r/ThredUp • • Mar 06 '26

Thredup is using false advertising

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

This has happened to me twice and wanted to warn others so they don't waste their time shopping based on the listed price and then having sticker shock when they go to pay and it's a much higher price. Items are listed as discounted on the individual product page, it is listed at that same discounted price in your cart, when you hit the pay button the price for each item changes and many items are no longer "eligible" for the discount. I reported this previously to Thredup to their marketing and IT departments and they dismissed my concerns as saying it is "up to x discount amount" but obviously they are not verifying the discount price through the end point of the sale. This is illegal.


r/ThredUp • • Jun 14 '26

I’m done with ThredUp

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I’m pissed off! I gave them a lot of stuff and yeah, I know some stuff falls through the cracks. Like I had three Torrid items. Two of these items I know were in really great quality. One was a long sleeve zip up sweater with pockets in the front, the other was a black short sleeves blouse with embroidered roses on the sleeves (that I originally bought from ThredUp!) Both of those items were in very good condition. I had another item that was a sleeveless romper from torrid, it was black with flowers. That one was a little faded, but I got it from ThredUp as well. The last one was a long sleeve teal Adidas lightweight sweater. The kind that has a half zip up of the top half of the sweater. Like a workout thing. Definitely a women’s cut. They listed all four of these items unbranded. Every item I send them I make sure they have a label and they are branded. All four of these items had labels, and they were clearly branded. In the pictures you can’t see the Brand or the label because the picture they take is a crumble piece of clothing. In fact, my short sleeve black torrid blouse with embroidered roses on the sleeves is pictured, but you can tell they folded down the top to hide the words Torrid. So of course I contact customer service and this is the response I get. I used to contact customer service if I had an issue and sometimes they would give me a credit. I usually do a chat in the app, but this is the first time I’ve done a text like this. Nothing was offered to me. I just felt like it was a big middle finger in my face. I’m done with this company. I’m not buying clothes from them. I’m not giving them any more of my clothes. I am a “VIT” and they couldn’t throw eight bucks my way to make me happy about this? And by the way, I’m sure they’re gonna go ahead and sell these clothes later for their own profit. Great.


r/ThredUp • • Sep 03 '26

Discussion Seller Experience

0 Upvotes

I sent about $8000-9000 (retail) worth of clothing to ThreadUp. It compassed three bags and the total weight was 47 pounds. Nothing was ripped, worn, torn, stained or damaged in any way. I sent them Valentino, Rag & Bone, Burberry, Barney’s NY, Brooks Brothers, Thomas Pink, Armani, Bergdorf Goodman, Paul Stuart. Etro, Gitman Brothers, Dunhill and more. It was all
Top of the line stuff. About ½ was rejected for no apparent reason. I am not going to pay highly marked-up shipping charges to get my own clothing back.Once you factor in the processing fees and a “Return Items that Aren’t Listed” fee, I’m going to end up with about $100 and that is
IF the items sell for their determined prices. 

I did not do my due diligence. I should have read the terms more closely and went on social
Media to see the reviews and complaints. That being said, you have absolutely no idea what
They will accept and what they will not accept, nor do you have any say on the pricing of your 
Goods. I was overwhelmed with clothing and looked for a fast way to solve the issue, that was my mistake. I would never sell, or basically donate, my clothing to them ever again. Use PoshMark or eBay and you will make, much, much more money. If you don’t need the cash
Donate the clothing to a local charity. You are basically donating your clothing to ThreadUp.

Even though they basically purloin your clothing and resell them and sell hundreds of millions of dollars worth of inventory a year, the company still somehow does not make a profit, with strong gross margins around 78% to 79%. It is a publicly traded company and its stock is in the toilet. 

Again, to recap for you: Payout rates are very low, processing fees apply to bags or boxes, and acceptance rates can be strict, meaning sellers often net very little per item.


r/ThredUp • • May 06 '24

Well - ewww. Blood on package

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Usually don’t have any problems with Thredup. They’ve randomly sent me “clean out your closet bags” here and there but that’s it.

Today I received my box of items - and - there’s blood on the box. It’s not coffee, it’s not a red dye stain, it’s absolutely blood. I work in the medical field and - it’s blood. It’s dripped down the box and is stuck in the tape.

Like - how does this happen?

Any idea how to get them on the phone for customer service or am I stuck in chatbot hell forever?


r/ThredUp • • Jul 04 '25

First bag update

0 Upvotes

They accepted 27/30 items I sent. Mostly Zara, gap, and boutique brands.

I'm looking to cut even on the $30

Holy shit I know payouts were low but I did not expect that ... Literally just gave them $300+ of merch for free. Almost all of it is selling at 18.99+

That's assuming everything will sell... Probably won't use this service again :(


r/ThredUp • • Nov 01 '25

ThredUp support has entered the “I cannot confirm or deny” era

Post image
6 Upvotes

I’ve been a ThredUp seller for a few years and usually try to be patient with customer service, but this latest experience kinda pissed me off.

A buyer initiated a return on one of my items. That’s fine, it happens a lot, and sometimes the buyer ends up keeping it. Since it was already a few days past the return date, I contacted support just to confirm whether the item was actually shipped back.

The first agent responded by saying it can take several weeks before being re-listed. Cool, that’s not what I asked. I clarified that I already understood that and just wanted to know if the return was postmarked by the due date. Other agents have looked that up for me before since they do have access to tracking info.

Then silence. Ten minutes go by. I ask who I’m speaking with and they just close the chat.

So I open a new chat and ask the next agent for their name. They say “Taylor.” I ask if I was just speaking with them a moment ago. Instead of answering, I get this bizarre line:

“I cannot share the name of other associates but I am happy to assist you today.”

I never asked for another agent’s name. I asked if they were the same person I was just talking to. When I pressed again, same scripted response. Asked a third time, same copy-paste.

Screenshots attached for context.

If you can’t even acknowledge a simple yes or no question or own up to closing a chat mid-conversation, that’s a serious customer service issue.

I swear I have a love-hate relationship with ThredUp. Don’t plan on escaping this toxic relationship anytime soon, just wanted to come on here and vent!


r/ThredUp • • Feb 16 '26

Discussion There needs to be a report button…

Post image
205 Upvotes

Am I the only one who thinks this is insane? I understand this is a band tee, but I feel icky that this was even processed and posted.

Edit: I seriously did not realize this was so controversial. I was born and raised in Texas, and I cannot think of a time when this symbol was accepted as completely inoffensive and solely representative of southern pride. I am 20, so it could be my age, but the only people I know who defend the Confederate flag's use as a unifying emblem of Southern pride are those who purposefully say provocative things to get a reaction out of others. I am shocked at the aggressive comments this post has received, and I did not mean to stir anything up. I just wanted to point out the flaws of Thredup's vetting system and lack of reporting features to show how a potentially offensive symbol can slip through the cracks and cause confusion, anger, or disappointment from customers.


r/ThredUp • • Dec 15 '25

Question They stole a pair of $300 shoes in a premium clean out bag

2 Upvotes

I’m so sad and pissed. A brand new pair of Chloe espadrilles gone. I kept a detailed list and put a copy in the box. These shoes simply disappeared, not in listing or return listing. What do I do?


r/ThredUp • • Jul 12 '25

I recently received my first order from Thread Up and soon after began to itch all over. All symptons suggesst bed bugs and the apparence shortly after order arrived suggest Thread Up. I am not a happy shopper.

2 Upvotes

r/ThredUp • • Apr 26 '24

Trying to sell on ThredUp is a waste of time!

2 Upvotes

Sent giant bag of high quality stuff on thread up. The payout for the ideals in minuscule and they charge a 15$ handling fee. So basically the get free inventory. I’m making no money. What a heist. I can only imagine they subsist by getting unsuspecting people like me to send them my stuff once. I feel disgusted by the experience.


r/ThredUp • • May 22 '26

Tiny XXS women of thredUP

5 Upvotes

Any other super tiny girls on here addicted to ThredUp? I’m talking truly petite/XXS, not “sometimes an XS.” I’m 4’11, 85lbs and so many brands people recommend still run huge on me. Madewell is usually too big, and even brands like Club Monaco and White House Black Market are way too big.

Would love to know what brands you’ve had the best luck with on ThredUp for genuinely tiny sizing, especially for feminine/classic clothes that don’t look juvenile.


r/ThredUp • • Dec 06 '25

Discussion Such a waste

5 Upvotes

Unless you’ve got Gucci, Prada, etc. trying to sell on thredup is such a scam. I sent in two huge bags of clothes hoping to make just a couple bucks and they listed five items from all the items. With a ton of the items being Disney branded so I know they weren’t brands they wouldn’t accept. Or items that they couldn’t “offer payout for” because they didn’t list it above $20 - including shoes that were brand new with tags. The processing fees eat up any “earnings” and the amount they keep on their end is outrageous and why you can’t even make $1 on an items listed for $10. I sent in a kate spade purse as well and it sold for $80 I made less than $20 from it 🤦🏻‍♀️


r/ThredUp • • Nov 13 '25

Literally why

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ThredUp • • Mar 11 '26

I thought.. “what an adorable bag for work”!!!

Post image
14 Upvotes

I have never seen this brand before but the bag is so cute… then I really got to looking at it trying to figure out the brand. Then it really was not that cute when I realized what I was seeing…Is that orange dot supposed to be an O to start the beginning of a word ending in RGY?!? I would have been ROASTED at work!


r/ThredUp • • Feb 13 '25

I Don’t Get It - My Unaccepted Brands for Sale With No Payout?

0 Upvotes

So I went thru threads here but I am still unclear. Thredup determined several of my items were unaccepted brands. And after checking they are. So I get that.

But how do they justify listing and selling those same items without paying me for them? What’s the logic? The price point is the same as on other items of mine they accepted.


r/ThredUp • • Mar 20 '26

My turn to be angry

Post image
8 Upvotes

Duluth Trading Co is such a good brand. Like what?


r/ThredUp • • Apr 27 '25

Humor/Memes “Minor wear on fabric”

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/ThredUp • • Sep 30 '26

Looking for similar stories of theft from premium bags

4 Upvotes

Hi! I sent in a premium bag and ThredUp rejected a Veronica Beard blazed in excellent condition. They won’t mail it back to me and offered a $80.09 credit (not sure where this number is coming from). I've seen from other posts that they’re most likely going to post it for sale anyway. I was hoping to learn about similar stories to 1) apply pressure on them to make it right, 2) debate filing a small claims case (I am a lawyer), and/or 3) learn more about how prevalent the practice is and see if there’s any consumer protection relief that can be sought via a class action. I’m very annoyed and unafraid to do some activist lawyering on it if possible (even if unfruitful). Please feel free to DM me!


r/ThredUp • • Sep 15 '26

Now they can just not list your items because of “oversupply”

Post image
5 Upvotes

Over half my items were not listed for this reason- ironically half of the ones listed are the same brands. This is BS, there is no policy I can find anywhere that says they cannot list items because they have too much of that brand or style. I read all the horror stories on here just wanted to share my own.


r/ThredUp • • Jan 21 '26

Spotted My First Overprice!

0 Upvotes

Oh ThredUp, how obviously overpriced you are. No QC on these listings, clearly.


r/ThredUp • • May 17 '24

I'm confused

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ThredUp • • Aug 05 '25

Question I have your We the Free Ts

Post image
0 Upvotes

Not sure if there’s anything to do but I got a package I didn’t order with two small We the Free Ts (small but oversized). I checked my credit card for fraud but seems like I just got someone’s order sent to me by mistake with a clean out kit. Curious what other people do in this case or if you do nothing.

I’m happy to send them to someone if you want to pay shipping otherwise they’re going in the trash.


r/ThredUp • • Apr 16 '26

PSA to ThredUp Directly and their Developers

1 Upvotes

Dear ThredUp,

In this economy, if you get a buyer who wants to buy something and makes you an offer, YOU TAKE IT!

Thank you for your attention to the matter.

On behalf of ALL the Offers that are not being followed through every single day.


r/ThredUp • • Jan 23 '26

Haul What age would you guess I am based off of my recent purchases?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes