r/Thomism • • Dec 30 '24

The Cosmic Christ Paradox

0 Upvotes

If the multiverse exists and is infinite, then it logically follows that intelligent alien life capable of thought, reasoning, and moral decision-making must also exist. Within this context, if Catholicism is assumed to be the true faith and the incarnation of Jesus Christ occurred uniquely for humanity on Earth, it raises a profound theological paradox. Would these alien civilizations, which are presumably capable of understanding morality, sin, and redemption, also receive their own divine figure—an “alien Jesus”—to guide them toward salvation and communion with God? Or, if no such divine intervention occurred for them, does this challenge the universality and completeness of Catholic theology, which holds that Jesus is the singular savior for all creation? Furthermore, does this imply that humanity occupies an unparalleled and uniquely divine role in the multiverse, or does it necessitate a reevaluation of how Catholicism addresses the possibility of sentient beings beyond Earth? These questions not only push the boundaries of faith and reason but also compel a deeper exploration of how Catholic theology integrates with the potential realities of a vast and diverse cosmos.


r/Thomism • • Sep 21 '25

Orientation to Beatitude: Nature or Grace

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/Thomism • • Mar 22 '25

What would Thomas Aquinas say about the rise of AI?

3 Upvotes

r/Thomism • • Aug 25 '25

St Thomas vs Bl Scotus on the Incarnation

2 Upvotes

I've heard that St Thomas, view on the Incarnation is that God chose this because of humanities fall, whereas Bl Dun Scotus meant that God would become man even if man did not fall.

How did they argue for their conclusions and can someone recommend the relevant passages from their works?


r/Thomism • • Apr 08 '20

A Short History and Theology of Spiritual Communion

Thumbnail
churchlifejournal.nd.edu
3 Upvotes

r/Thomism • • Mar 10 '16

The late Charles De Koninck, a faithful Thomist. Let him not be forgotten.

Thumbnail
charlesdekoninck.com
1 Upvotes

r/Thomism • • Oct 05 '20

Is Love Necessary to Grow in Virtue?

2 Upvotes

I was listening to the audio book version of After Virtue by Alasdair MacIntyre. At the end, in his responses to criticisms, he differentiates between skill and virtue. He uses the example of a chess player who becomes very good at chess in order to enjoy the trappings of winning at chess: monetary rewards, the feeling of victory, etc. This person may increase in the skill of chess, but he will not increase in virtue through chess. In order to use chess to increase in virtue, he must enjoy the internal goods of chess. This makes me wonder, does the chess player need to love chess for the sake of chess in order to grow in virtue?


r/Thomism • • Apr 17 '21

Today Thomist Philosophy

3 Upvotes

Which the better Thomist philosopher today?


r/Thomism • • Apr 29 '21

Summa Contra Gentiles

2 Upvotes

Some time ago I bought the Summa Contra Gentiles with the intention of reading it in the future because my knowledge in philosophy is quite limited, I ended up being entertained with other readings until then, would I be able to read it without a good philosophical basis? Accompanied by a comment or something.


r/Thomism • • Nov 15 '23

What is sin?

1 Upvotes

As in, what is it ontologically speaking?


r/Thomism • • Nov 13 '23

Aquinas on Alchemy

1 Upvotes

Hey guys, are any of you aware of any thomistic texts dealing with alchemy? I saw an excerpt once where he commented on alchemical medicine and I'd like to look more into how Aquinas viewed it.


r/Thomism • • Sep 05 '15

Fr. Thomas Joseph White OP on the Heart of Redemption

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/Thomism • • Nov 17 '24

Anyone well-versed in the works of Aquinas?

2 Upvotes

I need someone to talk to regarding his views on art and aesthetics (and maybe also how it ties to morality and goodness). Thank you 🥲


r/Thomism • • Apr 06 '24

Please critique my argument regarding Thomistic simplicity!

3 Upvotes

Hey guys - currently trying to understand Divine Simplicity from a Thomistic perspective. I am new to this, and would like to have my mind sharpened by those who have more experience/knowledge in this area. Could you please offer thoughtful criticisms of the following? I'm not trying to formulate a logical argument - it's just a train of thought to ensure I'm understanding the concepts correctly.

--------------

How to be a metaphysically necessary being 101:

  1. It cannot not exist

  2. Therefore it must be uncreated

  3. It must be the only uncreated thing, since if there are other existing things, there would be a distinction between this one and that one

  4. If there is a distinction between this one and that one, then these things would not be ultimately simple

  5. If these things are not ultimately simple, they are themselves contingent and therefore not metaphysically necessary

  6. Therefore, there must be only one metaphysically necessary being

  7. It must be at least partially causal with respect to causality and potentiality

  8. But it cannot contain any potentiality, because if it did, then it would result in a regress of causes until arriving first cause, which by definition lacks potentiality, caused the rest of creation

  9. Therefore it must be purely causal

  10. Therefore it must be the cause of all other things

  11. It must be purely simple because only contingent things have parts

  12. All contingent things are complex because something must exist 'outside' the complex thing to create/instantiate the complexity

  13. Therefore, to avoid a regress of complex things instantiating other complex things, there must be a simple, non-complex thing that begins the process of creating complex contingent things


r/Thomism • • Nov 09 '22

Hylomorphism and Personal Identity in Heaven

4 Upvotes

So I'm philosophically convinced of hylomorphism, but I'm having trouble at this point. If I am essentially a composite of body and soul, then when my soul is in Heaven, separated from the body after I die, how can I speak of "I" or "me" at that time? Does it make sense to speak of St. Paul praying for us from Heaven, or only the soul of St. Paul doing so? Does St. Paul even really exist, then, or does the soul of St. Paul refer to itself as "the soul of St. Paul" rather than referring to itself personally as a "himself" who may say that "I am St. Paul"?


r/Thomism • • Jun 30 '20

Love = Light/Heat? Will = Gravity?

1 Upvotes

I have been scouring over the first few pages of The Person & The Common Good by Jacques Maritain. He uses these terms constantly: LOVE. WILL.

Could it not be that this is just a vast metaphor for science being subsumed into Roman Catholic theology? I don't adduce anything; I only ask.


r/Thomism • • Dec 03 '20

The Collapse of the Intrinsic/Prudential Judgment Distinction

Thumbnail
churchlifejournal.nd.edu
4 Upvotes

r/Thomism • • Nov 15 '20

Questions: Virtue Theory, Humility, Magnanimity, Pusillanimity

1 Upvotes

Aquinas says that the deficient vice for both humility and magnanimity is pusillanimity. Additionally, he claims that magnanimity has three vices of excess: presumption, ambition, and vainglory.

Given these claims, is it wrong to think of virtue as being in the middle of two extremes? If not, how can magnanimity have four vices? Is the vice of pusillanimity with respect to humility separate from the vice opposed to magnanimity? If someone is pusillanimous, is she necessarily neither humble nor magnanimous?


r/Thomism • • Jun 10 '20

Before Academic and Religious Freedom

Thumbnail
churchlifejournal.nd.edu
1 Upvotes

r/Thomism • • Feb 12 '16

Most of the works of Aquinas online-in both Latin and English

Thumbnail dhspriory.org
1 Upvotes

r/Thomism • • Dec 24 '22

The Kalam

3 Upvotes

One particular argument for the finitude of the past is the alleged impossibility of traversing an actual infinite. One great example of this is Thomson's Lamp (sp?). Imagine that at every temporal interval, a light switch is turned on or off. At the present moment, the light switch is turned on.

Can an infinite past explain why the switch is turned on or off? The current state is explained by the prior state, and so on, but there is no terminus. Thus, there is no final explanation for why the light switch is presently turned on. It's like someone claiming to count down from infinity, "...-3, -2, -1, 0--Done!".

Why did they finish then and not an prior moment before, or an infinitely long time ago. You might also compare it to jumping out of an infinitely deep hole.

Take the light switch example. An infinite past cannot explain the present, because of the vicious regress of explanations. This strikes me as logically similar to Aquinas' claim that a causal series ordered per se, even if infinite, must have an ultimate explanation.

If the Kalam is right, even temporal series require an explanation because of the particularity of the present. Return to the light switch. In order to explain its current state, two things must be explained: why the light switch exists, and it's starting position as on or off.

What's fundamentally required is the explanation of a particular moment, in terms of a concrete union of finite composition of substance and accident. That seems just like the thonistic arguments which take actuality and potentiality, cause and effect, or existence and essence, as what requires explaining.

...

Is this analysis correct? Is the Kalam therefore fundamentally a temporal version of the thomistic arguments?


r/Thomism • • Dec 22 '22

Reading McCabe for the first time.

1 Upvotes

Like the title says, I'm working through God Matters and I'm just very impressed with the clarity and precision of his work here. Absolutely stellar work chipping away at our conceptual idols.


r/Thomism • • Mar 21 '24

James F. Ross Study Group

2 Upvotes

I'd like to invite anyone interested in the work of the late Catholic philosopher James F. Ross to consider joining me in a slow read of Ross's work. I just set up a subreddit group and put a list of preliminary glossary terms as a way of launching the group:

James F. Ross Discussion Group.


r/Thomism • • Dec 13 '21

Can God annihilate my soul and then recreate it?

3 Upvotes

Title basically says it all. According to Thomas' philosophy, would God be able to completely annihilate my soul and then recreate my soul, or does this necessarily imply a contradiction since it's hard to see how the recreated soul would be continuous with my previously annihilated soul?


r/Thomism • • Jan 24 '21

Fesser

5 Upvotes

What do you think about Edward Fesser and Analytic Thomism**?**