r/ToR_Meta • u/Tim3303 • Sep 26 '21
r/ToR_Meta • u/Itsthejoker • Jun 09 '23
Blackout Announcement
Hey all.
I know you've seen a lot of chatter recently about the Reddit API changes and the recent announcements that Sync, Apollo, RIF, and many more third party apps will be shutting down at the end of the month. This has some pretty widespread changes that Reddit didn't anticipate, and somewhat unexpectedly, we're very much in the eye of the storm.
Our friends at r/blind have been thrust into the spotlight because this nuclear option that Reddit has chosen effectively removes all the accessibility-related tools that they use to interact with Reddit, and we have 21 days from my writing this to plan for it. While Reddit has given us some concessions, it's not enough.
As such, r/TranscribersOfReddit, r/ToR_Meta, and r/DescriptionPlease will be joining the blackout in solidarity with r/blind on the 12th through the 14th of this month. This is the first time we have ever participated in a protest on Reddit; we pride ourselves on staying out of the fray and just focusing on what we do best: accessibility. But what we do best is one of the things that Reddit does worst, and while Reddit is focusing on bringing up their accessibility features, I have heard through the grapevine that they do not expect to have their mobile apps up to par until October at the earliest. Note that they are cutting off access at the end of the month. This is not only unconscionable -- it is unethical.
I personally have been in multiple calls with Reddit leadership over the past weeks, including a two-hour call yesterday with Reddit's CEO Steve Huffman, and they do not plan on backing down or changing course. This is just the way it's going to be.
If this is just the way it's going to be, we will join the crowd and make add our voice to the uproar.
If they're going to take away the voice of r/blind, we will lend them ours.
r/ToR_Meta • u/Cloakknight • Jan 10 '22
Meme | Transcribed! It doesn't render correctly everywhere
r/ToR_Meta • u/alexanderhameowlton • Jul 31 '21
Meme | Transcribed! I've fallen victim to this before
r/ToR_Meta • u/cute-lil-evil-spirit • Nov 22 '21
Meme | Transcribed! It was deleted 3 minutes after I started but didn’t tell me until I finished my comment 🙃
r/ToR_Meta • u/Itsthejoker • Jun 02 '23
Announcement June Monthly Meta: Not Quite the Rainbow We Were Expecting
Hey, everybody! Itsthejoker from the Grafeas Admin and Developer teams here to chat about the absolutely wild stuff you've probably heard about recently about third-party apps going away.
The explosion
If you haven't seen it, take a second and get caught up -- pick your favorite site here:
AOL (even they got in on this)
...and a whole lot more. Here's the tl;dr:
Reddit is changing the way that third party applications and bots interact with the site, and for some of us (not all of us), they're charging a lot of money. The "some of us" included above are all the developers of third-party mobile apps. If you use a mobile app that's not the official one, like Sync for Android, Apollo, RIF, or anything else, it will likely die on July 1st.
If you're looking at this and thinking "okay, so what? I use the official app and it's fine," the important part here is the missing functionality in the official app on the moderation side. Modding a subreddit, especially a larger one, is essentially impossible on the official app. The vast majority of folks who are mods use third party apps to help them out, and this move forcibly strips that ability away. As mods, we already lost our biggest spam-fighting tool last month when Reddit cut off Pushshift without warning and with no way to replace it, which is the biggest single reason you've seen a lot more spam comments across the site recently.
Okay, enough about modding, how does this affect ToR?
These changes also include how our bots, u/transcribersofreddit, u/transcribot, u/tor_archivist, and more all interact with the site. To date we've done pretty well on keeping within the rules of what's acceptable, but some of our bots are very busy. At one point, u/transcribersofreddit AND u/transcribot were both in the top 10 non-spam accounts across Reddit in terms of comment and post activity. That is a lot of posting. It's so much posting that it's hard to quantify, but over the years we've been very, very active. This poses a problem as we approach the coming month.
We've gotten several questions so far asking how this affects us, and the short answer is honestly, we don't know yet. We have begun laying the groundwork for identifying if we are impacted and by how much; there is a possibility that we are impacted by the new rules, though we may not be impacted yet given that some of the rules are being introduced on a sliding scale. Fun fact: the biggest problem that actually stands in our way is that Reddit has pledged to start enforcing rate limits, but the system's own understanding of how much you've used is frequently wrong. For example, if you host your app in a shared space or on the cloud, Reddit frequently aggregates all the requests from your IP address into one block, which leads to getting responses that say "hmmm you've used 50,000 requests in the last 60 seconds" when you only sent one.
What about this new Developer Platform thing I've heard about?
As a part of this, Reddit is rolling out a new system that they hope to essentially replace 'traditional' bots as we know them. However, this system has the following issues:
It's in beta
There is no proper release date available yet for when the Developer Platform will be open to all. As Reddit slowly cuts off access to the API, they are driving developers (us) towards a platform that isn't even open yet. There's also no guarantee that what we want to do is even possible, which leads me to the next point:
It's extremely limited compared to what we have now
When looking at the API, the way we get all of the information we need, we have access to a fairly large amount of information. The Developer Platform, while it has its uses, is not designed with large and busy bots in mind. It's much better suited for entry-level 'learning to code' style bots that we see frequently pop up on the site. Issues from data usage limits, data storage limits (500kb! Our database in Blossom is over 1.4GB), connecting to services outside reddit (which we have gotten special permissions for, I'll give them that), and more plague the development experience at the time of this writing.
It only works on New Reddit (and the official mobile apps, kinda)
We suggest that folks who do a lot of writing with ToR use Old Reddit specifically because the experience of working with markdown is so much better when writing out long comments (especially when paired with RES, the Reddit Enhancement Suite). If we were to move functionality onto the Developer Platform, we would be locking out a measurable portion of our volunteers.
It only works on bots written in TypeScript, which we don't use
Here's the kicker, the really big problem. All of our bots are written in Python -- battle-hardened code that we've been tweaking and growing for six years. In order to move to the Developer Platform, we would have to rewrite everything from scratch and completely start over. The same designs and paradigms won't work on the new system, so we would have to re-architect a large portion of our work, and that's with translating everything from Python to TypeScript.
So what's the plan?
I don't mean to sound dire, I promise. Right now, things are not looking good for every community with more than 10k members, and this includes us. Over the next month, we will:
identify exactly how we are affected
identify mitigation methods if necessary
figure out how this affects the long-term plan, if at all
keep you all up to date as we go
This is not a problem that is unique to us; it's a threat to the entire Reddit ecosystem and it's perpetuated by Reddit itself. Buckle up, because things are going to get bumpy.
Closing thoughts
I was lucky enough to be one of the first 10 developers granted access to the new Developer Platform system. I've watched it grow and I've helped guide its growth when I could. Even with having this incredible level of access, some things are still catching us completely unaware; the most recent change to the API requirements is a prime example, especially since we were told to our faces (literally, over Zoom) that this was not going to happen.
We're committed to keeping ToR running as long as we can and we have done so much for the broader Reddit experience. I really can't wait to share what we've been working on under the hood, so to speak, but for now we have more pressing things to attend to. I know that there's not a lot of hard data in this post, but that's because I don't have a lot of hard data to share right now. Hopefully we'll have some happier things to talk about next month.
If you use a third-party mobile app and want to let Reddit know that you want change, check out the Open Letter that we've signed here.
To all of you out there doing your transcription thing: we see you and we appreciate you. A lot. We'll keep forging ahead as best we can, and only time can tell what comes next.
Thanks for everything you do. Catch you next month.
Total Volunteers: 5,929
Total Transcriptions: 276,253
New here? FAQ | Discord | Twitter | Last month's meta
Want to help keep the servers running? Patreon | Individual donations | New: Support us and look cool whilst you're doing it! Merch now available!
Need more memes? Go check out our sister sub /r/ToR_Meta! A hub for discussion, memes and all things ToR!
Have you seen our map of volunteers? | Add your city (anonymous)
As always, please share any interesting posts you've transcribed, comments you've received or testimonials you've had below! We love hearing from you :)
r/ToR_Meta • u/halailah • May 26 '22
Transcribed! I cross-stitched the Grafeas Group logo!
r/ToR_Meta • u/Tim3303 • Jan 24 '22
News One of the longest transcriptions of all time
In this post I want to highlight the HUGE efforts of everyone who transcribed the Official Polandball World Map 2021.
This has been a collaborative effort between many transcribers. Not only did the map contain an insane amount of elements and detail, but also required background knowledge on the flags of the corresponding countries.
The finished transcription is 13 Reddit comments long (each comment has a maximum length of 10,000 characters) and is one of the longest transcriptions ever made. Not only that, I think it's the largest non-text transcription to date.
A big thank you to everyone who participated and helped to make this post accessible to everyone! Here's a list of all contributors, adapted from the last transcription comment:
u/andrewsjakko02 wrote the transcriptions of the clays in the Atlantic Ocean, the European Continent, the Middle East, Central Asia, and South Asia, while also substantially contributing to the transcription of Central America (and trying to give the project a general coordination :));
u/SammyzABanana is responsible for the section describing Russia and its States;
u/_Diabetes took the effort to transcribe the rest of the Asian continent (Southeast Asia and East Asia), Oceania, every other clay in the Pacific Ocean, Africa and Antarctica;
u/pntns worked on the upper portion of the frame and North America, while also working with me in transcribing Central America;
u/Frajnla took the lower part of the frame and South America.
With additional contributions by u/shirleyxx for giving them all the background knowledge they needed about the Canadian half of North America, u/halailah for helping them while recognizing flags and events in Central and South America, u/seeroflights for helping them with the Chinese characters and the folks of r/Vexillology, who gave them a huge hand in identifying some of the flags.
Big projects like this and our recently completed Clear the Queue event shows how much we have grown and how well we work together. A huge accomplishment!
Don't forget to check out the transcription here!
r/ToR_Meta • u/alexanderhameowlton • Jul 28 '21
Meme | Transcribed! It's like a transcriber feeding frenzy
r/ToR_Meta • u/andrewsjakkko02 • Mar 11 '22
Meme | Transcribed! Accurate depiction of #off-topic
r/ToR_Meta • u/Cloakknight • Jul 27 '21
Meme | Transcribed! Re: Transcribing your own posts
r/ToR_Meta • u/Cloakknight • Jul 27 '21
Meme | Transcribed! Some people transcribe too much
r/ToR_Meta • u/Cloakknight • Jul 26 '21