r/TheoryOfPony • u/laofmoonster • Jan 08 '12
r/TheoryOfPony • u/TheNittles • May 25 '13
Rarity: The Evil Mastermind of Mind Control [X-post from r/mlplounge]
Let me preface this by saying this isn't really a theory I believe, or headcannon or anything. Just a little thought I came up with that fit the canon of the show terrifyingly well.
I've always wondered why marshmallow pone's most popular dresses or outfits are always the ones that look like Equestria's precut gem factory vomited all over them. So, as I listened to a cover of Art of the Dress a few months back, I noticed a line that I'd never noticed before.
"Don't forget some magic in the dress!"
DUN DUN DUUUUUUUUUUUUN!
It seems like an innocent throwaway line, written for nothing more than a rhyme, but let's look at the facts.
Rarity's most popular creations are generally her ugliest, diamond encrusted monstrosities. Sapphire Shores loved them. So did her teacher.
Filly Rarity also managed to sew some awesome little food costumes for her classmates, and her teacher thought they were "very nice."
After Rarity plastered the costumes with jewels, her teacher thought they were much -um- better? I guess? She doesn't have any lines in this scene, but she's grinning hugely with the gems sparkling in her eyes. Only then did Rarity get her cutie mark.
Rarity is capable of presumably complex magic, as during Art of the Dress, she moves her entire studio in choreography at once, and at the end of Becoming Popular, she teleports a piece of fabric under an existing ribbon.
So what can we conclude from this? Clearly, Rarity's special talent is not fashion, as she would have gotten her cutie mark and gotten her teacher's approval when she sewed the costumes. It's not gemfinding either, because she didn't get her cutie mark when she found the rock.
It's mind magic, specifically infusing gems with it.. She infuses the gems with magic that alters the viewer's perception of or attitude towards the garment. We know that gems can hold magic in the MLP universe. The Elements of Harmony and the Crystal Heart are proof of that.
Clearly, fashion is Rarity's hobby, and she's quite good at it, thus explaining why she can make nice dresses like the Gala dresses without her mind magic, but she keeps a few emergency mind control outfits around, in case someone like Sapphire shores drops in and wants to see an outfit pronto. It also explains why she put "some magic in the dress." Even the dresses she spent time on couldn't suffer from a mental boost.
So there you have it. Rarity is a sinister magician playing with everyone's thoughts. Or maybe it's subconscious. Either way, her gems are evil.
All hail marshmallow pone.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/tiedyedvortex • Nov 11 '12
Twilight sparkle is being groomed to as heir to both Celestia and Luna
This idea came to me when reading thedarkdragon89's post.
Celestia and Luna are both unmarried and have no heirs. They appear to be ageless immortals; it's established in S01EP01 that the imprisonment of Luna occured 1000+ years ago, and both are still physically young. But a thousand years is a long time; it's possible that Celestia and Luna are considering retirement. Even if they don't, they probably recognize that they should have an heir to the throne in case the worst should happen.
But the successor could not just be anypony. The pony would need to be a potent magical force, to be able to assume the duty of raising the sun and moon every day. She would need to be well-educated, wise, diligent, and compassionate. She would also need to be able to wield the Elements of Harmony against outside threats; Celestia is evidently capable of wielding all 6 by herself, but her successor would probably need friends.
Enter a young filly named Twilight Sparkle. In her magic school entry exam, she displays extraordinary magic potential. Celestia recognizes that this filly could have the necessary qualities to assume the throne once she's ready. She takes the young Twilight under her wing, and begins to teach her advanced magic, while also instilling in her the necessary personality traits that a ruler needs. She keeps her true motives secret, however, because if it were public knowledge that she was contemplating retirement, then there would be a power struggle to seize the immenent power gap.
Fast forward a few years. Twilight has grown into a highly capable magic user and competent, responsible adult. However, she is highly antisocial. Celestia sends Twilight to Ponyville to learn about friendship. This is for two reasons. First, a good ruler needs to be able to relate to her subjects on a personal level. Second, Twilight needs friends in order to be able to wield the Elements of Harmony.
Twilight goes above and beyond these expectations; not only does she predict the return of Nightmare Moon, she successfully gathers a group of friends to use the Elements to defeat her and bring back Luna. Celestia is impressed, and at Twilight's request, she allows her pupil to remain with her friends and continue her studies independently.
Over the next few years, Twilight's magic grows continually stronger. She uses the Elements of Harmony to defeat Discord, and breaks Cadence out of jail so she can be with Shining Armor and help him save the day.
In the new season premiere, there were two important relevations. The first was that the saving of the Crystal Empire was a test, where the stakes were that she would advance to the "next level" of training, and Twilight passed this test. The second revelation was the existence of dark magic, and that Celestia and Twilight are both capable of it (Luna obviously can, from her Nightmare Moon days).
As thedarkdragon89 pointed out, in the final seconds of S03EP02, Luna conjures a book with a black cover. Celestia looks at Luna, and they both nod. After seeing how she handled King Sombra, Celestia believes it is time for Twilight to learn dark magic, as the next step in her path to assuming the throne.
Oh, and by the way: Celestia represents day, Luna represents night. At the border between these, where it is not quite day and not quite night, we have twilight.
**TL:DR; Celestia is tutoring Twilight to prepare her to assume the throne upon her retirement. **
r/TheoryOfPony • u/FaceDeer • Feb 18 '13
Starswirl's Last Spell was Celestia's fallback plan
I've been wracking my brains for the past few days over this alicorn thing and a new epiphany just occurred to me. Celestia said that what Twilight had done with the Elements of Harmony and Starswirl's Last Spell was something that had never been done before. Where did the other alicorns come from, in that case?
How about this: not via the Elements of Harmony, but rather the Crystal Heart. When Celestia sent Twilight to go save the Crystal Empire she was quite emphatic that it was supposed to be Twilight and Twilight alone who saved the day. She was trying to set it up so that it would be Twilight, and not Cadence (who was already an alicorn), who activated the Crystal Heart.
So when Twilight failed it was actually a real surprise and setback for Celestia. Not everything she plans works out exactly as it's supposed to, after all. But Celestia was understanding about the circumstances of the failure, and recognized that it actually spoke highly of Twilight's character, so she and Luna dug up Starswirl's old book to use it as plan B.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/synapticsynapsid • Feb 17 '13
The Season 3 Finale, Friendship, and the Apotheosis of Twilight Sparkle
This post started as a comment for the Discussion thread on the mane subreddit for the finale. It quickly grew into a little disquisition, with lots of that "over-interpretation" that gives some people the vapors, so I thought I might instead post it here. I hope prolixity is better received over here! It's my view, anyway, of this contentious finale. I wrote it mostly to get clear on how I felt about the episode, but perhaps some of you will find it illuminating or interesting too.
First, I should note as a disclaimer that ultimately there is one reason I love this show and am a brony: the character of Twilight Sparkle. I love other ponies and things about the show too, but it is Twi's character that from the moment I saw the premiere captured my interest and attention and heart. I've been sick to death with worry over what was going to happen to my little lavender pony ever since the ructions about the finale started a couple weeks ago. I sat literally on the edge of my seat this morning watching this episode on the Hub and then paced around the house for a while after it had finished, trying to collate my impressions.
Like many, I expected disaster at the end of this season (I’ve been rather like Twilight Sparkle in "It's About Time"). While I had long wanted the apotheosis of Twilight Sparkle, and it had always been my head canon that she was destined to surpass Celestia, when suddenly faced with the reality of an alicorn Twilight Sparkle, especially at the end of a season that I am really rather lukewarm about at best, I was very concerned. There was the great risk, it seemed to me, of Twilight Sparkle being lobotomized and reduced to a mere shell of her self, a vapid pretty princess. It was with this fear that I went into the episode this morning and I was prepared to abominate it with every fiber of my being. With all this said, I judge this episode to be extraordinary and am dismayed, even perplexed, by the hostility it has elicited from so many, even to the point of leaving the show and/or the fandom.
Let me review some initial points:
Let's tackle the pacing issue straightaway. I agree with the consensus gentium that the pacing is frenetic and leaves something to be desired. The episode could and indeed probably ought to have been in two parts, and had they axed some of the weaker episodes in this season, perhaps they could have done that. That, of course, is easy for a fan in the cheap seats to insist upon, but we don't really know what sort of production and other pressures were placed on the team. In any event, there's just nothing for it, and given McCarthy's remark on Twitter, I think it clear that further unpacking of the episode and its events is already planned. Moreover, while the pacing objection is legitimate, I think it has been grossly inflated as a reason for rejecting the merits of the episode and certainly it seems to me no grounds for writing the episode off altogether.
Related to the pacing matter is the claim that there's a basic rupture between two "halves" of the episode: the cutie mark mixup and then the apotheosis/coronation. I don't see any rupture and think the episode is in fact thematically unified (albeit, as we said, with a very clipped pace). My reasons for that will become clearer below.
There has been some considerable disparagement of the apotheosis/coronation as merely a marketing gimmick. Are there things about this episode that pander to marketing and to its intended demographic? Sure. It would be unrealistic not to expect some of those things, especially in a season finale which is going to draw, just for that reason, more viewers. The coronation ceremony itself is indeed frilly and schmaltzy, but not unbearably so, nor can I see that it vitiates the apotheosis (on which, again, I'll have more to say below). Still less can I see why this episode should be dismissed (or at least its second "half") as nothing more than marketing wrapped up with a little storytelling. That charge is far more accurately leveled at the season 2 finale and season 3 premiere than at this episode. At least in the case of "A Canterlot Wedding", which is so inexplicably adored by so many, few would be willing to admit the charge. If that episode is not mere marketing, to be rejected as such, then a fortiori the season 3 finale is also not to be rejected on these grounds.
Now let me get to the heart of why I'll defend this episode. It is, I think, an extraordinary and deeply moving testament to the core theme of this show: the truth and meaning of friendship, and the power that comes from that truth. Both the "halves" of this episode revolve around this theme and are not disparate elements stitched together awkwardly through incompetent writing or Hasbro interference--or at least with some charity they need not be interpreted that way. The apotheosis of Twilight Sparkle didn't just come out of nowhere, but is itself driven thematically by this message concerning friendship, and this would be true even if a diabolical clique of Hasbro executives locked the writers in a room and at gunpoint demanded an alicorn Twi. Let me try to explain what I mean. I don’t think I can do a very good job, and in defending this episode and trying to articulate why it meant so much to me, I’m going to pour in a good deal of my own passion and interpretations for the show as a whole. It perhaps means reading much more into the short scenes than what we saw, but so be it.
The calamity with the cutie marks and resulting damage to the sense of identity (viz. purpose) of the other mane six is something that they themselves cannot overcome. It was caused, moreover, by a spell that—as we will see, though it requires us to put it together ourselves—failed in the first instance (when Starswirl wrote it) because it completely misunderstood the essence of pony magic. The truth of friendship, and everything that real, true friendship means is required to restore the other mane six. That means, of course, that they need others—their friends—to restore again who they really are. A friend can do this because the love of friends is a solicitousness toward others that brings us out of a solipsistic, closed-off being only for ourselves, and into a being for others too. We find in this not a diminution of our identity but the fullness of truth about who and what we are. This is the light cast by a true friend, just as the song in the episode sings of, and it is by this light that the other mane six are restored, as they were before, under similar circumstances, in the season 2 premiere. Unlike that instance, however, in which Twilight Sparkle alone drove this restoration, here in the finale all the mane six together, sequentially, help each other. It is itself a fuller, profounder expression of this truth about friendship and what it can do and it is a lesson that crystallizes for Twilight Sparkle in that very moment when all the other mane six have been restored. She sees, as she did at the very beginning of her journey, the Spark (she literally does, as the same visual effect is used), and realizes how Starswirl’s spell should have been composed. I think that it can be inferred that Starswirl wished merely out of himself and by his own agency to achieve the supreme manifestation and understanding of pony magic—the magic of friendship—and that is precisely why he failed. Twilight understands that not alone, singled out, can this be achieved but only together, through and with knowledge and experience of the fullness and truth of friendship. When she does realize this, she can complete the spell as it ought to have been written. Note now, however, that when she does, it activates the magic powers inherent in the friendship of the mane six, and it is by the action of the other Elements upon her, in addition to her own Element, that she is transported to the celestial realm where her apotheosis occurs.
I think that we can take Twilight Sparkle’s apotheosis as the tangible expression of pony magic, the magic of friendship, understood at its essence. It is that which elevates and transforms her, just as it restored her friends. Twilight Sparkle wasn’t made an alicorn in some artificial sense, like one manufactures a drill bit. She became an alicorn and she became one not as the antithesis to her entire journey, and the journey of her friends through the show, but as the completion, as in the sense of final causality (yay, Aristotle!), of all that her journey has been thus far. It is precisely in understanding the true nature of friendship, as it was characterized above, that this transformation occurs. That is what friendship, real friendship, taken as it truly is and united with knowledge, does to us: it transforms us. Authenticity is found in us when we realize that we can always be more than what we are, and when we are drawn out of ourselves and thereby find ourselves for the first time. I see the apotheosis of Twilight Sparkle as an expression, in creative and allegorical terms, of this truth. And indeed, the very reasons Celestia gives for Twilight's apotheosis fit with this, both in their time in the celestial plane where the apotheosis occurs and when they return to Ponyville.
There has been and remains profound concern that Twilight Sparkle has nevertheless been, just as I myself most feared, lobotomized. Is she not, after this episode, really just a vapid pretty princess? Hasn't she suddenly been cloven from her books and her learning, her studies? Is this really still the beautiful bookish little lavender pony we know and love so much? Hasn’t she been corrupted after all? Not at all, or at least not just on account of this episode. She hasn't left aside or outgrown her books or her learning or studies or her scholastic life: she has come to the perfection of them. All that she was and is--the student, the librarian and lover of books--all are now united with the fullness of friendship in a harmonious whole. Here in this unity there is no discord, no part set against the other: her scholasticism and her friendship are not in antagonism but reciprocally illuminate and nourish the other. They are, if you will permit a saccharine expression, the metaphorical wings upon which she ascended, by which she earned her tangible wings. I freely own that in the fourth season, ruination might yet come, and Twilight Sparkle’s character might degenerate until she is nothing but a caricature of the pony she once was, but it need not happen and it has not happened yet. She need not be impoverished in the least because of her apotheosis, but rather we might view her as finding completion (her destiny, as Celestia put it) precisely in this fact. The contrast with Starswirl, so important to her apotheosis, is perhaps again illuminating. Starswirl was a brilliant scholar but nothing more, one might say, and that is why he failed. Twilight Sparkle is a brilliant scholar and she understands the truest nature of friendship. That is what makes her greater than Starswirl: she is a more complete pony. This has been the culmination of her journey thus far and now vast new journeys are open to her, with new lessons to learn, or certainly they can be in the fourth season. Celestia's comment about there being plenty of time for Twilight Sparkle to learn what currently does not understand about her transformation reflects this. Twilight Sparkle may no longer be Celestia's student as she was, but that does not mean the lessons are over. The lessons haven't ended for Twilight Sparkle because the lessons never end.
One might still object to her being suddenly a princess. Why not merely an alicorn? Why this coronation? Well, the philosopher returns to the Cave, doesn't he? And what is Twilight Sparkle—and all alicorns, perhaps—but a philosopher prince(ss)? I can envision the reasons given for the return to the cave (cf. Republic 519b-520d) being precisely those for which Twilight Sparkle is not merely to be an alicorn, meditating on the mysteries of magic, but a leader too. Given the often noted parallels between the Equestrian world and the ideal city of Republic, this is no great stretch, I think. Moreover, if friendship involves giving yourself—not merely what you have but what you are—to others, being open to this, as was discussed above, then this alone would further explain Twilight Sparkle's new role as not merely an alicorn but a leader.
At the end, then, it is in light of all these considerations that I will defend this episode. I think that if one views the episode with charity, with full appreciation of everything that has come before and got us to this point, three seasons in, one can find more merit in the episode than those who refuse to see beyond pacing issues or narrow marketing. It is in light of all these observations that I could be moved, as I was, to tears during the celestial plane sequence--tears of joy for all that my best beloved little lavender pony has achieved, for all that she might still achieve. I do not yet think we should despair. I think there is yet still life in this show. I will try to go through the summer with Twilight's exhortation in mind: all is yet fine.
Edited to add:
I should note in addition that part of the reason I reacted so viscerally, in this way, to the episode is because these are the very lessons that this show, and the many amazing friends--family, really--I have met through it, have taught me. I've not learned them half so well as Twilight Sparkle. I doubt I ever will. But I'm trying, and I owe so much of that to these ponies, and above all that little lavender one.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/laofmoonster • Mar 04 '12
Diagnosing Derpy
r/TheoryOfPony • u/laofmoonster • Oct 24 '12
My Little Feminist: Cartoons are Magic
r/TheoryOfPony • u/FaceDeer • Nov 14 '12
The Crystal Empire created the Elements of Harmony
The crystalline artifact is ancient, made by unknown agencies before recorded history. It must be "charged" by a group of ponies immediately before it is used, powered by the strength of the interpersonal bonds that exist between them, and then a single specialized "controller" pony directs the artifact's output. The artifact's effects generate a rainbow-colored lightshow and, while extremely powerful, are also very specific to thwarting evil forces and healing/protecting the good of heart.
Was I describing the Elements of Harmony or the Crystal Heart? These two artifacts operate under extremely similar principles and, I propose, come from the same source. My theory is that the Crystal Ponies created both the Crystal Heart and the Elements of Harmony a long time ago. The Crystal Heart is the "strategic" version and the Elements of Harmony are the "tactical" version. Or perhaps one is the prototype for the other.
The Crystal Heart is a large-scale harmonizing artifact. It's powered by the camaraderie of an entire city's population, with the city's streets and its central crystal spire acting as an accumulator and emitter for the energies channeled by the Crystal Heart. The city itself is located at the north magnetic pole to make it easier for the harmonizing emissions to be directed out over the entire planet by following the magnetic field lines (this assumes that magic and/or harmony effects are mediated by electrically charged particles, which is a reasonable assumption). The Crystal Heart's emissions bore a striking resemblance to the Aurora Borealis when seen from the ground, which I find highly suggestive of this.
The Elements of Harmony array is short-range and much more portable. It relies on a smaller number of ponies to charge it but those ponies require a stronger interpersonal bond to generate the necessary energy. Rather than spreading a uniform field of harmony across the whole planet, as the Crystal Heart does, it produces a more focused beam of harmony that is most devastating when directed against a specific disharmonious target (though as we saw with the defeat of Discord, the Elements can also generate an area effect to cleanse the local region of lingering negative effects much like a small-scale Crystal Heart).
So, where did they come from? The Crystal Empire created both of them long ago as part of their "imperial" governance. An empire is a country (or in this case a city-state) that imposes control over external satellite countries. In human history this control was generally through military and economic means, but in Equestria the Crystal Ponies used the much more subtle and humane method of projecting a powerful field of harmony over their neighbors.
Then, at some point, Sombre seized power. The Crystal Heart was no longer able to project harmony on the world, which eventually allowed the rise of Discord and his subjugation of Equestria. The Celestial Sisters, seeking a weapon capable of defeating Discord, went to the fallen Crystal Empire and did battle with Sombre. They defeated him and seized the Elements of Harmony from him but the city itself vanished due to his curse and took the Crystal Heart with it. Note that the flashback we saw of the Celestial Sisters defeating Sombre showed them fighting him with their own magic, and not using the Elements of Harmony. I believe this supports my theory that they didn't have them yet at that point.
I know Celestia said this all happened "a thousand years ago" but it must have been longer ago than that given Luna would have already been imprisoned by then. I think she was just using vague terminology to mean "a really frickin' long time."
This could also explain why the Celestial Sisters didn't send the Elements of Harmony along with their wielders to protect the Crystal Empire when it returned. They know that Sombre is intimately familiar with the Elements of Harmony and they don't want the Elements to fall into his hooves again.
Now that the Crystal Heart is back online there are some interesting times ahead for the planet. Equestria has risen to become a mighty and harmonious nation in its absence, not necessarily something that will bend its knee to the crystal ponies. Indeed, their new ruler (installed by Celestia) is Equestrian, and her husband is the captain of the Equestrian Guard. I think that the Celestial Sisters have now basically taken possession of the Crystal Empire and its power via proxies just as they took the Elements of Harmony. But that's a matter for separate speculation.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/laofmoonster • May 19 '12
The Uncanny Valley, or why people find anthropomorphic MLP:FIM art creepy
Inspired by this gif.
A lot of MLP fans find anthropomorphic MLP art creepy. Why should this happen? The characters in MLP:FIM are already partially anthropomorphic: they walk on 4 legs, but have humanoid faces, hair-like manes, and "personalities". Maybe the creepiness is from anthro art's association with furry art, but that begs the question: why would some people find anthro furry art creepy?
It turns out similar questions have been researched before. There is a point when an object looks almost human, where human reactions suddenly change from empathy to disgust. This point is called the uncanny valley*. There are multiple reasons for this curve, some aesthetic and some cultural. (See in the article, "Violation of human norms" and "Religious definition of human identity".)
Anthro MLP art is at a point dangerously close to the uncanny valley. Making the picture even slightly more humanoid can make certain viewers uncomfortable. Note that my positioning of the images on that curve are subjective.
So what about the significant population of people who enjoy anthro art? Perhaps their "uncanniness curve" is much smaller. Perhaps their curves are the same, but their positioning of those images on the graph would be different from mine.
* A similar thing happens in the "Soap Opera Effect", where soap operas look strange because they are recorded at 30 frames per second as opposed to 24 frames per second in movies.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/kinyutaka • Dec 15 '12
Lightning Dust isn't cut out for the Wonderbolts.
But they might welcome her into the Shadowbolts...
r/TheoryOfPony • u/Zennistrad • Sep 05 '12
If Discord is based off of Q, then is he really just trying to test the ponies' resolve?
We know that there was quite a bit of time between the founding of Equestria and the arrival of Discord, possibly decades or even centuries.
What if the ponies of Equestria had forgotten about the dangers of hatred and the threat of the Windigoes? What if the tensions between the three tribes did not entirely fade after Equestria's founding, and only grew again when the threat of the Windigoes had seemed to have disappeared?
My theory is this: Discord appeared in Equestria and caused trouble in order to prove to the ponies just how dangerous strife and chaos really are, and force them to learn the true value of harmony.
When Celestia and Luna became the first to realize the Magic of Friendship, Discord gifted them with the Elements of Harmony, and allowed himself to be defeated.
His appearance in "The Return of Harmony" was a way of testing the worth of the Mane 6 as the new bearers of the elements after their encounter with Nightmare Moon.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/baxil • Aug 18 '12
"Playing It Close to the Vest" -- An argument that deliberate ambiguity in the worldbuilding has enhanced the MLP:FIM fan experience
r/TheoryOfPony • u/dmdrmr • Nov 18 '12
Is the Crystal Empire where the mass exodus mention in the episode: 'Hearth's Warming Eve?'
All of the ponies leave a place where harmony was destroyed and everything was encased in ice, much like the artic surroundings of the crystal ponies.
This could be place mentioned in the Hearth's Warming Eve tale. Infact, King Sombra could be the unicorn tribe King who lost his daughter in the exodus. The pony tribes could have just split, which would mean everypony who didn't flee consolidated into the shielded city while everpony else, migrated to Equestria. Due to lack of food, crowded conditions, and the loss of so many ponies (since the crystal ponies may not have known the fate of the migrating tribes) King Sombra feel into despair.
Otherwise, the Windigos could just show up whenever ponies lose harmony.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/Zennistrad • Sep 27 '12
Could the Elements of Harmony defeat a hive mind? (x-post from the Plounge.)
Imagine a scenario where Equestria is threatened by a hive mind that seeks to absorb all things into itself. The Elements of Harmony should provide a handy Deus Ex Machina and solve the problem, right?
Wrong. A hive mind is by its very nature is an example of perfect harmony, for without individual minds to conflict there can be no strife. The Elements would be useless against the hive mind, or worse, make it even stronger.
It stands to reason that only thing that could save Equestria would be a force that directly opposes harmony. Only DisQord could save Equestria from the Borg.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/[deleted] • Jul 05 '12
An abridged analysis of Cutie Marks.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/GameFreak4321 • Jun 01 '12
Defining 1 wingpower.
While the term gives the impression of being approximately what 1 average pegasus would be able to produce. This is quite incongruous with the way that they were expecting all of Ponyville's pegasi to generate around 10 wingpower each.
It occurred to me this morning what '1 wingpower' is roughly what it takes for 1 pegasus to remain airborn. So when Fluttershy measured only 0.5 wingpower she could still remain airborn because the anemometer was measuring horizontal windspeeds. She was still generating 1 wingpower vertically.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/[deleted] • Feb 29 '12
On Winter Wrap-Up, Pony Genetics, and the Paradigm of Magic Classifications in Equestria
Before I begin, I will make a note that this post was primarily inspired by A) relevant material I have read on TV Tropes and B) pony genetics writeups I have come across, especially in this subreddit. I also apologize in advance for errors, omissions, or misunderstandings in some of the canon-related details (especially insofar as S1 is concerned, as it has been awhile).
In the first-season episode "Winter Wrap-Up", a significant portion of the conflict and plot was contingent upon the avoidance of magic use in the Winter Wrap-Up activities. I have also seen it said that earth ponies are superior with regards to producing goods from the earth than are pegasi and unicorns because of some sort of special connection between the two. Here, I argue that the restrictions on magic usage during Winter Wrap-Up serve only to restrict certain types of more overt magic as opposed to an all-around blanket ban for reasons ultimately tied into pony genetics and the aforementioned earth-earth pony connection.
It is quite obvious that unicorns have access to magical abilities. Magic is Twilight Sparkle's raison d'être, and Rarity employs it much to her advantage in the course of her dressmaking duties. Carrot Cake's mastery of magic at a young age is somewhat evocative of Neo or the Spoonboy from The Matrix. There are numerous spells at Unicorns' disposal; attested uses of magic by unicorns from canon sources include levitation of objects (e.g., quill pens), gemstone location, transmutation of matter, invigoration of hatchling dragons, macroscale tunneling, and teleportation. One common factor in these uses of magic is intent: In these instances there was some sort of will power or other more-or-less conscious control over the skill.
It has been brought up before (and in this very subreddit, no less) that pegasi wings should not enable them to fly. Pegasi also exhibit an ability to control, or at least significantly affect, weather conditions and related phenomena (hence Cloudsdale, which is essentially a cloud-forged Bespin). This evidence could reasonably lead one to conclude that pegasi also have access to magic. However, I submit that there is a difference between the two categories of magic.
At this juncture, two major differences can be identified between the two magics. First, unicorn magic appears to have a greater purview or scope of possible effects than does pegasus magic. Pegasi are relatively limited in what they can do magic-wise (v.s.); by contrast, unicorns have a staggering array of possible spells at their potential employ (again, v.s.). Secondly, and as somewhat of a caveat or a foil to this, tapping into or accessing this magic requires a more conscious component on the part of unicorns than do pegasi attempting their magic. Pegasus magic, while still requiring some willpower to execute, is a more latent ability. It would also be advantageous to here mention that unicorn magic seems to have to be (to a large extent, at least) learnt; pegasus magic appears to also require some amount of training (e.g., learning to fly), but less so.
Add into this the aforementioned "special connection" between earth ponies and the ability of the earth to produce. It may be postulated that earth ponies themselves do exhibit some sort of magical ability. The attributes of earth pony magic would be essentially a reversal of that of the unicorns: Almost completely unconscious and highly restricted, in the sense that there is a very narrow scope covered by the ability, but innate as opposed to learned.
What then of the restrictions against magic during Winter Wrap-Up? It is here submitted that the following classifications are conferred upon pony magic: In general,
Unicorns exhibit active magic, their control being almost entirely through an application of intent, and having much less limit (at least, comparatively speaking), but requiring much education to be able to use;
Pegasi exhibit mediopassive magic, their abilities being somewhat more latent and restricted and innate; and
Earth ponies exhibit passive magic, having no or almost no conscious control over it and less possibilities of scope, but also being a mostly innate function.
Thus the ban could only apply to magic that consisted solely of an active nature. Indeed, the citizens of Equestria might colloquially reserve the term "magic" for an active usage. It is also possible that the ban is due to active magic somehow overriding or nullifying the more backgrounded passive effects.
In this subreddit there was a recent post concerning pony genetics. I would like to largely concur with the analysis presented therein. I do, however, submit a question (which has here been reproduced): Is it possible that a single copy of one of the recessive genes could produce some small expression of magical ability pursuant to the gene? By way of example, Fluttershy is a pegasus, but is highly in tune with animals, and Pinkie Pie's reality-warping receives much comment from fans of the show. Is it possible that they be carriers of an earth-pony and unicorn gene, respectively?
If this is the case, what then can be said for Alicorns? Also, do Celestia and Luna fit into this classification scheme? If so, how? If not, what is their story?
r/TheoryOfPony • u/[deleted] • Nov 25 '12
The Mirror Pool summons a changeling.
Like notice how the clones seem to relate to fun in a different way than the original pinkie pie? when pinkie is playing with rainbow dash, she is endlessly considerate of rainbow dashes feelings. the clones are kind of assholes, or at the least inconsiderate and unobservant. thats because theyre changelings, and more interested in leeching off love. Pinkie pie loves having fun, but she has fun as a way of helping her friends. the clones all had fun as a way of helping themselves.
this makes me feel a little better about the test at the end, which seemed a little streched to me before. but actually it now makes sense if i think of how the one true pinkie was focused more on helping her friends instead of trying to be amused. thats why she had more will than the changelings who didnt have this underlying convictions about the situation.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/RandyGrey • Nov 16 '12
l admit fully that this is a biased opinion, but...
l was re-watching the Crystal Empire episodes and l stumbled across an interesting prospect: Fluttershy uses her left wing to hold her lance initially, while Rainbow Dash uses her right while holding her lance nonchalantly. Then RD uses her left wing to actually joust in the match, to match Fluttershy.
Clearly any situation where Dash could Give Fluttershy an advantage in a test of athletics she would, which says to me that being left and right hooved is as prominent in the pony world as it is in the human world. and Fluttershy is Left-hooved. This would account for her appearing physically weaker than the other ponies, but still being able to contribute when the chips are down, a la hurricane fluttershy
r/TheoryOfPony • u/[deleted] • Feb 19 '14
Theory about Discord and the Tree
So, this is going to be fairly basic, but I've had this interesting thought for a while now. Basically, what if there is an opposite to Discord like there is with Luna and Celestia?
My thinking is that there was a time before they controlled the cycles of the moon and sun, and Discord was around, so what stopped him from making absolutely everything crazy all the time? My idea is that the Tree of Harmony isn't just a tree, but a prison. I think Discord locked away a complementary being like himself, named Harmony. Harmony and Discord probably were in balance with each-other before Discord locked him/her away. Then, Discord was able to be much more powerful.
So, when the locks are found and used, I think Harmony may return in its anthropomorphic form.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/snickersnap • Oct 20 '13
The magic of Applejack & Earth Ponies
I had an idea that I wanted to toss out there and see if anyone else agreed with me. After thinking about it, it seems that there is more evidence of earth pony magic than just the one bit in "Heath's Warming Eve."
In about 28 of the 65 episodes somepony is bucking apples. Pretty much any time you see Sweet Apple Acres there are fresh apples being moved around. Whenever you see the trees they are always full of nearly or ripe apples.
Now the show is supposed to take place throughout the year. Apple season in the real world lasts from August to October. So how is it that while the ponies follow real world seasons they have fresh apples nearly year round?
I think that is the magic of earth ponies. They are able to work with plants in such a way that they can produce a much larger crop than we ever could in the real world with our science. They also harvest and maintain the whole thing without the use of machinery. It says something that the Apple family of four is able to maintain an orchard that would take about 25-30 humans to do.
It also explains why the other pony races were so dependent on the earth ponies. The earth ponies can just grow crops at a pace that would be impossible for the other races. They would most likely starve trying to keep up the same output as the earth ponies.
It's not just the Apples. In "Winter Wrap Up" they were able to grow grass in just twenty four hours. Cherry Jubilee seems to be able to grow an enormous amount of cherries in a desert environment (the same goes for the Appleloosians in Appleloosa).
So in conclusion it looks like earth ponies are more powerful than we thought. That's my two cents anyway. I look forward to reading any comments or criticism.
r/TheoryOfPony • u/kinyutaka • Jul 24 '13
Regarding the Element of Harmony in Equestria Girls. Spoiler warning for those that haven't seen it. NSFW
In an effort to make sens of the slightly contrived ending, I noticed three important things regarding the Element of Harmony stolen by Sunset Shimmer.
First, that the stolen Element is not the Element of Magic wielded by Twilight Sparkle. Upon her ascension at the end of the third season, the power of the other five Elements merged with the one embedded in the crown to created a single Element.
Second, the people of Canterlot High and the ponies of Equestria are causally linked to one another. While they have different experiences and memories, they each hold the same personalities, abilities, and relationships as their counterparts. Because of this, when Pony!Fluttershy earned the Element of Kindness, Human!Fluttershy was able to wield its power as well. It should be noted that when Twilight's transformation occurred, the other Elements remained intact.
Third, and most important, is that Sunset Shimmer had no way of knowing these previous points. She believed that bringing the Element of Harmony into the human world would give her the power of the Elements in the human world, where she could gather an army to take over Equestria.
But...
She had been living in Canterlot High for 2 and a half years. She had to have known that there was no magic working there. So, why would she believe that bringing the crown there would be a worthwhile endeavor? Why not just put the crown on inside the Crystal Empire?
The answer can only be one thing. The Nightmare Force.
For over a thousand years, something has been corrupting powerful individuals in Equestria, and turning them into cruel and evil beings. This force had been defeated by the Elements of Harmony before, possibly twice, depending on when Sunset Shimmer left Equestria, and it may have taken root inside Sunset Shimmer as well.
If it was whispering to her to take the crown away from Equestria, it may have believed that it could take over the Element in the Human World. When Twilight wears the crown before Sunset Shimmer, nothing happens, and when Sunset puts the crown on, she babbles about unlimited power, but the magic takes hold on its own. A Dark Magic, separate from the aura she displayed in the Crystal Empire. The transformation was not caused because Sunset wore the crown. It was because Nightmare did.
Season 4 will be exploring this Nightmare Force in more detail, and the events of this movie may or may not play out with that, but they seem linked.