r/ThreadsApp • u/toshex • Jul 05 '23
First impressions
THE CONS:
Not liking the home page showing me a ton of random influencers. I'd like to see only accounts I follow on there.
There are no hashtags.
There are no Direct Messages.
You can't see a list of quotes on a quoted thread.
Search is rudimentary (only searches accounts).
There's no GIFs integrated.
You can't edit your name independently from instagram.
No quick account switching.
No desktop/web app.
----
THE PROS:
NO ELON (and no Elon whim decisions)
It does seem that the followers/following list is separate from that one on instagram - meaning you could follow people on one platform but not the other if you want to (if you're using your main instagram account/handle on threads - you could create a new account to be completely detached from your main instagram).
You can have your threads public and your instagram private.
The app is snappy and nice, threads work well.
There's quoting and reposting.
Notifications tab/section looks and works fine.
Nice animation of the threads logo at the top on refresh.
People can't see what you've liked in one place (no likes tab on the profile).
19
u/jimmyjxmes Jul 06 '23
Surely they will implement a way to only see the people you follow. This isn’t even a “here is everyone you follow and a every now and then we will make a suggested post”. I’ve followed like 30 people and none of their post have showed up yet on my feed.
8
1
u/PinkPicasso_ Jul 06 '23
They all show up for me
4
u/jimmyjxmes Jul 06 '23
yea ngl its getting better for me as time goes by. Might have just been some hiccups early on.
1
u/-la_luna- Jul 07 '23
Same! I don't give a fuck about what a celebrity ate for breakfast or what corporation discovered a dead meme. Just let me see my friends ._.
3
2
Jul 06 '23
Not liking the home page showing me a ton of random influencers. I'd like to see only accounts I follow on there.
Big turn off for me from the get-go along with the feed not being chronological.
Although Musk has tried to force this on people with the 'For You' nonsense the 'Following' tab has always been the content I want to see with no other noise.
I hope this is something they address but I don't hold out much hope, especially the chronological part given that's something Meta seems to refuse to do. Twitter is an effective real-time tool for breaking news etc. and it's not much good seeing a post 18 hours later because Meta thinks I should see a post about an orange bundt cake first.
1
u/toshex Jul 06 '23
Developer said it’s on the list along with some other of the more popular remarks so that’s good.
1
31
14
u/rajde1 Jul 06 '23
It feels really rushed. It seems very random. I just want to see people I’m following not random people.
11
u/MorukDilemma Jul 06 '23
I guess it's been a quick reaction to the Twitter shithousery.
6
u/RichardBJ1 Jul 06 '23
Yes but I expected it to hang straight away, but they seem to have gone for “make it work” first, assume they will tart it up as time progresses.
1
u/RichardBJ1 Jul 06 '23
2
u/UndreamedAges Jul 06 '23
I've been getting "Sorry something went wrong. Try again." On every screen except home and that refuses to refresh. It happened last night and uninstalling/reinstalling fixed it. But I don't want to have to do that every few hours
1
9
u/zuma15 Jul 06 '23
No hashtags is disappointing. Also search only seems to search usernames and not content. Hopefully they address those soon.
1
7
Jul 06 '23
I'm sure they will make it more fully-featured with time.
6
u/TizACoincidence Jul 06 '23
The overall product design is very strong, the missing features can be added easily.
1
Jul 07 '23
If they were that easily added, why not add them from the start
0
u/arguix Jul 09 '23
each feature takes time. is tradeoff of perfect vs get attention, get users. too early and people quit, too late and …
1
Jul 10 '23
Why are you white knighting for a billionaire.
1
u/arguix Jul 10 '23
i certainly am not doing that. just have plenty experience in software projects and was explaining why a product might launch without every feature people might wish for.
consider feature A B C. all valid product needs. each adds 3 months dev time. could wait & get them in, but that is 9 months later to launch, which might matter if lose opportunity or another company.
6
u/fsociety_1990 Jul 06 '23
I may be wrong and I'm no Zuck fan or a tech expert but this seems the best competition for Twitter so far. Still lot of room for improvement.
6
u/CaptainPRlCE Jul 06 '23
The biggest pro is that so many people that I followed on Twitter are on there. That wasn't the case with the numerous other apps.
Threads needs some work but it's basically Twitter without actually being Twitter and for me and that's exactly what I wanted.
4
1
u/Future-Ad6407 Jul 06 '23
My theory is they rushed to launch Threads and will roll out new features over the next couple months.
2
u/toshex Jul 06 '23
They need that home page update within days otherwise people might get fed up from random accounts popping up on home page.
1
u/Future-Ad6407 Jul 06 '23
Agree. Not a fan of the "For You" style feed. But I'm assuming that's just until they reach a DAU threshold.
3
u/dailyCaffeinated Jul 06 '23
I agree with no Elon being the top pro. A desktop app is really, really needed. Especially if you work with social media. I'm excited to see what they'll add with the next updates.
But so far, first app in years that it actually has the potential to be big long term. We'll see!
4
u/Apexe Jul 06 '23
PLEASE don't lock usernames behind instagram. An app that has been around for well over a decade SHOULD NOT lock existing names on a different site. I can't use my username (not reddit name) on Threads because an account already has it, but it also doesn't exist on IG. What kinda horseshit is this?
2
u/TizACoincidence Jul 06 '23
I just made another instagram and account and linked it to my threads. So my thread app is an anonymous username. My insta world has always been very different from my twitter world
1
u/RichardBJ1 Jul 06 '23
Exactly. I leapt in first thing to grab my ideal username but it taken by an Instagram user who has never ever posted a thing!
1
2
Jul 06 '23
I really don’t see this app going anywhere
But I said the same thing about Tik tok so what do I know
2
u/Technical_Lab9830 Jul 06 '23
It's so boring, its just a bunch of lame local influencers stuck on my feed and I cannot control the content at all.
1
u/thatscomplex1015 Jul 06 '23
Right, all I see big Corp verified accounts all quoting each other to get more followers
0
u/Technical_Lab9830 Jul 06 '23
And they aren't saying anything interesting, unique or engaging at all. Some of them are just using it as another Instagram posting selfies and shit. I guess this is what happens when an Instagram userbase discovers Twitter. Vapid shallow content ensues.
2
Jul 06 '23
If I can eventually see trending topics about what’s going on in the world, then I’m deleting Twitter for good.
2
u/CrazyNalin Asia Jul 06 '23
Pros and cons of @threadsapp over twitter Cons
No hashtags
Feed is cluttered with threads from people you don't follow. (Twitter atleast had a seperate tab)
User Handle contingency with Instagram
The audience
Bugs
Pros
No DMs
Simple (Like Twitter used to be)
No limitations (Yet)
3
1
1
1
u/iamkoalafied Jul 06 '23
Can you have an account without having Instagram? I'm probably not going to use it anyway because there's no way to access it on desktop but I also don't have an Instagram.
1
u/shmishshmorshin Jul 06 '23
I’m sure they’ll add more basic functions as time goes on. Sooner versus later of course. Base functions are nice and as someone who never jumped into Twitter aside from sports/news updates I’m looking forward to being more active if this takes off. Lots of potential for sure.
1
u/nerdking314 Jul 06 '23
It's very strange that there is no hastags and direct messages. Instagram already has those.... I guess they delayed those features due to wanting to launch it soon...
1
u/nerdking314 Jul 06 '23
I'm glad they launched it on the Google play store and apps store at the same time.
1
u/ILoveScottishLasses Jul 06 '23
I can’t add friends easily after the first initial sign up. They must be on their way to update this, but right now it's a pain to find and invite people. So far there are tons of verified users I can careless about too.
1
u/TizACoincidence Jul 06 '23
No gifs is big, but I think they will add that.
I can't post an image though, for me it crashes everytime.
I just made another instagram account with nothing on it, and then linked it to threads, so my insta is not connected to threads
But I don't care, I get to read tons of things without the toxicity of elon and thats enough for me
1
u/winkandthebumblebees Jul 06 '23
I like the random people but I wish it was even more random at this point. I wanna see the content from people with like 10 followers.
No GIFs is the same as Instagram. It's like they hate fun.
1
u/RichardBJ1 Jul 06 '23
Mastodon will do that for you… you can set it to be purely a random list of posts from the “fediverse” or your own server? I liked the way Threads very soon shaped into posts I liked, but I would rather have choice of 1. my choice OR 2. their suggestions.
1
1
1
u/Jmrwacko Jul 06 '23
I’m less interested in Threads itself and more interested in how this sort of competition will improve Twitter and short-form content social media more broadly. Hope it doesn’t die like Google+.
1
u/Moegii Jul 06 '23
I really wish you could’ve had a stand-alone threads account without linking to your Instagram. I understand why it’s part of IG, but still.
1
1
Jul 06 '23
It's flooded. If they don't make it so you can see followed accounts only there's no use for me here.
I don't want random people in feed.
1
u/Introverts3000 Jul 06 '23
Yess the homepage only shows verified accounts sucks i wanna talk with my frienddd 🥺🥺
1
u/gulwver Jul 06 '23
Do you have to connect it to your instagram? Does it do that automatically?
1
Jul 07 '23
there is no way to even create one without instagram. the official name is Threads by Instagram after all.
1
u/redflavormp3 Jul 06 '23 edited Jul 06 '23
Really liking the UI on the first page just because it’s very minimalistic and honestly makes a Twitter feed seem a bit clunky. However, there are nonetheless a lot of things that they need to add to make it a true competitor. It’s kinda absurd that they haven’t already added a hashtag feature or a search function for keywords. I’ve never personally cared about seeing what posts other people like but I do occasionally scroll through someone’s follow list so it’s disappointing that I can’t see what accounts someone is following.
1
u/Gaurav-Garg15 Jul 07 '23
I can assure you that all these features will be implemented within a month
1
1
1
u/Agent666-Omega Jul 09 '23
Some people say it's rushed to capture the audience pissed at Elon and rate limit. But to me that's bad strategy because people are going to get on the app and if the first impression isn't good they will bounce.
Numbers are proving me wrong though. Perhaps peoples hate for Elon and Twitter is so great they might just use this out of spite long enough for them to release said features. But they will need to do it quick. My only reason for liking threads cause it's in the fediverse.
1
u/HixWithAnX Jul 09 '23
I’m not sure I understand why there’s such a frenzy about threads. This is a Zuckerberg company. You know, the guy who let Facebook spread rampant misinformation leading up to the 2016 election and has wined and dined with right wing politicians and influencers. Like yeah Elon is basically a QAnoner at this point he’s so extreme. But moving from twitter to threads feels like cutting off your nose to spite your face. Should I feel otherwise?
1
u/Plastic_Vacation9971 Aug 04 '23
The cons show how quickly they rolled out the software after coming up with the idea to subvert Twitter's market share! 😂 Updates and new features to follow no doubt...
1
u/zerointegrity Jul 06 '23
How is no elon a pro? Just a bunch of recency bias among users, its an okay app lol. Millions of people will get off this app by September
1
1
u/thatscomplex1015 Jul 06 '23
Funny thing is they tried launching the app 2-3 yrs ago and it failed bad. They’re doing it again but it’s still not going to kill off twitter unless Elon gets his act together.
2
1
1
u/Jamie-Tartt Jul 06 '23
This is DOA if they don't make it where you can only see followed posts chronology and ignore non followed posts. But seeing how FB and insta work I'm not holding my breath. This is going to die on the vine in this state.
2
-2
u/Consistent-Use-7982 Jul 06 '23 edited Jul 06 '23
My first impression : It’s a rip off of Twitter -“Threads” off people I have never heard of. It’s too much for me I’ll be sticking with my Twitter
-1
u/Bumble072 Jul 06 '23
Forgot a few cons.
Heavy handed censorship of any opinion that Zucks doesn't like.
Account suspension with no explantion a la Instagram.
Using your personal information openly.
-3
1

46
u/Tara_is_a_Potato Jul 06 '23
You forgot the #1 pro:
no Elon