r/ToTheStars • u/NotUnusualYet • Feb 23 '18
TtS Chapter 53: "Alignment" || Discussion Thread Spoiler
Chapter 53 on ArchiveOfOurOwn.org
All spoilers up to this chapter do not need to be spoiler tagged.
Any "Words of God", AKA spoilers coming directly from Hieronym, do need to be tagged as such. To use spoiler tags:
[WoG Spoilers](/s "Secrets!")Result: WoG Spoilers
Discuss!
And as always, there is also discussion on the SV thread and on Discord "latest-chapter-spoilers" channel (links in sidebar).
Announcement: If you're behind on the story or need a refresher on recent events, check out the Chapter Summaries page on the To the Stars wiki!
4
u/C4Cypher Feb 26 '18
This has me wonder exactly how much Simona (and the group she represents) have to do with Ryoko's 'unique' genetics and the chimeric part of her brain.
4
u/NotUnusualYet Feb 27 '18
A lot, probably. As Ryouko figured out from her first vision, Simona was "tank-born" and seemed to already know Ryouko before she moved to Japan. I would not be surprised if she had the same strange brain module.
9
u/MavisOfTheDead Feb 27 '18 edited Feb 27 '18
It's worth pointing out Simona's reason for being at Miki Sayaka High School was to learn the Japanese language. In chapter 1 she is using a translator during the breakfast conversation with Ryouko and yet in chapter 53 we have:
"The people I'm working for are not your enemy," Simona said, in flawless idiomatic Japanese,
That's not a skill you can simple gain over the relatively short time-frame of TtS.
15
u/Mysterius Feb 23 '18
A few thoughts on the new Chapter 52:
she was glad Sayaka had retained it, even after what had happened to her first daughter Uh oh. Is referring to Shizuki Sayaka's daughter Sakura in The One-Hundredth Floor? That doesn't sound good...
Huh, so Simona was the other mysterious magical girl in the Paris fight? I'll have to go back and re-read that scene to get a sense of Simona's powers.
Latest chapter definitely bolsters the theory that Valentin is connected to Homura. I'm not sure if anyone proposed Homura having multiple bodies, but I actually had a hunch that was the case too. Really interesting to see both of those ideas confirmed or at least strongly suggested by the latest chapter.
As for how Homura could have multiple bodies, and furthermore escape magical detection, I think there have been a lot of little clues throughout the course of the story, some of which include:
The wish Ryouko's aunt Nana made which turned Ryouko's mother Nakase from a MG back into a normal human: this provides an example of Soul Gem to organic brain transfer.
Ryouko's Soul Gem restoring TacComp!Clarisse: this proves Soul Gems can work with wetware as well as backup more than one brain. Also hints that the implications of multiple instances of the same person may be an important question, when the Goddess declines to answer any more of Clarisse's questions about AI backups.
Kyouko's vision: both Sayaka and Kyouko's sister Momo are rather explicit about the nebulous nature of personal identity across multiple worlds and timelines. This hints that identity is more fluid than we normally assume, limited as we are to one body and one instance of our mind at a time.
The quotes at the beginning of Chapter 51: Homura talks explicitly about how a person's identity changes day by day, year by year. Russel's quote is also apropos, of course. Pretty strong hint that theories of personal identity will play a role.
That's what originally led me to suspect something was up. Now that there's partial confirmation, I wonder if the rest will pan out.
7
u/360Saturn Feb 23 '18
This structure! So much secret and pre-planned going on behind the scenes in earlier chapters...I love that kind of thing.
The author of this is so talented, holy crap.
5
u/NotUnusualYet Feb 24 '18
One of the potential worry points here: What did Simona wish for that made her a "natural telepath" with potentially "wish‐derived mind magics"? She hinted to Yuma that her wish was directly related to Ryouko, too. Talking about why she was assigned to guard Ryouko on wormhole missions:
It's not clear to me if Simona was a part of this conspiracy organization before she made her wish, but it seems pretty plausible. After all, in Ryouko's first vision, she sees Simona looking directly at her when first transferring in.
(Which is, of course, distinctly Homuran. Since we know from the same vision that Simona was tank-born, and since we know now Homura is doing crazy stuff with multiple bodies, perhaps Simona is somehow templated off of Homura?)