves were so unlearned in Ring-lore that they had to go to Rivendell just to understand what was really going on. Boromir didn't know what Isildur's Bane was. Denethor, who was actually one of the wisest and cleverest people in all of Middle Earth, also didn't know and sent his favored son on a wild goose chase to a mythical realm they didn't know where it was and it took him over 100 days of travel to find it. Only Elrond, Galadriel, Gandalf, Aragorn, and a handful of other Elves (and the Istari) even understood the real importance of the Ring.

Sauron knew a halfling named Baggins who lived in the Shire had found it. He didn't even know where the Shire was and barely had an understanding of what a Hobbit was. It's a small miracle (not a coincidence. This is Eru pulling the strings) that Gandalf was aware of the location of the One Ring. The overwhelming likelihood was that the Nazgul could search the area, find the Ring before it went to anyone who knew what it was, retrieve it, and then Sauron wins. It was literally an act of God (through Gandalf having been part of the mission that led to Bilbo finding the Ring) that got Frodo out of the Shire in time.

Using it was what the Vast Majority of People would do
Imagine you're at war. The enemy has a larger army, a better stronghold, and isn't pressed for time. You are aware defeat is inevitable if the war doesn't end soon. Let's suggest you're one of the allied forces in WW2, but Hitler's army is significantly stronger than it was in real life (maybe the USSR made a real alliance with them and they fought together as a united front indefinitely). Hitler's scientists created a nuclear weapon, but the only way to use it is a specific batch of Uranium that you got in an accidental mistake, and you also have the ability to make your own bomb if you so choose.

The only problem with this analogy is that destroying the Ring destroyed Sauron (although they weren't 100% sure that would happen. It was only Gandalf's (correct) assumption). But the point is, you're fighting a hopeless war, and now you have an opportunity to gain the upper hand. Lots of readers look at Boromir as weak-minded that he wanted to use the ring, but that's what the vast vast vast majority of people would do. Gandalf himself even stated that if he possessed the Ring, he would eventually use it trying to do good, but through him it would have too much power. In the real world, the Allied Powers did develop a nuclear bomb before Hitler did, and they used it. Now, were the Allied Leaders the peak of Morality? No. But the point is, in the real world, when presented the most similar situation, mankind used the weapon.

This is really the critical section in my opinion. People often act like destroying it was the obvious answer (I'll get to why that's not true in a later section). But using it was a much more obvious answer. The Free Peoples of Middle Earth had their backs up against the wall, and a tool that could change the tides of the war fell into their laps. This isn't even to mention the fact that the Ring corrupts you, and there's a high possibility if you did want to destroy it, that you would convince yourself, "I'll just use it to defeat Sauron, and then destroy it afterwards when he's out of the way." 99.9999% of us would react the way Boromir did. It was an opportunity to save his friends and family, and the longer it took to defeat Sauron, the more of his people would die.

I wish I were more eloquent. I cannot stress this section enough. We all think we're better than we are and choosing to destroy the one Ring sounds so obvious to us. But in reality, using the one Ring was much easier, had obvious upsides, and really could have ended the war (against Sauron). This was by far the most obvious choice to the point where it's almost impossible to do anything else.

The Ring will corrupt you into using it.
In addition to all of this, the Ring would corrupt you into using it. Any person who had it for a sufficient amount of time will use the Ring. The only two people to touch the Ring and not use it are Deagol, who was murdered before he had the chance, and Gandalf, who cast it in the fire of Bag End (knowing it wouldn't be harmed) immediately to prove it was the One Ring.

The only reason Frodo made it to Mount Doom was because he was by nature unambitious and lacked power. The more powerful you are, the faster the Ring would corrupt you. Frodo was the perfect mixture of wise and ignorant. He was wise enough to not want to use the Ring, but ignorant enough that when he did use it, he didn't have the will to claim it. Any of the more obvious Ring Bearers (Gandalf, Galadriel, Aragorn, Glorfindel, etc.) would have claimed the Ring the moment they used it. That would corrupt them to the point of no return after a single use.

Remember, Sauron didn't even really know what a Hobbit was. Most people didn't even know what a Hobbit was. When Merry met Theoden, he was astounded Theoden had a vague idea of what a Hobbit was. The idea that there was a being out there that could put on the Ring without claiming it was foreign to him. People still ask why didn't Glorfindel go on the mission with the Fellowship. We use our logic to say let's put the most powerful being/wisest on the most important tasks. Logic dictates the Ring should be trusted with a person who has sufficient stature to bear it. Instead, they chose a weak person to keep it. It was very reasonable to expect someone of high standing to be the Ring Bearer. It was a impressively wise choice to leave it with a Hobbit, and Sauron didn't even have awareness this was a possibility because no one even knew what a Hobbit was. He literally didn't know it was a possibility for a being of such low-standing ambition to have the Ring.

Destroying it was literally impossible except for an Act of God
There were only two ways to destroy the Ring. Have a craftsman of superior skill to Sauron unmake the Ring, or cast it into Mount Doom. No such craftsman existed in Middle Earth during the Third Age, and the Valar, most Maiar, the Vanyar, and most Noldor (especially the most learned Noldor) were in Valinor and would never return to Middle Earth. The Council of Elrond also agreed that sailing the Ring to Valinor isn't a possibility because they would be turned away. This gets a bit meta, but this is the point in Tolkien's legendarium where the hierarchy of angels were essentially telling the peoples of Middle Earth it's up to you now, similar to how Catholicism doesn't expect Angels or God to come solve our problems for us.

This meant the only way to destroy it was casting it in the fires of Mount Doom, which was literally impossible. The previous section was about how the Ring would corrupt you, but it gets even stronger the closer to Mount Doom you get. Sauron could have invited Frodo to Mount Doom, flown in him, fed him a feast and had a celebration for him, and welcomed him with open arms into Mount Doom and told him, "go ahead and destroy it," and Tolkien explicitly stated in Letter 246 that he wouldn't have been able to. The only reason this plan worked was Gollum came along (against Frodo's will) and their fight led to him falling into the fires with the Ring. It was literally an act of Eru that allowed for this to happen.

Summary:
It took a being Sauron didn't even know existed, multiple acts of God, and humility beyond comprehension (by both Frodo and the rest of the Council for letting Frodo keep it) for the Ring to not get back to Sauron. His actions weren't that of an idiot, but instead of someone planning for the 99.9999% of responses, and the 0.0001% is what actually happened.


r/tolkienfans • • Nov 21 '19

Happy birthday to Christopher Tolkien who turns 95 today.

1.8k Upvotes

We all owe him an enormous debt for his years of tireless work to bring his father's works into our homes.

You and me - we know that land

And often have been there

In the long old days, old nursery days,

A dark child and a fair.

Was it down the paths of firelight dreams

In winter cold and white,

Or in the blue-spun twilit hours

Of little early tucked-up beds

In drowsy summer night,

That You and I got lost in Sleep

And met each other there-

Your dark hair on your white nightgown,

And mine was tangled fair?

The first paragraph of my favourite writing by any writer You & Me / and the Cottage of Lost Play.


r/tolkienfans • • Feb 27 '21

Shout out to everyone on this sub, especially the mods. This is probably one of the most intellectual, decent subs out there.

1.7k Upvotes

I’ve been re-reading LOTR, and as much as I absolutely love Tolkien’s writing style, sometimes the depth of the lore and history can be a bit overwhelming.

I use this sub as a reference regularly now, I didn’t think I could get any more fascinated with Tolkien’s world. Most of the discussions here are thought provoking as hell.

Hoppin over to the Silmarillion next. Thank you all for being a part of this.


r/tolkienfans • • May 06 '20 This

I was today years old when I learned that Sauron was defeated not by Isildur cutting the Ring off, but by wounds he sustained from fighting Elendil and Gil-Galad.

1.6k Upvotes

One of my favorite pieces of art from the Jackson movies is this marvelous painting that depicts a desperate Isildur wielding his father's broken sword against an imposing Sauron. We also get this version from the prologue; Isildur is the hero that miraculously defeats Sauron, and the roles of Elendil and Gil-Galad are downplayed.

But the text suggests that Sauron had already fallen in his fight with Elendil and Gil-Galad, and Isildur merely had to walk up and cut the Ring off his finger. This is from Elrond:

‘I was the herald of Gil-galad and marched with his host. I was at the Battle of Dagorlad before the Black Gate of Mordor, where we had the mastery: for the Spear of Gil-galad and the Sword of Elendil, Aeglos and Narsil, none could withstand. I beheld the last combat on the slopes of Orodruin, where Gil-galad died, and Elendil fell, and Narsil broke beneath him; but Sauron himself was overthrown, and Isildur cut the Ring from his hand with the hilt-shard of his father’s sword, and took it for his own.’

The Fellowship of the Ring, Book Two, Chapter 2: The Council of Elrond

A very similar passage is presented in Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age section of The Silmarillion:

But at the last the siege was so strait that Sauron himself came forth; and he wrestled with Gil-galad and Elendil, and they both were slain, and the sword of Elendil broke under him as he fell. But Sauron also was thrown down, and with the hilt-shard of Narsil Isildur cut the Ruling Ring from the hand of Sauron and took it for his own.

All of this is a little ambiguous. Was Sauron defeated by Elendil and Gil-Galad, or by Isildur cutting the Ring off? Well Tolkien is a little more clear in Letter 151 to Milton Waldmen, which can be found near the beginning of The Silmarillion:

It ends with the overthrow of Sauron and destruction of the second visible incarnation of evil. But at a cost, and with one disastrous mistake. Gilgalad and Elendil are slain in the act of slaying Sauron. Isildur, Elendil’s son, cuts the ring from Sauron’s hand, and his power departs, and his spirit flees into the shadows.

So what do y'all think? Clearly Sauron's spirit was not vanquished until the Ring is removed from him, but I think any version that shows Isildur fighting Sauron directly is totally fabricated. And then the question should be asked, why is Isildur considered such a hero if Gil-Galad and Elendil did all the heavy lifting?


r/tolkienfans • • Sep 08 '22

Rest In Peace to Queen Elizabeth II. Fun Tolkien-related fact: she appointed Tolkien a Commander of the Order of the British Empire in the New Year Honours of 1 January 1972 "For services to English Literature".

1.6k Upvotes

With how global the Tolkien community has become, I know the passing of a British monarch may not affect all of us the same, if at all. But in light of the news of her passing today, I felt like mentioning her place in Tolkien history, and I respect her appreciation for Tolkien’s literary contributions. Feel free to share your thoughts


r/tolkienfans • • Mar 29 '26

Ever wonder why Rosie had been expecting Sam since the spring? Well, here's the answer.

1.6k Upvotes

When Sam is reunited with Rose Cotton, she greets him with: "‘Hullo, Sam!’ said Rosie. ‘Where’ve you been? They said you were dead; but I’ve been expecting you since the spring. You haven’t hurried, have you?’"

As far as the published text goes, this is a mystery, But it is explained in the unpublished Epilogue, near the end of which Sam reminds Rose that it is Marth 25, the seventeenth anniversary of the fall of Sauron, a day when he had given up hope of ever seeing her again:

“I never hoped at all, Sam,” she said, “not until that very day, and then I did. About noon it was, and I felt so glad that I began singing. And mother said, 'Quiet, lass! There's ruffians about.' And I said 'Let them come! Their time will soon be over. Sam's coming back.' And you came.”

HoME IX p. 128..

The obvious explanation for Rose's sudden feeling of joy is that she shared in the spontaneous elation experienced on the same day by the people of Minas Tirith, described in “The Steward and the King,” when “in all the houses of the City men sang for the joy that welled up in their hearts from what cause they could not tell.”

The question that remains is why the sudden, unexplained impulse to sing is felt only by Rose, among all the hobbits of the Shire. I think it may have been related, in Tolkien's mind, to the fact that in all four Gospels, women were the first people to learn of the Resurrection. A similar thought has occurred to me in connection with the fact that Ioreth is the first person in Gondor to recognize Aragorn as King,


r/tolkienfans • • May 03 '16

The Two Towers Ultra

1.5k Upvotes

Post with pics here http://imgur.com/a/r4nk2

I've really got into running recently. Most of my training runs take me through the prairies of southern Wisconsin (Rohan). As my mind wonders, I childishly imagine myself as a member of the Three Hunters tracking an Orc pack.

Hey, I wonder how far they actually ran?

Before we begin our journey we should settle on defining time and distance.

TIME: In the books, the characters read time in relation to three positions of the sun: sunrise, noon, and sunset. Noon is obviously 12:00, but when is sunset and sunrise? We need a two pieces of information: our heroes’ latitude and the time of year. Middle Earth is actually very ancient Europe. It is possible to overlap the two maps in a way that the scales match. Emyn Muil, the stony, hill land where the Hunters begin their run is located roughly on the 41st parallel. We also know that the Fellowship arrive at Parth Galen on the banks of Anduin on February 18th and spend the night. With this information, we can begin to define the days of their journey.

DISTANCE: Characters measure distances in terms of ‘leagues,’ the equivalent of three miles.

Now that we have our measurements, onward for Gondor! On February 19th, after a day of fighting Saruman’s Urukai and giving up their friend Boromir’s body (RIP Sean Bean) to the roaring falls of Rauros, Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli set out to pursue the Orcs and rescue Merry and Pippin. Fun fact: their pursuit was not a given. They debated following Frodo and Sam to Mordor. According to Aragorn, “I would have guided Frodo to Mordor and gone with him to the end; but if I seek him now in the wilderness, I must abandon the captives to torment and death.” They depart from the glade where Boromir was slain, which is about a mile from Parth Galen, the place at the banks of Anduin where the Fellowship had rested the night before. The afternoon was fading. The shadows begin to lengthen with the coming of dusk. I estimate that they leave the glade around 17:15. The Hunters run through the night. At dawn, they reach the plains of the Rohirrim and keep running, stopping only twice for short breaks. Finally, as sunset approaches on February 20th, they halt and decide to rest for fear of losing the trail in the dark. The sun sets at 17:48. I estimate the distance traveled so far to be roughly 24 leagues, or 72 miles in 24 hours 33 minutes. If you’re keeping track, that’s an average pace of about 20 minutes per mile. The Hunters sleep.

The sun rises on February 21st at 6:58. Our heroes march again until sunset at 17:50 without stopping. Twelve more leagues in 10 hours 51 minutes for an average pace of roughly 18 minutes per mile. Sunrise on February 22nd at 6:57 finds the Hunters weary and full of despair as they begin to lose any hope of catching their quarry. They march until sunset (17:51) for an estimated 9 leagues. That’s a slower average pace of over 37 minutes per mile. On this final night they rest on a hilltop with the Misty Mountains and Fangorn Forest far in the distance.

This marks the end of their trek on foot. In the morning Legolas and his binocular elf eyes spot a group of riders merely five leagues away bearing down on them. They descend the hill and await their arrival. After a brief and fiery discussion with Eomer, they continue their journey on horseback.

135 miles in 72 hours, 34 minutes? 32 minutes per mile? Let’s take a closer look at what Aragorn probably went through (he’s pretty much human. (While grueling for Gimli, the journey was not outside the heroic feats of Dwarves. And it was probably just a nice day for a run for Legolas.).

After a night of poor sleep, have a night of breakfast and run around for a few hours fighting super orcs in a dense forest on the side of a hill. Oh, and after that, row your companion’s body (RIP Sean Bean—again) out into the current of a raging waterfall then row back to shore and hurry up every wasted second is a second your quarry is using to sprint away from you.

And now you're ready to begin. The sun is setting, so have fun running in the dark through the western range of Emyn Muil. To traverse through the rocky labyrinth, you need to tackle two separate ridges. Although the uphill is gently sloped, you risk getting lost in the maze of dead-end ravines. After you reach the top of the first ridge, you see that the other slope falls much more steeply into the night. After you make it to the bottom, repeat once more.

If you've been keeping pace with the King of Gondor you’ve reached the East Wall of Rohan, a steep face of sheer rock. After you make it down the cliff, it’s time for an easy 36 mile training run. You can have two short breaks.

At sun up it’s time for another 36 mile jog. Try not to think about the fact that while you slept the super Orcs kept running. At the end of the day you reach the downs, a hilly section of land that slopes up and down as you near the Entwash. The hills go on as far as ol’ Eagle Eyes can see, so you’ll have that to look forward to tomorrow after a cold night of fitful sleep.

The next day will consist of an easy 27 mile jog. Congrats, you’ve finished the Two Towers Ultra! But you’re friends are probably going to die horribly in Isengard. RIP.

Three more factors are a constant through the entire journey. First, you’re not running down a trail, you’re tracking for a trail, so hopefully you have decades of wilderness experience.

Let’s not forget your gear, which includes: sword, bow, quiver, arrows, hunting knife, leather/cloth clothing (imagine the opposite of UnderArmor), leather boots (maybe they had gel soles?), a flask of water, some lembas bread, and an Elvish cloak.

Finally, a crazy wizard has bent his will and his power against your purpose. He works to darken the moon and stars, making tracking at night impossible. His magic also works on your strength of will. Are you up for the challenge?

A final thought: What did the Three Hunters run for? They ran for friendship, for freedom, and for Good. What do you run for?

tl;dr: Aragorn is a badass and an ultramarathoner, running 135 miles in 72 hours. Legolas can see far. RIP Sean Bean.

edit: duplicate sentence

EDIT: Silly me, I failed to convert from Shire Reckoning Calendar to the Gregorian calendar when calculating sunset/rise. The times above have been adjusted. All glory to Uluithiad!

Edit frontpage: Hey I'm glad everyone enjoyed the post! I for one am really enjoying the discussion too. I think we need to add one more condition that I hadn't considered until reading the comments: it's not like if/when they caught up to the Orcs their job was done. They were probably anticipating fighting an Orc hoard. My God, could you imagine? "Congratulations, you've finished the Sean Bean Memorial Ultra, hope you have enough strength left to actually battle your enemies who outnumber you greatly and rescue the hostages."


r/tolkienfans • • Mar 16 '20

"Some who have read the book, or at any rate have reviewed it, have found it boring, absurd, or comtemptible; and I have no cause to complain, since I have similar opinions of their works" J.R.R. Tolkien

1.5k Upvotes

Tolkien was throwing some serious shade in the forward to my copy of Fellowship


r/tolkienfans • • Oct 12 '26 Despair Regret Heartwarming

My wife passed last week, Tolkien's work is the only thing that has given me anything close to peace

1.5k Upvotes

My partner of thirteen years and wife of thirteen days passed away last week. I cannot begin to express the grief and hopelessness I have felt in the intervening days; despite having family and friends close by, nothing has given me any real comfort or peace.

But throughout her battle with cancer, and particularly over the final few weeks my mind has returned constantly to Tolkien's work.

We were both huge LOTR fans, we made it an annual (minimum) tradition to watch the extended movies. We last watched them this summer after she had been diagnosed. Like I'm sure everyone else here, I have always loved and admired Sam and the strength of his character, but watching in this new context I felt a totally new understanding and empathy for him. My wife was my Frodo, I promised I would follow her through whatever fire and hell she would go through and I kept my promise. And I kept Sam in mind through it all. When the scene came where Frodo is lying, seemingly lifeless, in Shelob's lair and Sam begs him "Don't go where I can't follow", I felt like I could hardly breath. We did both manage to make it to the end of the trilogy; until the fellowship is finally broken at the Grey Havens and my wife burst into tears. We were both feeling the same fear, that one day we too may have to part. I held her tight as Into the West played in the background. This was the first moment of true catharsis we had had together since she was diagnosed.

Her treatment continued for most of this year. In the moments she was well, we would talk about our future plans. One we looked forward to most was going to New Zealand, visiting the Shire and hiking the hills and mountains where we could pretend we were in Middle Earth.

But that wasn't to be. In mid September a PET scan revealed that her final round of chemo had also failed, and the doctor informed us that she would die within weeks. My world fell into utter shadow on that day, I hadn't cried for twenty years before that but it felt like all the tears I should have shed in that time came bursting out of me, she was going where I couldn't follow.

The next day I asked her to marry me. The nurses were amazing, they arranged a wedding in two days that was indistinguishable from one that had been in planning for two hundred! She wore a set of earrings which had on them the device of Lúthien Tinúviel. I had bought her them for valentines day this year and being the bigger nerd of the two of us I told her the story of Beren and Lúthien, and that she was my Lúthien. She read the story often after that, and wore the earrings constantly.

She entered our wedding to Evenstar and looked every bit as beautiful as Arwen. We had our first married kiss to Aniron and I couldn't keep the tears back. I was the happiest and yet most heartbroken I had ever been. Afterwards the nurse came to her room and, knowing we were big old nerds, thought we would like to know that we had coincidentally got married on Hobbit day, the 22nd of September, the day of Bilbo and Frodo's birthdays.

She came home the next day and I kept my promise to her. I kept watch over her day and night for nearly two weeks, catching sleeps of a half hour at a time whenever I could. And then she left me. There was no poetry there, no metaphor, nothing in Tolkien or any other work of fiction that could ever accurately describe the absolute desolation of losing the person who made your world green and beautiful.

I'm planning her funeral now, I feel such a huge weight to do her justice, which obviously I could never really do. But I have made sure our shared love of Tolkien's work is well represented. She will be laid to rest to Into the West, as played by the Prague Philharmonic Orchestra, and I will read a quote that represents the hope she made me promise to hold on to.

"Far above the Ephel Dúath in the West the night-sky was still dim and pale. There, peeping among the cloud-wrack above a dark tor high up in the mountains, Sam saw a white star twinkle for a while. The beauty of it smote his heart, as he looked up out of the forsaken land, and hope returned to him. For like a shaft, clear and cold, the thought pierced him that in the end the Shadow was only a small and passing thing: there was light and high beauty for ever beyond its reach."

Her passing is a dark thing, and it is right that it brings sorrow and pain beyond description. But such darkness cannot be allowed to obscure the light and high beauty that was my wife's life.

I am glad I have Tolkien's words in my life. This is an unbearable pain to carry, but through his world and the characters that inhabit it, I have found a way to express and understand my feelings better than I otherwise could.


r/tolkienfans • • Aug 15 '22 Bravo Take My Silver

Recommended Reading for Tolkien Fans

1.5k Upvotes

A frequently asked question in this sub-reddit is, "I'm just getting into Tolkien, and wonder what I should read, and in what order?" This post is intended to help answer that question.

Basics:

The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings

First, read The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings (which is really one novel, published in three volumes). I'd recommend that order, but it doesn't matter that much. Keep in mind that The Hobbit was definitely written for children, and The Lord of the Rings was not. Also, read the Appendices to The Lord of the Rings, especially Appendices A and B.

The Legendarium:

The Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales

After you've read the basics, you have a choice: You can read The Children of Húrin (see below) or go straight to The Silmarillion. To some extent which you read first depends on how you reacted to the Appendices — if your reaction was, "This is so cool! Where can I get more of this!", jump straight into The Silmarillion; otherwise read The Children of Húrin, which will give you a somewhat easier introduction to the style and substance of Tolkien's other works. Overall they are much darker and denser than the better-known novels. If you enjoy The Children of Húrin, by all means read The Silmarillion. Don't be afraid to skip around in it or take notes. Whichever path you choose, the next step should be Unfinished Tales. I also recommend reading Tolkien's Letters at this point.

The Children of Húrin, Beren and Lúthien, The Fall of Gondolin, The Fall of Númenor

The first three books are self-contained versions of the three "Great Tales" of the Legendarium. The first is presented as a continuous narrative, as the tale of the unfortunate Túrin Turambar was the most complete of these stories. The latter two present all the material on these two tales from the relevant volumes of The History of Middle-earth (see below), put into appropriate order, and are intended to provide a full telling of each saga, albeit sometimes with material from different stages of development. The Fall of Númenor, edited by Brian Sibley, is similar to Beren and Lúthien and The Fall of Gondolin, in that it contains all the relevant texts about Númenor's rise and fall. It's a bit different in that the texts are keyed to the Tale Of Years and vary considerably in length and depth, but it provides an excellent overview of the history of Westernesse.

The History of Middle-earth and The History of The Hobbit

Both the Letters and the Tales show Tolkien's mind at work as well as providing more details about his world. If you like that sort of thing and want more, there is the 12-volume (yes, twelve) History of Middle-earth series, which is a blow-by-blow presentation of the manuscripts Tolkien wrote for his legendarium, including the history of the writing of The Lord of the Rings. Some of us think this is the greatest thing ever, being able to peer over the shoulder of the Creator at work, while for others it is far too reminiscent of college English classes. Your call. There's also The History of The Hobbit, by John Rateliff, which does the same for The Hobbit. On first reading of any of these you may wish to simply read the manuscripts and ignore Christopher Tolkien's or John Rateliff's commentary. Also, if you decide that The Silmarillion and related matter is not to your taste, you should be aware that Volumes 6 – 9 of The History of Middle-earth cover The Lord of the Rings, and you may very well find it fascinating how Tolkien developed his masterpiece.

Some more detail on what's in The History of Middle-earth:

I. The Book of Lost Tales, Part 1

II. The Book of Lost Tales, Part 2

The Book of Lost Tales was Tolkien's first go at creating his mythology. It is sort of a proto-Silmarillion; all of the tales are retold in other forms in the later works, but here Tolkien is a very young writer feeling his way.

III. The Lays of Beleriand

"The Lay of Leithian" — the tale of Beren and Lúthien, in several variants, and "The Lay of the Children of Húrin", told in rhyming couplets and alliterative verse, respectively. There are also the fragments of some additional alliterative poems.

IV. The Shaping of Middle-earth

V. The Lost Road and Other Writings

These two volumes comprise the early Silmarillion, a more mature version of what originated in The Book of Lost Tales. The first part of Volume V, from which it takes its title, is a history of Númenor. Volume V also contains a significant amount of information on the Elvish languages.

VI. The Return of the Shadow

VII. The Treason of Isengard

VIII. The War of the Ring

IX. Sauron Defeated

These four volumes cover the history of the writing of The Lord of the Rings. Volume IX also includes "The Notion Club Papers", which is another attempt to tell the tale of Númenor.

X. Morgoth's Ring

XI. The War of the Jewels

These two cover the later Silmarillion, that is, Tolkien's work on it following the publication of The Lord of the Rings.

XII. The Peoples of Middle-earth

This final volume covers the writing of the Appendices to The Lord of the Rings and also some other miscellaneous writings and unfinished tales.

An index to the complete series was originally published in trade paperback only (but the pagination is the same), and it's very valuable. (Unfortunately, the hardcover print-on-demand edition is no longer available from HarperCollins, and it doesn't seem that the edition being released with the new box sets (see below) will be available separately.) The complete series is also available in a three-volume set, which takes up a lot less shelf space but can be a bit awkward to read as the volumes are large and the paper quite thin. The series is also available in trade paperback format, and was recently reissued in hardback in four boxed sets which include The Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales, and the Index, with the first two being reprinted with the same pagination that is referenced in the HoMe volumes.

A very complete listing is given at the Mellonath Daeron website.

A closely related work is The Nature of Middle-earth, edited by Carl F. Hostetter, which contains many short essays and excerpts of essays similar to the material in The Peoples of Middle-earth. This volume was undertaken with Christopher Tolkien's encouragement and begun before his passing in early 2020. The material, mostly drawn from the same late period as the material in The Peoples of Middle-earth, touches on such things as how elves counted, their reproductive habits, how they aged, and many other topics besides.

The Languages

It's well known that Tolkien considered his invented languages the primary impetus for his creative writing. If this interests you, you can read Tolkien's Middle-earth linguistic writings, which are being published in the journals Parma Eldalamberon and Vinyar Tengwar. Of the latter, I highly recommend the freely downloadable copy of VT issue 43, which contains Tolkien's Quenya translations of the Paternoster ("Our Father"), the Ave Maria, and the Gloria Patri. All of the back issues of Vinyar Tengwar are now available on Amazon; information about ordering can be found on the Vinyar Tengwar website. Christopher Gilson has now undertaken to make the issues of Parma Eldalamberon available via a similar print-on-demand service. Some issues can be ordered via links on the PE site.

The Shorter Works

Tolkien wrote a lot of other things as well, most unrelated to Middle-earth, and some of them fairly scholarly. I'm going to list these with some brief commentary:

Short fiction

  • (1) Mr. Bliss: A children's picture book with a motor car, some cantankerous bears, and a girabbit.

  • (2) Roverandom: A story about the adventures of a toy dog, written somewhat before The Hobbit.

  • (3) The Father Christmas Letters/Letters from Father Christmas: Letters Tolkien wrote to his children, profusely illustrated. There are many different variants of these available.

  • (4) Farmer Giles of Ham: featuring a very fine dragon. Originally published in 1949 as a bit of a stopgap between The Hobbit and the then in-progress Lord of the Rings, it has appeared in several collections (see below). An expanded 50th anniversary edition, edited by Christina Scull and Wayne G. Hammond, was published in 1999, and contains a map, the original story outline, and Tolkien's notes for a possible sequel.

  • (5) Leaf by Niggle: a curiously allegorical story about a painter and a painting he can't seem to complete.

  • (6) The Adventures of Tom Bombadil: poems "from the Red Book". Published in 1962 as a standalone volume. An expanded version was released in 2014, edited by Christina Scull and Wayne G. Hammond, with some additional poems and notes.

  • (7) Bilbo's Last Song: a poem/song supposedly written by Bilbo as he traveled to the Havens. Originally released as a poster(!), later published as a small book.

  • (8) Smith of Wootton Major: the last story Tolkien wrote. An expanded version was published in 2015, edited by Verlyn Flieger, which contains the first draft of the story, an essay by Tolkien, and notes and an alternate ending to the tale.

  • (9) The Bovadium Fragments: Together with The Origin of Bovadium: Exact date of composition unknown, but likely in the 1960s. A "satirical fantasy," described by Clyde S. Kilby, one of those who had read it, as "an early comment on the commercialization of our world." Published in 2025 in an edition edited by Christopher Tolkien. "The Origin of Bovadium" is an essay about the situation in Oxford that inspired Tolkien's satire, written by the 25th Bodley's Librarian, Richard Ovenden. (If you're wondering why this wasn't published until more than five years after Christopher's death, it's because Ovenden didn't deliver his essay — which he agreed to write while Christopher was still with us — until then! It seems somehow appropriate that this volume was delayed by an author's inability to get something completed on time, given Tolkien's own propensity for delayed publications.)

Academic or semi-academic works

Many of these have been published in standalone volumes and I've indicated those herein.

  • (10) On Fairy Stories: a classic essay which describes in some detail what Tolkien was attempting with The Lord of the Rings. A single volume containing the essay, drafts, and related material, edited by Verlyn Flieger and Douglas A. Anderson, was published in 2008

  • (11) Beowulf: The Monsters and the Critics: one of the most influential articles ever written about "Beowulf". Michael D.C. Drout's book, Beowulf and the Critics, contains the original lectures that this was derived from along with some commentary and related material.

  • (12) "The Homecoming of Beorthnoth, Beorthelm's Son": A brief verse-drama based on "The Battle of Maldon", along with an essay on the poem. Originally published in Essays and Studies by Members of the English Association, Vol. 6. See the section on scholarly works below for more information on this text.

  • (13) The Legend of Sigurd and Gudrún: Tolkien's verse re-telling of a northern legend. Published in an edition by Christopher Tolkien.

  • (14) Sir Gawain and the Green Knight; Pearl; Sir Orfeo: Tolkien's modern English translations of three famous Middle-English poems. The first posthumous publication of Tolkien's work, released in 1975, edited by Christopher Tolkien.

  • (15) The Lay of Aotrou and Itroun: Originally published in The Welsh Journal, a poem in the style of a Breton Lay. Published in 2016 by HarperCollins with notes by Verlyn Flieger.

  • (16) The Story of Kullervo: Tolkien's (prose) retelling of the Tale of Kullervo from the Finnish epic poem Kalevala. The influence of this story on the "Tale of the Children of Húrin" is very notable. First published in the journal Tolkien Studies with commentary by Verlyn Flieger, later published by HarperCollins in 2015.

  • (17) Beowulf: A Translation and Commentary: A prose translation of "Beowulf", with notes and commentary. Tolkien never attempted a full alliterative verse translation of the poem, but he did translate some lines into that form, which are included in the essay cited above. The published edition of the prose translation also includes "Sellic Spell", a short tale by Tolkien reflecting his thoughts about the roots of the poem.

  • (18) A Secret Vice: An essay/lecture Tolkien wrote about the art of creating artificial languages like his Elvish tongues. An extended edition, edited by Dimitra Fimi and Andrew Higgins, was published in 2016.

  • (19) The Road Goes Ever On (with Donald Swann): A song cycle with musical settings by singer/pianist Donald Swann, which contains a significant essay by Tolkien on the poem "Namarië" and the Quenya language. The most recent edition contains a CD of Swann performing the music with vocalist William Elvin.

  • (20) The Fall of Arthur: An unfinished original poem in alliterative verse based on the Arthurian legends. Published in a volume with several interesting essays by Christopher Tolkien on the context of the poem and its composition.

  • (21) Tolkien's Lost Chaucer, edited by John M. Bowers: Covers the story of the discovery of the manuscripts for a student edition of Chaucer's works that Tolkien worked on early in his career; in the event, the edition never appeared and the manuscripts were thought to have been lost. This book contains images of some of the manuscript pages, details of the drafting of the book, how the manuscripts were rediscovered, and much about why the volume never appeared. Sadly, it doesn't contain the actual manuscripts.

  • (22) Tolkien on Chaucer: 1913 – 1959: Features many of Tolkien's writings on Chaucer, with extensive commentary by John M. Bowers and Peter Steffensen. It reprints a couple of Tolkien's academic papers on Chaucer that are otherwise somewhat difficult to find, and includes previously unpublished notes from the abortive edition discussed in item (21).

  • (23) The Keys of Middle-earth: Discovering Medieval Literature Through the Fiction of J.R.R. Tolkien: Might seem an odd thing to include here, but this book, by Stuart Lee and Elizabeth Solopova contains a number of excerpts from Tolkien's lecture notes about various medieval writings.

Many of these shorter works have been anthologized in various collections:

  • The Tolkien Reader: Contains 4, 5, 6, 9, and 11

  • Smith of Wootton Major and Farmer Giles of Ham: 4 and 8

  • Tree and Leaf: 5 and 9; later editions also contain the poem "Mythopoeia," which is referred to in 9

  • The Monsters and the Critics and Other Essays: 9, 10, 17, plus "On Translating Beowulf", "English and Welsh", an essay on "Sir Gawain", and his "Valedictory Address" on retiring from Oxford

  • A Tolkien Miscellany: 4, 6, 8, and "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight"

  • Tales from the Perilous Realm: 2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9

  • Poems and Stories: 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 11

HarperCollins recently released a boxed set titled Myths and Legends, containing items 13, 14, 17, and 20, all in hardcover editions.

Poetry

Tolkien published many poems in various magazines as well as, of course, in his fiction and in The Adventures of Tom Bombadil. Most of his poetry has now been published in a three-volume boxed set:

  • The Collected Poems of J.R.R. Tolkien: Edited by Christina Scull and Wayne G. Hammond, this contains more than 200 poems, many with variations, and extensive commentary. It does not contain all of his poetry; most of the works that are included in his novels are not included, nor are his longer works that have been published separately. About 1/3 of the poems included here have never been published before.

Art

Tolkien was an accomplished amateur artist and produced many sketches and paintings related to his work as well as other subjects. Several collections of his works have been published, and his publishers HarperCollins have now produced editions of The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings, and The Silmarillion illustrated with Tolkien's own art.

Pictures by J.R.R. Tolkien: There are three editions of this collection of images selected by Christopher Tolkien; the most recent is still in print and features newer, higher definition scans of the artwork.

J.R.R. Tolkien: Artist & Illustrator: A more general collection of Tolkien's art, with text by Wayne G. Hammond and Christina Scull.

The Art of the Hobbit: Text by Hammond and Scull.

The Art of The Lord of the Rings: Text by Hammond and Scull.

Tolkien: Maker of Middle-earth: A spectacular book assembled as part of the exhibition of Tolkien's art and manuscripts at the Bodleian Library at Oxford in 2018. Edited by Catherine McIlwaine, who is the curator of the Tolkien papers at the Bodleian.

Tolkien: Voyage en Terre du Milieu: Another spectacular book celebrating a similar exhibition held in France at the Bibliothèque François-Mitterand in 2019. Alas, the essays are in French.

J.R.R. Tolkien: The Art of the Manuscript: The catalog of the 2022 exhibit of Tolkien's manuscripts at Marquette University. The paperback second edition adds some remarks by Simon Tolkien.

Reference Works

These are works that are not by Tolkien but which are highly regarded as accurate.

The maps in The Lord of the Rings and The Silmarillion were redrawn by Christopher Tolkien from his father's work. However, the scale leaves a bit to be desired, so others have filled in the blanks, based on detailed reading of the texts. The gold standard here is the late Karen Wynn Fonstad's Atlas of Middle-earth — be sure to get the Second Edition, which includes information from The History of Middle-earth. Barbara Strachey's Journeys of Frodo is also very good and both will give you an idea of the difficulties of reconciling Bilbo's journey in The Hobbit with Frodo's later trip over the same territory — a problem even Tolkien found insoluble.

For a general reference, Robert Foster's Complete Guide to Middle-earth is well-regarded, and has the approbation of Christopher Tolkien, no less. A deluxe edition illustrated by Ted Nasmith was recently released by HarperCollins. It should be noted that J.E.A. Tyler's Complete Tolkien Companion is also a good reference.

Douglas A. Anderson's Annotated Hobbit contains much information about both the history of the text and its allusions and sources. Similarly, Wayne G. Hammond and Christina Scull have written The Lord of the Rings: A Reader's Companion, which contains similar annotations.

There's a now rather dated but still extremely useful bibliography by Wayne G. Hammond and Douglas A. Anderson, J.R.R. Tolkien: A Descriptive Bibliography, which is sadly out of print and trades for fairly high prices as a result. Quite worthwhile for collectors, though.

Addenda

I've added some comments below about less-common aspects of Tolkien's writing that people may be interested in.

Editions

Tolkien's works were a trial for his publishers and their typesetters, what with Elvish names, antiquated and idiosyncratic spellings, and so on. Much work has been done in the last 20 years by Christopher Tolkien and several others to correct the text — finally put into electronic form so a definitive version might actually be possible — so most modern editions are actually very close to what Tolkien intended, at least as far as can be determined. In the case of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, however, there's a slight complication: The versions currently in print are not what was originally printed; unlike most fiction, the terms second and third edition are actually meaningful for these works, as they were significantly revised.

The Hobbit

There are, for most practical purposes, three editions of The Hobbit. The first edition, published in 1937/1938, was very much a children's book and references to Tolkien's wider legendarium were more by way of background atmosphere than anything else. The writing of The Lord of the Rings and the much-enhanced significance of the Ring that Bilbo finds caused Tolkien to re-write a large portion of Chapter 5, "Riddles in the Dark", and tweak a few other related passages. These changes were incorporated into the second edition (1951), which became five pages longer. In 1965, in response to an issue over the American copyright of The Lord of the Rings (see below), Tolkien provided further revisions which were first incorporated into the Ballantine paperback edition and then taken up into the 1966 hardcover Allen & Unwin editions. This latter edition is the one most people have read.

Reading the first edition is an interesting experience, as the changes, although mostly minor, definitely affect the overall atmosphere of the book. HarperCollins, the successors to Allen & Unwin, released a facsimile of the first edition a couple of years ago, which is a good thing: Genuine first editions sell for anywhere from $500 to >$50,000, depending on impression and condition.

The first five printings of the Ballantine edition actually contain the second edition text because it was thought to be important to have something in print rather than await Tolkien's further changes. These five printings may be distinguished easily by the presence of a lion in the cover image; it was removed (at Tolkien's request) for later printings that contain the third edition text.

The Lord of the Rings

When Houghton Mifflin first published The Lord of the Rings in the United States, they relied largely on copies printed in the UK, to which they did not affix an American copyright notice as required by the US law at the time. There were also some clauses in the US copyright laws of the day requiring that books sold in the US be printed in the US beyond certain limits, and Houghton Mifflin seem to have violated those clauses as well. In the early 1960s, Ace Paperbacks, after unsuccessfully trying to gain the rights for a paperback edition, decided that the copyright was invalid and so proceeded to issue a completely unauthorized edition. Allen & Unwin cried foul, and Tolkien was asked to provide some revisions to the text to allow a firm copyright claim to be made. This resulted in the second edition in 1965, and the Ballantine paperback editions. The changes to the second edition were much more minor than those to The Hobbit's second edition; many of them fixed minor errors or clarified details of the geography. The details of the changes can be found in the Reader's Companion mentioned above.

More Academic Works

The texts I mentioned above in the main article as "Academic Work" are derived primarily from lectures and other writings that, while academic in nature, were nevertheless intended for a less specialist audience than Tolkien's academic peers. He was, of course, a professor at Oxford, and as such published various papers and books related to Anglo-Saxon/Old English and Middle English. Some of these works are listed here.

  • The Old English Exodus (ed. Joan Turville-Petre): Tolkien's edition of this poetical version of the Biblical book of Exodus, a translation, and comments derived from his lecture notes. This is one of the rarest of Tolkien books. (But it is now being reissued by HarperCollins, albeit as part of a box set of related books.)

  • Finn and Hengest: The Fragment and the Episode (ed. Alan Bliss): Like the Exodus, based on Tolkien's lecture notes. The tale of Finn and Hengest comes from a fragmentary poem called "The Fights at Finnesburg" and an episode in "Beowulf".

  • Beowulf and the Critics (ed. Michael C. Drout): Tolkien's famous essay was based on lectures he delivered at Oxford, and Drout presents the texts of those lectures and shows the evolution of Tolkien's thought. (The second edition is definitely the one to get if you go for this.)

  • The Battle of Maldon: together with The Homecoming of Beorhtnoth (ed. Peter Grybauskas) Contains Tolkien's prose translation of "The Battle of Maldon" along with "The Homecoming of Beorthnoth" and its accompanying essays, and Tolkien's previously unpublished lecture, "The Tradition of Versification in Old English." The deluxe edition includes a CD recording of JRR Tolkien and Christopher Tolkien reading the verse-drama.

  • A Middle English Vocabulary Originally published separately (in 1922), this was later bound with the text it was meant to accompany, Kenneth Sisam's Fourteenth Century Verse and Prose. In that format it is currently available from Dover as A Middle English Reader and Vocabulary.

  • Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, standard edition of this text co-edited with E.V. Gordon. Revised edition 1967 edited by Norman Davis is still in print.

  • Ancrene Wisse: The English Text of the Ancrene Riwle, Early English Text Society, Oxford University Press. Contrary to popular belief, this is still in print.

Academic papers

Many of these papers are now available online due to the digitization of academic journals; however, lots of them are behind paywalls. If you have access to a university library you can probably download them there.

  • Contributions to the Oxford English Dictionary, described in The Ring of Words: Tolkien and the Oxford English Dictionary

  • "Some Contributions to Middle-English Lexicography", The Review of English Studies, Vol. 1, No. 2, pp, 210-215.

  • "The Devil's Coach Horses", The Review of English Studies, Vol. 1, No. 3, pp, 331-336.

  • "Ancrene Wisse and Hali Meiðhad", Essays and Studies by members of the English Association, Vol. 14, pp, 104-126.

  • "The Name 'Nodens'", published in Report on the Excavation of the Prehistoric, Roman, and Post-Roman Site in Lydney Park, Gloucestershire.

  • "Sigelwara Land, parts I and II", in Medium Aevum, Vol. 1, No. 3 pp, 183-196 and Vol. 3, No. 2 (June 1934), pp, 95-111.

  • "Chaucer as a Philologist: The Reeve's Tale", Transactions of the Philological Society, Vol. 33, No. 1, pp, 1-70.

  • "The Reeve's Tale: version prepared for recitation at the 'summer diversions'", Oxford.

  • "Sir Orfeo", Oxford, The Academic Copying Office, 18 pp. An edition of the Middle English poem prepared for students at Oxford, this was subsequently published in Tolkien Studies, Vol. 1, pp. 85-123, edited by Carl Hostetter.

  • "Middle English 'Losenger': Sketch of an etymological and semantic enquiry", in Essais de philologie moderne: Communications présentées au Congrès International de Philologie Moderne, Les Belles Lettres.

  • "English and Welsh", in Angles and Britons: O'Donnell Lectures, University of Cardiff Press.

  • Contributions to the Jerusalem Bible, as translator ("Jonah") and lexicographer.

Books About Tolkien

Obviously there are literally hundreds of books and articles about Tolkien and his works, including an annual review publication called Tolkien Studies. So this list is merely a somewhat biased selection of a few highly recommended works — and is the list I'd most like to hear comments on, as well.

  • J.R.R. Tolkien: A Biography, Humphrey Carpenter: The only authorized biography of Tolkien, it's worth a read, but some of it should probably be taken with a grain of salt.

  • The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, ed. Humphrey Carpenter: I mentioned this above, but it's probably best to include it here explicitly. A new edition, containing more than 150 letters that were excluded from the original, as well as more complete versions of some of the originals, was released in November 2023.

  • Tolkien, Raymond Edwards: A newer biography that draws on material that wasn't available to Carpenter, although it also draws heavily on Carpenter's work.

  • The Tolkien Family Album, John & Priscilla Tolkien. Mostly pictures, as one might gather from the title, but it's a nice look at his family life. It's also the only publication I know of from Father John (his oldest son, who was a Catholic priest) and Priscilla (his youngest child and only daughter).

  • The J.R.R. Tolkien Companion and Guide, Wayne G. Hammond and Christina Scull: A three-volume chronology and encyclopedia of Tolkien's life which is an excellent supplement and extension of the official biography by Carpenter.

  • Tolkien's Faith: A Spiritual Biography, Holly Ordway. The only major biography to emphasize Tolkien's Catholicism and its place in his works. Having now read this myself, I do recommend it, but with some reservations. It definitely provides a deep dive into how Tolkien's faith played a significant role in his life and his writing; however, some of her inferences don't seem to be based in actual evidence.

  • Tolkien's Modern Reading, Holly Ordway. Dispels a lot of myths about how familiar Tolkien was with modern literature. My caveat about Ordway's other book applies to this one as well.

  • Master of Middle-earth, Paul Kocher: Written pre-Silmarillion, it's still an excellent analysis

  • J.R.R. Tolkien: Author of the Century, Tom Shippey

  • The Road to Middle-earth, Tom Shippey: Shippey's two books are a good starting point

  • Tolkien and the Critics, ed. Neil D. Isaacs and Rose Zimbardo: An early collection of criticism, including the infamous review, "Ooo, those awful orcs!" by Edmund Wilson

  • Understanding the Lord of the Rings, ed. Neil D. Isaacs and Rose Zimbardo: A more recent similar collection by the same editors

  • J.R.R. Tolkien Encyclopedia: Scholarship and Critical Assessment, ed. Michael D.C. Drout: A collection of scholarly articles on various topics by noted Tolkien scholars. Now available in paperback, so less onerous price-wise than previously.

  • Tolkien and the Great War, John Garth: An excellent book about Tolkien's experiences in World War I and the influence that had on his developing Legendarium.

  • The Worlds of J.R.R. Tolkien, John Garth. Subtitled "The Places That Inspired Middle-earth," looks at various real world locales that are known to have influenced the geography of Tolkien's legendarium.

Journals and Periodicals

There are a number of scholarly and semi-scholarly journals dedicated in whole or in part to the study of Tolkien's works:

  • Tolkien Studies: Annual journal published by The University of West Virginia Press, available online as well. Has published a few rare Tolkien works, including the first publication of "The Story of Kullervo" and Tolkien's edition of the Middle English poem "Sir Orfeo".

  • Journal of Tolkien Research: An online journal that covers similar material to Tolkien Studies.

  • Mallorn: The journal of the Tolkien Society.

  • Mythlore: The journal of the Mythopoeic Society, it covers authors like C.S. Lewis and others as well as Tolkien, but has published some very insightful work on Tolkien.

  • Beyond Bree: The monthly newsletter of the Tolkien Special Interest Group of Mensa, edited for decades now by the indefatigable Nancy Martsch. Contains lots of information about upcoming events and publications, and also publishes articles of serious Tolkien scholarship.

There are several journals dedicated to the Inklings, the Oxford group that Tolkien was part of with C.S. Lewis, that also frequently publish material about Tolkien.

Recommended Authors and Editors

  • Tom Shippey

  • Verlyn Flieger

  • Christina Scull

  • Wayne Hammond

  • Jane Chance

  • Douglas A. Anderson

  • Dimitra Fimi

  • Brian Sibley

  • Corey Olsen

  • Brian Rosebury

  • Janet Brennan Croft

  • Joseph Pearce

  • Walking Tree Press has a whole series of books devoted to Tolkien, most of them collections of papers from various conferences.

Authors to Avoid

The most obvious one is David Day; despite making a career out of Tolkien-related books, his works are full of errors, bad assumptions, and other quirks, and are not recommended. Beware of his maps especially! They do usually contain some really nice illustrations, though.

I also cannot recommend the numerous books self-published by Alex Lewis and Elizabeth Curry (sometimes under the name "Elansea"), and the "biography" by Daniel Grotta (sometimes Grotta-Kurska), nor the works by Nancy Bunting (with or without her occasional collaborator Seamus Hamill-Keays), and Toby Widdicombe. All of these authors have a tendency to take their assumptions and surmises as fact, alas.

Some Useful Online References

Another resource I just discovered on this very sub: u/philthehippy's very useful list of Tolkien open access journals and blogrolls.

[Post last updated 07 March 2026. Tweaked a few sentences here and there, updated a few entries, and add TolkienGuide.com to the useful online references.]


r/tolkienfans • • May 24 '21

Tolkien's world is NOT dystopian nor postapocaliptic. I am not sure how anyone could ever arrive at such a conclusion.

1.4k Upvotes

A few days ago, there was a post here claiming that the world of LotR is dystopian and postapocalyptic. It got nearly 1k upvotes. I am not trying to stir shit or anything, but i am surprised that somebody could arrive at such a conclusion. I am even more surprised it somehow got 1k upvotes.

According to Cambridge English, a "dystopia" is a world in which there is a lot of unfairness/injustice/societal division. Examples would include George Orwell's "1984" or "Animal Farm", or Huxley's "Brave New World'. Imagine a world in which all or nearly all freedoms have been abolished, your life is constantly being monitored, and you are forbidden from orgasms. Alternatively, imagine a world in which the human race was conquered by aliens, and we now serve them as pets/sex slaves/source of food. This is what the term "dystopia" refers to. Is the Lord of the Rings dystopian? No, of course not. It's simply a medieval society in a fantasy setting. There is societal division, true (for instance, Frodo seems to be of a higher standing than Samwise), but it was that way throughout real life Middle Ages, so that's not a very shocking thing. Sure, there is some wilderness/abandoned settlements, but there are also plenty of well developed places. As an example, the Shire has been around for 1400 years. By comparison, my real life country, Poland, has only been around for 1060 years. So... If the Lord of the Rings is dystopian, is my country dystopian, as well? I mean, the Shire is very young compared to Gondor or Arnor, let alone Rivendell or Lórien, but they still manage to be older than the vast majority of European states.

The postapocalyptic part... I am totally dumbfounded. I have been wondering about it for days, and i still don't know how anybody could think that way. The world Apocalypse means "disaster". How many disasters there were in Arda's history? Well, plenty, actually. The destruction of the lighthouses by Morgoth, the flooding of Beleriand, and the destruction of Numenor. But at the time of LotR, there have passed thousands of years since those events. The Elves may remember them, but they hardly affect Frodo or Sam. Sure, some knowledge/culture/wisdom has been lost to time, but does that warrant calling LotR a post apocalyptic book? No. First of all, because the "disasters" were thousands of years ago, and second, because the world is not anywhere near "postapocalyptic". Gandalf was able to unearth documents regarding Isildur that were written 3 thousand years earlier. How many pieces of literature do we, in the real world, have that have survived for 3 years and are just randomly lying in a library?

The world of LotR is not post apocalyptic, nor is it dystopian. It's simply a fantasy interpretation of pre-Crusades Europe. Tolkien was fascinated by Beowulf, Arthur and the like, so he based his literature on that period of time. That's why there is a feeling of desolation and abandonment. This is what the people of the early Middle Ages felt when talking about the legacy of Rome and Greece. It took a lot of time for society to recover after whatever the hell went down between the 4th century and the Viking raids. But was that society post apocalyptic or dystopian? No. Here we are, using the Internet and debating a book.

That's the case with LotR. At the moment, civilization is on the down, but it's sure to recover. At the end of the day, Tolkien's world was intended to be a predecessor to our own.

So, that's all i had to say. I realize this will be buried, but i am just completely dumbfounded.

I apologize for my abysmal English. I am 19, and i haven't been able to master it yet. Hopefully though, i am getting my point across.