r/ThomasPynchon • • Sep 20 '24

Discussion Love them but...

0 Upvotes

I love Thomas Pynchon and David Foster Wallace(though from all his work iI've only read the all of Infinite Jest 3 times) but today I'm thinking they might not be for me.They are very addictive to me but they can bring me up and down maybe in a matter of 20 minutes or something..!Maybe I am on a reading slump,I don't know,do you guys feel like that too?I am very confused...


r/ThomasPynchon • • May 04 '24

Tangentially Pynchon Related Don't know where else to post this to receive the intellectual noogie I deserve : Am I the only person who thinks Don DeLillo is...vastly over rated?

6 Upvotes

Not trying to offend anyone here--this is just my opinion (one I've struggled with for a long time, in fact), and I'm happy if anyone cares to agree with me or argue the case: Most writers/critics I like and respect worship Don DeLillo. I've been trying to convince myself that I like him for my entire reading life and I just don't get it.

For starters, I find it absolutely baffling that fans seem to openly acknowledge and joke about the fact that every character in every one of his (very dialogue heavy) novels talks in the exact same way. It's shocking to me that younger writers who worship DeLillo like Jonathan Franzen, DFW, Zadie Smith etc. who specifically champion strong characters, character-driven stories etc. in an almost overly pious way are able to countenance the undeniable 2-dimensionality of so many DeLillo characters in this regard. And he seems to enjoy some bizarre immunity there. Incomprehensible that this same literary community that spent the late 80s and 90s bestowing laurels on DeLillo simultaneously derided someone like Brett Easton Ellis for populating heavy-handed satires with flat, off-putting characters.

I'm on the younger side, under 30, and I can see how some of his treatment of consumerism, technocracy, etc., might have been revolutionary for its time, but the satire feels kind of quaint now. It's one thing to appreciate something in its context and acknowledge its influence and quite another to call someone a genius who produced timeless masterpieces. Also can't get over the, like, Baudrillardian discourses that populate his novels where people are watching something on TV and talking about how the fact that they're watching the thing on TV is etc. etc.

White Noise, Libra, and Underworld are all great books, sure, but they're not great enough to elevate him to the pantheon of America's best contemporary writers as he often is. Haven't read much post-Underworld, but I find everything pre-White Noise to be entirely execrable. I've been shocked to learn that people like Franzen and Wallace jacked off to DeLillo's early, pre-White Noise work while they were in college in the early 80s. I rarely RARELY let myself put down a book once I've started it and I had to stop End Zone, Great Jones Street, Running Dog, and The Names. I found the first 3 absolutely incoherent and terrible, and the narrator of the last was a kind of insufferable poor man's Jack Gladney with none of the seeming critical distance that I feel we get in White Noise.

Obviously, Underworld is what has raised DeLillo to the top tier for most people (it's what made Harold Bloom place him alongside Roth, Pynchon, and McCarthy). There's that Times poll in which authors rank it as the 2nd best novel since the 1980 or something. All of that makes me feel like I'm the problem when I say...eh Idk about that. It was fantastic, and doubtless contains some of the best prose of the decade, but I would personally place it far behind Gravity's Rainbow or Blood Meridian or Sabbath's Theater, or any of the other masterpieces written by his contemporaries (maybe it's all of that DeLillo dialogue...). There are massive ~1,000 page books that I wished continued forever while reading and have since reread, and Underworld definitely isn't one of them. Anyway. Tell my why I'm dumb.


r/ThomasPynchon • • Jun 05 '24

Gravity's Rainbow What Are The Odds Pynchon Comes Out Of Retirement And Literally Writes A Book That Has The Ultimate Meaning Of Life, The Universe, And Everything Within Its Pages

0 Upvotes

An explanation of how nothing became something, how unconscious matter became conscious, what happens after death, etc.


r/ThomasPynchon • • Jan 30 '25

Discussion Am I allowed to read Vineland?

5 Upvotes

For context I have only read TCOL49 (The Crying of Lot 49)

I was planning to read GR (Gravity’s Rainbow) next.

But I am a big film person and am excited for PTA’s (Paul Thomas Anderson) upcoming (loose?) adaption of VL (Vineland).

So I am considering reading it next in advance of the film, making it my second Pynchon book read.

Is this okay? Will anyone be mad at me? Will I be arrested or something? Thank you.


r/ThomasPynchon • • Dec 13 '23

Gravity's Rainbow Comparing Gravity's Rainbow to DFW's Infinite Jest

1 Upvotes

I've gotten about 250 pages into GR currently, and as much as I want to like it, it just isn't hooking me. The historical context and metaphor, the surrealist imagery and humor, the erections, all great... it's just all so maniacal and incoherent lol The only other big postmodern brick I've read is Infinite Jest, and I struggled with that too for the first 200 pages. But by then I was totally attached to Infinite Jest's absurd world, lore and characters. I'm writing this post so hopefully some hardcore Pynchon heads can disagree and tell me Gravity's Rainbow is the better book, and I should keep reading, or read it differently, or maybe suggest a different novel of his?

The thing that makes IJ such a page-turner for me is that it's hilarious, but in a more meticulous way than GR. It's fragmented and dense like GR, but the interiority of the characters is much more refined. You really understand them and where they fit in the novel's world. It can be hard to keep track of IJ's multiple sections and factions and subplots, but at the very least you know where you are and who are you reading about in each section. Midnight's Children by Salman Rushdie was also dense and full of colorful characters, but was way easier to follow.

GR has none of this lol It's so much more external and hyperactive and bounces from one thing to the next, making it totally exhausting to read for me. There is no thematic through-line like Infinite Jest. So much so that it makes me feel like Pynchon may be hiding behind the mystique of dream-like, maniacal prose, instead of daring to make more a more substantial point. It was the psychedelic 60s after all! "Who needs plot!" lol

Anyway I feel DFW as the newer author really improved upon the post-modern shtick, instead of just relying on absurdism and "the destruction of meaning and grand narratives" for its own sake. But could Infinite Jest have been written without Gravity's Rainbow setting the precedent? Maybe not.


r/ThomasPynchon • • Feb 25 '24

Vineland B.C. Project

0 Upvotes

is currently being called that because Vineland is the prequel to Bleeding Edge, the first four chapters of which was written as an allegory for the immaculate conception of Mary (AKA Vyrva) along with Archangel Gabriel’s (AKA Gabe Ice) news to the Virgin Mary that she will give birth to a son. The rest of the book deals (in encoded allegory format, mind you) with the birth of this inanimate ‘Christ’ incarnation of V.

Vineland is before ‘Christ’ (read: “B.C.”)

Don’t believe me? Ask the dishes. - Angela Lansbury, Beauty and the Beast (1991)

OR

watch the Bleeding Edge promo closely for clues - and listen to each and every word that Pynchon carefully chose to script it and intended for his son Jackson to shoot his friend from high school acting in.

OR

re-read Bleeding Edge and think hard about it. Harder than you’ve been thinking about it- (I’m looking at you, ‘scholars’)

Edit: my bad, it wasn’t Lansbury who said that in the Disney cartoon. It was Lumiere, who happened to be voiced by the actor that portrayed Lenny on Law & Order. Btw: Maxine Tarnow compares herself to both Lenny and Lansbury in Bleeding Edge

Edit #2: the bleeding edge trailer was curiously removed from YouTube. Here it is on Vimeo: https://vimeo.com/73716114


r/ThomasPynchon • • Oct 08 '25

Discussion Can we not make this a PTA sub

0 Upvotes

Idk if I'm the only one but I'm personally getting sick of all the obaa content on here. I feel like everything that can be said about the movie has been said already, and now we've reached the stage where we have people who've never read a Pynchon book coming in here and posting the same tired "which book should I start with" engagement baiting, the same shitty fanart, and the same generally inane half-thought-out cold takes you've already heard a billion times over, that every subreddit seems doomed to descend into. Idk what to do about this but I just hope this clears up soon and we can get to our regularly scheduled content bc this used to be far and away the best sub on reddit imo and lately it's become unrecognizable. This isn't a PTA sub people, the movie wasn't even technically an adaptation, there's literally a new book out and I'm still seeing more posts about muh le heckin epic French 75 than our boy Hicks McTaggart.


r/ThomasPynchon • • Jan 26 '24

Image Theo Von as Tyrone Slothrop

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’m about 200 pages into GR and I have been picturing Slothrop as Theo Von in my head. I don’t why, I don’t even like Theo Von or follow him closely. I’ve only seen like 2 interviews with him. And I know their will probably never be a GR movie and that this guy is not who would be cast, ever. But idk. It works somehow in my head. Thought I’d share.


r/ThomasPynchon • • Sep 01 '23

Discussion When does Gravity’s Rainbow get better?

4 Upvotes

I’m 150 pages in and honestly kind of bored.

I will say I hated Infinite Jest for about 200 pages and then kind of had an epiphany and got it. Is that going to happen here or should I think about bailing?

No spoilers please. Thanks!


r/ThomasPynchon • • Jul 16 '25

Discussion What is the best book to read to get into Pynchon?

0 Upvotes

Preferably a shorter novel as my attention span is cooked and I’m quite busy. Also, what are 3 words that describe him as a writer? Trying to get a feel for him


r/ThomasPynchon • • Apr 22 '24

Gravity's Rainbow I finally figured out the main theme of Gravity's Rainbow

0 Upvotes

When god created man, the devil was at his shoulder.

After having forged the most noble of all creatures, god gave him a weapon, with which he would surpress his fellows, which would drive him to great evil.

This weapon, much like the oven state, would drive man to his ascendancy.

The dick was the most evil creation of all time, the happiness of the few at the cost of the many.

But much like the oven state, the dick will shatter upon it's own declaration of grandiosity.

We are now between two points, we are ascending, ascending, sexuality is now nearing the one, but... once it nears the one it's descent will become inevatble.

Sexuals are coming out in increasing numbers. But they are manufacturing their own destruction.

Oboy, the end is near, the dick finally shattering upon the coming [redacted]

The Age of the Dick is almost over, the Age of Love is about to begin!


r/ThomasPynchon • • Sep 26 '25

Custom Is Vineland out of print?

0 Upvotes

For obvious reasons, I'm really wanting to read Vineland. It'll be my first Pynchon, so I'm very excited. The problem is I can't find a physical copy ANYWHERE. My university library doesn't have it (they've got all his other books), my city library system doesn't have it, no bookstores have it. I found a copy online, but I'm not big on reading on my iPad.

I was hoping for a movie tie-in like Inherent Vice, but no word on it.

Edit: Canadian here, no Barnes and Nobel and wouldn't even dream of shopping American for the next decade.

Edit II: Went to Indigo yesterday and the employee said they just got a bunch of copies in the other day!


r/ThomasPynchon • • Sep 26 '25

Meme/Humor One Wolf After Another (OBAA Fanart)

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I watched OBAA last night (Haven't read Vineland) and really enjoyed the score, cinematography, & message. So I channeled that energy into making this, hope you Pynchonites enjoy!


r/ThomasPynchon • • Aug 28 '23

Discussion How to read tp

0 Upvotes

Smoking first is best


r/ThomasPynchon • • Sep 22 '26

💬 Discussion Why Pynchon isn't name dropped like other writers?

17 Upvotes

People casually name drop Dostoevsky or Tolstoy or Kafka everywhere,but for Pynchon,its very hard to find people name dropping. Paul Thomas Anderson is the only person who name drops Pynchon afaik. Why's that?


r/ThomasPynchon • • Jul 18 '25

Discussion Interested in Mason & Dixon

4 Upvotes

Hello. I wanted to say that I really like Mason & Dixon, though I have not read it. I haven't read any of Pynchon's work because I have plenty to read as is, but something about M&D really attracts me: the writing style and this historical fiction aspect of it. I liked Blood Meridian because McCarthy put a spin of his own into the story of the American Redness. It just attracts me, and I love the cover as well. So I just thought up of asking you guys whether you'd recommend M&D to a newbie who wants to read it, and I can confidently say that I won't desert it once I start. I'll stick with it because I just love the writing style. It almost invites me.
Thanks.


r/ThomasPynchon • • Jan 17 '24

Discussion How to prepare for Gravitys Rainbow (GR reading list)

0 Upvotes

Hey my guys. How are you doing.

Gravity’s Rainbow is a complicated book, perhaps the most complicated book ever. So, reading up on some of the subject matter will help in understanding Pynchon. Got any suggestions for the reading list? Here are mine:

  1. A history of the Herero people

  2. A history of WWII

  3. A physics textbook

  4. Hansel and Gretel

  5. The Gnostic bible

  6. Books on Jewish and Hermetic Kabbalism

  7. An introductory textbook to quantum physic

  8. Astrophysics nonfiction, not a textbook

  9. An introduction to classical economics, possibly Marx, Ricardo, not modern economics though.

  10. Maybe a book on the history of the Blitz

  11. The Bible, obviously

  12. A book on 50/60’s pop culture

  13. A book on chemistry/bio chemistry

What are your suggestions for the reading list?

Edit: wanted to add a few more:

14. Philosophy textbooks on free will 15. Try to find something on German runeology 16. French Philosophy in the 20th century I, II and III 17. Heideggers being and time could help as well

Also, I am not saying that you need to read this before Gravitys Rainbow, this reading list is meant for rereads, and I think it odd that no one seems to agree with me that reading other books will help. Please, be amiable and consider that this could help in appreciating Pynchon’s genius.


r/ThomasPynchon • • Dec 05 '22

Mason & Dixon What in gods name is this jumble of a musing??

0 Upvotes

It’s a break in the dialogue between Mazcaline and Mason inside their little cottage on St. Helena as they wait for this new planet to show itself.

A little traveling stage troupe is St. Helena really. All performance. A plantation, sent out years since by its metropolitan planet which will remain invisible for years indeterminate before revealing itself and acquiring a name. This place till then serving as an aid memoir, a representation of home.

What is “this place”? St. Helena or the cabin Mason and Mazcaline are in? Or the planet itself?

Is St. Helena a stage troupe or a plantation? These are two wildly different metaphors. Who are they performing for? The unnamed planet, the Royal Society or England itself?

Is the unnamed planet the plantation? Is the cabin or St. Helena supposed to be the “aid memoir” for it? What does he mean when he says “reveal itself?” Is St. Helena revealing itself? It already has a name. Is it the planet?

THERE’S NO REASON FOR THIS TO BE THAT GODDAMN CONFUSING.

I’m sorry but this book is littered with puzzles like that. Sentences that run on together for so long that the ideas the author is attempting to explore get diluted by their deliberately disjointed writing style. And look, maybe this is just a me problem. Maybe I’m not smart enough for it. But I’ve had to relisten to the same parts of the story over and over and over again just to get a handle on what the hell he’s talking about. And you can’t just ignore it and move on!

Because you just know the damned man will reference that in some oblique way in the form of a joke or in some larger way as a plot point. And it doesn’t feel fucking worth it when an editor could just mention “Hey Thom, uhhh this shit makes no fucking sense. Can you write it like a normal human being?”

I really enjoy Pynchon, I won’t say love because it’s too strong a word imho and too early considering this is my first Pynchon novel, but sometimes it feels like he gets lost in his own sauce. Too in love with his writing or the act of writing to remember to write clearly. There’s making your audience work to understand what you’re talking about, the deliberately archaic writing style, using the older definitions of words such as “plantation”, which I had to look up, and then there’s just bad writing that gets a pass because it’s coming from an “artist”.

UGH. Sorry, this turned into a vent but goddamn. This is why people don’t fucking read postmodern authors and why Danielle Steele is a multimillionaire.


r/ThomasPynchon • • Nov 28 '24

Custom Bianca, Pedophillia in Gravity's Rainobow NSFW Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I responded to a comment earlier which some of this analysis is from but especially in light of gthe news of cormac mcarthy and his underage muse i was wondering if people were interested in discussing the scene with Bianca and the role of pedophilia in gravity's rainbow. the bianca seen i always felt like it was so over the top in terms of suggesting she was a child that it wouldn't go as straight up erotica. For one it's surrounded by sexual depravity on the Anubis, where slothrop goes from one extreme sex situation to the other, adopting to the decadent sexual practices around him . And CW its gross but this quote " baby rodent hands race his body
|| unbuttoning, caressing. Such a slender child: baby rodent hands race his body
|| unbuttoning, caressing. Such a slender child:".

To me this quote and the use of language describing bianca as small is evidence to me that the scene is meant to be gross rather than sexually arousing. But others disagree and I can see the argument that pynchon went too far. Certainly I think most can agree this section would be handled differently today but I am curious of others opinions


r/ThomasPynchon • • Oct 25 '25

💬 Discussion Will there ever be a film adaptation of Gravity’s Rainbow?

5 Upvotes

I’m one of those quasi-mature Pynheads who still hasn’t read some of the man’s most glorified works (Against the Day, Mason & Dixon) but I did survive through Gravity’s Rainbow. So I don’t know which of his works would be the toughest to pull off as an adaptation, I just feel like - in the right director’s hands - GR could be a cinematic masterpiece (not as great as the literary masterpiece it is but that’s part of the dream).

The best format for it would probably be a limited series of 8 1hour-long episodes or something, but.. the real question is.. could an adaptation ever see the light of day? What director (besides PTA) could have what it takes to pull it off? Is there something already brewing? Etc.


r/ThomasPynchon • • Aug 16 '25

Discussion Shower thought re: Gravity's Rainbow

1 Upvotes

Excise the beautiful (<- don't get me wrong) pointless/meandering/"atmospheric" stuff from Gravity's Rainbow and the book would be about 75 pages long.


r/ThomasPynchon • • Jun 25 '24

Custom I love when tp is being serious, but I hate when he’s being silly

12 Upvotes

Or something like that idk. I guess i just kind of feel meh when he’s being silly, which takes up most of his books. But when I get to one of those really emotional beautiful parts, it’s like… I need more. I also know that the silliness and the seriousness can overlap. But whatever, hopefully you know what I mean


r/ThomasPynchon • • Jun 30 '25

Bleeding Edge How much of Bleeding Edge do you speculate had been written / sketched out prior to the events of 11 September, 2001.

0 Upvotes
  • None.

  • Some.

  • Hardly any.

  • A good bit.

  • Not so much.

  • this is stupid to speculate & ima downvote you for it

  • He re-used some material that originally had been meant to be in other books, sure.

-Obviously none you jackass / imbecile / nitwit / stooge

Or:

All!


r/ThomasPynchon • • Jun 04 '25

Discussion Shadow Ticket & Vineland page count similarity

0 Upvotes

So Shadow Ticket shall be 384 pages, according to TP’s good friend Jim Knipfel.

Let’s observe the fact that Vineland is 385 pages.

Could this have been an intentional near-twinning? If so, I wonder why…

Do you think this sort of thing is worth wondering about?