r/TheSequels • u/Secure-South3848 • 3h ago
Discussion and Speculation Obsession with bloodlines ( somewhat of a rant )
I know this sub focuses on positivity, but this is something i need to get off of my chest, and i'd like to know your guys' opinions on it.
So, something i've noticed a lot in this fandom, the sequel fandom specifically is a very strong Obsession with bloodlines in some discussions. ( not the novel by Claudia Gray, i haven't gotten around to it yet, but i heard good things lol ) but instead the entire concept of the Skywalker bloodline. The one that, in canon as far as we know, started with Shmi Skywalker and ends in Ben Solo.
Now what's the Obsession i'm talking about? Ever since the end of Rise of Skywalker, and now with the potential continuations, be it in the form of the hunt for Ben Solo, or episode X, i've frequently encountered the same talking point:
"Why do they call it the Skywalker Saga, if all Skywalkers are dead by the end?"
"Ben Solo needs to return, because we need him to continue the Skywalker saga as a real member of the Skywalker bloodline"
"How do they want to continue the Skywalker saga, if Ben is dead?"
So often, i see comments like these WITHIN sequel spaces. Why do so many people undermine Rey as a Skywalker? They absolutely can continue the Skywalker saga, because we still have someone with the Skywalker name running around. Why does she suddenly not count, only because she isn't related to the Skywalkers by blood?
It pains me to see, even seeing some people go as far as saying that Rey, being a biological palpatine taking on the Skywalker name, means that the Palpatine family ultimately won, taking over their family.
Why do so many people ignore the themes of found family, the ability to chose who you are by yourself despite rough upbringings? People don't chose what they are born into, and oftentimes aren't lucky, having abusive or neglectful families. Why is breaking out of such harsh scenarios, to forge your own identity disregarded by such a large piece of this fandom?
I personally think the message of TROS is incredibly important not only to Rey's character, but the entire franchise as a whole. There's also a queer analysis to be made, of Rey finally finding an identity for herself she feels comfortable in, taking on a new name and rejecting her fascistic, conservative family.
Why is that invalidated? How is Ben solo returning the only way to "salvage" this to so many people? Don't get me wrong, i absolutely do want him to return. However, i want him to return because i felt his story felt very much unfinished, and the characters deserved a happy ending, breaking the cycle of tragic romances in this franchise.
What do you guys think?